Wharton Professor Jonah Berger on "Losing to Winning"

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Pay attention to the first-half scores in the early rounds of the NCAA basketball tournament, which began yesterday with 64 college teams vying for the National Collegiate Athletic Association championship. According to recent research by a pair of Wharton professors, teams that trail by a little at the half actually have a better chance of winning the game than the squad in the lead. The findings, they say, apply to the business world, too. 📂 Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at Wharton for more information please visit knowledge. won.
  2. up.edu so in general in any sort of competition if you're a sports team let's say you're
  3. a basketball team trying to win a game or you're a group of employees trying to win a competition uh your group of kids
  4. trying to win your school book drive something like that in general any sort of competition it's good to be ahead if
  5. you want to win so the more points you're ah head in basketball the more uh dollars you've raised towards your goal
  6. whatever it is the further along you are the more like you are to beat your competitor so uh take sports for example
  7. um so you wanted to look at NCAA basketball uh in general teams that are four points up at halftime they win
  8. about 60% of the time teams that are eight point up at halftime they win 80% of the time and so in general the more
  9. you're ahead the more likely you'll be to win um but what we looked at in this paper is whether losing along the way
  10. could actually be a good thing being behind someone else could actually be help you uh to be more likely to win and
  11. so what we found actually is that basketball teams uh as one example that are slightly behind at halftime are
  12. actually more likely than their opponents to win so uh you might think that a team down by one should lose or
  13. win less than 50% of their games right the team that's up by one should win um but we actually find the opposite teams
  14. that are down by one are actually more likely to win and in general they're about five to s% more likely than you'd
  15. expect by chance uh and the reason is motivation so we can always uh we can all think of examples where where we've
  16. been a little bit behind a goal something we really really wanted we almost got there but we just didn't get
  17. there um and that's exactly what's going on in this so being close to winning right being close to winning at halftime
  18. but not quite there is very motivating um and so what we look at is we also look at what happens at the beginning of
  19. the second half so you've been in the locker room you're down by one how does that change how you might come out and
  20. what it we show is that you come out a lot stronger you work a lot harder you score a lot more in those first couple
  21. minutes after halftime um and what we also find similarly is if you just bring people into a laboratory and you say
  22. okay have them do a little task they're pressing buttons on the computer and you
  23. tell them they're going to be competing against someone else in the room and you
  24. never show them that person but you give them feedback halfway through the task how they're doing half the people you
  25. tell you know what you're almost there but you're just a little bit behind and the other half the people say oh you're
  26. beating your opponent what we find is that in the second half of that task people work harder they pass those keys
  27. faster they press them very hard um when they've been behind and so being behind
  28. just a little bit can actually encourage people to work harder sure um so let's say you're a manager
  29. and you have a group of employees and you guys are competing against another group uh another company for a
  30. government contract right so maybe you're Boe and you're competing against another company for an airline U but
  31. building Bunch airliners for for a government or the the military or your some other competition you want to
  32. figure out how to motivate those employees how are you going to get them to work harder and how you going to get
  33. them be more likely to win that competition um and so one thing this research suggests is that you want to be
  34. very strategic about the way you do that um so one thing you can do is take breaks strategically so you could first
  35. of all you could tell your employees that they're a little bit behind but you could also you say oh guys we got to
  36. work harder those guys they're barely beating us they're two weeks ahead of us we're behind but you could also take
  37. breaks when you take stock of the the progress at times when you guys are a little bit Pine so rather than actually
  38. giving your employees false feedback just pick a metric or take a break at a time or look at the metrics and ways
  39. that make your team your employees feel like they're not too far behind you don't want to make them think that oh
  40. we're so far back that we can't do it but we're just a little bit we're almost there but we're just not quite we just
  41. have to work a little bit harder and what this research shows that when people feel like they're that just a
  42. little bit behind they're going to work harder and that's going to make them more likely to succeed in the long run
  43. for more business news and Analysis from knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge. won. up.edu

Brief Summary

Being slightly behind in competition can boost motivation and performance, as discussed through sports and employee strategies.

Key points

  • The Power of Being Behind. Research shows that being slightly behind can motivate teams to work harder and succeed.

Related episodes