China and India: Different Roads to a Common Destiny 2/3
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Girija Pande, chairman of Tata Consultancy Services for Asia Pacific, knows both India and China well, looking back and looking forward. In a conversation with Wharton management professor Jitendra Singh, he shares his thoughts on the strengths and weaknesses of both countries, and the challenges facing their businesses and governments. He also offers glimpses into his own brand of leadership, and the "impatience" in his DNA, as he puts it.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- any thoughts about the weaknesses yes a lot of them i'm sure impatience in my dna
- sometimes people feel i'm running much faster than them and don't give them enough time to
- unrealistic time standards sometimes of expect expectations um i tend to have some of our best
- performing people in the unit around me both for coaching them and having them so when you have
- someone who's not really performing as well i think he he he finds it difficult working with me
- right now that could be a signal for him to improve or that could be a signal to leave but i have done that i think
- one of the things i have sometimes over here seen when we have to remove someone from the
- leadership position we sometimes take too much time on it we sometimes dwell on it
- think about it you know while he's this and while he's that i think that now i look back sometimes should have
- been done much faster is that is that something that now it's come probably over years but
- i mean i'm clinical now when i have to get someone to leave right right and but initially
- it takes time you know you you think about it too much and you just waste that much more time well it
- is of course a very difficult decision always and and it is a natural tendency to not want to
- deliver the very bad news it's but as you say sometimes it's better to get it done with and move on
- i think that's something which was a weakness so one of the things just by way of summary before i
- move on to another another domain it seems to me one of the greatest strengths you're talking about
- is on the one hand a concern for people particularly developing your people but also a strong concern for
- results and it's not one or the other but both would that be a fair summary absolutely i tend to keep both in mind
- when you are doing anything indeed you had mentioned in passing gerja in an earlier answer role models
- and i wondered if there is any one person or more than one person either in real life
- or in the world of literature who has actually been a role model for you would you say who is the person or
- persons and how that has influenced you in your journey as a leader yes i've had role models i suppose all
- of us look to role models to benchmark ourselves and see what we think are the best
- and in different aspects that different role models really i look at my father who was a very
- successful civil servant integrity and openness came from him a strong believer in that um
- when i look at some of my bosses in the bank and they're in tcs i i used to wonder why they became
- bosses that's where the question is to start and what do they have that made them
- bosses and listening capability very interesting something i always saw in all my role
- models over bosses amazing the successful ones would say less and hear more um i tried doing it many times but i think
- sometimes i'm impatient i think that has been certainly both two or three of my bosses in the bank and
- tcs have been very very good listeners they're very successful people they built big businesses
- in and out of the organizations and listening skills and motivating skills of their people
- getting the best out of them was really where the role model was well that's that's a very very fantastic
- insight sometimes i myself have been the beneficiary of this sometimes when we are getting along with our lives
- getting along with our careers from time to time some of us are fortunate enough
- to find someone who actually takes on the role of a mentor it's really a two-way choice
- in a sense you seek to be mentored and he or she seeks to mentor did you ever have any mentors and and
- again what was the role this mentor or mentors played in your career i think i was lucky in having bosses
- some bosses who were very keen to develop me i think they saw in me a potential and they naturally became the mentors in
- the organization and i have my had my share of mentors i have had respect for them i think in
- mentor it's a two-way street of you know developing mutual respect for each other
- understanding the the the the council as it is given whether it is uh good or bad you know
- the trust that the mentor develops with you so i've had mentors and i think they have developed my
- leadership styles very substantially i don't think no one ever comes with a leadership
- style that evolves and mentoring helps the leadership style to develop especially managing
- people so you see really multiple mentors over time few mentors over time and they have helped develop
- the leadership style is it that no one particular person stands out above the others or
- i know there are two or three of them who have been my mentors in different phases of life and i have learned a lot
- from them all right as you went through your leadership journey as i said you know we are talking today
- at a phase in your career where you've already achieved a great deal and you're uh you still have many good years ahead
- of you do you ever remember making conscious decisions based upon your experiences
- based upon role models of mentors to consciously change your leadership style uh
- if if you did would you talk about that a little bit i think some of the changes come with
- age as well and the role that you play i think when i was running an organization at a middle
- management level there was a different leadership style just short term as i became heads of units
- because i became heads of a whole business which i had to create like when i created the mutual fund
- in india as a executive chairman uh clearly the leadership style you know you're starting with
- zero is just white it's challenging where do you start you're going to convince your people who
- are going to join you that this will be a great business but also very exciting as you're and
- also excited so you you got to actually get them to see your vision why are you so excited and if they're
- not excited that business won't take off so i think the leadership style changes
- when you are doing at different levels roles of different levels and the the most challenging aspect of
- it is when especially when you're doing a ground up new business that is the crux of any
- leader can he build a new business from scratch i have done about four or five like that
- that's something which i always think has been the high point when i look at not
- what my titles were but where we built from scratch businesses and that perhaps is where
- your the inner entrepreneur comes out and plays a role let's switch gears a little bit garja i
- had mentioned to you right in the beginning that the study which this interview will
- be a part of is of indian and chinese business leadership obviously this is something that has
- influenced you as well but if you focus on indian business leadership or chinese
- business leadership and i'd want you to talk about both what are some of the most
- unique or even most distinctive aspects of this indian or chinese business leadership style
- and what have been some of the main sources of influence for each country i'm sure you have a
- vast amount of rich in experience in both countries but just start laying it out for each
- country yeah let me just take one of the common aspects to both you know i see that in china as well you
- know we built a business from scratch there and of course india where i work sometimes
- both countries over the last 15 to 20 years have taken growth for granted a given in the mindset of leadership
- double digit triple digit that doesn't matter in particular areas so both are highly aggressive
- in terms of growth parameters in when i look at our budget numbers a 15 growth in our jargon is called flat line
- interesting anyone who says that we said this is a flat growth and a lot of chinese say the same thing
- you don't hear that in the west naturally because there's a slow growing economy
- so both countries and the manager leadership i have to struggle with growth high growth and these high growths then
- require you to do many things for it to happen orderly orderly growth you do not want a disorderly growth
- so one is that both are struggling with growth second both are also globalizing i'm not talking about those companies
- which are globalizing not everyone is globalizing but the big companies and both countries are globalizing because
- they are seeing and tcs and we of course are in 45 countries so right so globalization is i'm seeing it
- in china now many of our customers are going global and the questions we ask them
- how will you support me globally that's the question i'm asked all the time yeah
- what are the challenges you faced when you went global because you're kind of ahead of others in doing it so
- both countries organizations are looking to global globalize both countries are looking at
- aggressive growth so that's that's common in that also at least in india and to some
- extent because private sector is not so dominant in china as yet concern for all stakeholders
- entire group we of course have a huge corporate social responsibility story which is part of our dna
- so looking after other aspects so there's a stakeholder management which is more comprehensive
- i hear the same thing in china there are there are issues of labor there are issues of government there are
- issues of poverty there are issues we have to look at it it is not just a bottom line driven
- q and q growth of eps that is only one part of the story and not just shareholder wealth maximization either
- that is good yeah so both sides look at that we are also short of people on both
- sides meaning and we're not short of people we've got one and a half billion people each and both countries but
- qualified leadership qualified management ranks are scarce in both countries because bo or the rest of the world has
- also assumed that there is some good talent in these countries that they also pick them up so it's a
- hunting ground for everyone a lot of multinationals run by good people from these countries
- so trying to develop management and leadership becomes a big challenge for senior
- leadership you can't divorce it you will not grow orderly and the metrics that you seize unless
- you develop your team simultaneously this is so hr and developing of people and leadership
- takes a long time and it takes a lot of time of ours in both countries china has a bigger problem sometimes
- because they are growing so far so much faster and this is a challenge that we hear
- from them and i when i talk to our customers and our own team in china talks to me about this problem
- and i talk to them a lot about this so these are the two these are three or four common things
- what about the different things the differences are obviously as you would expect a little bit of history and a
- little bit of culture so in india both of us have common sort of colonial experiences
- and and then you know we roughly both of us came out of the colonial experience as independent countries around the same
- time um and and the the the difference in in india is that our uh uh the the commonwealth system of
- government allowed us to internationalize much faster our legal systems or government
- whereas they for a long time were part of a very different philosophy so we are different in the
- way we think and different the way they think it's like the question once i was in one of
- the mayor in one of the cities asked me the question he said in china in china and we were they were going to give us
- some award or the other and during the lunch time the first question he asked so mr pandey
- how did you like slum dog millionaire so i said yeah good he said he also liked it and he saw it twice with his family
- the third question he asked me how did the government allow it allow the film allow the film to be
- produced so i kind of looked puzzled i said you know frankly i know the company knew about it
- government may not have been aware they're not even aware of it and even if they were aware of it there was precious
- little they could do about it that's right so you got a mindset which is different
- in these matters second the confusion thinking which dominates chinese mindset in everything they do
- has a lot of respect for authority and a lot of respect for a certain restraint on leadership so it's a very top-down
- driven issue there are no arguments and i always have a challenge when i'm in with our chinese team
- i want them to argue i encourage them to argue i say to them all knowledge does not
- reside in me in fact the least resides in me i am here to listen hear from you it's difficult in india
- you open a room full of young people and you don't have a chance to talk you you don't have it
- you don't have to invite them to challenge your chance yeah so that's two different
- styles it is not to say that there are not great ideas coming out in china but it's just
- the way you have to address it is different they maybe sometimes you have to do it individually in smaller groups
- and they come out with as good as yes i have no issues of one is better than the
- other i'm just saying that the mindset of the two management and teams are slightly different when they come to
- solving problems and which would mean you'd have to use different leader behaviors to elicit
- that is true to elicit the ideas true and then if you were implementing something if everyone has
- agreed to implement a china team would execute it perfectly absolutely perfectly
- not the same in india not the same in india because they would argue continuously
- interesting and i always remember mathias book the argumentative indian right they would continuously argue and
- you have to keep on arguing with them while you're doing it third i think over the years chinese have
- realized the value of delivering on time it is sacrosanct in that country to sacrifice you don't miss deadlines
- whether they're building a bridge or they're building a i.t system and a customer is expected
- i i was asked we were building a huge system for the central bank of china id system massive trading system
- they wanted an hour to hour project plan hour two hours in some key what was the
- length of the whole project two and a half years my god the main trading system for the chinese yuan
- training that is how they have built bridges that's how they're built large organizations and cities
- with an amazing amount of what i call military precision indian organizations don't yet know the
- value of that i think they're learning but if you ask me the difference the execution capability in china is
- absolutely outstanding now is there any potential downside to this command and control
- military precision as you're talking about i think they are realizing that there
- are downsides creativity doesn't flower easily new ideas are not expected from people who face
- customers that easily and i think many of them are are also understanding that while there
- are upsides to this strategy in terms of project implementation there could be downsides in in india we
- find lot more of ideas coming out some crazy some work while worthwhile but they're coming out all the time
- um because i think we we either allow it or it's part of our dna argument and the leader has to
- actually address those arguments you you you cannot just say i am the leader that is unacceptable
- to an open style that you are diverse so you have to argue with all of them takes
- much longer let me bounce something off you it seems to me based on my knowledge of both
- china and india and most recently you know my years in singapore the whole notion of social order in the
- chinese world is really quite different than in the indian world do you have views on that
- as i said there is a much larger emphasis given to order right i was once telling a chinese senior
- chinese official about how the indian trinity of gods of creation destruction and that's a very unusual concept to
- them very unusual concept because order is so much part of the preserving order and running it and not only so much part
- of that like so i think it's it's it's around us this the different experience that they've had
- the confusion the style uh uh and the whole confusion mindset along with the 50 years of a very hard
- driven communistic system has probably brought that you
Brief Summary
The episode compares Indian and Chinese leadership styles, emphasizing mentorship, impatience, and cultural differences in communication and execution.
Key points
- The Challenge of Leadership Decisions. Making tough decisions about team performance can be a lengthy process. 'Sometimes it’s better to get it done with and move on.'
- The Role of Mentorship. Mentorship plays a crucial role in developing leadership styles over time. 'Mentoring helps the leadership style to develop.'
- Cultural Differences in Leadership. Leadership styles differ significantly between India and China, impacting execution and creativity. 'The execution capability in China is absolutely outstanding.'
Episode highlights
- The Challenge of Leadership DecisionsMaking tough decisions about team performance can be a lengthy process. 'Sometimes it’s better to get it done with and move on.'“It's better to get it done with and move on.”1:45Jul 17, 2010
- The Role of MentorshipMentorship plays a crucial role in developing leadership styles over time. 'Mentoring helps the leadership style to develop.'“Mentoring helps the leadership style to develop.”5:38Jul 17, 2010
- Cultural Differences in LeadershipLeadership styles differ significantly between India and China, impacting execution and creativity. 'The execution capability in China is absolutely outstanding.'“The execution capability in China is absolutely outstanding.”17:13Jul 17, 2010
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





