Backlash: How Early Adopters React When the Mass Market Embraces a New Brand

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A well-established principle of product development holds that a small group of early adopters can spur mass-market acceptance of a new product. What is less well understood is how those early adopters react when that product or its brand is accepted by the mass market. As Wharton marketing professors David Reibstein and John Zhang explain in this video, the company could experience a backlash as early adopters move on to other new products. A case in point: Porsche saw a decline in sports car sales after it entered the SUV mass market. Research by Reibstein and Zhang discusses reasons for the backlash and suggests a strategy for dealing with it. 📂 Marketing

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at Warton please visit knowledge. won. up.edu for more
  2. information it is a well-established principle of new product development that a small group of early adopters can
  3. influence Mass market adoption of a new product there's lots of cases where you know I buy they buy the more they buy
  4. the more excited I am about buying as well what is less well understood is the effect the mass Market has on the early
  5. adopters the question is when they start selling to those other individuals what
  6. is the feedback or what's the impact on the uh on the original group Wharton marketing professors John Jang and David
  7. rebstein are shining a light on the topic by quantifying the degree of negative influence the mass Market has
  8. on early adopters it's not surprising in a lot of image oriented products you know I buy they buy I'm less inclined to
  9. buy and I'm ready to move on to something different for example um I was getting ready to teach a case on diesel
  10. to my uh seconde marketing strategy class and I thought I ought to go to the diesel retail outlet and maybe buy a
  11. pair of jeans I go into the store and they quickly want to Usher me out you know and they say to me um excuse me sir
  12. um were you looking for another store and actually tried to get me out of the store before I had much of a
  13. negative influence on other customers and I think their belief was that if I bought the product this would not be
  14. good advertising for them rebstein and jang's paper suggests first of all that firms should be cognizant of the
  15. potential backlash effect when introducing a product to a new segment of customers when we explain it to
  16. people intuitively it makes sense what's interesting is that we're quantifying it
  17. and example that we talk about in the paper and we've got data to sort of show that this effect happens Porsches is
  18. doing great selling to you know sports car Enthusiast and had a great reputation there they're looking and
  19. saying whoa look at this other Market over here of SUV drivers and Porsche moves to introducing an
  20. SUV it's not clear to me how much they thought about what the backlash would be what you will see is the Porsche cells
  21. were doing well you see a direct impact as the SUV sales start going uh and taking off not
  22. only were the there letters to you know various different Publications complaining about how could how it could
  23. Porsche possibly be doing this and destroying the brand but you saw it in the sales too and and it is my belief
  24. and the data supports it that um the introduction of the SUV the Porsche SUV had negative repercussions one of the
  25. purposes of the paper is to get people people to concentrate and think about that backlash Jang and rein's paper not
  26. only documents the backlash effect but presents a strategy for managing product introductions in the presence of that
  27. effect what we develop in the paper is sort of an issue of What's the timing how far do you want to get in the
  28. penetration it's also a function of what's the relative size of those markets and you know you're willing to
  29. sacrifice some sales in that first Market if that second segment is sufficiently large our study shows that
  30. uh in fact that even with the backlash effect in many kind of a situations you still want to get into this General
  31. market um the reason is very simple the backlash effect is a dynamic effect the leverage effect is also a dynamic effect
  32. and by judiciously select the timing of a market entry you can actually maximize
  33. The Leverage effect and minimize the backlash effect so one of the interesting consequences are if I'm
  34. going to go into the second Market should I do it with a different brand and so there's going to be some
  35. followup in trying to think about you know what's the cost of developing a second brand and try and compare
  36. development of a second brand versus staying with the uh with the original brand for more information please visit
  37. knowledge. won. up.edu [Music]

Brief Summary

Wharton professors discuss how mass market adoption impacts early adopters and strategies for managing backlash during product introductions.

Key points

  • The Backlash Effect. Exploring how mass market influences early adopters, revealing potential negative impacts.
  • Porsche's SUV Dilemma. Porsche's shift to SUVs sparked controversy and impacted their brand reputation.

Related episodes