HP's New Leadership: A Vision for the Future?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

New Hewlett-Packard CEO Leo Apotheker and non-executive board chairman Ray Lane take over the reins at the technology giant November 1, and the to-do list is daunting. Apotheker, the former CEO of business software company SAP, will have to convince doubters he is the right leader for HP, do battle with rivals such as IBM, Oracle and Apple, and set the company's long-term strategy. In addition, Apotheker must maintain the efficiency the company enjoyed under former CEO Mark Hurd, while gaining the buy-in from employees that his embattled predecessor reportedly lacked. 📂 Technology

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] okay what does it say about the board strategy let me begin this way let's
  2. look first at hpn Oracle for many years they were complementors they helped each
  3. other Hardware software they got along well they sold each other's products then Oracle bought son Microsystems what
  4. Hardware maybe a little tension creeping in little competitive tension so we saw
  5. some of it growing what happens next the board HP fires herd uh gets rid of him and that creates a furar of course
  6. people start questioning the board why there was Carly fiorina now there's herd and other problems like that it's do
  7. they know what they're doing do they is this a smart move well Larry Ellison at Oracle jumps on this of course and said
  8. the board is silly they're crazy they're doing the wrong things so he uh feeds the flame if you will of of conflict so
  9. what does HP do they hire Leo Apotheca from uh sap and is it a good move well is the board
  10. doing the right thing time will tell on one hand if the move is to get a or develop hp's moveing towards software to
  11. get away from the pure Hardware I think software accounts for approximately only
  12. 9% % of their revenues and if you look at the growth of other companies like IBM and others that had hardware and
  13. then move to software move to services this could be an absolutely wonderful mood move that the board has planned it
  14. could backfire the question of course that we'll probably get to is is Apothecare style is his leadership
  15. capability does it fit with the new strategy does it fit with hp's movement into software and to broader Horizons
  16. that's really the next question yeah this there's a lot going on here uh when Apotheca was uh still at sap an employee
  17. survey was done to talk about his leadership capability and and confidence in the direction of sap and it was
  18. decidedly negative it didn't look very good for him he wasn't doing people thought a good job he had some few
  19. missteps too he made some decisions strategic and operating decisions that didn't fly so he didn't do that well but
  20. he only was there really in the CEO's role for about seven months not really a lot of time to prove yourself and so
  21. when the board let him go or he resigned whatever the official thing was uh his capabilities or his uh skills were up in
  22. question so when he comes into HP then let's look at the Strategic and Leadership issues number one portfolio
  23. question can he manage such a diverse portfolio they're on the consumer side they're on the
  24. commercial side they've got uh printers and PCS they compete with Dell they compete with apple uh on the other side
  25. of course the Enterprise SES they compete with IBM and others they it's it's it's a broad portfolio so when
  26. you're a consumer you're in commercial and you're strong in hardware and now we want to add software to this mix I know
  27. he's he has a software background and they did bring Lane in also on the board to give that software thrust the
  28. question is can anyone including Apothecare can he in fact manage this complexity can he manage this portfolio
  29. the portfolio question raises smaller questions I'll mention briefly like the structure of the organization do we
  30. leave the different parts separate do we create a new service business as a new strategic business unit what about uh
  31. resources resource allocation I mean there's a lot of portfolio issues involved with his coming in and pushing
  32. uh software another question might be uh and it's really a leadership issue but it's an important one if he's doing all
  33. these new things can he heal the wounds that clearly I think exist currently at HP you've had at least two or three
  34. people who were candidates for this position Apothecary comes in and in effect those three people were passed
  35. over and they run some pretty important businesses uh they're pretty important I
  36. can imagine right now the their phones ringing the head hunters calling them saying you've been passed over how can
  37. you work with Apotheca and so on and I I I think that this could probably uh be some a major challenge for him to get
  38. people on board uh in essence can you develop a kind of endtoend strategy now with HP does he have the
  39. skills to do that does he have the capabilities to pull this off and he can he get people behind him where does he
  40. go from here does he buy sap the rumors are starting already now if you're sitting back and you want to create
  41. software he knows sap it would be sort of a interesting strategic move not only do they get
  42. software but he could also like take a little shot at at sap that you know you didn't give me much of a chance now I'm
  43. taking you over can he do that well yes and no I'm not sure yet sap is approximately 155 of the size of HP but
  44. still to buy it would be close to $60 billion or roughly that's what the market cap is right now approxim I think
  45. it's around 60 billion so this is a major Challenge and if he doesn't buy sap can he really
  46. enter strongly into the software Market strategic issue Oracle has basically made all these Acquisitions people soft
  47. and so on do they have the software Market locked up nothing's ever locked up but you know
  48. my point that they're very strong there if he doesn't purchase someone like sap or someone who can give a
  49. significant uh move in software if he doesn't do that can he compete with uh the on the software side can he compete
  50. with some of the organizations out there it's a tough road too it's a very good question this is why I say the the
  51. answer did the board do the right thing is up in the air because it's going to be tough entering this software Market
  52. there's no question about it but if you look you know IBM did it and okay at a different time in place they didn't have
  53. uh some of the competition out there that clearly HP will have and yet I go back to the portfolio uh is HP content
  54. with its consumer business its commercial business with such a small percentage of revenues coming from from
  55. software and from endtoend integration and Communications uh they could decide not to go strong into software but I
  56. think there's my opinion is that there's still enough some opportunity in software that if they bought someone if
  57. they bought sap if they bought someone else they could get an instant presence and really reap some revenues but again
  58. it's a very complex organization now Hardware software commercial consumer just to manage that large organization
  59. the complexity of it the size of it is going to be a challenge it's going to be a challenge for the top management team
  60. is the in nutson Bolt sky is that what HP needs I'm not sure about that I'm sure it can work out but remember uh
  61. he's German he's coming from a German company a much more hierarchical company than HP from what I've a little bit I
  62. know about their structures uh much more hierarchical in nature and so he has to come into a uh
  63. situation where in fact it's more of a what networking organization it's a little looser it's a little bit more
  64. decentralized it's a I mean this is my impression of it I could be wrong but this is what I've uh been led to believe
  65. so if he comes in and tries to move too quickly or impose things especially on people who are a little touchy because
  66. they were passed over I mean he might run into problem this is why of course he's doing his little honeymoon strut or
  67. walk around the organization getting to know people uh they're going to give them a little time whether that will be
  68. sufficient to smooth him a bit I read a quote and said he wakes up in the morning he chews glass eats iron and
  69. spits out nails that was a quote I found somewhere Apothecary so uh I don't know
  70. if it's that bad or whatever people love to exaggerate and newsprint articles but
  71. in essence what you're really raising is a kind of culture issue culture Clash style Clash leadership style might be an
  72. issue I think he's smart enough probably to overcome that and if he surrounds himself with good people keeps the good
  73. people gives them incentives to stay and work makes it worthwhile for them to cooperate with him he can build a strong
  74. organization around those people time will tell on that one I studied German at College in uh apota in German
  75. basically it means something like pharmacist so let's end the interview by saying let's hope that Apotheca is a
  76. good pharmacist he has the right drug and cure for HP because it's going to be a competitive interesting situation
  77. that

Brief Summary

HP's board strategy and Leo Apotheker's leadership challenges are discussed amid competitive tensions with Oracle.

Key points

  • HP's Leadership Shakeup. HP fires its CEO, creating turmoil and questions about the board's decisions.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes