The World Bank's Robert Zoellick: Countries Doing Badly Should Worry about Those Doing Worse

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The current financial crisis is no time to let emerging and yet-to-emerge markets lose their momentum, according to World Bank president Robert Zoellick. During a recent talk at the University of Pennsylvania, he suggested that despite the weakened state of the industrialized economies, it is in their best interests to prevent backsliding in the economies of Africa, Latin America, Central Europe and South Asia, many of which have successfully tied themselves to the global markets in recent years. πŸ“‚ Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] before introducing our speaker this evening let me thank John and lri reinsberg whose generous gift
  2. established this lecture series John an alumnist of the college who is now Deputy chairman of Lazard
  3. Asset Management wanted Penn students to learn from those working in the international
  4. arena in positions that we might Now call social impact and he and his wife lri established this series and lri is also
  5. very involved at pen and she's on the board of the instit for contemporary artart I think that you will agree that
  6. this evening's speaker demonstrably fulfills John and L's purpose our speaker this evening decided
  7. that he did not want to stand up in front of you and deliver the conventional lecture this is midterm week and perhaps
  8. he thinks that at this point in this semester most students don't want to listen to another lecture so we're
  9. having a moderated discussion and he suggested this moderated discussion and we are
  10. fortunate this evening to have Professor Howard pack of Wharton's business and Public Policy Department to join us to
  11. moderate Professor pack is an expert in international and developmental economics and by the way he was uh Bob
  12. zelich's teacher at one point in the past it's my great pleasure to introduce this evening's speaker Mr Robert B zel
  13. president of the World Bank group who and there was a title who will speak about the impact of the economic
  14. crisis on developing countries but I do think the discussion May range broadly when we asked Mr zelich to speak
  15. we knew that there was a financial crisis this was a months ago we asked him to speak and we knew this but now we
  16. realize that this crisis is much more far-reaching in an article published in the financial
  17. times two weeks ago Mr zelik was quoted as asking what started as a financial crisis became an economic
  18. crisis and is now becoming an unemployment crisis and to what degree does it become
  19. a human and social crisis he then observed that this Stark question should occupy the minds of all
  20. those those struggling to find answers to the global recession Mr zelich is superbly
  21. qualified to discuss possible answers to this question let me note some of the highlights of his long career in public
  22. service he became the 11th president of the World Bank group on July 1st 2007 immediately prior to joining the
  23. bank Mr zelich served as Vice chairman International of the Goldman Sachs group he served in President George W
  24. Bush's cabinet as the 13th us trade representative from 2001 to 2005 and as deputy secretary of state from 2005 to
  25. 2006 from 1985 to 1993 he served at the treasury and state departments as well as briefly in the
  26. White House during the 1990s Mr zelich served as an Executive Vice President of Fanny
  27. May Mr zelich is no stranger to Philadelphia he received his bachelor's degree from swore College where he was F
  28. Beta Kappa um he then went further north along the coast and spent some time at Cambridge he received his JD Magnum L
  29. from the Harvard Law School and his masters of public policy from the Kennedy School of government at Harvard
  30. please join me in welcoming Mr Robert celik president of the World Bank turn it over to you okay so when I
  31. going to start with is a set of questions which will allow us to get the discussion going and the first thing is
  32. that when uh you became president of the World Bank the big challenges all of 18
  33. months ago were you're going to list some of the newly emerging uh economies to become Partners
  34. in uh with the World Bank and fostering development throughout the world you're going to encourage growth in the Middle
  35. East you're going to try to deal with fragile States emerging from Civil War and disaster use free trade to Spur
  36. growth and in general build sustainable inclusive globalization and now that you
  37. face a crisis every morning and probably every night and uh the world has changed
  38. quite dramatically especially in the last six months can you in retrospect say uh that
  39. the topics you chose to emphasize when you first came in still remain important are they doable and is it uh feasible to
  40. address them given the crises that are occurring on a daily basis um well well first let let me
  41. thank all of you for uh for joining us tonight and uh particularly since as you mentioned it's the heart of the midterm
  42. but let this be a caution to you um uh Professor pra was my professor he's still asking me questions so you never
  43. get away from it it's best just to give up and accept the role of the faculty uh what what what Howard had
  44. mentioned were was that when I joined the World Bank I thought it was very important to identify some strategic
  45. themes and I talked about them uh as themes because I was trying to recognize that the the velopment mission of the
  46. bank um had to customize its services for different challenges and so we were focusing on uh the poorest countries in
  47. Africa the particular challenges of some of the middle- inome countries and the rising uh uh economic Powers the unique
  48. issues of fragile States uh which uh really require a combination of governance and security and development
  49. um Global public goods uh which included the trade issue but also uh climate change questions I also highlighted
  50. uh the Arab world in the Middle East because I thought there were some unique issues there that we could make a
  51. contribution but another one which cuts across was a knowledge and learning agenda and the reason I drew that out is
  52. because I think one of the key functions of the World Bank group is not just to do loans and business every day but to
  53. continue uh to draw on that experience um compare it with other learning and try to see how we can upgrade and
  54. provide additional insight and in that sense uh those challenges remain at the heart of
  55. what we need to do in a global crisis because part of the uh the issue for us is how do we customize uh our services
  56. uh for each of those those groups and categories given the nature uh of the problem that we're in um obviously uh
  57. there's there's ones that will rise in prominence so I was talking with some of the Huntsman fellows uh uh and louder
  58. fellows earlier today about the particular challenge in the area of trade of identifying the need for trade
  59. Finance given the problems that or the amount of of largely government guaranteed debt in the developed world
  60. this has presented a special problem for some of these Rising economic Powers uh
  61. that otherwise would have had open opportunities for finance so one of the challenges that uh runs across all this
  62. for us at the World Bank group is to try to be faster and more flexible in adapting to client needs and seeing how
  63. we can solve problems uh at the same time there's a ongoing uh requirement to try to anticipate and we can get into
  64. this further with your questions or others I think we are in a period now of uh extraordinary uncertainty in the
  65. world economy it's a very dangerous period a lot of risk to the downside so as a public institution what we have to
  66. try to do while serving clients is try to get a sense of those issues uh that are immediately on the horizon
  67. and work with other parties because um while the World Bank group has some considerable resources given the
  68. challenge of this problems our real uh need is to try to figure out how we try to mobilize other players uh in support
  69. of the things we're doing some of the things on your agenda presumably required funding and a lot of attention
  70. by you and the World Bank staff and your attention is deflected from those issues
  71. for example we know that the Arab countries are having remarkably rapid increases population and labor force uh
  72. they've had some troubles liberalizing but given the amount of time one has to spend on something like that compared to
  73. the fact that Eastern Europe is in a freefall can you really pursue that as well well Howard I don't have to do it
  74. all myself we have 15,000 people there right so uh in a sense part of the challenge
  75. here uh as organizational management leadership is that in to take your case of the uh the Arab world um we tried
  76. over the course of the past 18 months to work with our Arab partners and try to identify some of the major challenges
  77. that they saw compared it with our own sense they include issues of Education to Workforce uh women in the labor force
  78. uh Water Resources uh I was just at the Arab League Summit in the middle of January those remain very very vital
  79. issues now uh of course you have to adjust about what resources they have to provide and with many of the Arab
  80. countries the role that the bank was playing was not a financing one it was taking the experience and knowledge and
  81. we were providing some of this as a fee for service business uh so part of what we instituted or focused on when I came
  82. to the bank was trying to adjust our business model uh for different needs and so that flexibility uh is actually
  83. something that gives us the strength at this point now you mentioned Central and
  84. Eastern Europe in the same vein uh we were talking beforehand and I was asked which region I felt was probably uh most
  85. exposed to this crisis and I mentioned Central and Eastern Europe because it's a region that over the past 20 years has
  86. used trade investment movement of Labor Force which leads to remittances to integrate with the international economy
  87. uh but in that sense it exposed itself to Greater vulnerability than some other countries would that were shielded from
  88. the system but it doesn't have some of the cushions that uh one had in Western Europe or in North America or Japan and
  89. in part because a number of the countries were in transition to the euro Zone you have this added danger of
  90. assets such as mortgages that may be in a foreign exchange in this case the Euro
  91. or Swiss Franks that adds to some of the risks so part of what we need to do at the bank is something that we were
  92. working with some of our partners at the European bank for reconstruction development the European Investment Bank
  93. uh just last week to try to put together a fund where we could try to support some of the key uh Western European
  94. banks that provide a lot of the the banking structure uh and support uh for Central and Eastern Europe but this
  95. won't work unless the European governments also provide the overall uh support and framework and that's a
  96. challenge that you were probably just for those of you that had time to read the newspapers we reading about this
  97. week another thing which immediately pops up and it's probably a touchy topic is historically developing countries
  98. have been very uh Out Of Tune with the advice both from the international monetary fund and the World Bank their
  99. advice differs IMF is macro the World Bank is micro but on things like the the desirability of import liberalization
  100. are you now finding that some developing countries are saying we don't want to liberalize look at what has happened in
  101. the world we're not going to try emphasizing exports because our export Market of the oecd are falling apart
  102. well one of the things that makes this a fascinating period and will be for graduating students is uh it's a time of
  103. great flux with these issues and uh given the diversity in the world you get countries that are turning to different
  104. answers so I was just reading as I was coming here um Ecuador is probably um putting on some of the greatest import
  105. restrictions and so it's one of the countries you see first moving to protectionism um I don't think that will
  106. succeed um uh we'll see over time but interestingly enough I got a similar report uh from one of my colleagues that
  107. was just uh in East Asia and some of the East Asian countries were actually recognizing this may be a time to
  108. continue to move forward with reforms to try to achieve greater flexibility of markets so to come back to the role of
  109. the bank um what we're trying to do is to focus on some of the Lessons Learned From The 9798 Crisis and elsewhere and
  110. help clients uh try to deal most efficiently and effectively with what are probably the primary needs one is
  111. safety net systems uh particularly given what I believe will be the depth and length of this crisis uh in all
  112. developing countries one needs to be able to use resources effectively to deal with those that can least help
  113. themselves now um you know if in some countries there's about 10 or 12 starting with Mexico and Brazil that
  114. develop something called conditional cash transfer programs which are programs that devote uh cash resources
  115. to those that have been selected as being most in need and the conditions are you need to send your children to
  116. school and you need to get basic health checkups and that's been particularly helpful for uh maternal Health those
  117. programs are welld designed to be able to uh increase the amount of resources expand the scope but in some countries
  118. in subser Africa you don't have the organizational capacity so there we're trying to learn what's worked with food
  119. for work programs or School feeding programs or School feeding programs that would bring some food home for the
  120. parents as well um and so part of what the policy advice is if you have limited resources but you want to help those in
  121. most in need you probably don't want to increase all Civil Service salaries or uh try to increase an overall wage
  122. structure because that's an inefficient way so part of what we can share is the expertise now a second area uh learning
  123. from the Chinese experience in 9798 uh is that countries can wisely invest in infrastructure to both create
  124. jobs and create a basis for future productivity which is what China very much did now this doesn't always have to
  125. be in hard infrastructure there's various types of soft infrastructure and one of the points we've been making to
  126. the Chinese actually that have a lot of hard infrastructure is this might be a time to invest in some of the soft
  127. infrastructure uh and this includes some areas of educational and additional Social Development um the third area
  128. that we're trying to encourage is the small and medium Enterprise sector uh because it's easy in an environment like
  129. this where you get big public responses to lose the fact that the greatest engine of creativity and flexibility and
  130. job creation is the small private sector but they're often on the short end of the credit uh stream and so what can we
  131. do with microf finance and others to be able to keep that section going now the reality is you in each country we have
  132. to customize based on the circumstances uh and their own history and their own support uh I mean one of the hard
  133. lessons of development over the decades is Outsiders can't do it for a country a
  134. country has to be able to own it they have to be able to have a sense of of uh of control over their project and to
  135. give you a very practical example on that uh this week I was talking with the president Ukraine and the prime minister
  136. of Ukraine shortly beforehand the first challenge is to get them working closely
  137. together to get some IMF program but in the process of offering what people call
  138. Budget support some basic financing I was trying to suggest that um we had some experience with some programs to
  139. try to help those most in need and this could be both good politics and good economics so in a crisis like this part
  140. of the challenge would be issues of political economy how do you get people to the right policy solution recognizing
  141. the institution and political structure and one of the challenges for us as a as
  142. the World Bank group uh is that U we have many fine economists and analysts some of what whom you've worked with
  143. over the years but we also need to try to make sure that the analysts see themselves as problem solvers with this
  144. broader uh complexion of of political and social issues and one final question before we
  145. turn it over um the poorest countries in the world the ones that have had slowest growth
  146. have been the African ones and from roughly 2002 2007 there were a number of about 18 African countries that are
  147. actually growing quite well and now one senses that with commodity price decline collapse in some
  148. cases the African countries are having enormous problems and they're going to have increasingly bad problems
  149. as the oecd countries slow up and as China and India demand for exports from them go down is there any prospect that
  150. the bank could redeploy efforts towards the African countries let me start uh with the foundation that you referred to
  151. because many people don't recognize some of the success of African development in
  152. recent years if you go back uh over about the past decade and you look at some uh 17
  153. countries that represent a little bit over a third of the population without mineral resources uh that group of
  154. countries grew on average about 5 and a half uh 5.6% then there were about eight
  155. countries uh that were the Prime energy producers uh and over that and they represented a little bit less than a
  156. third of the population that group um grew at about an average of 7.2% so you have about two-thirds of the population
  157. of Africa growing in a pretty significant range now the problem in part was the missing third and this is
  158. one of the issues going back to your first question of postconflict in fragile States and one of the tragedies
  159. of those countries is not only the harm that they caused their own people but often their neighbors and you know we
  160. now have the statistical evidence that if you one country is next to a postconflict state on average or growth
  161. is about 1.2% less one thing that would be a great tragedy of this crisis is that people
  162. lose the sense of Africa's potential and uh having worked with Africa over the years one of the things that I found
  163. very striking in recent years was a changed attitude among many African leaders of thinking solely of of a
  164. Social Development agenda and in a sense being Wards of the International System
  165. and instead wanting to have uh frankly what people in Western Europe wanted to have 50 years ago they wanted to have
  166. Regional integration linked to global markets they wanted energy and infrastructure and they wanted a healthy
  167. private sector now in this this crisis uh what that suggests to me is uh one immediate aspect is you want a direct
  168. attention uh to those who have been the good reformers so uh in a sense you have
  169. a version of the Central and Eastern European problem some of those that are most linked to the International System
  170. could be made particularly vulnerable now you mentioned commodity prices separately uh one of the things that we
  171. began at the World Bank and I actually was at a discussion audit this morning with a our extractive Industries group
  172. is how for for the for the natural resource producers the real challenge was one of governance how do you take
  173. the resources and Paul CER and others have written about this build transparency in
  174. the system build broad-based development um and in this current environment this
  175. group that we were meeting with this morning was seen that uh if you believe as I do that at some point uh you will
  176. have a recovery and for various reasons I could see that commodity prices will rise again you actually want to be
  177. putting in place the platform now um so you don't have um the great volatility and everything from property rights to
  178. laws to the contracts um and it's not only a question of investor government confidence but it's also a question of
  179. developing the benefits for the larger population so that uh it's socially sustainable and politically sustainable
  180. so part of the challenge of any policy job and a development job is how do you combine the near-term challenge uh with
  181. looking a little bit further out and I would argue that in the case of Africa while you do want to provide uh
  182. targeted assistance for example in social safety net you don't want to lose the opportunity to build the future
  183. basis for growth and that actually brings me back to the point about infrastructure at productivity basis
  184. again there's a tremendous opportunity and this is one of the things things we were talking about with regional
  185. integration if we can bring some of the smaller markets together uh relying on whether it be transport structure use of
  186. the waterways some of the energy systems you know one could come out of this crisis with Investments that would
  187. actually create uh the basis for future growth so you know one of the challenges
  188. um whether for me as a international policy maker or those at the national level is to try to keep the eye on on
  189. those those steps uh whether it'll be how you deal with future or the current liquidity and danger of future inflation
  190. um how you deal with the uh a large expansion of of expenditure and budget deficits uh at the same time that you're
  191. trying to cope with today's problem um Bob I I've been been sitting here listening and you Ed the word
  192. crisis 17 times but recovery only once so my question is as Jenice said you talk about a economic crisis a financial
  193. crisis an unemployment crisis even perhaps a social and um and human crisis what Milestones or um metrics ought
  194. should we be looking at that's going to Signal a recovery well and I'll add one more that I've added since that piece
  195. well it's political crisis um and uh you know uh as you could tell a little bit my background is a little bit of mixture
  196. of economics and law and governance in different fields and so I I tend to look at these issues from a sort of
  197. multi-disciplinary perspective um and uh no reason people would be aware of this
  198. but when I was um in the state department from ' 89 to '92 I worked on German unification all the events of the
  199. Cold War so when I look at the issues of Central and Eastern Europe now has a very striking effect because I think of
  200. the danger of reversal of what was I think a historic Global achievement and trying to unite Europe whole and free um
  201. so in terms of of what I would look at um I guess first uh I would I would keep an eye on what's going to happen with
  202. the with stimulus programs you've had a number of them start as we were talking about before I think actually the
  203. state-of-the-art of knowing um exactly what are the right tools or things that people have to approach with a certain
  204. humility but there are certain ones still in the process like looks like China's moving towards a second phase um
  205. Second and I think this is critically important uh stimulus programs will be like a
  206. sugar high unless you fix the banking system I mean you'll get a surge uh but and and uh I'm sure none of you uh in
  207. your circumstance either drink a lot of coffee or eat chocolate or anything like
  208. that but you kind of get this high and Bam you hit it to the ground um and what Dominique Stan the IMF has talked about
  209. is they've analyzed some 122 financial crisis and unless you fix the Banking and Financial system you can't get it
  210. back going and so I think the core issue not only for the United States now but for others is how do you deal with this
  211. conundrum of cleaning up the Bad Assets and recapitalizing the banks um a third question uh is to keep a watch and and
  212. again I think in this area I think the United States through the Federal Reserve has been pretty creative is how
  213. do you keep some of the credit markets working right now the banking system doesn't provide that the Federal Reserve
  214. has actually used its balance sheet to provide a secondary Market by buying commercial paper and mortgages and other
  215. assets I personally think that it would be useful for some of the other central banks globally to look at that uh more
  216. closely as as a tool to use but I do see potential downside risks and and so in the anticipatory sign uh one that I have
  217. a concern about is something that happened in 97 and '98 hasn't happened yet which would be the collapse of a
  218. major currency you've had depreciation significant depreciation but you haven't had a currency really come down now as a
  219. policy maker knowing that that's one of the reasons why I believe that the calls
  220. for the IMF to double its resources are very important so it would have the resources to be able to intervene and
  221. support again the role of anticipation um a second area is uh protectionism um you know probably all
  222. of you have read about smooth Holly and what happened in the 30s and the traditional Terror forms of
  223. protectionism that would be bad enough um but uh frankly there's a lot of uh sort of Insidious ways that you could
  224. start to take steps that start to uh create counter reactions in other countries and I just have to emphasize
  225. this as a former US trade representative people look at the US and the biggest countries with under under a very close
  226. uh microscope so when you saw this bi America provision came in uh you know fortunately it got some close attention
  227. so people uh made at least uh what I it appears to be some adjustments but uh as
  228. you look at these big pieces of legislation and stimulus passes you got to look closely at these to get a sense
  229. of some of the trade effects the WTO which doesn't have this capability actually recently asked us to try to uh
  230. examine some of the stimulus packages uh and even though it'll be sensitive in some quarters I think it's a good idea
  231. to try to uh identify these topics then there's an aspect of um of of political economy that I don't know how to
  232. describe other than the fact that it's a global crisis you need a global solution
  233. that means countries have to cooperate and uh one of the D me as we get further into increas in unemployment rates is do
  234. you start to see actions that show countries pointing fingers at one another as opposed to uh trying to work
  235. together and I think that's something that I would watch very closely during the course of 2009 you know as as a
  236. leader of one of the international institutions you know I can try to play a modest role in identifying these but
  237. uh part of the challenge in this whole system is you know we still have an Economy based on nation states that's
  238. the political basis those are where the decisions are made people have to be responsible their local citizenry but
  239. the issues that we're dealing with are certainly crossborder and transnational so how do you uh interconnect those two
  240. looking a little further ahead uh we talked about this this afternoon in this anticipatory Spirit uh one would
  241. certainly want to be alert to the fact that there's a lot of liquidity out there and at some point when um the
  242. velocity of money picks up you could have an inflationary uh boom and bust again and so I think the good news is
  243. the fed and the European Central Bank have identified that they've suggested how they would withdraw the liquidity
  244. but is in a lot of things in life timing is everything so knowing when and how to
  245. do it is still going to be a big issue and if you had to design it what would the post crisis world look
  246. like or if you could do well I um it it's hard because I'm trying to think of uh sort of the Practical
  247. reality versus what I would wish um I guess I would say this uh at at this General level um I believe that
  248. globalization has brought a lot of benefits uh to people and that you know I've been in a lot of developing
  249. countries where I've seen the incredible opportunity it's provided not only economically but in terms of openness
  250. and freedom I think it would be a huge tragedy if that were lost and reversed but from the start of my period at the
  251. bank I felt that to sustain globalization uh one has to uh make it both inclusive
  252. and I use the term sustainable inclusive within countries so that you get a broader sense of benefits of it but also
  253. across countries and then sustainable has both the environmental meaning but also it has a systemic meaning how do
  254. you try to learn some of the lessons uh from what happened in financial markets try to see how you can head them off um
  255. how do you try to strengthen some of the disciplines in in in the trading system
  256. and sort of move the the bias towards uh Freer trade uh and so what I hope will come out of this is a recognition that
  257. um many of the forces that have created incredible Economic Opportunity over the
  258. 50 past 50 years uh remain very valuable you don't want to throw out the baby with the bath water but you have to
  259. create some changes in the institutional structure and here again this affects the institution that I had the World
  260. Bank I don't know how it is now in courses I remember when I was taking courses you we read about the creation
  261. of the multilateral institutions you know so these are the grand old institutions that were created in 1944
  262. and 45 not surprisingly public institutions uh often change more slowly than private institutions do so frankly
  263. coming back to the mission of the World Bank group part of our challenge is how do we overhaul and update these
  264. institutions to play play a role some of that can happen in crisis sometimes crises can be an opportunity to move I
  265. mean it's useful to remember that the World Bank and the IMF were created while World War II was still going on so
  266. those people were kind of busy doing something but they took time to deal with these institutions so you can walk
  267. and chew gum at the same time but I do think sometimes uh whenever you have an event like we've just or are going
  268. through sometimes you also have um uh political responses that uh can overreact and there you have to figure
  269. through um whether you might do more damage you know so just one the to flag is is that obviously there needs to be
  270. lessons for uh regulatory reforms um there were lessons of excess but one has to be careful in the present environment
  271. that if you want to get the private sector back engaged uh that you don't uh undermine further confidence in the
  272. private sector so those are some of the balances people have to strike [Music]

Brief Summary

Robert B. Zoellick discusses the economic crisis's impact on developing countries and the World Bank's adaptive strategies during a moderated session.

Key points

  • Introduction of Mr. Robert B. Zelich. Mr. Zelich, president of the World Bank, discusses the impact of the economic crisis.
  • Challenges in Developing Countries. Zelich discusses the unique challenges faced by developing countries during the crisis.
  • The Role of the World Bank. Zelich outlines the World Bank's focus on customizing services for different countries' needs.
  • The Future of Growth. Investments from the current crisis could lay the groundwork for future growth.
  • The Importance of Globalization. Globalization has provided incredible opportunities, and reversing it would be tragic.
  • Crises as Opportunities. Crises can lead to necessary changes and reforms in institutions.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes