Balancing Competition and Cooperation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A new book by Maurice Schweitzer and Adam Galinsky explains why success depends on being able to cooperate and compete effectively in every relationship. More: http://knlg.net/1XPmiCx ๐Ÿ“‚ Leadership;Management ๐Ÿท๏ธ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we often look at our relationships in terms of extremes someone is either a friend or a foe but a new book suggests
  2. that we should actually be looking at how someone is both a friend and a foe friend and foe is also the title of the
  3. new book by Wharton Professor morce Schweitzer and Adam galinsky who's a professor at Columbia business school
  4. they're here today to talk to us a little bit about their book and how you can apply it in both your life and work
  5. Maurice and Adam thanks for being here thank you thank you now you write that a key Insight of the book is that both at
  6. work and at home we're competing and cooperating all the time often at the same time you also point out that we
  7. often miss the mark by focusing the on the discussion about whether it's better to do one or the other so wh why is that
  8. well I think it starts with the idea that we love to categorize things in our world it really helps us navigate our
  9. way through our social experience so from a very young age we categorize their girls and their boys and that
  10. extends to thinking about people as other are friends or our foes we just do that natural categorization and and as
  11. academics we also do that natural categorization when we construct our theories you said you know we missed the
  12. mark all the time because it's really easy to come up with Theory it says we are born to compete it's also very easy
  13. to come up with the alternative Theory it's like we have an innate Instinct for empathy and so even as academics we're
  14. trying to simplify the world to try to understand it and it's easy to take that one's lens now to keep both those lenses
  15. you know and describe this idea there's a tension between them and a balance between them it makes the world a little
  16. bit more complex although obviously more realis realistic um and so this idea that we're competing cooperating all the
  17. time exists for every relationship in fact it it you know it even exists for co-authors I think right yeah it was
  18. true for us I mean even going back and forth uh taking terms writing and revising and you know we we talked about
  19. whose name is going to go first on the book and we had to go with the convention of alphabetical order even
  20. though you know we both contribute are equally Cadena coin TOS you know there's really no difference between um it's
  21. just it's just an alphabetical but even that you know creates some tension like how are we going to decide who gets to
  22. be first who gets to be second because being first is still a little bit better you know and so fortunately I was born
  23. with a slightly you know earlier name in the alphabet but you know it's it's it's
  24. you know you see that cooperation competition tension existing even as we wrote the book right now you identify
  25. actually three forces that influence how we shift from friend to Foe and those are scarcity sociability and dynamic
  26. instability can you describe each one of those one of those and talk a little bit
  27. about how they interact with each other yeah so you know let me give you one of the examples Us's in the book which I
  28. really love which is the grevy zebras in Africa now you take these three forces of sociability scarcity and sort of
  29. dynamic instability and you can see that happen so they have an incredibly scarce
  30. important resource on the plains of Africa and that's water now when water's abundant they form in a particular form
  31. of social organization these strong collectives with lots of people interacting with each other in stable
  32. units around the water sauce but when water becomes scarce then they quickly sort of dissipate from the collective
  33. form um they they're um uh they form more sort of small bonds with each other um and that often are temporary bonds
  34. too and so you can see how this scarce resource which is dynamically changing over time produces different types of
  35. social relationships yeah that's true even with people um we find for example siblings often compete for a scarce
  36. resarch which is Parental attention and so we have siblings and we think about Brotherly Love where siblings can be
  37. incredibly collaborative the best of friends but we also think about sibling rivalry they can be incredible
  38. adversaries often competing for some of these scarce resources and this can change quickly dynamically as the family
  39. structure changes or even at at the very beginning uh breastfeeding for example is one way infants delay the arrival of
  40. a new sibling uh that is by breastfeeding longer women are less likely to get pregnant and that that
  41. preserves their their attention uh for for as long as they possibly can and you can even see that change happen let's
  42. say a parent gets a new job that's more demanding of their attention the family structure hasn't changed but now the
  43. cooperation might become a little bit more competive as they compete for that that scarce
  44. resource and one thing that actually connects Maurice and I is that I'm I'm a twin and his a wife as a twin and so
  45. even in the womb you're competing for scarce resources so I was born much smaller than my my my sibling and
  46. there's a weight difference for with marica's wife and and her twin sister you know I'll give you just one other
  47. example think about Thanksgiving Thanksgiving starts as the most Cooperative day of the entire year we
  48. come together as family and friends we have an abundance of resources all this food and then we switch sometimes within
  49. an hour of the end of Thanksgiving dinner into one of the most competitive moments of the Year Black Friday these
  50. what's scarce these incredible deals two TVs you know for $30 and what do people
  51. do they literally trample each other to death to try to get one of these TVs and
  52. so we can see these these re scarce resource whether it's a good deal whether it's parental tension whether
  53. it's water it changes quickly over time and fundamentally Alters social relationships
  54. now you also have a lot of examples in the book so again I mean where how can we take kind of the daily things that a
  55. leader of a country goes through which I mean I don't think a lot of us could really even imagine but then also we can
  56. apply them to our lives I think you know I think there's I think we can talk about just three examples of presidents
  57. you know one of the things that we talk about is um one of the key things that we want to do is we want to Signal trust
  58. to other people we want them to trust us and since the Advent of Television um every president in the United to Signal
  59. trust in one very very simple but specific way they get a dog right so take Barack Obama Barack Obama's
  60. daughter is allergic to dogs and yet he still felt compelled to get a dog Scott Walker he's got two dogs Scott Walker
  61. headline in the New York Times is Scott Walker allergic to dogs will he defy history by knocking dogs so that's you
  62. know one of these examples but we also even see like in presidential or uh you know in parliamentary politics right how
  63. important social comparisons are which is another incredibly important part of the book and you know Maurice has a
  64. great example there well I mean yeah in the book we talk about uh two brothers David and Ed Miland and if you're from
  65. the United Kingdom they those will be familiar names they were both vying for the leadership of the labor party in in
  66. the United Kingdom and uh David was the first to announce that he was going to run and his younger brother Ed announced
  67. that he was going to compete for that position they went through several rounds of voting and finally at the very
  68. end uh the younger brother Ed edged out David now this this social comparison there is we're constantly comparing
  69. ourselves with people around us including our siblings and here that sibling comparison is a really intense one and
  70. when we go out of order when the younger brother gets Advanced first or we can think about when one sibling gets
  71. married before another sibling when we go out of order we're making these comparisons that can be very unpleasant
  72. and and David for example he he not only resigned from Parliament he ended up leaving the country he actually came to
  73. New York he he didn't do it right away but but he talks about the invidious comparison that was really corrosive for
  74. him and as a as a final example you know just take presidential debates we're going to see Republican debate tomorrow
  75. night and the question is you know do I want to like break out on my own or do I
  76. want to sort of be in step with other people and and one study that I did with some of my colleagues is we actually
  77. analyzed every transcript of every televised debate and we looked at something really simple did I mimic or
  78. was my verbal structure similar to the person who asked me the question or the person who I was responding to let's say
  79. my opponent and now you might think you know if I really use a different sort of
  80. verbal structure I'm going to show him a leader I'm going to be different but if
  81. I use a similar verbal structure it shows I'm kind of in tune with you that I'm makes it more smooth it makes it
  82. easier for you to process what I say and so we actually showed that people who did more verbal mimicry actually got
  83. higher boost in the polls after the debates now this occurs in every Walk of Life so just for example waitresses
  84. studies showed that if waitresses mimic the behavior um and words of their customers they get higher tips study I
  85. did if you know you like to lean back if I lean back a little bit my in my chair
  86. and we're negotiating I get a better um I get a better deal if you like lean forward if I lean forward a little bit
  87. towards you I get a better deal and so this mimicry occurs at the presidential level you know in restaurants in
  88. negotiations at work all over the place there's a lot of examples in the book that seem to contradict a lot of
  89. commonly held thinking and one of the ones I thought about is you know two that really stood out was one that teams
  90. may actually be better off when they have less talent and another one is that it's actually better to be interviewed
  91. last for a job whereas I think our we might all think that you know it's it's better to be first because then you're
  92. first you came in first so I was just curious about like how did that how does that play out like why is what we think
  93. is true not actually the case yeah so with the talent one you know we call this the too much talent effect um and
  94. the idea is that when we have a lot of talented people in a group one of the problems that can occur is it can create
  95. what's called status conflicts like who's really the best person who's going to be the alpha person who's going to
  96. take control who's going to dominate now sometimes that's not really a problem at
  97. all let's take a sport sport like baseball right um in baseball the more Talent is always better right if we get
  98. a bunch of people can hit home runs you're always going to win more games a bunch of people can pitch really well
  99. you're always going to win better but in baseball I don't need to coordinate my behavior very much with anyone else I
  100. just need to hit the ball as hard as I can now let's take another sport like basketball it turns out in basketball
  101. you see this too much talent effect you really see this phenomenon where at a certain point Talent is helpful but then
  102. it goes down and actually hurts you now in basketball we have to coordinate our Behavior incredibly well when I'm
  103. shooting that means you're not shooting and so therefore who gets the ball is a scarce resource in addition it's much
  104. easier to score if I get the ball in a position close to the basket or there's not a Defender so that means it requires
  105. a lot of coordination even like rebounding and defense requires a lot of coordination and so what we found is
  106. when teams get above a certain level of talent they don't coordinate very effectively they don't have a lot of
  107. assists they have more turnovers and their winning percentage actually goes down and just take you know a good
  108. example recently was when um the Los Angeles Lakers at Kobe Bryant Dwight Howard Steve Nash and even their coach
  109. said I don't even like watching us play it's like no one likes watching an All-Star game because All-Star game is a
  110. Just J bu people jacking up shots this is what we have right now is we have an All-Star team but we don't have a real
  111. team and so you can see this too much talent so the key variable and this is what really matters is how much do you
  112. and I really have to coordinate if we have to work together as a team you can have too much talent and sometimes you
  113. do you're you're better off less is more getting a little bit less Talent if we don't have to coordinate it all and
  114. we're just independent people um whose own talents contribute directly to Performance more Talent is always better
  115. so it's really cool because we can really see like basketball and baseball how one variable interdependency and the
  116. need for coordination determines whether more Talent is always better or you get
  117. too much talent I mean related to these sort of structural ideas you can think about uh these order effects you
  118. mentioned before and in many cases it's better to go last particularly when there are many different competitors or
  119. we're we're choosing among a lot of different candidates if you look at for example American Idol you look at
  120. ratings of the Olympics uh going last is a huge benefit particularly when the judgments are subjective where one of
  121. the things we're doing as judges is we're holding out we leave room in our first judgments because we want to see
  122. if somebody better might come along by the time we've gotten to the end we no longer need to keep that buffer uh and
  123. second there's a recency effect that is our memories are remarkable but they're limited and we forget things over time
  124. and our memories are sharpest for the most recent things so there are two benefits at least two benefits that the
  125. last person receives and you see this play out in a lot of of different competitions where it's often best to go
  126. last and and you know part of this where I got really interested in this topic was back when I was in grad school I got
  127. an interview at the University of Chicago great you know job and they wanted me the first one to come in and I
  128. was back of my mind feel little apprehensive but I asked you know uh a lot of my f professors like oh we always
  129. want our best candidate come first and I went and interviewed it was the first one interview didn't get the job you
  130. know and then still kind of thinking in the crawl of my mind about this and then
  131. I realized in my entire five years at Princeton we had had five Job searches and the last person had gotten hired
  132. every time and then you know when I was at Kellog and and I got interviewed there I was the last person to be
  133. interviewed and I got the job and so you can really see how you know the this effect really really takes place I don't
  134. know if everybody knows this everyone's gonna want to go last now and now there's speaking of job interviews there
  135. was also something in here that there was also something in here about you guys had a colleague who used a really
  136. interesting exercise right before her inter interview that actually helped her aset and this was in your chapter about
  137. power so you tell us a little bit about that yeah so you know many years ago I was trying to understand how to study
  138. power and you know if you go in the lab and you say you know Maurice you're going to be the boss you know Adam
  139. you're going to be the subordinate there's a lot of things going on to really just try to understand the basic
  140. psychological consequences of being in power um other than just the power like Maurice has to think about what am I
  141. going to say to Adam and direct him um and so we came up with this you know manipulation to study experimentally
  142. where we just said think about a time when you had power really just sort of recall the experience and what we found
  143. is that actually the same effects if I if I told marce to think about time you had power is the same effects if I
  144. actually made him the boss and so what happened is one of my former students Jillian CP who's now a tenur professor
  145. at London business school but she went for an interview and her first interview was at at Harvard and it didn't go very
  146. well they really plunged her with question she was kind of knocked off her game she walked out of there feeling
  147. pretty demoralized and so when she goes to do an interview at London Business School you know she's trying to sort of
  148. you know regain that sense of confidence and they give you about a half an hour before your talk to settle in she said
  149. you know what I'm going to do I'm actually going to do Adam's experimental manipulation you know just see if it
  150. actually get the same effects and so she wrote about a time when she had power literally physically wrote it out to
  151. really like get into it and then she was complete control of situations she was just you know knocking the questions
  152. back you know answering things and you know she got the job and you know she's still there to this day and it was you
  153. know just one of those examples we had another who had been in the market a couple times um hadn't done as well went
  154. in the market a third time before every talk wrote out a um the power Prime um and got four offers that year you know
  155. so you can just really see how you know you can just by taking this reflection and thinking about time when you had
  156. power has this transformative effect let's say I mean there a lot of great examples but um but Adams run hundreds
  157. of studies where not hundreds I mean do yeah probably hundreds uh where where this this experimental manipulation
  158. brings back it sort of creates a psychological sense of power and it's been incredibly widely uh adopted yeah
  159. now the book I mean we it stresses that you know we're both cooperating and competing constantly and simultaneously
  160. but I'm wondering now I mean are some people better at one than the other I mean like if I'm really good at
  161. confidence but maybe I don't always know how to defer who to defer to like how can I use the knowledge about which one
  162. I'm better at to sort of help me in these situations kind of check myself for example well yeah so so certainly
  163. some people tend to be Cooperators some people tend to be competitors and some of us are sort of in the middle harder
  164. to classify and there's a social value orientation scale that can help us classify people so so there are
  165. definitely individual differences and there are things about a context that can push us one way or another that is
  166. there there cues in our environment that can easily push us one way or another yeah and I I think you know you asked us
  167. really a great question of like how do we you know recognize the fact that there always is this tension and we're
  168. Co cooperating and competing um and that we have to find a balance between these
  169. forces and I think about the interview context is a really great one how do we do well when we're going for a job
  170. interview well we want to express confidence but we also don't want to express arrogance so the key balance
  171. there is to express confidence as a way to sort of compete well but also to express some humility as a way to sort
  172. of show cooperation and I think that one of the things that you know Maurice and
  173. I really think as valuable about this book is that it it allows people to ask themselves the question am I finding the
  174. right balance am I finding the right am I being exploited so I'm cooperating too
  175. much am I losing opportunities to make connections because I'm competing too much and I think that just by asking
  176. ourselves that question periodically maybe once a month it allows us it gives us a sense of power it allows us to
  177. correct course um but allows just asking the question allows huh no know maybe I
  178. need to be a little bit more Cooperative to get back more in balance or maybe I need to toughen up a little bit to get
  179. back more um into the competitive mode and so I think that what we hope this book does is allow people to recognize
  180. we're always cooperating we're always competing to recognize that tension and also to ask ourselves if we're finding
  181. the right balance well and I I had one other idea which is um something that I tell my students uh I think you a lot of
  182. us tell our students to keep a journal um for negotiations uh and I tell my students
  183. you know after the course ends you know keep keep this journal as you go through
  184. life jot down some things about your negotiation what you expected what surprised you and how things ended and I
  185. told them to look for one thing in particular if you look back across 10 negotiations and you find that you're
  186. satisfied with your outcome every single time you're probably not setting your goals high enough if you look back
  187. across Ross an arc of negotiations and you find that you've ruptured relationships nine out of 10 times
  188. you're probably being too competitive and so here we can think about looking for data to help us bring ourselves back
  189. into balance now one of the things I thought was interesting I mean you're talking
  190. about the individual there but I also found that the book I would think has a lot to offer for say I'm a manager and
  191. I'm managing a team and I have a diverse team of people like really thinking a lot more deeply about the team dynamic
  192. and how to deal with them and how to kind of structure things so I'm getting the best out of each person we talked
  193. about social comparisons before we compare ourselves with other people and as a manager we might think well okay
  194. let's try to make everything equal or let me try to gain trust by by creating better transparency and so gravity
  195. payments they they made payment information transparent they so they shared that information and they brought
  196. everybody up to you know sort of equal salaries uh a disaster is sort of and and I would say a rather predictable
  197. disaster that is we We crave comparisons we we want to know how we're doing compared to the people around us that's
  198. how we figure things out in our in our social world the salary information a really
  199. key piece of information um and there's a good reason why we don't talk about salaries as freely as as we might um
  200. because it's going to make some people feel absolutely terrible and when you start moving people's salaries around
  201. people are going to find inequity uh it's it's easy for us to justify why I should be paid more
  202. somebody else should be paid less and and it's an easy source for us to become completely miserable and I think in this
  203. case it's really interesting he was motivated by an incredibly well-meaning intention which is some my employees
  204. can't afford to live in the Bay Area like they're getting paid $35,000 they just can't pay rent what if I just move
  205. them up to $70,000 everything's going to be great they're going to be able to pay
  206. now how do the people who are getting paid $70,000 feel now they before were getting paid twice as much and it made
  207. them feel like I'm twice as valuable maybe they have more valuable jobs maybe they work a little bit harder now
  208. they're like you know it means nothing right and so then they end up getting and quitting and then you actually lose
  209. some of your best workers because they don't feel they're being rewarded for their value and so you can see how this
  210. fluctuation changes dramatically and so by understanding social comparisons we can we can motivate people sometimes but
  211. we can also sort of undermine them incredibly well without without Our intention now in this book I mean it's a
  212. lot about accepting the inevitable of that you know we're going to make social comparisons we're probably going to be
  213. labeled or we're going to label other people or sometimes people are going to be deceptive in negotiations and
  214. sometimes we ourselves might be deceptive in negotiations so I mean when you're entering into a relationship with
  215. someone just as kind of a final question I mean are there certain sort of taking
  216. stock questions that you can ask when entering into a new relationship to kind of assess this and figure out what the
  217. dynamic is and how the dynamic might change and I mean I think you know the question that you're going to want to
  218. ask at the beginning of a relationship also in the middle you know it's like how do I find the right balance right
  219. between these forces how do I recognize what are the competitive forces and what
  220. are the Cooperative opportunities you know is one way to think about it and I love this one example that I that I've
  221. often taught in class a guy named John Clint Denon who got hired um right out of Harvard NBA at Xerox and he got a job
  222. that the person just below him had really wanted to get his name was Tom gunning you know he was gunning for that
  223. job right and John talks about how do I start off with this relationship right we're going to be co-workers you know
  224. anytime we walk into a job we're going like how am I going to preserve that right balance between these forces and
  225. he said the first thing I did is I didn't invite him for a first meeting into my office CU he's going to be
  226. thinking this should be my office right it's going to make him competitive I didn't invade his office maybe you know
  227. as another way of power play I found out what his favorite restaurant was and I invited him out to lunch to show a
  228. little thing and the first thing I said to him was like I need you and the reason why I need you is you know lots
  229. of people at Zer I'm new here right you can really help give me the lay of the land and you probably need me too right
  230. you didn't get the promotion that you wanted and maybe I can help you get the next promotion but then he you know to
  231. make sure that it's the right balance he's like and if you're not the person that can help me I can find someone else
  232. right so it wasn't just all hugs and kisses it was a little bit to like you know we're there's a there's a tension
  233. here and it's just a great example of saying we can work together but I'm not going to be exploited by you but I'm
  234. also not going to exploit you either you know and so just recognizing I think that example is a is a really great one
  235. well I think it's important yeah this idea of you know getting off on the right foot is exactly exactly right
  236. there we need to think about this balance and I think often it's you know start stting cooperatively but also you
  237. know recognizing that that tension in many relationships we often come to a place
  238. where we violated somebody's expectations so we can think about how to rebuild a relationship and and we
  239. talk about an example from uh Baptist Hospital in Florida where there was a tragic medical error uh there was a very
  240. young child who had uh who's breathing to had been disconnected uh during a scan and because of that error suffered
  241. severe brain damage now what's interesting about this case after this tragedy the hospital
  242. staff took actions to repair that relationship they were very candid they were quick they they apologized
  243. immediately and they took actions to change things at the hospital they ended up bringing this family
  244. in to become advocates for the h the hospital and the parents talked about how these changes were dramatic how
  245. they're committed to making sure this never happened again they ended up transforming what would be an adversary
  246. into an ally and there a couple of interesting things about this first there are specific steps that they
  247. followed to transform this relationship but second these steps had been instituted at a policy level from the
  248. head Administration so that is they had instituted steps to transform these relationships and they were informed by
  249. by research that is the the steps they followed um had a very predictable outcome and so I think there's a
  250. predictability to how we can transform our relationships to really transform foes into friends and find and find our
  251. balance yeah and and I think you know what Maurice said I think really captures um I think the the essence of
  252. the book whether it's you know the beginning of relationship whether it's in the middle of relationship just again
  253. asking your your yourself a couple questions one is have I found the right balance between cooperation competition
  254. um what do they need getting back to perspec taking but also what do I need we're most successful when our needs are
  255. being met and your needs are being met simultaneously um are there areas where I could be exploited right but are there
  256. opportunities to make a connection and cooperation and so if we periodically ask ourselves that question
  257. sometimes the beginning of the relationship sometime it's after a violation has occurred sometimes it's
  258. just maybe we think the relationship is sort of you know not humming along as well as it could um it gives us those
  259. opportunities and that's whether we're parent thinking about child or their spouse thinking about our partner
  260. whether a friend thinking about a friend whether a colleague thinking about another colleague a boss thinking of
  261. employee and vice versa asking ourselves these questions are just going to give us so much more control so much more
  262. balance balance and they're going to make us so much more successful in [Music] life

Brief Summary

Professors discuss their book on balancing competition and cooperation in relationships, with practical insights for personal and professional contexts.

Key points

  • Friend and Foe: A New Perspective. A new book suggests we view relationships as both competitive and cooperative.
  • The Tension of Relationships. Relationships are complex, involving both competition and cooperation.
  • Scarcity and Social Dynamics. Scarcity can change social relationships, as seen in siblings and zebras.
  • Finding Balance in Relationships. The key to successful relationships is recognizing the balance between cooperation and competition.
  • The Importance of Social Comparisons. Understanding how social comparisons affect motivation and satisfaction in the workplace.
  • Transforming Relationships After Conflict. A hospital's response to a tragic error shows how to turn adversaries into allies.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes