Why Boards Must Be Active In Managing Risk

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

πŸ“‚ Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Fundamentally what we're looking at is whether board oversight of risk management actually makes any difference
  2. at all. I mean, there's been big push for risk management given the financial crisis and many other things including
  3. the economy now. And so uh institutional investor companies uh regulators have been pushing boards to
  4. do more board oversight of risk management. The question is is it real or is it just window dressing? Do you
  5. just see companies putting this in because this is what everybody wants? So what we're looking at, does it really
  6. make a difference how board does risk oversight? Does it have an impact on the risk management practices of the
  7. companies? And ultimately does it pay off? Do firms have lower risks when they have more board oversight and higher
  8. stock returns? Well, one important thing is it really matters who is responsible on the board for risk
  9. management. There's a lot of controversy right now in terms of should it be the board as a whole? Should you have a
  10. committee like the audit committee responsible for this? Should you set up a separate risk management committee?
  11. And various uh regulators groups have taken different stances on this. If you're a member of the New York Stock
  12. Exchange, your audit committee is required to do board risk oversight. The Australian Stock Exchange is
  13. completely different. They say the entire board should be responsible for board oversight. And the financial
  14. institutions, a lot of them are required to have a separate risk committee. So one big issue was, okay, does it really
  15. matter where you put this? And it turns out it matters a lot. You better have the entire board responsible instead of
  16. delegating this to something like an audit or a risk committee. And something really interesting was even if you have
  17. a separate risk committee, seemed to have zero impact overall in terms of what the company does in terms of risk
  18. management practices and performance. So there is an instance where it does look
  19. like it may be window dressing. Boards are putting this in, they're setting up separate risk committees to
  20. look like you know, we're paying a lot of attention to enterprise risk management, but in truth it really does
  21. not look like it makes all that much difference if you do that as opposed to using existing board structures.
  22. I guess some of it was just pure descriptive statistics cuz we did this this was a survey of companies that we
  23. did in conjunction with Aon, the big insurance broker. And one of one of the interesting things
  24. was how informal a lot of the discussions between the board and the top management are in
  25. terms of risk management. You would think these days companies would make these much more formal and tame in terms
  26. of things like risk appetite. How much risk are we really willing to take on? Cuz the idea of risk management is not
  27. get rid of risk. Do it within your risk appetite. And risk tolerance, how much variability am I willing to take on
  28. this? And you just look at the survey responses. These are people admitting that well, if we do it, it's very
  29. informal. And we found this very surprising given the atmosphere now that you would think boards would much more
  30. formal in trying to figure out what is the risk appetite we want to go after and what kind of tolerances, how much
  31. variability are we willing to accept once we've done this. But it's very very informal.
  32. Again, one of the big things is who is going to be responsible. You really have to set in your charter having the whole
  33. board responsible. Now you may decide that certain types of risks are handled by different committees. So obviously
  34. financial risks are generally audit committee. But you might have other risk go to other committees where the
  35. expertise is, but overall the board has to be responsible. This is not something
  36. you can delegate. The other thing is you have to have much better communication between the board
  37. and your senior management. Because what we found out is if the only time that you actually talk to senior management
  38. about risk practices is during the annual or quarterly board meetings, it's very detrimental. You really have to
  39. have these discussions outside the board meetings and an ongoing review of what is our risk appetite and what is our
  40. risk tolerance. You need to hire risk expert. Somebody who's an expertise. Once you've
  41. identified here are our key risks, you need to have somebody on the board. And this is part of the problem with
  42. delegating it to a committee. Right, the audit committee, which is generally the committee that's
  43. responsible, their expertise at financial risks. Credit risk, market risks, you know, we're going to use
  44. derivatives or not use derivatives. They know almost nothing about cybersecurity.
  45. And that's where you're seeing the big push that once the board kind of spends time figuring out where our issues are,
  46. maybe that's when you need expertise there. That you can't expect to just take existing board members to know much
  47. about this stuff. If nothing else, get have them figure out who is the risk expert
  48. they're going to hire within the firm and enhance the communications that go on even if you don't have somebody on
  49. the board specifically who has that expertise. I think one of the big issues is risk is a responsibility of the audit
  50. committee. And and it's all an issue of that's where traditionally risk is. We've
  51. always thought of financial risks in the companies. It's not that companies don't
  52. think about risks, but it's always been financial risk, credit risk that people have worried
  53. about. I'm in an accounting department. Let me tell you, finance and accounting people
  54. are not experts at any kind of risk outside financial risks. So putting it there, which is the requirement of the
  55. New York Stock Exchange listing is the board audit committee will have board oversight over risk. It's just not
  56. right. It and especially as you pointed out, as you expand the number of risks we're facing or at least recognize them
  57. even if we've had them in the past, this notion that it should be the board audit committee cuz they've always done
  58. risk is not right. They've always done financial risks. They just do not have the expertise outside there.
  59. What people generally have looked at is there some association between some overall risk management index or score
  60. and things like firm variability in stock price. We're really trying to say, okay, what
  61. are the mechanisms here? Right, if I'm a manager just saying, okay, I should have
  62. better risk management really is not going to help you much. What I want to know is how do I organize my firm? And
  63. the reason we start at the board is the whole notion that the tone is always set
  64. at the top. Forget about worrying about how I do individual risk management. You
  65. know, the first thing you got to do is get the whole company on board. And it's got to start with the board of
  66. directors. And that's very different than what other people have done because until you could say, well, what's the
  67. mechanism I have to put in place to make sure that we put risk management as a strategic issue in the firm,
  68. there's no point. There there are requirements in the United States and other countries where
  69. there's actually board performance evaluation. Very few people actually realize this, but you're supposed to
  70. evaluate the performance of your own board. And part of it is actually putting responsibility for risk management
  71. practices and board oversight into the performance evaluation on this. And what we actually did find in our results that
  72. companies that actually one, they do performance evaluations of their boards, and two, they incorporate risk
  73. management responsibilities in the evaluation, actually were the ones who put in better risk management practices.
  74. So again, incentives and accountability are key. Not just looking at the managers in your firm, but also looking
  75. at the board, you know, and lining getting their incentives aligned with risk management.
  76. Well, part of what we're looking at is when you look at what's the objective of risk management in your company, how
  77. does it that impact which practices you're going to put in and what the implications are? Because one simple way
  78. to think about risk management is all we're trying to do is avoid risks or at least mitigate them if they happen.
  79. That's only looking at the downside of risk. But if you really believe that there's a risk-return tradeoff, which is
  80. the only way to make higher returns is to get to have take on more risk. You can also use risk management to
  81. increase the value of the firm. Let's take on the right risks. Let's figure out where I have multiple risks in the
  82. firm, how they interact with each other such that I don't take one that has a big impact on somewhere else. So when
  83. you take companies that really see it risk management as a value-enhancing objective as opposed to just a cost
  84. minimization or avoid a problem, how does that impact the practices you actually put in and which ones are more
  85. effective? And ultimately how does that impact firm performance? And some of our
  86. initial results suggest that it makes a huge difference. The firms that that have looked at this as a value-enhancing
  87. objective as opposed to just minimize a cost or avoid the downside, are really the ones those are the only firms really
  88. that are seeing any kind of real financial gain as opposed to just minimizing costs from enterprise risk
  89. management practices.

Brief Summary

Board oversight of risk management impacts company performance, emphasizing the need for full board involvement and better communication with management.

Key points

  • The Importance of Board Oversight. Does board oversight of risk management truly impact company performance?
  • Who Should Manage Risk?. The debate on whether risk management should be handled by the entire board or a committee.
  • Window Dressing in Risk Management. Are companies just creating risk committees for appearances?
  • Understanding Risk Appetite. Risk management should align with a company's risk appetite, not eliminate risk.
  • Evaluating Board Performance. Companies that evaluate board performance see better risk management practices.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes