The Real Reason Your Multinational Team Has Trouble Communicating

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

When you work for a multinational business, you often have to share information with co-workers around the world. But that frequently doesn't work as well as it could. More: http://knlg.net/1XQODbw πŸ“‚ Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. yeah so This research was really motivated by the idea that multinationals as we know it's a fact
  2. use lots and lots of teams right to get their work done but multinational teams struggle to really succeed um and we
  3. know that is a big problem um in these in lots of organizations so one of the big things they really struggle with is
  4. you've got people all around the world people don't share their information their knowledge enough with each other
  5. as much as they could right so we're trying to figure out why is that and what are some of the problems that these
  6. teams face and how can they be overcome so the particular focus of this study is
  7. on the fact that these teams are so diverse right so when you've got a multinational team it has people we talk
  8. about four different kinds of diversity we've got people from different Geographic locations all different
  9. countries around the world we've got people of different nationalities we've got people who work in different parts
  10. of their organizations right different um parts of the organizational structure we call them structural differences so
  11. people who work in different divisions or business units or functional areas and people are demographically diverse
  12. some people are older than others some people have been in the organization longer than other so lots of different
  13. kinds of differences so the question that we focus on in this um particular research is which of these differences
  14. actually matter for sharing knowledge in these teams and moreover which of them matter most um so that's the real focus
  15. of the study that's the research question and to address it what we did is we um collected survey data original
  16. survey data from U more than 2,000 members of around 289 teams so almost 200 0 teams in one very very large
  17. multinational it's a very well-known multinational organization more than 100,000 employees around the world and
  18. we collected data on all the differences between the members of these teams and we um did a lot of research to
  19. understand which differences matter most um and also how might they be overcome and in particular we looked at whether
  20. the people knew each other and had worked together before as one of the things that might help them to overcome
  21. those kinds of differences so again the the real question is which differences matter
  22. most so we're looking at these four kinds of differences Geographic uh um nationality based structural differences
  23. working different parts of the organizational structure and demographic differences and what we found was that
  24. two of these kinds of differences mattered much more than the other two and in particular Geographic differences
  25. really mattered so working in different countries um and uh structural differences mattered so working in
  26. different parts of the organizational structure and when I say they mattered it means they created barriers to
  27. knowledge seeking within this team for people going and asking each other for help or for information related to their
  28. work nationality differences um and demographic differences also mattered they also created barriers between the
  29. team members but not so big so the ones that were really big were the geographic
  30. differences and the structural differences and they created the greatest barriers but the good news was
  31. that if you'd work together before in a team so we're looking at sort of the diads of pairs of people within the team
  32. if you'd work together before you could get over some to some extent those Geographic and structural barriers so
  33. those were the key findings I think probably the most striking finding and it kind of emerged really
  34. early on as we were looking at at the data here um was the importance of structural differences organizational
  35. structure so when you think about uh multinational teams you know there's a lot of attention on the fact that people
  36. work in different parts of the world and their different nationalities um but you
  37. know we know that this is true we just don't think about it multinational teams so much these people are also coming
  38. from different parts of the organization usually and we found this was a really strong to some extent the strongest um
  39. barrier so the fact that people worked in different divisions in the organization or different functional
  40. areas or different business units again it was a huge complex organization those
  41. were really problematic um for those those kinds of uh differences were really problematic for the members of
  42. those teams and I think that was the most surprising to us given that the focus is usually on the nationality and
  43. the geographic stuff I think part of it is um recognizing the real variety of differences that there are right and I
  44. think you know we tend to focus a lot on specific ones like we know that the fact
  45. that we're in different time zones is really a big problem right and that's part of different Geographic locations
  46. um we know that the fact that people speak different languages is a big deal right and so managers tend to focus on
  47. some of these most obvious things that are really Salient when you're when you're internationally um dispersed um
  48. but the structural stuff for example which we found to be you know surprisingly important um we don't think
  49. about as much in in a global team so I think for managers it's being really aware that there's a very wide variety
  50. of differences that you need to pay attention to and monitor if you really want people to be sharing knowledge as
  51. much as they could be um inside the teams again on the plus side um for managers though if you've got people who
  52. worked together before that can help right so when managers are composing their teams it suggests that really
  53. paying attention to that we know there's lots of good things about people um having worked together in the past but
  54. often we don't put people that worked together in the past because we're trying to you know get the best team for
  55. that particular project we tend to downplay that criteria but I think managers um you know could benefit a lot
  56. the research suggested they could benefit a lot from really paying attention to trying to get people um who
  57. know each other a little bit already I think probably the uh most important one and there is one in particular I
  58. think is that nationality is not so important in our findings um at least then again it's not that nationality
  59. differences don't matter also nationality being where you were born where you come from as well as your
  60. native language right and they do create those kinds of differences we come from
  61. different countries originally that creates a barrier to knowledge seeking between us but what we is a much less
  62. important barrier than the fact that we may be in different countries um so if we're in the same country and we're
  63. different nationalities it's actually not a very big deal if we're in different countries even if we're the
  64. same nationality that's a big deal um so you know there's a lot of attention again on multinational teams we tend to
  65. focus a lot on these kind of crosscultural differences and and and nationality based differences in fact
  66. our research suggests if you compare them to other kinds of differences they they matter but not as much as some of
  67. this other stuff in terms of geography or organizational structure seems to matter more
  68. so most of the research in this area is a lot of research on teams um there and there's some research not as much
  69. obviously on multinational teams most of the research tends to focus on one or two kinds of differences right so most
  70. of that research will say nationality differences matter look we find it matters or Geographic differences a lot
  71. of research on geographically dispersed teams right that matters but um I'm not aware of any studies really that have
  72. pulled together as many different kinds of differences and said well if you look
  73. at them all together we agree they all matter we find they all do matter and actually create barriers within teams um
  74. but look some of them matter quite a bit more than others when you're able to compare them side by side so I think
  75. that's one of the things that's probably most distinctive in terms of what our study has been able to do uh the other
  76. aspect of it is that we have a large sample of teams um that we're able to compare so around 290 teams 20,000 you
  77. know team members and we're looking at all the individual uh you know the pairs within those teams so that's a much
  78. larger and richer data set with lots of different differ is going on in there than then the prior research has has
  79. often tackled uh so my co-author Jonathan Cummings and I um both do a lot of research related to uh teams in large
  80. complex organizations like large multinationals um and collaboration more generally across these kinds of
  81. organizations uh so you know one of the things that I'm most interested in is what are the conditions that enable
  82. teams to be more effective right and in this case particularly multinational teams
  83. so certainly thinking about uh you know teams do have these kinds of differences
  84. usually we can't make those go away right so what are the conditions that can help those teams to be more
  85. successful and not just in terms of being able to share knowledge effectively but also you know what makes
  86. them more Innovative um what makes them you know more efficient or more able to implement um their their projects or
  87. their programs successfully so that's where the main focus is of this work going forward
  88. [Music]

Brief Summary

Multinational teams struggle with knowledge sharing due to geographic and structural differences, not just nationality.

Key points

  • The Struggles of Multinational Teams. Multinational teams face significant challenges in knowledge sharing due to diversity.
  • Key Findings on Team Diversity. Geographic and structural differences create the greatest barriers to knowledge sharing.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

More from Knowledge at Wharton