How Amex Turns Transactions Into Marketing Insights
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE What if marketers could connect an offer or ad directly to a verified purchase?
Jacob King, Senior Vice President of Amex Offers & Digital Media at American Express, explains how Amex is using transaction data to help brands deliver more relevant marketing and measure real business results.
King discusses personalized offers, the rise of commerce media, how brands can reach customers at key moments in their journey, and why trust will be essential as AI agents begin to make purchases on consumers’ behalf.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Marketing Matters is hosted by Wharton marketing professors Barbara Kahn and Americus Reed. Each week they discuss marketing and advertising trends, consumer behavior, data and analytics, the latest in retail marketing, brand-building, and much more with their expert guests. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- One of the big things we think about American Express is it's not just a payments
- platform, not just a credit card, it is a lifestyle brand. We're creating engagement and we're building lifetime loyalty
- and we're building membership. Hello and welcome. You're listening to Marketing Matters on the Wharton
- Podcast Network. This is our weekly podcast where we analyze the latest in advertising, marketing, customer behavior, new
- product launches, branding, retailing, everything marketing. I'm Barbara Kahn, the Patty and J.H.
- Baker Professor of Marketing, and I'm joined by my co-host, Americas Reid, the Whitney M.
- Young Jr. Professor of Marketing and the Identity Theorist. And today we're joined by, with, we're joined
- with Jake King, who's the Senior Vice President and he's the head of Amex Offers Digital
- Media. He has spent more than a decade at American Express and he leads the company's digital
- advertising and commerce media initiatives. So with that job, he helps brands connect
- with Amex's premium card members by helping them provide relevant, measurable offers and experiences.
- Jake, welcome to our show. Thank you for being here. Thanks for having me. So you've been at American Express for over
- a decade. I imagine you've seen a lot of changes over that time. Any kind of big takeaways at Amex?
- Yeah, I have been here. I think I just celebrated 11 years at the company. That has been through a lot of changes,
- a lot of interesting sort of things. I started my career actually, or started my
- time at American Express on this, this little known loyalty coalition program that was short-lived
- for American Express called Plenty, and I did that for a few years. And then we shut that down.
- It wasn't the right business model for us. And then worked within our merchant services business,
- looking after data marketing. And that's what then led me to Amex Offers, which I took over in 2022.
- And at that time, Amex Offers was a decade-old card linked offers program. It was probably by most measures, one of
- the largest in the industry. And I was very happy to sort of take that on. My bread and butter, my love and my
- passion is like performance marketing and sort of card linked and sort of loyalty programs.
- And so it was cool to take that on. And then in about 2022, 2023, we had this idea of, can we expand beyond that
- and think about things even beyond offers into media? And at the time, there was a bit
- of an explosion in media networks. And so all the cards sort of aligned. And we decided to build out a media
- network on top of the offers business. Well, that's interesting that you call it a
- media network. I mean, I think of them as retail media networks, but essentially you're doing the same
- thing. You're a platform where you have access to the data. And because you have access to the end
- user data, you can provide these really personalized experiences. And so what what's been your experience on
- what kinds of unusual activity you can do with that data for your for your customers,
- which I assume are the brands? Yeah, absolutely. Well, actually, we think about our our customers
- on both sides. So one of the things that's unique about American Express is we are a closed loop
- network. We have all of our card members, which so we are an issuer. We issue the cards.
- As many people know, you can carry around an Amex Platinum card or you can carry
- those sorts of things. So we are the issuer. And so all of that card member data,
- those are our card members or our customers. But we also are an acquirer and a network.
- So we kind of do all three pieces in the ecosystem. So American Express is a network similar to
- MasterCard and Visa. We are an issuer similar to Chase or Citi. And then we're also an acquirer that's similar
- to other players in the space like like WorldPay, FIS and other players. But we actually do all of that together,
- which is kind of an interesting space for us to be in. So it's a complete closed loop environment where
- we own everything sort of beginning to end. And Barbara, to your point around customers, we
- actually view both sides of that equation as our customers. So both the card member, which we which
- we hold very dear, like they're very precious to us. That is the sort of lifeblood of this
- organization, of this organization. But then at the same time, it's then all the what we refer to as merchants
- or those that, you know, places where you can spend on your card that are also our customers.
- And to your point, in my case, my customers, my clients are the merchants or the
- advertisers who want to get in front of our card members or our joint customers.
- So can you give us an example of the kind of experience you can provide? Like, because it does seem like you have
- very interesting data, but like, what do you do with it? Like, how do you get this personalized experience?
- So let me start with the Amex offers program, which has been around since 2012. So in the industry, referred to as card
- linked offers, CLO, like there's a lot of banks that kind of play in this space.
- If you guys are ever redeeming those sort of offers, you know, you enroll, you see
- them inside of your your your app experience, you enroll in them and then you go
- and spend. And we as American Express, we qualify all that transaction and then we give the redemption
- and then we charge back the merchants accordingly. And so a little bit to your point,
- one of the things that's kind of cool and unique about Amex offers is I can see all of the data holistically.
- So when when advertisers come to us and they're like, hey, I want to target and I want to go after net new customers
- to me. But people that maybe have shopped in the industry and maybe could have other factors turn
- turn geographic areas or like we're limited to those any of those sorts of things.
- I have that wealth of data at my fingertips. I can see all of that information. And so we can build out a targeting
- plan for a for a merchant that is very specific to their needs. And in fact, Barbara Americus, a lot of
- times what we do is you sit down and you say, well, what's your objective? Well, I want new customers.
- OK, great. We'll find people who have never shopped with you before. I want to grow with my existing customers.
- OK, great. So you're looking for either more trips from them or more spend when they come and
- see you. And we can build out sort of offer programs that are very tailored and targeted to
- those specific sort of user groups and those and those segments. And then all that together makes up makes
- up a campaign. And so that's like sort of the offers side when we've expanded into the advertising world.
- This actually has created some new interesting signals in our data. So we also you know, you may or
- may not know, but we are one of the largest online travel agencies. We have American Express Travel dot com for
- all of our card members. We own Resi, which is a dining reservation platform that is also part of the ecosystem.
- And so when it gets to our advertising network, what's kind of cool about that is
- now I have all of that spend data that we talked about on the offer side. But I also have signals like, are you
- booking travel on our travel website? Did you just make a reservation at a restaurant in the New York City area?
- All of those particular pieces are now at my fingertips to potentially build out segments or
- audiences for our advertisers to get in front of. So let me let me just put my framework on it.
- And you tell me, yes, it sounds like the first bucket of stuff you were talking about.
- I would talk about that is maximizing customer lifetime value. So and the way you might maximize customer
- value lifetime that is like reducing acquisition costs, increasing frequency in spend, increasing retention.
- And you told me you kind of have all of that. And when the merchant comes to you with
- one of those goals like I want to get, you know, one more purchase a year or something like that, you can feed up
- that data. But then you also have where these customers are in their customer journey.
- So, for example, if they're about to book a travel or they're about to do this or that, you know that they've been doing
- that kind of stuff or they're a frequent traveler or something like that. I'm assuming is that am I using the
- right terms to describe what you're talking about, like maximizing LV in one case?
- And where are we in the journey? And we're going to link all of that together to give you the best chance to
- make your campaign work. Yeah, you're you're spot on. I'll give you a real life example.
- So when we were building out this advertising network, we actually started with display ads on
- our travel website. So literally on American Express Travel dot com. And when we obviously have a bunch of
- great partners and a bunch of great relationships, you know, we have co-brand deals where
- we have relations. And one of the those co-brand relationships is with Marriott.
- And so we were working with Marriott. And Marriott also has several hotels in an
- exclusive program offered by American Express called Fine Hotels and Resorts FHNR.
- And so there's certain properties that are part of that program. And so when Marriott came to us, they
- said, look, what we want to do is we want to target people who have already booked an airline ticket, let's say to Miami,
- but they have not yet booked their hotel. And we also know they have an affinity
- for spending at FHNR or Fine Hotels and Resorts properties. And then we want to target a specific
- property in the Miami area. And so they literally gave us some creative and we loaded we loaded those segments and
- those audiences on our site so that when somebody came on, they actually then could we
- could find those audiences of somebody who's booked airline travel, not booked a hotel and might
- be interested in fine hotels and resorts properties. Oh, that's that's like in like you have
- a window that's short for that. You got to get them exactly the right time, right?
- Yes. I mean, and we did lots of campaigns like some of them are our brand awareness.
- They want people to be, you know, be familiar with J.W. Marriott or like the Ritz-Carlton.
- And that's more of a brand wide campaign. And, you know, we're obviously measuring things like
- brand recall and those sorts of measurement metrics all the way down to a specific property
- where they have either sometimes they've launched something new or something or they just want to
- focus on a specific area. And then we can get all the way down to down bottom of funnel.
- So we have top of funnel, but we also have bottom of funnel where we're saying, OK, did we actually drive a transaction or
- a spend or a booking at that specific hotel and location? And we we do the myriad of all
- of those things with our with our partners. That's amazing. That's like so textbook.
- It's like so perfect that you can execute right to these precise ideas. So thinking about this, like how how do
- you execute it then? So like, how do you what's the mechanism that you get these out to the consumer?
- Is it on an app or is it an email or like? Yeah. So we we have a series of display
- advertising placements across our owned and operated property. So, again, that would be the likes of
- AmexTravel.com, the Rezzy, the Rezzy app, our Amex app and website. And so what we do is, you know,
- and again, part of this beauty of this closed loop that I mentioned earlier is we
- can one of the things that American Express takes a lot of pride in. We've been around for 176 years and we
- feel that our you know, we've got the back of our customers and trust and safety
- is an important component of our pillar of our of our brand. And so one of the things that's really
- important about this and I'll make a compare and contrast, but you can today you can
- go into a DSP demand side platform. You can sort of buy audiences. You can put up advertising in front of
- them. And there's a little control in terms of what's kind of happening, who's seeing what and
- all those sorts of things. And one of the things that's really important to us is one that I'm putting brands
- that are very relevant to my customer, to the card members in front of them. So it's finding those right audiences and in
- those contextually relevant moments, Barbara, like you were talking about. But then also for the advertiser themselves, they
- want to know that it's brand safe, like they want to know what they're sort of what they're surrounded by, what else is going
- on. And in that case, we know that we can say, hey, you're showing up in our travel experience when you know people are coming
- on to discover, get inspiration and ultimately book a travel experience. And so it's really creating this brand safe
- environment for advertisers and our card members to feel like, you know, they're they're sort of
- protected. And we take data privacy very seriously. And so one of the things that this
- kind of closed loop environment of owned and operated does is we own the data from
- beginning to end. We don't we aren't shipping it out anywhere. We aren't doing anything.
- So all of it is sort of contained within our ecosystem. So to your question, Barbara, we we take
- the ad creatives, we set up. We understand their objectives. We set up a myriad of campaigns.
- We take their creatives. We set up those audiences in our environment. And then as you visit, you know, Amex
- Travel, if you meet the criteria of one of those audiences, then we in real time
- serve that ad creative to you. And so we can capture that information. So then we can like you're going looking
- for a restaurant or you're going to look to make travel. You're going to go on to an Amex
- site or Amex owned site like Resi or something like that. And then you're going to serve up the
- the targeted creative messaging. Yes, person at that point in their journey with their background, with the goal that, you
- know, brand awareness or increased spend or whatever it is, and that's going to hit you.
- But the customer has to opt into it. They have to opt into an Amex site, right? A travel site or.
- Correct. Are you mostly in hospitality and travel then? Is that most of what your stuff is
- about? So what I would say is we have owned and operated properties in travel and dining,
- but we also have the American Express app. And so, you know, people are coming in
- all the time to look at their benefits, check, you know, their statements, you know, pay
- their bill clearly. Are you advertised there? Yes, we advertise there as well. And so what I would say is, you
- know, we are constantly building out our products. Like let's I'll take the platinum card as
- an example. We recently refreshed the platinum card in at the end of last year, Q4 of last
- year. And on that card, you get certain benefits like there's a Lululemon credit.
- So, you know, you get a Lululemon, you get a Resi credit, you get some fine hotels and resorts credit.
- You also get, you know, membership rewards points for travel and sort of dining.
- And so there's also a streaming credit for like some streaming services. So it's really a lifestyle.
- One of the big things we think about American Express is it's not just a payments
- platform, not just a credit card. It is a lifestyle brand. And so it's really about how we're catering
- to the lifestyles of our card members from sort of beginning to end. So that's the ecosystem.
- And then on top of that, to where you were going, is then we have people coming in that are, you know, looking for
- luxury shopping experiences. We've run a bunch of advertising with Louis Vuitton as an example, who's a big advertiser
- in our ecosystem, because they know that our platinum card members or our centurion card members
- love to buy Louis Vuitton or love to buy luxury goods. And so there's an opportunity for them to
- get in front of those audiences in matters that the moments that really matter to them
- and in these contextually relevant journeys. I'm sorry, just to I want to understand
- a bit more about this, the offers piece, because I have a friend who is a member of the platinum card, and I am
- amazed at how they are able to demonstrate to me how much how much they I think the card, I don't remember the annual
- fee, but it's like three hundred dollars or something like it's it's not trivial.
- But the stuff that they were able to get back was like outpaid by five X. And I was just it struck me as
- like, you probably don't want this type of person, this exact type of person to always
- be the person that's, you know, that's that's in the car. You kind of want the person that made
- is not true, but the person that is like maximizing all of the benefits. Are you losing money on them or no?
- No. So so that's part of the part of the program for us. Right. Is that we're creating engagement and we're building
- lifetime loyalty and we're building membership. And so the the platinum card you referred
- to, actually, the fee is 895. So a little bit more than that. But you're going to get you are making
- money. Wow. But as we advertise, you can get more than thirty five hundred dollars worth of value
- out of that card. Yeah. And that's not even adding in the MX offers program, which is the program that I
- run, which is over and above those numbers. And so to your point, there's a mix.
- America's there's a mix of what's funded by American Express and what's funded by partners of
- ours. So there's always a mix in terms of where the funding sort of comes from. And then additionally, you know, our our business
- model is built on, you know, this concept of what we think is more of like kind of subscription like services fees.
- So you've got that annual fee. You also have the spend. We the discount revenue link to the to
- the spend on the card. And then there's obviously things like lend and whatnot on the card.
- And so that entire ecosystem, you know, we're looking at all of that. But actually, we actually encourage our card members.
- One of the things that some of our competitors do is is can sometimes make it a little bit difficult to redeem some of
- these some of these things. And we've created quite the digital experience. When you're onboarding to a new card, we
- get you enrolled in all these benefits right away so that you know how to take care of I take advantage of the Lululemon
- benefit, how to use your resi credit, how to use all those things, because for us,
- that is all about sort of the engagement and the lifetime loyalty of the program.
- But what America said is interesting, because I know looking at loyalty data that it follows
- this 80-20 law, which says like 20 percent of your best customers are going to generate 80 percent of your revenues or profits.
- And then there's going to be a whole lot of people that don't generate as much. That's what Americas was talking, throwing this friend
- right under the bus. But anyway, he was suggesting maybe there are some people that just take it.
- But the thing is, you're more sophisticated than that, it sounds like, because you know a
- lot about the customers you're offering these deals to. And so you're going to offer the kinds
- of deals that will try to be mutually beneficial to your merchants and to yourself.
- So I suspect you're not offering every single customer the exact same deal, that you're making
- more personalized based on things you know about the customers. We do personalize.
- We do a mix of things. One really interesting thing we did just recently, we launched it in July of this year,
- but we did a set of limited time offers that were geared towards our platinum cardholders.
- So this was a bundle of brands that included Nordstrom and included Eight Sleep and included
- Perplexity, Bose, Tumi. It was a myriad of like sort of retail and like LLM or, you know, that
- that sort of space kind of together services. And what the and all of that is merchant funded.
- Right. All that is funded by our partners. And they want to be part of this program.
- Wow. To get exposure to our to our customers. Right. And so and so what they get out
- of it is they get spend. They get net new customers or they get incremental spend from their existing customers, Barbara, some
- of the stuff you were talking about earlier. They're earning one more trip or one more
- dollar or whatever. So and our card members tend to be more loyal. They tend to on average, they spend three
- times more than those on other networks. And so we have a very valuable card member base.
- And so we launched that. And actually, some of those offers are still alive. The Nordstrom offer runs actually through the holiday
- season, through through the end of the year. And so it's about bringing this value that
- we know that our card members are interested in and putting in front of them. And but to to your point around the
- mix and match so that that myriad of brands that I mentioned, that was not by accident.
- So there was some deliberate selection around saying, oh, well, we want some, you know, some
- department store, luxury retail. We've got some luggage in here. We've got some services like HBO and perplexity.
- We've got, you know, some the Eight Sleep is a very luxury sort of betting company.
- So you have a mix. And so the idea is, is that you may not you may not find all of
- them relevant to you, but you'll find one or two of them relevant to you. And those are the folks that both our
- merchants want and those who we want sort of engaging in our ecosystem. Interesting.
- Quick question for you, Jake. This I mean, to Barbara's earlier point, I mean, it's fascinating how bespoke it seems that
- you're able to get in the context of the ecosystem because of what Barbara was saying
- with respect to so much data that you have. I'm wondering, like as you test and learn,
- can you tell us about some things that I want to call these mistakes, but I want to call them like key learnings that
- where you where you tried to do something in an initiative, an ecosystem, and it didn't
- work. But you learn something that might be interesting in terms of, you know, how we understand
- creating customer experiences from large scale data. So, yeah, I'll give you one example.
- This dates back a few years, but one of the things and actually it's a little bit of why we sort of built the
- advertising ecosystem. So in the CardLink to Offer space, one of the things I mentioned earlier is that
- we sort of control the ecosystem beginning to end. So if you Americas, you come and spend
- that transaction qualifies for you enrolled in an offer and that was a spend 100, get
- $20. If that transaction qualifies, you spent more than $100. Then we issue the credit of the $20.
- And then we go back and we take that money from from the merchant and we sort of settle up and and talk about
- like incremental spend and what we've done for them. A few years ago, though, we had tested
- out some ideas where we actually let the merchant themselves do the fulfillment.
- So the idea was, is that instead of us doing the qualification of fulfillment, we would
- actually drive to their site and then they would be responsible to make sure that the
- card member or their customer in that case sort of gained the reward. And what we learned out of that was
- that if a customer doesn't get what they want, do you know who they call? They call us.
- You know, we're known for our customer service. We're known. We're known to be, you know, putting our
- card members first in that experience. And so there are cases nobody's nothing malicious,
- but you have cases where something was missed. The the merchant or the advertiser, you know,
- something didn't fire in their system, whatever the case may be. But those card members are then calling us
- and saying, where's where's sort of my reward? But your responsibility. Yeah, it's a hit to the ram, perhaps.
- Yeah. And so and we want and we always want to do what's best for our card members.
- We always want to make sure that they're made whole, that everything is sort of done.
- And what we we back up the promises that we make. So if we made a promise to deliver
- on that, we want to make sure that we deliver. And so we we actually stopped doing those.
- We only do offers that in our offers ecosystem that we qualify and fulfill for ourselves
- so that we don't run into this issue. But however, when we we that that one of the things that sort of built out
- was the advertising platform. And so the idea in the space of advertising and Barbara, you mentioned earlier retail media
- networks. And I was going to talk a little bit about like I think they had those
- names because traditionally and when it all started, you know, you got Amazon. You've got the likes of Wal-Mart.
- They were all retailers. Right. And it was all sort of the brands that were being sold.
- But kind of everybody started to expand in this place. You've got travel players in the space.
- You've got not traditional retailers. And in our case, financial services, you know,
- we're not the only ones playing in the space. And so the the name got a sort of coined commerce media networks.
- But the idea is that, you know, you have advertising placements within your owned and operated
- space and they're they're they're labeled, you know, as advertisement. You then direct out to a partner site,
- whatever the case may be. And so that allows us to talk about what an advertiser wants to talk about.
- It may have an offer that they're offering. It may not, but it's not within our our offers ecosystem.
- And so that allows them to talk to the our card members in the way that they want to talk to them.
- And so that was actually sort of born out of this need for advertisers to want to tell lots of messages, not just the
- messages that were linked to the offers program. We only have a minute left and I
- got to ask the question now. So I understand what you're saying. And it totally makes sense.
- These personalized offers in your own commerce media space. And so one of the things everybody's asking
- us and it can't help it. I got to ask you, like, what's the role of generative AI now in this?
- And how has that changed everything you're talking about? Because you're talking about traditional, very well-executed
- marketing, customer journey, CLV, all these things that we've been talking about.
- And now all of a sudden generative AI is in it and everybody's like, changes everything.
- So you have the data to tell us. How have you responded to that? Yeah. So it's a great question.
- I'm I'm I'm glad you asked it. So one, I'll start with saying that we we work with all these players.
- We work. They are, in some cases, merchants of ours. They're partners of ours. They're like so we are working constantly with
- the players in the in the AI space, generally speaking. So that's one. Two, we definitely view this as an opportunity,
- not as a threat to our to to to us and to our ecosystem. And so one of the things that, you
- know, we that you're seeing every day is that and if you're you know, if you're reading the same articles I'm reading, you're saying
- that a huge component of the world of AI is trust. And do you trust what either the agents
- or these brands that are sort of doing for you? And this is and we think the trust
- is going to be so critical to sort of the future of how the role of these things are.
- These LLMs are playing in the ecosystem. And the beauty is a couple of things. One is we have 176 year history of
- building trust with our card members. And we we stand by that trust. So that's that's that's number one.
- Two, we actually launched a an agent registration program called the Ace Framework, where we're essentially
- saying we've actually announced to the public, we've said that if you have an agent, make
- a purchase on your behalf and it's a registered agent with us. And for some reason, the agent messes up.
- We've got your back. We will cover that for you. So we're actually saying, you know, the the
- example that we like to tell is you went on, Barbara, you were on some website and you set up an agent and you
- wanted to you wanted to get a blue dress and, you know, of a certain price point of a certain size.
- And what got shipped to your house was a red dress. And it's like and if we actually look
- and we say, well, the agent actually messed up, it was the agent that actually made
- the wrong decision in terms of making that purchase on your behalf. And then we've got your back with with
- with with those agents if they're registered within our ecosystem, because trust is going to be
- so critical to that particular piece. And then when you think about the advertising
- world, a lot of people are talking about like, you know, is search dead? Like, where is that sort of going?
- And for us, like we're actually working with these players and very closely. I can't talk about it too much now,
- but we're going to be talking about how offers can be actually embedded into these LLM
- experiences. Imagine being able to ask the agent, hey, I'm looking for a pair of shoes and
- it shows you some shoes and then saying, hey, do I have any MX offers for this particular pair of shoes?
- And the agent saying, actually, you do. Would you like me to enroll in this offer for you?
- And so creating experiences where you can actually create those things together is an amazing sort
- of where we think this is going in the in that sort of space. I mean, that's so positive.
- It's win win. Jake King, it's been wonderful talking with you, head of the Amex.
- It's been a pleasure getting to talk to you. And we personally know how secure the Amex
- system is because we could hardly connect. They were so we had to go through. So definitely a brand that can be trusted.
- Thank you. Thank you for your patience. Thank you so much for joining us today. And where can our listeners go to find
- out about all this cool stuff? They can go to the American Express dot com website and then you can click from
- there into the Amex offers Amex offers tab within there. OK, well, thank you very much.
- And thank you so much. Yeah, that's all we have time for today. We'd like to thank our producer, Jacob Grodnick,
- and thank you all for listening. We'll be back soon. Till then, this has been Marketing Matters on
- the Wharton Podcast Network. I'm Barbara Kahn here with America's Read.





