China and India: Different Roads to a Common Destiny 3/3

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Girija Pande, chairman of Tata Consultancy Services for Asia Pacific, knows both India and China well, looking back and looking forward. In a conversation with Wharton management professor Jitendra Singh, he shares his thoughts on the strengths and weaknesses of both countries, and the challenges facing their businesses and governments. He also offers glimpses into his own brand of leadership, and the "impatience" in his DNA, as he puts it.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. you've already started to talk about my next question but maybe you have any specific thoughts that maybe have some
  2. specific thoughts you might share both about Indian annabelle Chinese Li business leadership as a general
  3. phenomenon I know this is painting with a broad brush what do you see as some of
  4. the strengths or some of the weaknesses both on the Indian side and on the Chinese side of business leadership they
  5. are there are some similarities as you said there are also differences could you evaluate them more I mean if you're
  6. looking at the weakness of both the Indian and Chinese system clearly they have to they are trying to address this
  7. issue growth faster rapid and they just don't have the some of them don't have the experience or the the way with all
  8. the in terms of resources to manage it and they don't have sometimes the systems to manage it they are evolving I
  9. think that's a weakness they leave a lot on the table sometimes there are holes and what they do is I'm down their
  10. losses especially in China their growth because there many of their companies are not driven by the stock market so
  11. large investments are made which are sometimes wasteful so I think they are struggling with that same thing happens
  12. determine India where the Indian government entities do the same thing right at least in the private sector not
  13. sure in the private side anymore you know tyranny of the market driving out all right so I think that's where the
  14. difference is China is so largely government dominated in terms of their growth and so they they did tend to do
  15. it their view is that you know you should take a longer-term arise and if you're building a road or a big plant
  16. they'll add capacity six times in India we would do it incrementally now their view is that why are you seeing at five
  17. years why don't you see ten year this is infrastructure and therefore they have a
  18. huge infrastructure whereas we are now struggling to build infrastructure so dear in India so this is where I think
  19. the difference and the way they look at it so they tend to take a much longer view
  20. they have the scale in mind which is much larger than the way India thinks of scale still staying with leadership
  21. patterns in China and India it seems to me one of the themes you have talked about is how just as your leadership
  22. pattern changed over time depending on the context you were in do you believe the leadership pattern of Indian
  23. business or Chinese business has changed for instance has there been the emergence of a different kind of
  24. leadership pattern in Indian business after the reforms of 1991 any thoughts you'd care to share in that domain well
  25. I mean I used to work in India before the reform and post reform so there's a clear watershed there's no debate in
  26. anyone's mind in India that the private sector of Indian business was shaken substantially when I won't turn a group
  27. we had big changes so that was a watershed and the mindset opened up to growth competition globalization all
  28. those nice things that we now talk about happened with that so that was the change in Asia China had it earlier but
  29. they also went two phases you had the Deng reform then you had zoo wrong g as a prime minister and WT opening for
  30. china in the 90s so there was there were a lot of that china and 90s post WTO was
  31. a very different china from the danks china and and and subsequently you know I with China having the last five years
  32. clearly demonstrating superior growth globally by a long shot is another different China so that three phases
  33. that I see of China i have seen it in the dang leadership time I've seen it post WTO when 1998 I think the zoo wrong
  34. she was a prime minister and he opened up China to the world in a much bigger way and then in the last three or four
  35. years where China has grown so substantially in every aspect the eight and a half nine and a half percent
  36. growth rates are astronomical for a country of that scale and size so what are the child
  37. at that rate right I totally different so let me invite you to just extend that logic and think about the future both
  38. India and China currently on very impressive growth trajectories or also of course some potential constraints to
  39. this impressive growth continuing indefinitely at this rate is the availability of skilled leaders going to
  40. become one of the important gating factors in either India or China or both I think that's an issue which worries us
  41. every day where are we going to find people and more importantly good leaders who are going to take handle this group
  42. because we see this growth continuing for some time in both countries it's not going to taper off in re unless so
  43. availability of leadership which is global in nature now because now we are globalizing both of us and china i think
  44. has a bigger challenge in finding global leaders than india to some extent because they start a little late and
  45. their global companies are mostly the public sectors which are and resources the state-owned enterprises the internet
  46. but i think what both of us will do will use a we will develop leadership through
  47. accelerated systems I think China is using it better than India I think they tend to use their non residents who are
  48. coming back to Chinese many of them were in this country to use them and get them
  49. back into and I have seen some very good talent which is coming back into China so they have a pool of talent which is
  50. outside which they are drawing on then they have a pool of talent around Hong Kong and on Taiwan and some of the
  51. Southeast Asian countries which have the Chinese ethnic ethnic Chinese who that so they have that big pool to draw from
  52. that's about 50 million has to say India has this 20 million pool outside India many of them in this country doing well
  53. so I think we have to start using that pool better especially in global affairs they have started a little faster
  54. because they are running short of good talent but both of us will have this issue of how do we wanna get it isn't it
  55. starting to happen in India as well it is Indian government has made efforts and individual companies have started
  56. doing that but it's not in the same scale as China's not so if you actually think of two or three action steps that
  57. either business might take or government might take or both might cooperate in increasing this availability of skilled
  58. business leaders what would it be for China and for India to build these know what steps my business or government
  59. take to increase the supply of skilled leaders of the kind that you believe are really needed I think what will happen
  60. is what will need to be done in both countries is to the one will be in company development where companies will
  61. have to develop themselves through mentoring through training leadership training and most Indian companies the
  62. big good ones have started leadership training in a big way there's no debate a lot of budgets are going into that and
  63. that is a reflection of the shortage that we foresee high attrition rates etc that are going on so that the companies
  64. have to do but they can do all of it together the government have to build this this infrastructure of Basic
  65. Education and then thereafter management education technical education certification processes which has to be
  66. done leadership at all levels so there's a part of government which I think both
  67. are realizing the government and the big role in this it can't just abdicate this
  68. to the private sector and finally I think there will be select mobile hires whether they are Indians are non in
  69. resident indians are non Chinese or global people I mean in dollar group we have just hired x-gen
  70. what is person to run tata motors i did see that so yeah and the same thing in Terra hotel's run by chinese american so
  71. select global hires a lot of indian companies are going to do that same thing with detour china as you know
  72. lenovo used to be run by the ex tell person so they are both companies will countries will do select global hearts
  73. but those can be large numbers there will be at leadership levels who can bring a level of globalization into the
  74. organization so just you mentioned education and it occurs to me that recently i have read in the news that
  75. the current human resource development minister in india mr. Sibal kapil sibal is leading some interesting initiatives
  76. in trying to bring foreign universities into india this bill has been passed by the cabinet and will be tabled before
  77. Parliament what you see is the role of foreign universities going forward in a country like India how might they
  78. contribute to this need for skilled business leaders of course this will take time what are your thoughts on that
  79. I didn't that is what is driving this this the two things that are driving it if from economics point of view a good
  80. economics that eighteen ninety thousand people come here to this country to study to the University of the US yeah
  81. surely we can have the US universities coming to India and doing the same thing so there is an economic logic for that
  82. second of course is to build a skill base Indian India does not have other than a few T's and ims does not have
  83. good university structures and nothing if these can catalyze good university education that could be a great story
  84. for India I think that's necessary is needed we have taken too long debating on this very narrow parochial
  85. nationalistic view which I think an open society in India has gone through the debate I think the debate is over
  86. clearly a lot more people want it to happen there will be always naysayers who would not want to see that happen
  87. but I think this is great idea and you are up to mistake that it I think it'll go through yeah
  88. there is no debate there is a consensus behind it indeed any comparable comments
  89. about china china has also done it some of the universities have already tied up
  90. with a lot of euro US universities a european university so there they understand the value these universities
  91. bring they haven't yet fully opened it up to have a complete University I think some of the pedagogy is kind of
  92. controlled right so but they have some large arrangements with most of the large US universities I see that all the
  93. time so they have done the same thing let's return for a moment to the question of Chinese and Indian business
  94. leaders I know we talked about the future and what the gating factors might be but do you see the very nature of the
  95. requirements changing I know you mentioned for instance growth has been a top priority in Asia but either for
  96. China or for India do you see any different kinds of leadership challenges coming up in the next few years let's
  97. say the next 10 years or so will it be more of the same no I think what we find is that every five years the market
  98. change substantially and either this technical innovation or social societal reorganization which throws up
  99. challenges for organizations you know sometimes the change is five years and I was ten years seven but if we saw the
  100. internet movie so before that every so we are expecting something else will happen as well so we are going to see
  101. though even though coming even though it's difficult it may not be in the horizon yeah I mean you you have to be a
  102. very big optimist to think that life will remain as it is I mean the only change change is the only constant as we
  103. say especially in our business with technology you can't even think of not having change so I think we are all
  104. anticipating change how ready we are going to be all of us is going to be different it'll that would determine the
  105. victor no winners and losers really in those nations so there are going to be game
  106. changers there will be people who are going to come and kill your business we are paranoid I mean Lee as Andy Grove
  107. said you got to be paranoid to survive returning to you again yourself as we come to the toward the end of our very
  108. enjoyable interview is there anything that you can identify in your own leadership style that is particularly
  109. Indian or for that matter were you influenced by being in China in a certain way well certainly my growing up
  110. years were in India you know it's kind of steeped in Indian tradition and mythology I think it it allows me to
  111. really revel in the world of uncertainty much better the world of uncertainty making order out of what is commonly
  112. seen by many as chaos I think our mythology and the sum of our part of our religious ethos is around that it is you
  113. know the from the sublime to the ridiculous if you can handle these two ends of an issue you have this ability
  114. to move without getting confused i think india has taught me that in the leadership style in china i have always
  115. appreciated the level of order orderliness and the confusion view which goes around family respect for elders
  116. order face from china can we bring the two together to get the best out of these two is really the challenge of
  117. companies which are managing both countries do you see that as desirable trying to sort of create a take the best
  118. of both and try to get soaked white polar opposites as you they are very different yeah one creates innovation
  119. and ideas and the other creates a huge powerful execution machine I remember when the Chinese prime minister visited
  120. TCS in bangalore and he said you are good in software and we have gotten hardware together two of us can
  121. be leaders I remember he made that statement in our Center in China in bangalore and i think that's what it is
  122. the software side of thinking clearly is an indian strength and it comes out of the seesaws of our backgrounds and the
  123. execution capability of china is and their ability to stink scale and big is is advantage if you can combine the two
  124. I think it's a can we combine the two is the question I all very often think about very interesting of course not
  125. only do corporations need both I think each country needs both so there is much to learn in India from China and vice
  126. versa oh yes oh yes both of them were asking Lee learn from each other as I always say we have been neighbors for
  127. 5,000 years we have given them some of our their spiritual background to Buddhism we have taken from them a lot
  128. of things about innovation that they had in the early parts of the history just before the end I would tell you that in
  129. my travels in China there was a one incident that really stood out at which I was talking with the Dean of a
  130. prominent business school in Shanghai and we were talking about the possibility i introduced the possibility
  131. of doing a three-vehicle aberration between singapore and china and india and after a pause my chinese host
  132. returned to it and said something which I found pretty astonishing and the statement was Professor saying we in
  133. China are deeply aware of the civilizational contributions that India has made to Chinese culture and society
  134. and the point was he says we would be very happy to cooperate in your travels through China is this something that you
  135. have noticed that rather deep level there is a recognition of India's contributions to china in the
  136. past there is also a recognition that in the contemporary present china is in many fields ahead of india although in
  137. some fields india does have the edge my travels a lot of i have traveled the length and breadth of china made a lot
  138. of people government individual students or employees one thing is very clear nearly ninety nine percent of them would
  139. have a huge respect for what they call indian wisdom this has been the southern neighbor and they have respected over
  140. 5,000 years there is no debate on this issue and I I said the anonymity of this issue indeed no that's as far as the
  141. historic issues come up what I think that has we translated into present present no I think Indians are on the
  142. other hand are a little wary of the growth of China in terms of the scale and size that they are so when we look
  143. at I've let business delegations of China as you say can we do something Indian businesses is a scared of being
  144. able to operate in China in the scale and the competitive message I that is a very competitive industry in markets
  145. extremely competitive market very entrepreneurial people so the Indian businesses are scared of putting a foot
  146. in there and I keep telling them you want to do it the way we did it which is built brick by brick there is no
  147. shortcut so this is going to be a huge marker of the future so they are scared of the scale and size the China builds
  148. and I give this example to everyone I went on the ningbo bridge which is for the shanghai expo they're built 28
  149. kilometers over the over the sea over learning sbobet in three years flat six-lane highway it has taken us 15
  150. years in Bombay to build a ceiling of two and a half kilometers indeed I still not done or still a fail hahahaha so
  151. very interesting is there anything else you would like to add just an open-ended invitation to say
  152. anything you want about the subject we have been talking about I think we've covered a lot of ground we've talked
  153. about leadership we've talked about how leadership's are developed a mentoring we've talked about of course India and
  154. China later baby see the coop titian cooperating and competing we talked about management style I think we live
  155. in very exciting times sometimes in when you are sitting in the West it looks a little more slower than we see it in our
  156. part of the world so we live in exciting times we are the lucky continent as I say to our people where growth is at
  157. least underwritten now for the next few years by the growth of these two charts there is a very interesting picture
  158. which defines the growth of Asia in the Copenhagen seventh where you had the US president dealing with the Indian Prime
  159. Minister and the Chinese Prime Minister as one photo the Brazilian President there were just four of them doing the
  160. Copenhagen deal very interesting that was a world challenge that is how it was may not be everyone's not happy with it
  161. but I'm just saying to you that I think the role of Asia is going to be critical
  162. Asia are more mature economies in terms of maturity of thought and leadership we
  163. are learning a lot technology and management styles from here a lot of our people are trained here and it's a great
  164. story so it's an exciting time for our younger people in both countries because they are going to see growth they
  165. haven't seen too much of a recession as yet but one day you will have cycles there are business cycles which will be
  166. the next challenge we can talk about you Japan day thank you very much this has been very enjoyable thank you very much
  167. attended thank you for having me here

Brief Summary

The episode compares Indian and Chinese business leadership, discussing strengths, weaknesses, and the future need for skilled leaders in both countries.

Key points

  • The Role of Foreign Universities in India. Discussing the impact of foreign universities on India's leadership skills and education.
  • The Future of Leadership in Asia. Anticipating the challenges and changes in leadership requirements in India and China.
  • Leadership Patterns in India and China. Exploring the evolving leadership styles in Indian and Chinese businesses post-reforms.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes