Why Auto Renew Could Be Bad for Business
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Automatic subscription renewals seem like an easy way to guarantee recurring revenue. But they could actually discourage customers from signing up.
Wharton Marketing Professor John Zhang explains the business tradeoffs of auto renew and auto cancellation.
He explores how customer behavior, company size, and market competition influence subscription strategies, and why keeping customers isn't always the same as earning their loyalty.
ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- So many companies have gone to using a subscription model to connect with consumers in the
- last couple of decades. Part of that is the auto-renew. It allows the company to automatically renew a
- customer in a manner that is much less time-consuming. But is auto-renew a good thing for
- your business? We asked that of Wharton Marketing Professor John Zhang. Hi, John.
- How are you? Good to catch up again. Very good. How about you? So good to talk to you again.
- Absolutely. I guess we should start with the fact that auto-renew seems like it is just
- an easy byproduct of the subscription model in general. Like we knew it was going to be
- in here at some point. Well, auto-renew obviously is a huge effective instrument for many companies.
- You can imagine that if you could put people on subscription, then you could do the
- auto-renew and you're going to have a steady revenue coming year after year. Of course, that's what the firms hope to
- do. What do you see as the positives and the negatives of auto-renew? Well, I think the firm ought to realize
- the fact that auto-renew does do something and for consumers in terms of whether or
- not they're going to join the subscription. In fact, auto-renew is an instrument that's
- front-loaded. What I mean by that is that if consumers actually know they have auto-renew, they
- tend to be a whole lot more careful to subscribe to the service. The reason is because they may actually forget
- about the cancellation. So in that case, of course, they're going to be obligated to pay for the things
- that they probably don't use. So in a sense that if you have auto-renew, it will increase the renewal rate
- at the end of the subscription period. But it will reduce the number of people who would actually subscribe to the service, simply
- because people will realize that they may forget and cancel. Well, and I'm going to put my hand
- up because I'm one of those people. I've had it happen to me a couple of times. And so my question to you off of
- that is, does it have the potential of negatively impacting the relationship with the consumer because
- they forget about it? And when they get that charge on their bill, you know, they're most likely going to
- be, oh, they're frustrated and they want to dump the service anyway. I do exactly the same thing as you
- do. So and I think that if you look at our recent research, research actually has shown
- that, in fact, that if you do also auto-cancellation and people seem to like that
- better. So which basically means there will be more people join the subscription.
- But of course, at the end of the period, you may not have as many people who would actually renew their services.
- But if you use the auto and renew, you're going to have fewer people subscribing to
- the service. But you do get a higher renewal rate and because people forget and all that.
- So which basically means that this is actually a careful decision you have to make.
- It is a strategic decision you're making, whether you want to get front-loaded customers come
- in or, in fact, you get more people to renew your service. So that's a decision.
- So then does the business and the CEO really need to think about their business and
- how auto-renew would potentially impact it to make that final decision of whether or not
- to use it? Yes. And past research have, in fact, shown that, indeed, when you make that kind of decision,
- you need to worry about two factors. Number one, what kind of customers are you dealing with?
- Are they already second customers? Are they the inertial and purchased customers?
- In a certain kind of a market, people tend to switch around. In a certain kind of a market, people
- tend to stay with the same product forever. So it turned out that if you're talking
- about already second market, you want to actually use the auto and renew. But in the inertial market, you want to
- have a front-loaded incentive to get more people to sign up for your service. So in that particular case, you probably want
- to use auto-cancellation. That's one factor. The other factor is really whether you're a
- big company or you're a small company. If you are the company that has a lot of customers and are using your service,
- you have a big customer base to start with, your strategy should be more defensive, which
- basically means that you want to keep all the customers you have. But if you're a small company, of course,
- what you want to do is to be a little bit more aggressive. And so in that case, you want to
- purchase somebody else's customers. You want to switch the customers. So in that case, for instance, when you're
- a big company, you want to use a more rear-loaded strategy, which is really auto
- -renew. And if you're a small company, you want to have a more front-loaded strategy, which
- is really the auto-cancellation. But does that impact how the business, whatever
- size it is, thinks about the relationship it wants to have with their customer? Absolutely.
- I think that you certainly don't want to attract the kind of customers who use your
- service and they don't really like your service, but because of auto-renew, they stay with
- your service and generate all the bad word -of-mouth communication and bad feelings from customers
- and so on and so forth. So that's definitely one factor you need to consider. Is this an area where artificial intelligence is
- going to play a significant role in the years ahead? Well, hopefully that artificial intelligence can actually gather
- a little bit more customer information, gather a little bit more customer sentiment, and figure out
- exactly what are the right customers to use your service. And then you could, in fact, offer a
- more differentiated strategy, which means that for certain kind of people, you may want to use
- auto-renew. For certain kind of people, you probably want to use auto-cancellation.
- And somebody because, for instance, if I love the service, I want to stay with the
- service, auto-renew property will help me to stay on the service. And for the people who just want to
- sample the product a little bit, and you certainly want to give them a way out easily.
- I think frequently in reality, and firms tend to, in fact, arm-wrestle with the customers
- and keep more customers than what customers want to stay. John, great to talk to you again.
- Thanks very much for your time. All the best. Good to talk to you again. Thank you.
- John Zhang, Wharton Marketing Professor.
Brief Summary
John Zhang explains why auto-renew can boost retention but deter sign-ups, and how company size and customer behavior shape subscription choices.
Key points
- Auto-renew can scare customers away. Automatic renewal may increase the share of subscribers who renew, but customers who know they could forget to cancel may be less likely to sign up in the first place.
- A strategic choice, not a default. Businesses must weigh attracting more subscribers against retaining them. Auto-renew and auto-cancellation each favor a different side of that tradeoff.
- Company size changes the strategy. Large companies may focus on keeping their existing customer base with auto-renew, while smaller companies may use auto-cancellation to attract customers from competitors.
- Retention isn’t always loyalty. Keeping customers who dislike a service can create bad feelings and negative word of mouth. Zhang says firms should consider whether customers actually want to stay.
- Personalize renewal with AI. AI could help companies use customer information and sentiment to decide who should get auto-renew and who should have an easy way out.
Episode highlights
- Auto-renew can scare customers awayAutomatic renewal may increase the share of subscribers who renew, but customers who know they could forget to cancel may be less likely to sign up in the first place.“They may actually forget about the cancellation.”1:22Nov 20, 2026
- A strategic choice, not a defaultBusinesses must weigh attracting more subscribers against retaining them. Auto-renew and auto-cancellation each favor a different side of that tradeoff.“This is actually a careful decision you have to make.”3:27Nov 20, 2026
- Company size changes the strategyLarge companies may focus on keeping their existing customer base with auto-renew, while smaller companies may use auto-cancellation to attract customers from competitors.4:52Nov 20, 2026
- Retention isn’t always loyaltyKeeping customers who dislike a service can create bad feelings and negative word of mouth. Zhang says firms should consider whether customers actually want to stay.“You certainly don't want to attract the kind of customers who use your service and they don't really like your service.”5:50Nov 20, 2026
- Personalize renewal with AIAI could help companies use customer information and sentiment to decide who should get auto-renew and who should have an easy way out.6:12Nov 20, 2026





