The Best Time to Ask for Donations: Behavioral Science Lessons

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW When should hospitals contact potential financial donors? Research from Wharton professor Katy Milkman finds that asking at the right time is key. This episode is part of a series on “Charitable Giving.”

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#donations #fundraising #development #behavioralscience ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Katy Milkman: As behavioral scientists, we actually find it quite unusual that people give at all. So being generous,
  2. making donations to organizations, is something that a strict rational actor model in economics might say should never
  3. happen, right? Unless you have a financial interest in the organization yourself, because you'll somehow gain. And so this
  4. is sort of a ripe area for Behavioral Science Research. Dan Loney: Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>,
  5. the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host,
  6. Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that
  7. Wharton professors have conducted, and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today.
  8. - When you think about donating to an organization, when is the right time for that organization to make contact?
  9. Research looked at how hospitals contact potential donors, especially ones who had
  10. been at their facility for treatment in the recent past. One of the people involved in that research is our guest here
  11. in studio, Katy Milkman, who is a Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School.
  12. Great to see you again. - Great to see you too. How did this idea come about in the first place, when you're
  13. thinking about the charitable component? Obviously, hospitals do rely, a component, on their revenue
  14. being from a charitable avenue. Yeah. Well, so first of all, of course, we were really
  15. interested in charitable giving, because the team that did this work, led by Amanda Chuan and also with Judd Kessler, another
  16. Professor here, we are interested in charitable giving because as behavioral scientists, we actually find it
  17. quite unusual that people give at all. So being generous, making donations to organizations, is something that a strict rational
  18. actor model in economics might say should never happen, right? Unless you have a financial interest in the organization
  19. yourself, because you'll somehow gain. And so this is sort of a ripe area for behavioral science research. And then hospitals are
  20. a place where a lot of charitable giving takes place. So many hospitals benefit immensely from charitable giving
  21. each year. And so that seemed like an interesting place to study this. But when you asked specifically about this project,
  22. where we're interested in the speed at which an "ask" follows the receipt of service—this was really something that we got
  23. interested in when we realized that there's a lot of different theories that might predict that you'd want to capitalize quickly
  24. on people's emotions and gratitude when it's an organization, say an animal shelter or a hospital or a
  25. religious organization, or even an organization providing relief after a natural disaster. People may have a quick feeling of warm
  26. glow, to use the economic terminology of gratitude. And that might crater as time passes. And so you may want to
  27. be quick to take advantage of those warm feelings that are going to arise right after this interaction. On the other hand,
  28. though, there's sort of the risk of being perceived as too quick to ask, too quick to capitalize right after doing something that
  29. was generous and charitable, which is the nature of charitable organizations. If you quickly say, "Oh yeah. Now, could
  30. you give us some money?" the person who received that, you know, positive encounter may feel like this is kind of icky,
  31. and I don't like being contacted by my hospital. Or by the— you know, shelter that— where I got my puppy, so quickly after they
  32. did something nice for me. And it feels like they're trying to capitalize. And so there could be reactants, which is the word
  33. we use for when it's negative. So we thought that was interesting. We always love studying questions where you
  34. could imagine the result going in either direction, and that got us excited about this project.
  35. But seemingly, then— that is the issue, or the question that a lot of organizations deal with— is, how you formulate that plan
  36. with the timing component being right near the top in terms of the importance of making that contact with that person at the
  37. right time and getting the best positive outcome. That's right. We want to be top of mind and sort of maximize the feelings of
  38. gratitude, and minimize the sense that we're being sort of too grabby for money after a positive encounter. So it seemed
  39. like a really interesting research question that would also tell us something about human nature. And to what extent
  40. is gratitude a stable feeling, and to what extent does it really decay quickly over time?
  41. So as we're taping this, we're actually a couple weeks away from two massive hurricanes that hit the United States, and so
  42. that dynamic in terms of the donation really differentiates from what would be, I guess, traditional models or paths of
  43. asking for donations. Because you have such an immediate impact and such a disastrous impact on so many people in
  44. communities across the Eastern half of the US. That's right. And of course, charitable
  45. giving goes up in response to need, because people can empathize with victims. And
  46. there's some wonderful work that's been done on how important it is to have identifiable victims. This is
  47. work by former Wharton Professor Deb Small and George Lowenstein at Carnegie Mellon. When we think about a person and their
  48. suffering, we're much more willing to open our wallets and give if we think we can impact them than if we think about
  49. statistical victims. So just describing how many people have been displaced. And these organizations know that. They
  50. wisely fund raise at times of need and do so in effective ways. But what we're studying in this project is actually for
  51. those who were recipients of, say, rescue workers' aid. What is the optimal time to think about asking them, "You've benefited,
  52. and now let's think about sort of turning around and asking you, would you give because someone else in the future is
  53. going to also need help?" So we didn't, again, study this in the exact context of hurricanes or disaster relief. We studied it with
  54. hospitals, but the idea is that there'd be a similar dynamic where you'd want to think about, what's the right timing after
  55. someone has benefited from an organization that's a charitable organization's contributions, to ask that recipient of the
  56. benefit giveback. And so with this work, in many cases, you were talking with individuals, or you were finding out about individuals who had
  57. been at a hospital in recent—in the recent past, they had had some sort of procedure or medical connection with the
  58. hospital, and it's—so it is a very unique dynamic of that hospital having treated that person, having that interaction
  59. with that person, and then also asking them for, potentially, a donation to support the—
  60. kind of the operation of the hospital as well. That's exactly right. So these are first time patients at a large
  61. hospital system, and within 20 to about 130 days after their first patient encounter, they're going to receive a letter from
  62. the hospital system asking them to make a charitable contribution to the organization. And what's sort of
  63. interesting about this context is that this is a large hospital system that's sending lots and lots of these asks for
  64. donations. It's a big part of how they can run the organization, is the generosity of these donors. Both patients
  65. and non patients are contacted, but we're focusing on the patients. And what they do is they send these mailings every
  66. few months in a batch. Basically, an administrator has time on their calendar, and they sort of sit down and all this
  67. gets prepared, and the messages all go out at once. And what that means is that there's natural variation in how long
  68. after a person has their encounter with a hospital system— because maybe I came in for surgery on April 1, and
  69. you came in on May 1, and the next batch goes out on June 1. You, then, are going to have a much shorter follow up period
  70. after your encounter with a hospital than I am. I'm going to have to wait 60 days for my ask. You're only waiting 30. And we're
  71. taking advantage of that natural variation to see—and over a period of many years, when these batches are sort of happening
  72. erratically, is there a consequence? Can we identify a consequence of a faster versus a longer lag time after that
  73. patient encounter, for the likelihood the patient says, "Yeah, I would like to donate?"
  74. So were you able to determine what is kind of that sweet spot for a hospital, for an organization, to make that ask
  75. of a person who'd been in a— you know, in that facility? Yes. And actually— you talk about a sweet spot, and that's because
  76. we talked about these— this tension between the two competing theories that, you know, you don't want to act too
  77. fast and seem grabby, right— like, "Oh, this wasn't done out of the goodness of the organization's mission. It was
  78. just, you know, all a ploy to get you to give us money as fast as possible. It's almost like a payment." And then the sort of, "We
  79. want to capitalize on that feeling of gratitude." So we thought there might be sort of a U-shaped relationship. I should
  80. say, an upside down U. Like, it might be better to wait— yeah, hump— to wait a little while, but not too long. And what we
  81. actually found is, you can't act fast enough, essentially. In our data, we never saw anyone getting a mailing asking for a
  82. donation faster than 23 days after their encounter. But faster was simply better. We just saw that there was a pretty
  83. linear decline in giving. And basically, every extra 30 days after an encounter you wait to contact a patient leads to a 30%
  84. decline in the likelihood that they will make a donation in response to that ask. So a really precipitous decline. And it
  85. continues over the whole course of the time that we were able to follow patients. They— you know, they don't ask years later.
  86. - Right. Is that kind of— you think— kind of the format that hospitals will take with all patients? And I only ask that because I think
  87. some people will react differently to being contacted, whatever the time is. You know, some people, no matter the time,
  88. will feel like, "Oh, my God, it's another ask from the hospital." Or they're like, "Oh, yeah. They did such a great job of taking
  89. care of me. Yes, let me write a check to them." That's right, not everyone is going to be affected, but it is remarkable
  90. that you'd see this 30% decay with every 30-day decline. That's a pretty huge effect. So it suggests that a lot of people
  91. are impacted by the time frame in which the ask is made. Now, I do want to be clear that, again, the fastest anyone was asked
  92. here and that anyone got a letter was at least three weeks after their encounter. So it's not like, you know, what you
  93. should do is set up a Venmo and ask people to give 30 seconds after they leave your organization having received
  94. some sort of benefit, right? So maybe that would work. It's possible, but that would require further research. But when
  95. you're thinking about a range of, you know, do I contact them three weeks later or three months later, you're much better
  96. off with that three weeks later, because we do see this decline. And it suggests that the way we think about the gratitude
  97. that we feel towards organizations that help— that help us— much like many things about human memory, just sort of
  98. decays over time. Right? When you have a positive encounter with an instructor in the classroom here at Wharton, when you have a
  99. positive interaction on the street with a friend, whatever it might be— these things, we tend to feel really great right
  100. after them. And then pretty quickly, you know, all the other things going on in our lives take over and dominate our mind
  101. space. And so those feelings decay. That— that strong positive feeling decays. And so you just want to make sure that you don't
  102. wait too long. You want to capitalize on that positive feeling. How important then, does it become for the organization to
  103. have a kind of understanding of this component of behavior, you know, in terms of making that ask in the first place?
  104. You know, again, the effect sizes we saw were remarkably large, with a 30% decline in the likelihood of any donation for every extra 30
  105. days they wait. That suggests it really is important for the organization to get its act together and get these kinds of
  106. asks out quickly. I think organizations should be thinking more about timeliness, given how strong the effects are. And I
  107. think more research is warranted to try to figure out, what is that sweet spot? And maybe there is a too fast. Maybe there's
  108. not. Maybe every organization should be asking the day after. My guess is that that would be a little too fast. But again, more
  109. research would be warranted, because these are, you know— there's a lot of organizations that really do rely tremendously
  110. on— on donations in order to do their good work. And so being more attentive to this issue of speed seems important to me.
  111. Well, and probably, you know, using the example that you studied with the hospital, in comparison to, say, the SPCA or some other
  112. organization like that, the type of contact that you have with that person probably plays a factor in this as well.
  113. I appreciate you asking about that. Yeah, that's absolutely right. One of the things we thought it would be actually
  114. interesting to look at in the hospital was sort of the acuteness of the illness that brought the patient in. And so
  115. it's a little bit tricky to say. Because we— you know, we didn't have detailed patient medical records in addition to
  116. the data we had on giving. But we did know which portion of the hospital the patient had been seen in. So we asked— we had—
  117. there were 11 different sort of divisions. And we asked a set of doctors who worked in the hospital system to classify
  118. which were the most severe types of patient encounters, and there was 100% agreement that it was patients who came in for
  119. surgery, for oncology— right? So for cancer or for cardiac— cardiology, right? Something related to their heart. Those
  120. are the patients who are having the most significant health issues, according to these raters. And we just took a look
  121. to see whether or not these effects, this decay, this decline, was any larger for the patients who had had those kinds
  122. of encounters than patients and other groups. And we found that it was substantially larger, suggesting sort of these more
  123. acute and emotional extreme encounters might show the biggest benefit to making sure that you follow up quickly
  124. before people sort of have gone back to their normal lives and aren't thinking so much about their gratitude for the life-
  125. saving service that potentially was provided. You talk a little bit in the paper about the element of reciprocity.
  126. Is there an expectation of an organization, whether intentional or not, that they should receive some sort of a
  127. donation because of the work that they have done, or is it just, you know, we will make our connections with people and see,
  128. you know, how they react to us asking them for a donation? Yeah, that's a great question. I think reciprocity is a very
  129. fundamental human reaction. We see reciprocity in lots of contexts. When— when I scratch your back, you scratch mine,
  130. it's very common. And so it is very natural for the strongest donor bases to organizations like hospitals, for instance, to
  131. be their former patients. So I think there is an expectation of that. Certainly it's going to be less extreme in cases where
  132. people don't have the means to provide it, right? So asking donors who are very low-income and could barely afford the care
  133. would, I think, be seen differently than asking someone who has the financial means to be a contributor and received
  134. care at a reasonable rate. And— and you know, maybe had their life saved. Then you'd expect to see a larger degree of
  135. reciprocity. So it's going to be on a scale depending on how much someone can give. But in general, that's a major motive
  136. for donations to many organizations. Having done this research, what do you think is—
  137. is the message then to organizations about how they should put together their plan
  138. of contact, how they should look at the process of asking for a donation from individuals that have been connected with them?
  139. I think the main message is that timeliness matters. And I think we don't think enough about how time changes the way that
  140. people think about what decisions they'll make. I've done a lot of research in this area. I have some work looking at
  141. something called "the fresh start effect", where at the beginning of a new year or a new week or a new month, people are more
  142. motivated to pursue their goals. We see these ebbs and flows and motivation over time in a lot of parts of life. And I think it's
  143. something that doesn't get enough attention when we're thinking about everything from fund raising to promoting
  144. employee well-being— is recognizing that every day we don't wake up equally motivated to take action on behalf of
  145. another organization or on behalf of ourselves. There are moments when we feel more open to making a change in our life
  146. or expressing gratitude to another individual, and that we have to think about that, that time course of people's feelings
  147. and people's motivation more carefully, in order to get the best results if we're an organization trying to motivate
  148. our workforce or an organization trying to motivate a donor base. So, attention to timeliness, I think, is just a critical thing
  149. that all organizations need to keep top of mind. Katy, great to see you again. Thanks very much.
  150. Thanks so much for having me. Thank you. Katy Milkman, Professor of Operations, Information and
  151. Decisions here at the Wharton School. - Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this episode
  152. informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight
  153. from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Katy Milkman discusses the importance of timing in hospital donation requests to maximize charitable giving.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Dan Loney introduces a podcast exploring insights from Wharton faculty on behavioral science.
  • Charitable Giving Research. Katy Milkman discusses research on the timing of donation requests after hospital visits.
  • Impact of Timing on Donations. Research shows a 30% decline in donations for every 30 days after a hospital encounter.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes