Zvi Eckstein: Global Economic and Social Hot Spots

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Fragile stability probably best describes how visiting Wharton finance professor Zvi Eckstein sees the world. From Cairo's Tahrir Square to Wall Street and beyond, the former deputy governor of the Bank of Israel recently shared his thoughts with Knowledge@Wharton about the world's economic and social hot spots. As 2011 draws to a close, people around the world -- including those in his home country, Israel -- face numerous challenges whose solutions are hardly easy. πŸ“‚ Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] Professor Xin thank you so much for joining us today thank you thank you for
  2. inviting me uh I'd love to start by asking you about something that Israel's uh Finance Minister yal steinitz
  3. recently said he said that he thinks Israel's uh economy this year is going to do quite well but he's really worried
  4. about 2012 mainly because of Europe what is your view of Europe's sovereign debt
  5. crisis and how it could affect Israel's economy okay uh Israel economy uh has been doing very well uh growth this year
  6. is expected to be 4 .8 4.9 maybe reach even 5% uh unemployment went down to 5.6 uh inflation expectation forward are
  7. about the uh 2% so the economy in the macro sense is doing very well and uh export have been growing very well the
  8. key uh threat and risk for the economy is that uh the demand for Israeli product abroad would go down Europe hold
  9. about 35 to 40% of our exports and given the Slowdown expected in Europe which is
  10. going to be quite severe and we have seen already the ECB reducing uh interest rate uh uh we have seen just
  11. the forecast on the US economy together with Europe they are making more than 70% of the total exports so that's the
  12. key risk is really the reduction in Israeli grow of exports uh to go down to uh 4 5% and basically that means that
  13. the economy May grow next year in the range of 3.5 and that's what he sees main of the risk and 3.5 may actually
  14. may cause a little bit rise back in the unemployment I see well since we were talking about Europe and the ECB what do
  15. you think Europe's Central Bankers could have done differently well it's not only the
  16. central Bankers Europe now with the euro is putting together together 17 to 19 countries and then the EU which is
  17. consist of more than 30 countries uh did not really generate the central government uh decision making and uh and
  18. did not Implement uh strongly deviation from the M agreement of debt to GDP of 40% of deficit less than 3% etc etc and
  19. what we have seen is really Europe tackled back a big uh sovereign debt problems of uh uh Greece in particular
  20. but uh actually more threatening is uh uh potential problems with Italy and Spain and the key problem is that the
  21. Greece problem is already known to people who are analyzing data already from at least early 2010 if not before
  22. and it become to the public and uh markets reacted already from May 2010 and the main problem is that what
  23. has been done a few weeks ago and uh should have been done a year ago and that's mainly the one important decision
  24. they made is separating the European banking stability problem from the Greece uh debt uh default or or debt uh
  25. uh potential risk and that's what they did few weeks ago at least announcing they did it and that certainly reduced
  26. the tension in the way that markets now are less sensitive to the Greece problem
  27. because they view that June 2011 U mainly all the big banks in Europe will recapitalized to a 9% with a
  28. real haircut of 50 and more per of the Greek debt and potentially even an haircut on other debts if they would
  29. come and that's really provide the stability of the banking sector what do you think uh is on the cards in Italy
  30. and Spain well the cards in uh Italy is the main problem is that the political uh
  31. stability uh inside or instability inside generate uncertainty about the de to GDP ratio Italy economy has been
  32. doing not great to say the least really very slow growth even a negative growth uh debt is 115% of GDP um deficit is not
  33. terribly high but really to get back to a reasonable debt to GDP to back to the 60% sometimes in the foreseeable future
  34. Italy should take important steps and to revive its economy and to uh reduce the
  35. current deficit and uh to do that they need to probably have a more decisive government that they have now and as
  36. long as they don't do it we see the markets react and spread uh increase from the German debt and
  37. they have to finance this debt on a 6% interest rate that become going to be very very uh complicated and generate an
  38. increasing debt and if Italy debt which is trillions of dollars get into a the area of CDs uh uh risk that we might
  39. consider below AAA then uh Europe is in a real uh great trouble and the rest of the world world is in great trouble uh
  40. and Spain as well you feel I think Spain uh the feeling is that uh in Spain things are more stable uh is more
  41. manageable uh Spain the Spanish economy is doing bad unemployment is extremely high uh but uh it seems that overall uh
  42. the change in the political uh structure there will generate a path of back to uh
  43. uh normality also the level of the Deb they started with is much lower uh so there is overall Prospect of getting
  44. into instability are much lower and also the past behavior of the Spanish governments in controlling a very uh
  45. responsible fiscal policy uh and and banking regulation policy uh which come back they had one default on these local
  46. banks that generated too much household debt would be fixed I think uh Spain more likely will get very soon toward
  47. this year into a stable uh European standards let's uh come now to our this side of the pond uh looking at the
  48. persistent problems in the US economy how do you expect uh that to affect Israeli Farms well uh there are two
  49. aspect uh of course Israel more than about 30% of the Israeli export is going to the US however uh we are really
  50. exporting a lot to the high-tech sector and so far the high-tech sector has not suffered tremendously in the US and
  51. therefore the demand still uh uh was uh uh going well and we when we look at the
  52. indices of uh uh growth of the high-tech sector in the US it's still keeping up uh and that's where there is growth in
  53. the US it's not a big grow of uh jobs and therefore the US economy doesn't really get a gain a huge gain from this
  54. but the Israeli economy does so we see the new generation of the iPod and the iPhone and the Androids and all the
  55. different products and Israeli high-tech sector is a a key uh aspect there and so
  56. so overall uh uh the slow uh the the slow of the US economy G back to normality which is now foreseeable by
  57. the FED only to the second half of uh uh 2013 uh is going to have some effect on
  58. the Israeli economy but probably not tremendous effect right well as so as you have just said uh profin both Europe
  59. and the US economies are slowing down do you think that one possible solution for
  60. Israel could be greater economic cooperation with Palestine and the other Middle Eastern economies and would you
  61. what what's your view on that well in fact what has been going on in Israel is that that as the uh us and European uh
  62. economies were relatively growing slower uh since 2007 and even before we have seen an export shift into the Far East
  63. uh Israel exports are very Hightech uh we are on the if you do any comparison with other countries in terms
  64. of uh the combination of products that we are exporting we are really export software and uh and um machines and uh
  65. Pharmaceuticals and other things which are on the high-tech which is about 50% of our exports even more and therefore
  66. the possibility of exporting those goods into the Middle East doesn't seem to be
  67. the opportunity for Israel and uh we know that most of the trade uh of most developed countries is among uh more
  68. developed countries um what then can be done to increase greater economic collaboration within the middle east
  69. region I think the key to collaboration uh and the key to economic development for the Middle Eastern countries is
  70. stability peace and competition uh policies and uh I uh the key issue is stability and competition policies and
  71. uh really I think this is the main drawback of most uh Middle Eastern count countries and that's include the you
  72. know the West Bank and Gaza and maybe even Jordan Syria and Lebanon and Egypt is really uh uh economic stability
  73. political stability and then uh economic uh competition promotion uh in the country and also the open up of the
  74. country to Imports and Export and getting their comparative advantage to grow has has been the policies in most
  75. uh Far East countries which came from a very low income per capita to a growth um so one of the big importance uh to
  76. get really the West Bank is really to provide uh stability for uh the the economy there uh for the uh rules for uh
  77. rule of law for rule of property rights uh for ability to have a trade within the West Bank that's one of the main
  78. problem coming up from the um instability in the instability of the political and the defense problem and
  79. the terror activity and the and the involvement of the Israeli Army is the segmentation of this area and what we
  80. see is really the importance of first of all having an internal economy working and blooming but then the second part is
  81. really to let uh to them using their comparative advantage in some products and getting them exported because it is
  82. small economy and they can export export to Israel but really what they can do is
  83. really uh developing a large export abroad and not necessarily only to Israel well as you know the uh the re
  84. the political balance in the region has shifted quite a bit because of the Arab Spring uh do you think that the
  85. political shifts that have taken place in the Middle East as a result uh will uh enhance the possibility of great
  86. economic joint development with Israel and the region or could it hurt the situation I think why uh well first of
  87. all the the spring that we see in I think uh the the call in uh uh the square El in Cairo of uh justice and uh
  88. and social freedom and freedom and democracy hard moving to anyone who has been living in the Middle East
  89. and seeing Israel as only the model of what I would say modern democracies uh so just the possibility of having uh de
  90. democracy at pure democracy uh on a style which is close to what we see in the developed World in Egypt in Tunisia
  91. in uh Libya uh I I think uh would be uh great hope for the people there and that's I think the key what is important
  92. it's great hope for the people now how this democracy will shape into their economic policies it's a huge question
  93. mark um I think there are two important so if I have to mention two and I mentioned two I said it the other time
  94. what we need is first of all stability it's a uh political stability it's uh security stability and it is
  95. macroeconomic stability it's a budget policy stability and monetary policy stability those are necessary conditions
  96. but they are not enough without promoting competition and using the comparative advantage of the country in
  97. the world trade and getting integrated in a global economy it's hard to economy to start growing and what we see in
  98. India what we see in China what we have seen in Singapore Hong Kong Taiwan Korea
  99. and Japan many years ago it's really the this aspect that I mentioned stability consistent macroeconomic policy
  100. promotion of competition and I hope these countries uh will learn the lesson will listen to IMF uh uh advice on this
  101. aspect and uh then they will grow I think the relationship with Israel is one aspect of that I would say with
  102. Israel the key is to establish a stable um political environment and and uh uh geopolitical uh situation once we reach
  103. a stability and rather getting into uh debate and and fighting on every little aspect then it will grow I mean the key
  104. good example is the gas pipeline I mean there is a gas pipeline going from Egypt
  105. to Jordan and to Israel it it provides a lot of benefit to the Egyptians I mean very cheaply they provide us with a
  106. great gas to use uh for our electric uh production and for Jordan which a cheap price they make a lot of money out of it
  107. but then if they cannot really control the viability and the stability of this product it's very hard to see uh
  108. cooperation in other things I can give you just one more example I mean Israel in the south is a desert country Egypt
  109. in the sou in in in the area between Israel and Egypt is a desert country Egypt has a huge amount of water from
  110. the Nile for several thousand years um um it's Unthinkable uh in the geopolitical situation today to think
  111. why we not use this water to really Bloom the area why people think to bring water so far away from Turkey why not to
  112. bring the water which is already flood flood from the Delta to Alish which is just on the border why not to bring it
  113. into Israel into Jordan where we pay a huge amount for water maybe twice as much as would cost to transport it but
  114. it is the history and the geopolitical and and the threat and why do you take my water to give it to you water rather
  115. than thinking about the benefit it can bring to the people on two sides of the Border that's something that we have to
  116. really go through and if they would be able to do it politically it would be a huge gain yeah I think that's a thank
  117. you for that very thoughtful answer uh but speaking of protests as you referred to you know the the T Square um protests
  118. Israel also during the past summer saw a lot of protests in many different cities
  119. uh a lot of young people were shouting slogans against the Tycoon I think as they are called tycoons uh what what do
  120. you think are some of the main issues economic issues that face young Israelis and what policy changes are required to
  121. deal with those situations I think uh it's hard to me to say What are the underly mechanism to generate this
  122. protest uh first of all I'm not a sociologist or Psy social psychologist uh so I would just want to
  123. point out to an important issue which come up also with Occupy Wall Street which came later and which came uh there
  124. in Israel and maybe to some extent in the Arab Springs I mean young people want to see
  125. lights in front of them they want to work hard and to get to a better place um that has been in the last uh I would
  126. say during the 20th century or the second half of the 20th century of many young people in many places not old
  127. people old places and I think what the people at the streets of Israel the young people were telling us um we
  128. telling the policy makers we don't see uh a hopeful light there uh we see uh inequality we see deterioration in
  129. the services we receive uh we see uh a lot of people which are below poverty line uh and we ourself do not see
  130. ourself living in that standard that we were thinking we could in terms of uh reaching
  131. uh houses and reaching uh support we can give to our children support for education and so forth and I think to
  132. some extent there is a common view about this in uh in Wall Street uh I I would say that it's it is a populist uh
  133. common uh phenomena historically that when uh things get worse and you don't see the light then you point out to the
  134. very top people who entrepreneurs which some of them probably um earn their income legally but using Monopoly power
  135. um maybe some of them were even uh uh some of them were cooks and the police callede them or did not it's easy to
  136. point out to these people but really uh uh things are much deeper and much more complicated and uh and I think this
  137. aspect of uh uh actually trying to blame uh few people who were at the top of the
  138. earning scale uh in the last few years is not uh the way to think about changing the economy in fact when you
  139. look back on history there were always some people at the top of the scale and um there were people trying to um uh
  140. replace them and usually what happened is that they replaced them with other people it didn't change the situation I
  141. think what we have learned over time as Economist is that policies set by governments which uh enable people uh
  142. equal access to Opportunities and prevent monopolies and enhance competitions hard the policies that
  143. enhance growth and the light for the people at the end of the road and that's I think is what we try to implement in
  144. Israel and I would say not necessarily always with great success uh Professor xan I'd love to ask
  145. you some questions now about your research uh maybe I could start with a small question about a big issue what
  146. role has education played in shaping Jewish history oh that's a topic that uh we have been studying for the last more
  147. than 10 years we are publishing a book which says the Chosen Few our education the shape uh Jewish history uh I think
  148. the Jews uh have made a big change in their religion uh very much after the destruction of the temple um at the year
  149. 73 when where they make uh the learning of reading and later of writing by the boys
  150. of the Torah as the core of Judaism and when they promoted it over the years they basically generate the
  151. society or the first Society of mandatory education and I think uh uh already uh
  152. before the turn of the millennium Almost 100% of Jewish boys knew to read where the level of literacy
  153. on the farming societies around was at most 10% and that provided the Jews a big uh
  154. Advantage economically in choosing occupations that can fit their ability to read but not only to read I mean
  155. basically the reading was an infrastructure to a Jewish religion which is based on the Jewish law and
  156. rabbis and a whole system of uh decision and uh and uh there is a mishna which is
  157. the interpretation of the Torah the Torah itself is a law but then there is the mishna which take it into details
  158. and in the mishna it says that you have to read and then this mishna was interpreted by another set of law which
  159. is the Torah the talmud and then with the talmud there were rabbis who are using the talmud for years and they
  160. built on each other and and that generated an infrastructure for the Jews in the Muslim empire to start to become
  161. Traders on different distances where they can write contracts and they could if they have a disagreement on the
  162. contracts they could assign arbitrators which were the rabbis and they can move their
  163. families and they were trading from India uh from China all the way to Spain and to England and to France already in
  164. the e n 10 centuries way before Marco Polo in the 14th century start traveling over there and that's
  165. basically base the Jews as a what is called a merchant Society Urban society and they move into being Urban dwellers
  166. um earning uh relatively much more than most of the population around but in the
  167. process of moving to that um they separate themselves from the other religion which was
  168. Christianity which they called themselves the new Jews when they started which based on a on not
  169. requiring people to learn and expanding to a lot of people and basically the Jews live next to the Christians and to
  170. the Muslims mainly as an urban uh uh minority that migrated from its own will to find more income and being merchants
  171. and money lenders doctors Etc um I mean they continue to be leading in this aspect the world because the rest of the
  172. world reached to mandatory education only in the early 20th century so that was a big advantage of
  173. the Jews uh when they uh came to the US uh in the end of the 19th century they were they all came literate so for them
  174. gr into the education system in the US was kind of a natural so education that started with
  175. the change in the religion Norm had a huge impact on the whole occupational migration and population size of the
  176. Jewish people that's what we find in the book and we document it year by year our
  177. book actually end up just before the uh where the Jews were expelled from Spain in uh 1492 96 uh so we but we basically
  178. show that up to this period the key reason for the Jews choosing the particular occupation they were was
  179. mainly uh the comparative advantage they had from literacy and their uh goal of uh of uh of uh uh building up this
  180. Jewish community and this Jewish law rather than uh uh uh restrictions or uh as sometimes other historians and other
  181. people were saying the Jews couldn't own land most time they could own land they
  182. could be Farmers but the jobs they have chosen to do gave them much higher standard of
  183. living uh thank you for that do you also have a very uh uh another very interesting book coming out next year
  184. dealing with uh large of large scale immigration into Israel could you tell us about that research and your main
  185. findings yeah in uh in the early 1990 when uh uh we start seeing the large wave of immigrants from the former
  186. Soviet Union to Israel uh we established a group of researchers uh and we uh together um collected data on their
  187. integration of the Jews immigrants who arrive from the former Soviet to Israel uh during the decade from 1990 to 2000
  188. about 900,000 people came and they become like 20% of the Jewish population and which
  189. uh what we study is how well they integrated in the labor market and and there are several question one question
  190. is do they affect negatively the local the natives you know always the native are afraid of immigrants and what we
  191. document is that the the negative impact on netive was is very minor was very little was maybe for a year at the
  192. beginning and and really the main reason is that the government provided them way
  193. to invest in local human capital meaning they invested in adjusting their skills
  194. to the local market learning the language learning the uh jobs that are available in the new country like
  195. engineers in the new countries in the new country or other jobs uh with the with the machines that are available in
  196. Israel with the Israeli market and very quickly they integrated into the labor market and basically they expand the
  197. economy and the economy expanded by their interest in working in this and learning how to work in this so
  198. basically by allowing them to choose their occupation by allowing them to choose their location of study but
  199. helping them in investment in local skills uh made the integration in to the economy very smooth and make the economy
  200. growing through the entire period without any uh downturn so I think what we learn is uh
  201. if you bring immigrants the main issue that you have to worry about is uh providing them the
  202. resources to invest in the local human capital to get them integrate in the labor market and uh providing all the
  203. gains for the economy from their human capital to the economy that's sounds really fascinating because as you know
  204. immigration is such a huge issue in Europe in you know many European countries and also in the US what could
  205. uh the rest of the world learn from the way Israel dealt with this issue I think
  206. uh the Israel the way it uh mentioned is that you have to manage your immigration
  207. policy and um you cannot just uh think about uh immigration as a whoever want to come we make a qu or something like
  208. this uh what we what you have to think about is when you let people to come in you really want to provide them the
  209. mechanism by which they can learn how to integrate into the economy otherwise they may have a negative impact
  210. especially if you bring a low skill people in large amounts they really push the wage down to the to the low skilled
  211. people and that generate uh inequality and that's really the devastating so what you need is to control uh when you
  212. get immigrants in you want to control the diversity so they would come with different uh um skills and then when
  213. they come in you want to uh make sure that they have the means how to invest in the language in the skills required
  214. in the new country because the market does not provide uh the resources for this investment and the government uh
  215. investment there would pay uh very much with through the tax system to Y return to the whole country that's a great uh
  216. thank you for that I have one last question for you uh Professor xan you are a labor
  217. Economist and as you know the US economy has been struggling to create jobs if President Obama were to ask you your
  218. advice on on how can the US generate jobs what would you tell them well I have to study this uh issue I have to be
  219. honest I we have to really identify where are the main uh blocks in the labor market and the key question
  220. always in labor market is to match demand and Supply uh we have uh a long-term unemployed a lot of them from
  221. construction business uh with a lot of experience and relatively some of them with high wages in the past um and now
  222. we have uh the housing market is not really absorbing in them back um we have to study in detail what is the main uh
  223. blocks what are the main uh problems they find is it the demand side or is it the supply side in terms of adjustment
  224. of their skills and what we learn in the labor market is that uh it's not just the demand and supplies the matching
  225. quality you need to find the right workers to the markets uh so this I think is a today in
  226. the US it's highly complicated because what we do see already is a real problem in the uh demand side uh because still
  227. investment and consumption and uh consumer and investor and public um feeling and and uh and public perception
  228. of where the economy is going are not high enough to provide demand another thing is really I'm not sure that the
  229. workers who are there really understand fully the opportunities and whether they
  230. invest really in the right skills for the job market that they would face given the change uh of the economy and
  231. the Del leveraging and other things so I the one thing I want to say that I have
  232. not seen a good uh comprehensive research that um survey this data map the problems and provide a good enough
  233. uh solution that works on the two sides on the demand and the supply side focus on the on the people who are really
  234. unemployed and search for work and that I think is missing and um well Alan Krueger is a good Economist uh he's a
  235. labor Economist in fact most of the advisers to the government to the president now are labor Economist
  236. microeconomist and I hope they do this kind of research and really study the details of what's going on but if I want
  237. to summarize what we learn in the academic research it's really the matching and the quality of matching uh
  238. between uh the workers and the firms if I go back to the if I go back to my uh story on the uh immigrants what we find
  239. is really the mismatch of the quality is something we want to fix and when we enable the
  240. two-sided uh uh to overcome that it was uh much easier one reason there in Israel it was easier that the people
  241. came from the Soviet Union were willing to work for a low wage and that generate a lot of Demand
  242. by the firms I am afraid that one of the main problems now in the US is a lot of
  243. the people are not willing to work for a lower wage than they used to in the past
  244. it's hard for them to do that and that's uh uh make a problem for the firms to hire them and uh in this sense there
  245. might be a place for some subsidies on the match between workers and firms but I want to be careful
  246. on before I go and provide a to President Obama and his advisor a menu I I'm just guessing that that's could be a
  247. a way to look into this problem Prof Xin thank you so much for speaking with us today thank you thank you for inviting
  248. [Music] me

Brief Summary

Professor Xin discusses Israel's economy, European debt risks, and potential Middle Eastern cooperation amid global economic slowdowns.

Key points

  • Israel's Economic Outlook. Professor Xin discusses the risks to Israel's economy due to Europe's debt crisis.
  • Political Stability in the Middle East. The need for stability and competition policies in the Middle East for economic growth.
  • The Role of Education in Jewish History. Professor Xin explains how education shaped Jewish society and economic success.
  • Impact of Jewish Migration. The migration and population size of Jewish people had a huge impact on their occupational choices.
  • Integration of Soviet Immigrants. In the early 1990s, Israel saw a large wave of immigrants from the former Soviet Union.
  • Job Creation Challenges in the US. The US economy struggles to create jobs, particularly for the long-term unemployed.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes