Risks and Rewards of Social Media and Networks

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Social networks of digitally-connected customers and employees are growing in power and influence each day, but companies are often still blindsided by this phenomenon. Barry Libert, CEO of Open Matters and author of Social Nation, says the reason is that corporate leaders tend to focus on internal issues like operational excellence, but are confounded by external forces such as social networks that they cannot control. In this interview with Knowledge@Wharton, Libert shares a four-step process that companies can use to harness the power of social media and networks. 📂 Technology

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Barry, thank you so much for joining us today. Thanks for having me today.
  2. As we know, Brian Dunn, the CEO of Best Buy, resigned. What does this show about
  3. the role of social media and its ability to affect corporate life? Very simply, networks, including social networks that
  4. include customers and employees, are gathering strength relative to organizations. And believe it or not, as
  5. they gather strength in the marketplace, they create real risk for enterprises and in many shapes like Best Buy, they
  6. take them down and destroy their business model. There have been other examples as well,
  7. right? And Best Buy was hardly alone. What were some of the other recent examples of this type? Well, my favorite
  8. one is Encyclopedia Bratannica that had been around for 244 years. It only took Wikipedia about 11 years to destroy a
  9. business that had been around for 24 almost 50 years. And so that's another good one. But there's so many now.
  10. There's Kodak, there's Best Buy, there's Borders, Susan G. Kman, and the list goes on where the social networks now
  11. have much greater power than the businesses that serve them. You know, there was also recently the example of
  12. banks which had imposed some fees and and it was a virtual onslaught of social media outrage that forced them to roll
  13. back their decision. If you take all these things together, what are some of the lessons that companies should be
  14. learning from these experiences? Well, I think risk is the first one as should as reward. Let's talk about risk.
  15. In the days in which you and I grew up as a business leader, it was clear that execution was about and operations was
  16. about what we did. But the first lesson I think organization have to realize is that the risks live outside the
  17. organization because that's where the power is in the network and in the social communications. That's rule
  18. number one. And rule number two I always say is you have to embrace that risk or
  19. you have to embrace those social networks if you want to prosper in a sociallyorked world.
  20. So what are the implications for companies when risk resides outside rather than within the organization?
  21. Well, I think that's a great question. Currently, organizations be boards and management teams are organized and
  22. oriented towards inside data, financial data, sales data, marketing data. That's
  23. internally focused data and they're trained operationally to be sales executive, a marketing executive, a
  24. finance executive. I think people have to start thinking externally. They have to build brand new skill sets. And so I
  25. think the first thing I have to do is begin to gather large amounts of data. It's called big data, customer
  26. sentiment, and employee engagement. and get comfortable thinking about that's the data I need to make good decisions
  27. and companies are not uh the only ones that are vulnerable as we saw during the Arab
  28. Spring a number of uh governments also uh toppled because of u social media uh do you have any sense of what actually
  29. drives some of these social media uprisings I think for a long time we all have been
  30. waiting for a voice um you know it wasn't more than a decade or so ago know that Thomas Friedman wrote the book the
  31. world is flat but he was thinking about it physically he wasn't thinking about once the world becomes flat you and I
  32. can connect digitally and so although he was saying that India and America connected from an outsourcing
  33. perspective he wasn't thinking crowdsourcing and open sourcing and virtual sourcing so once the world's
  34. digitally collected and connected all of a sudden countries and city states and religions become subject to I want to
  35. say people's desires to be connected regardless of their country and city state and therefore countries like the
  36. Arabs and other countries that rule like that will fall to the basically these new ways of thinking.
  37. But if you if you push a little harder on that same theme, uh the connections always exist, but every once in a while
  38. there's something that sparks an uprising of this sort. Something goes viral. What what what sparks these uh these
  39. waves and uh what sustains them? Well, I think they've always existed. remember the old French revolution and
  40. basically people said let them eat cake right well there's a big difference today um and I always say I carry my
  41. weapon of mass destruction I along with you and this is my WMD and as long as there's a billion of us carrying social
  42. networks and five billion people carrying one of these things then what happens is as as long as you and I begin
  43. to agree that the leader is not serving us which is the important part serving your constituents not serving yourself
  44. then an uprising becomes viral role in today's world and somebody sparks one of these things which is called Twitter and
  45. Facebook and LinkedIn to begin to realize I feel the same way you do and let's work together to change the
  46. leadership. So I mean you you brought up a really good point you referred to Facebook and
  47. Twitter and and and generally speaking uh people use uh social media in a generic way to refer to these platforms.
  48. Uh now addition to th to those two are there any other social media platforms that you think that companies should be
  49. paying attention to? Absolutely. So all all the people talk about those two there's so many there's
  50. so many exciting ones. Everything from Dropbox which is a way to store data to Evernote to how do you share information
  51. to Pinterest which is how you build brand relationships. I'm only talking about America. You and I had a
  52. conversation about one in China yesterday. There are social networks everywhere. So what's happening is
  53. although people see Facebook and Twitter as sort of the leaders, these are very powerful movements that are using
  54. today's technologies to connect our interests. Why are companies and their CEOs often
  55. so reluctant to recognize the growing impact of uh social media? I think two reasons. One is we all have
  56. been trained to look inwards to build operational components I would say and greatness which is in search of
  57. excellence re-engineering the corporation. So their skill sets lie inwardly focused. The second reality is
  58. these outside networks are uncontrollable. They're self-organizing. They flare up and they calm down. They
  59. organize and they disorganize. And so they're not controllable. They're individual in their nature but connected
  60. collectively. And so leaders have not been taught and do not understand how to embrace this new way of acting with a
  61. network as powerful as these. And it's not just the consumer networks. It's true in the financial networks. They're
  62. called electronic trading funds and ETNs, electronic trading networks. They do risk on and risk off in the moment.
  63. Assuming a company figures out how to embrace the network, how can a company use them for positive
  64. outcomes? I think um whether it be investors, partners, customers or employees, the
  65. networks want to be embraced. They want to feel just like you and I do cared for. They want to know that you're there
  66. to serve them. That governments are in the business of serving others, not serving themselves. So once companies,
  67. countries, and industries really go back to the basics, how am I going to serve the people that I'm responsible for? I
  68. think the networks will feel cared for and they'll embrace the people that serve them. So, it's a change in mindset
  69. because my view is these networks want to be heard and as soon as they're heard, they're going to basically act on
  70. behalf of the organizations. In practical terms, how do you actually embrace a network?
  71. You let them have a voice in your business. You let them help you design your products called crowdsourcing. You
  72. help them deal with your customer service problems. You even help them design like Doritos does um their
  73. marketing programs. you make them a part of your business, not just a marketing outlet for your business.
  74. So, we talked earlier about companies that haven't done such a great job in recognizing the power of uh of of social
  75. media. What would be some contrary examples? You referred to Doritos, but are any companies doing a good job in
  76. leveraging social media? Absolutely. Um Nike has done a spectacular job and there's some great
  77. research about it. They've reallocated, which is important, 800 million of their
  78. traditional advertising budget. And they did something very simple. They allocated it, as they said, to where
  79. their customers are. They allocated it to mobile devices, to social interactions, to crowdsourcing. And let
  80. me give you simple examples. They literally embedded, as you know, mobile device in your sneaker. They now have a
  81. wristband that my son wears that allows you to keep track of how much running and how much weight you lose. And you
  82. can socialize that with your friend. and they let you keep track of how many miles on the courses you run. They're
  83. really taking their product and making it part of your life both on a social and physical basis. So they reallocated
  84. their capital and they doubled their revenues while they cut their cost in doing that.
  85. Uh well, one final question, Barry. U what advice would you give CEOs and corporate boards about how what are some
  86. of the two or three things they need to be doing with relation to uh harnessing the positive power of networks and
  87. social media? Well, I think it's a basically a four-step process is one and I'm going
  88. to call the process called care. Take care with what you do. One is create relationships with these networks
  89. because they are existing and they're growing exponentially and they're larger than countries and companies. Now two is
  90. begin to add which is the second letter of kitten care add their competencies their insights to your product and
  91. service offerings. Three hard to believe this I think you begin to need to reduce
  92. the internal focus you have in your organizations. Stop being focused so much about what you do and more on what
  93. they can do for you the way Apple's done with their developer network. And finally, you need to eliminate your fear
  94. of them because they're here to stay and there's nothing you can do about it. Barry, thank you so much for speaking
  95. with Knowledge at Warden. Thanks for having me today. [Music]

Brief Summary

Barry discusses social media's impact on corporations, highlighting Best Buy's CEO resignation and strategies for businesses to adapt.

Key points

  • The Power of Social Media. Social media has become a formidable force, capable of toppling long-standing businesses like Best Buy.
  • Nike's Social Media Success. Nike successfully shifted their advertising budget to social media, doubling their revenues.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes