Partnerships for Healthcare Innovation in Africa

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 ESG;Health Care Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. good morning I'm alen gattino I'm here with Luke Disney who's the executive director of the Northstar Alliance
  2. working out of utest in the Netherlands and doing fantastic work uh setting up and managing health clinics to address
  3. uh uh mobile populations who are at risk of HIV and AIDS across Africa morning Luke hi elen nice to be here how are you
  4. doing very well thanks thanks can you tell us a little bit more about the work that Northstar is doing sure so
  5. Northstar Alliance was set up in 2006 by the United Nations world food program uh
  6. with support from TNT Express a express delivery Transport company and the issue really um they
  7. focused on was the fact that HIV at that point so we're talking sort of the middle beginning 2000s middle 2000s was
  8. having a devastating impact on Supply chains in Africa subsaharan Africa so from the h from the world food programs
  9. perspective this was really about their humanitarian supply chain so were they were trying to get food from ports out
  10. to Hungry communities and in particular in sort of 2003 2004 they were responding to a
  11. crisis in Southeastern Africa and they noticed that they couldn't find enough trucks to move the
  12. food from the ports out to the communities and this was strange to them because normally they're pretty well
  13. prepared for crisis situations in these vulnerable areas and so they've got a list of all the transport companies
  14. they've made estimates on the capacity but what they hadn't calculated into their model was the impact of HIV which
  15. was you know on the Rampage at that point um in this part of the world so they were losing truck drivers or the
  16. local companies who they rely on were losing truck drivers at an enormous rate and that as a result was affecting their
  17. ability to deliver food at the same time so the flip side of the coin was when they did analysis
  18. into the situation um they also discovered that the very Supply chains they were setting up and you've got to
  19. think of sort of long Supply chains hundreds of trucks in some cases going into into areas for periods that can be
  20. up to two years in the case of a protracted relief and Recovery operation we're also a factor in spreading HIV so
  21. you have these communities isolated relatively isolated communities which all of a sudden have this huge influx of
  22. truck drivers coming in and at that point they started they got very concerned not only because of
  23. their own supply chain risk but of of course the ethical implications of doing trying to do good and at the same time
  24. inadvertently uh bringing harm to some of these communities so they um I I remember the
  25. first time that I was in Africa um in an isolated Community when I actually met somebody who had full-blown HIV um it
  26. was a truck driver uh named Edward and he was lying in on his back in a Hut in the middle of nowhere literally and you
  27. you were just thinking to yourself how in God's name did HIV get to this place and and the fact that he was a truck
  28. driver is probably how he contracted it and sadly brought it back to his village
  29. where infected other people so that was wfp's part of the story TNT Express at that point um was busy expanding in
  30. subsaharan Africa and of course as an express delivery company also very reliant on the transport sector as a
  31. backbone to move packages this case commercial Goods around so together they got they were they had already started
  32. working together on on proving Logistics of food delivery and they then turned their attention to this issue and really
  33. um coming at it from Logistics perspective as opposed to from a traditional Public Health perspective
  34. they started to say right well where what's the problem here and the problem is in subsaharan Africa and other places
  35. that you get truck drivers spend enormous amount of time away from home um in Africa they're on the road uh
  36. long-distance truck drivers can be away easily for up to 22 26 days a month you know on these long areas spending
  37. enormous amount of time at truck stops which are isolated uh parked on the side of the ro road where they interact with
  38. um women who have been forced into sex work because of the lack of other economic opportunities and really just a
  39. lot of the time women who have no other way of making their their living and feeding their families so you get these
  40. hotpots growing up what we call disease hotpots growing around these truck stops
  41. border crossings ports and this is where you get high-risk groups like sex workers interacting with what we call
  42. Bridge groups truck drivers who then take the disease HIV in this case back to their their families so and it's not
  43. just diseases like HIV we also see for example in the recent Ebola crisis in West Africa that mobile populations
  44. again play an enormous role in spreading the disease from one place to the next so that's that's how the whole thing got
  45. started and and the philosophy was well if it's happening at these hot spots then the traditional Health
  46. infrastructure of hospitals and high Den highly dense uh populations in cities and towns is not going to work we need
  47. to get the facilities or the services out to the people in these areas to prevent uh the disease from being
  48. transferred in the first place so we started by setting up small container-based clinics we used shipping
  49. containers because they're cheap and easy to manufacture to move around and also to control the quality uh and if
  50. you're inside one it looks like a doctor's office that you and I would see here you know we Ki them all out they've
  51. got air Co they've got water uh lights electricity of course and we started putting down these containers with nurse
  52. uh run teams of with Outreach workers at the uh different hotspots and then building networks them along the
  53. transport Corridor so as drivers move from one place to the next and sex workers who are also mobile we could
  54. start to build a continuity of care and and get into these hot spots uh where the actual transmission was happening so
  55. we started that in 2006 2007 Northstar Alliance was created as an independent organization to take this forward
  56. because obviously TNT and wfb had other things to do with their time and and since then norstar has grown now almost
  57. 10 years later into an organization we've got 35 clinics uh in 13 different countries at the moment we've served
  58. over a million people uh we've actually helped establish uh 50 different clinics
  59. in Africa and transferred some of those to governments others to other local um partners and the networks continue to
  60. grow and expand so that's in a short perhaps not so short explanation of who we are and what
  61. we've done so I remember um back last May I was visiting one of your clinics in South Africa and I actually um met a
  62. commercial sex worker who was at the clinics uh her name was Michelle and she was saying that you know she was telling
  63. me about the huge difference that the clinic had made in her life and uh she was saying that she wanted to become her
  64. ambition was to become kind of the the president of the sex workers and so you this really made me think that you're
  65. you're basically giving a voice to populations who don't have one in these areas and um so I was wondering if you
  66. could maybe tell me a little bit more about how the work that you're doing is moving from a sort of top- down approach
  67. towards Healthcare to maybe a more bottoms uh up approach where you're really involving these local populations
  68. in finding solutions to their to to these kinds of issues sure and I I think that's that's a lesson a really
  69. important lesson that we learned in the process I mean when we started trying to
  70. figure out how to do this we went in with I guess you could describe as the typical supply side mentality of an
  71. orthodox healthare system we will put a service in place and then expect people come to us and take up the service that
  72. we have put there and in order to improve and become more effective and particularly to get the people like the
  73. sex workers coming into our Clinic we realize very cck quickly that you can't just go and say this is what we
  74. think is the problem in your area you need to actually address what they experience as the problems because
  75. preventing disease is not something that you do by just putting in a one-off solution you need to build long-term
  76. relations with your key Target groups and in order to do that you need to be talking to them about what they think is
  77. important to them and what their health considerations are so very quickly because of that bottomup influx of of
  78. data or of information we were getting from the communities they were saying you know HIV is fine but I've got uh a
  79. child that needs to be inoculated uh I've got uh a problem with uh empyema or I've got a problem with uh skin rash and
  80. so a more Primary Health Care uh approach was definitely very quickly what they were looking for so we very
  81. quickly I think almost in the first uh half year realized that okay we've got to position ourselves differently
  82. because you know you need to be working with what their concerns are and I think
  83. you see that tendency spreading across uh not only in our sector of the healthcare industry or the healthcare uh
  84. field you see it other places where we've gained a lot of knowledge about what health is and are we're in the
  85. middle of a paradigm shift in my opinion that we're moving away from this traditional or Orthodox focus on top
  86. down Supply supply side Health Care Services which say okay we've got hospitals here doctors the healthcare
  87. establishment including the pharmaceutical industry identifying problems and trying to plug gaps which
  88. is moving towards working with the communities and uh people in trying to figure out from their perspectives okay
  89. we know they're going to be go through life as a cycle of Health feeling better at one point and less uh healthy at
  90. another Point that's just how we all work we're all in constant flux when it comes to states of health and if you
  91. start to work with these people and help them to navigate those changes in their
  92. pattern by leveraging the assets that are closer to them as opposed to moving into uh something you're trying to guess
  93. from a top down perspective as to what's going to be the remedy at a given point
  94. in time I think that's that's really changing how people are are focusing on health and what we're learning you see a
  95. very big movement now in health as an asset so trying to build people's capacity to leverage what's in their
  96. their local communities based on the knowledge that the things that impact your health are not just contagious
  97. disease there's been an enormous shift in disease patterns over the last hundred years where you see in the past
  98. what was killing people and and reducing their quality of life for diseases like
  99. tuberculosis here in the US and uh contagious disease towards what we call the non-communicable diseases such as uh
  100. type 2 diabetes heart disease cancers things like that which are influenced by a different set of factors and the
  101. vectors of transmission are not just people passing uh pathogens between each other they're people are being impacted
  102. by their Lifestyles and where they're living and as a result the way to deal with that of course needs to change as
  103. well so the hospitals the idea of bringing everybody together in one place to treat them is is really something
  104. that's changed in people's thinking well if we're trying to deal with diseases that are caused by people's local
  105. circumstances and living patterns hospital is not really best way to approach that is it so one thing
  106. that's really interesting about the way that you've actually organized to address this kind of issue and and
  107. create this bottomup kind of healthcare solution is you've got a model that is essentially the same for all of the
  108. countries you work in but you work in a number of very different countries and these blue boxes still manage to create
  109. this local embeddedness with the communities and so what's kind of the what's the secret to actually managing
  110. um that mix of uh somewhat stand ardized system that has clear processes and routines and uh ways of measuring
  111. outcomes but at the same time having that that local embeddedness I think I think it relates
  112. back to your previous question and turning of of turning your perspective upside down instead of looking at it
  113. from we're coming in to solve the health problem to a realization that there are
  114. so many different factors that influence Health that you can only provide one piece of that puzzle as a healthcare
  115. provider today it's very difficult for everybody to be good at everything of course in terms of healthcare provision
  116. the person who's going to help you prevent getting HIV is not necessarily the person that's going to help you quit
  117. smoking so in order to if you take that mentality as I'm a piece of the puzzle I'm part of a larger system which
  118. impacts these individuals health and you focus on being as good as you can at the one piece of the puzzle
  119. so in our case running a Primary Healthcare Clinic in an isolated area that's the starting point but the
  120. more important aspect I think after that is opening yourself up to engaging the other pieces of the puzzle to connecting
  121. with the governments who are able to provide additional you know second tier services for example or on the other end
  122. to the community organizations such as youth groups or church groups who are working with the communities and by
  123. having a very reliable solid Anchor Point for different groups to work with um you can really find that you can fit
  124. into many places places because the basic ideas of health services and and Primary Health Care Services are pretty
  125. standard you know how you treat uh a disease like HIV is is fairly standard uh there are some variations in in
  126. treatment protocols but that's really to do with the pharmaceutical side but how
  127. you do that basic element is pretty good the mentality of how to work with other
  128. people is different depending of obviously at the at the superficial level with what their requirements are
  129. but the underlying mentality also is fairly uniform in you have to be open to it and that's
  130. where it starts that idea that we are one piece of the puzzle we're going to connect with these other people and help
  131. them and we're all in this together and what's I think uh especially interesting
  132. is the fact that you're connecting a bunch of very different puzzle pieces I mean you have partners that go from uh
  133. usaid or Global uh you know Partners to to help fund uh healthc care and development all the way down to the
  134. local dance troop that's doing you know referrals and advocacy for your clinic how do you actually manage to you know
  135. first of all establish such a diverse group of partnership set of Partnerships and then how do you actually manage to
  136. leverage them in ways that are going to improve your Healthcare outcomes so I I I think the I mean the
  137. funny thing people ask often I mean how do you get a big multinational company uh like Chevron or heinan to work with a
  138. local dance you know group from the community is is the short the flippant short answer I suppose is they don't
  139. have to work together you know we can be there as that linking pin because they both are reliant on
  140. highquality affordable Clinical Services to be able to do what they want in the case of a multinational it could be
  141. keeping their local Workforce uh healthy in the case of the local community organization it's the same thing their
  142. their constituents need to be be healthy but because we're able to leverage because we we we have that Central
  143. linking role they're both able to come together and in a way that they probs on their own would not dealing with each
  144. other directly um we just sort of fit a gap that's between there and again how do you do it um I think one of the key
  145. things that we've done and and it starts with that mentality of wanting to do it
  146. but after that giving your local teams enough agency in the field that they are empowered they understand the local
  147. circumstances they know which local community groups are going to be worth working with and which ones are perhaps
  148. not going to be as effective or or more difficult they know the local government
  149. uh Partners they have to work with them on a daily basis that's not something you can manage centrally from
  150. particularly not from from the Netherlands where our head office is based or our regional office in Nairobi
  151. for East Africa or or Durban for southern Africa they can't do that so what we've realized over the time and we
  152. were actually caught I by surprise at the extent to which our local teams and and we've been working with you guys to
  153. try and map this out and get a handle on it but when you prevented presented your
  154. first findings to us you know I think all of us were shocked at the vast size of the networks that we had and I
  155. experience it when I go and visit the clinics but truly to see to to map that all out then
  156. you realize all of a sudden that you're the impact you're having as an organization is much larger than you
  157. perhaps initially anticipated so I think a lot of times organizations see a tension between
  158. decentralization in the sense of giving people agency at the local level to execute and build those Partnerships but
  159. at the same time wanting to very be very tight in terms of their control on key things like quality for example and
  160. maybe even your branding in case of commercial companies as well but I don't see there as much inherent intention as
  161. people necessarily think there sometimes if people know what they're supposed to
  162. be doing and I think this is where your culture as an organization is very important I think it's where your your
  163. the clarity in your mission and your vision as what to what you want to achieve are very important if those
  164. things are clear and we train people on that we work very intensely with our our
  165. teams particularly at the lower management levels the people running the clinics to make sure that they not only
  166. that we're giving it to them and saying this is what you should be thinking but we've involved them in actually creating
  167. and defining those cultural keystones our our core values so it really is coming from them and then we've what
  168. we've done is just taken that codify it and repeat it and make people aware of it and constantly remind them and if
  169. they know that and they share that Vision it's much easier then to give them the agency to operate at a local
  170. level because you can rest assure that they are linking that in their own minds to what you want to achieve as a group
  171. anyways and they're they're a fairly exceptional group of people for having LED workshops with them uh last year um
  172. they're they're really extraordinary um one of the things they have to be really
  173. good at doing is kind of wearing different hats and adapting to very different kinds of Partners right
  174. they're developing these ecosystems but that means means they have to work with public private nonprofit sector
  175. organizations um and and bring these pieces of the puzzle together what are the kinds of implications of having to
  176. bring together organizations Partners from different sectors um you're talking about or organizational culture
  177. obviously that's going to be very different um in terms of the way you're going to partner and approach with a
  178. public or nonprofit or private sector uh company MH I I think um it starts with uh a
  179. natural that that natural um building on the natural culture of the company is a
  180. starting point but it's not sufficient in itself I think you have to go beyond and what we try and work on in groups
  181. and our training programs is helping people to understand and identify pitfalls that they can get
  182. themselves trapped into sometimes by some people who don't and particularly in certain cultural circumstances at
  183. local levels there may be enormous moral pressure or community pressure to go in
  184. a certain direction and to try and give them uh the tools and uh awareness to try and
  185. protect themselves from getting into those positions and if they do get into those positions how do you get yourself
  186. out for example if you're working with uh a local communities in in some parts of Africa you may have to deal with uh
  187. the village Chief headman uh who has certain ideas of how his community should be run which may be very much at
  188. odds with how the local uh government authorities think that you should be delivering your health care
  189. services so how does the local clinical officer balance those two things because
  190. those are very competing uh edges now he or she and most we have a lot of females
  191. running our our um clinics will know what we want to achieve but still sitting between those
  192. two fires is pretty intense and and can get very uncomfortable very quickly so what we've tried to do is build in
  193. escalation mechanisms as well where they feel that they're under so much pressure
  194. we try and give them as I said techniques are saying right well don't commit yourself in this when you enter
  195. into a conversation be conscious of the fact that you can't go beyond this line and if you feel yourself pressured to do
  196. that and you're in a tight situation and we've tried to build escalation measures
  197. so they can always kick it up the management line and then we can bring in somebody who doesn't have that local
  198. pressure and that's really effective sometimes it's just you know I'd love to help you but my hands are tied oh so
  199. you've uh nicely exploited that bottom up uh uh concept into the the organization itself as well I think you
  200. know every every individual um is used to wearing different hats I mean all of us um you know whether it's be your
  201. professional hats or your personal life your your friends compared to your family there's we're all used to wearing
  202. different things and I think instinctively a lot of us can figure out that we're going to get into trouble
  203. sometimes and there are conflicts we face on a daily basis you know do I go to my daughter's dance recital or do I
  204. go to that meeting um I think recognizing that is a natural healthy part of any management progam process is
  205. important and building in enough flexibility into your system that helps people to navigate that in a way that
  206. they're going to feel comfortable with and spending time talking about those conflicts so one of the things at the
  207. workshop you were with uh us in South Africa recently we did spend time going through role playing situations with our
  208. teams how do you deal with this sort of thing getting them to share and and a lot of it's not us going in and teaching
  209. them what to do a lot of it's letting them share their experiences and talking about how they solved it because again
  210. their local knowledge of those situations is far superior to anything that we're going to
  211. be able to put in in many cases uh from an external perspective so just by acknowledging and running them through
  212. it giv the opportunity to practice exchange ideas can be you know it's not something that's rocket science but it's
  213. something you have to consciously recognize as being important MH so these tensions are they something you
  214. experienced yourself you you started out in the private sector and then moved into the nonprofit sector um you know
  215. bridging those two worlds what are the kinds of tensions that you've experienced personally in in from a
  216. career perspective moving from from one sector to the other yeah not perhaps as many as people
  217. would think um I I think sometimes people have an artificial um division in their mind
  218. between and it particularly revolves around the issue of discipline that that corporations and the private sector is
  219. by nature very disciplined and NOS are by Nature not very disciplined and that is complete fallacy I mean obviously I
  220. think if you look at the vast number of uh private sector companies that U go under on a given year uh or don't make
  221. it past their third birthday um or if you've walked into and had an interesting customer support uh issue
  222. which many of us have whether it's on a variety of services then you start to uh
  223. poke through that that veneer quite quickly on the other hand working with um a lot of um nonprofits I've seen a a
  224. level of professionality and discipline that is equal if not surpassing uh a lot
  225. of the NOS the difference of course at the end of the day is financial reward in a lot of cases you and that attracts
  226. perhaps different sorts of people into it um you're not going to become extremely rich in most cases working in
  227. the nonprofit sector but increasingly a lot of people are making other choices in their lives and that's maybe not
  228. their biggest motivation as long as you can pay your bills but it's you know so I haven't noticed a
  229. huge difference in in in in that respect what has surprise me is the amount of competition that you see in the
  230. nonprofit sector I you know coming out of the commercial world I thought oh we're now all going to work together and
  231. it's going to be a better world but again there is you know competition for scarce resources and that's something I
  232. think where Northstar has tried to to do things differently and and positioning ourselves at somebody who we try and
  233. work with anybody we say in principle um and to try and really fit into that that piece of the puzzle
  234. mentality um but it doesn't completely eliminate that drive for competition at the end of the day unfortunately Luke
  235. thanks a lot for sharing your experience and the great work that your organization is doing my pleasure thanks
  236. very much for having me

Brief Summary

Luke Disney discusses Northstar Alliance's work combating HIV in Africa through community-based healthcare solutions.

Key points

  • Northstar Alliance's Mission. Founded in 2006, Northstar Alliance addresses HIV and AIDS among mobile populations in Africa.
  • Innovative Healthcare Solutions. Northstar Alliance uses container-based clinics to provide healthcare where it's needed most.
  • Empowering Local Communities. The organization shifts from a top-down to a bottom-up approach in healthcare delivery.
  • Bridging Sectors. Exploring the complexities of partnering across public, private, and nonprofit sectors.
  • Navigating Tensions. Understanding the pressures faced by individuals in conflicting cultural circumstances.
  • Competition in Nonprofits. The unexpected competition within the nonprofit sector challenges assumptions of collaboration.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes