The Braggarts Dilemma

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. i study philanthropy both what causes people to behave generously and how generous acts
  2. are perceived by others especially in light of the fact that oftentimes when people behave generously
  3. they reap some benefits in return and those benefits come in different forms so we receive tax breaks when we give to
  4. charity we earn reputational benefits for being perceived as a generous person which is valued in our society
  5. and we reap emotional benefits feels good to help others and so this is kind of a contradiction
  6. because altruism generosity in its purest form is supposed to be selfless and yet we
  7. benefit from it in this paper we look at what happens when people brag about or advertise
  8. their good deeds to others we ask the question of whether and when bragging is effective
  9. and the answer is really that it depends on the one hand bragging signals a selfish motive for behaving generously
  10. it signals that perhaps the person behave generously not because they're truly a good person who cares
  11. but because they wanted to earn credit for for being a generous person and so in that sense bragging shouldn't
  12. help your reputation if others realize that or others perceive you as doing it for a
  13. ulterior motive on the other hand bragging is just marketing it's providing information if
  14. nobody knows that you did a good good deed then you don't get any credit at all and so to the extent that
  15. bragging provides new information about your generous behavior bragging should enhance your reputation
  16. as a generous person so through a series of controlled experiments we're able to
  17. tease apart or disentangle the different sorts of effects that bragging has on a person's reputation and the key
  18. finding is that bragging only pays in situations for which bragging provides new news so if a person's reputation is
  19. not so generous bragging can help by providing information that the person has behaved
  20. generously but if a person's reputation is already generous then bragging doesn't provide any new
  21. information it only signals that the motive isn't pure that the motive is is to improve one's reputation
  22. so we found this pattern in a number of ways in one study that i like in particular
  23. we described a person who volunteered for a community service organization and then in some cases they subsequently
  24. posted on facebook telling their social network that they had done this volunteering
  25. now one thing we did in the study was we varied whether this individual was an investment banker or was a social
  26. worker now investment bankers don't have the kindest warmest reputation in fact they're perceived to
  27. be pretty selfish whereas social workers are perceived to be generous warm people
  28. and so somewhat surprisingly we found that bragging actually paid for the investment banker
  29. by providing new information so when the investment banker brags people learn that in fact
  30. he's a bit generous after all whereas the social worker has already thought to be generous
  31. and so bragging doesn't pay for the in the case of the social worker well public displays of generosity are
  32. ubiquitous nearly every new building on a university campus hospitals and in the arts is emblazoned
  33. with the name of some illustrious donor who's signaling to the world just how generous they are
  34. now this these forms of boasts are not just the purview of the super rich in fact if you look around on social
  35. media you'll note just how pervasive bragging is so people advertise or brag about their
  36. achievements they brag about their relationships and they brag about their good deeds
  37. and so our research sheds some light on whether this is actually strategically smart or in what cases it's
  38. strategically smart to brag and what we find is that it makes sense to brag in the cases
  39. for which bragging provides new news about a person's character if a person's reputation is already
  40. thought to be generous then bragging fails to to provide any benefit and only signals a potentially
  41. selfish motive this research has other implications as well so a reluctance to brag by some
  42. individuals may actually be a hindrance for fundraising a very generous person may want to keep
  43. their donations and other good acts private so that it's they can signal to themselves that their motives are pure
  44. however we know that one of the best ways to fundraise is by telling other people of
  45. of your own donations when you tell a friend about your donations that inspires them to donate as well and
  46. so this really gets at the conflict between doing the most good possible and appearing the most good
  47. so beyond studying how selfish motives are perceived by others i also investigate how selfish
  48. incentives influence altruistic behavior in a recent study we asked people to make a pitch on video
  49. advocating a co for a cause that they care about now after they agreed to do this we gave
  50. some of them a financial incentive we told them that for every ten dollars donated
  51. based on somebody watching their video we would also send them ten dollars in return
  52. other participants receive no such incentive and what we thought was really informative
  53. we found that donors gave less money on average when they viewed a video made by
  54. somebody who had received a financial incentive and this is because even though they
  55. were unaware that the incentive exists they can detect the sincerity and the self-interest of an incentive
  56. taints the person's ability to convey sincerity in their pitch you

Brief Summary

Bragging about generosity can enhance reputation if it provides new information, but may backfire for those already seen as generous.

Key points

  • The Paradox of Generosity. Exploring how generosity can be both selfless and beneficial to the giver.
  • Bragging and Reputation. Investigating when bragging about good deeds enhances reputation.
  • The Impact of Financial Incentives. How financial incentives can influence altruistic behavior and donor perceptions.

Related episodes