The Israeli Way of Doing Business - Interview with Oxford Professor Derek J. Penslar

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

KNOWLEDGE@WHARTON ARCHIVES: Does ethnicity influence economics? Knowledge at Wharton investigates this issue with Derek Penslar, professor of Israel Studies at Oxford University and also professor of Jewish History at the University of Toronto. He has written a book about the history of the Jewish people and the group’s strong association with commerce, Shylock’s Children: Economics and Jewish Identity in Modern Europe. Penslar argues that there is no monolithic “Jewish economy.” Rather, certain forms of economic behavior persisted throughout the Jewish world that tended to repeat themselves in many situations, enhanced by a sense of unity among Jews from different regions.

More on this interview: https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/israeli-way-business/

#jewishhistory #economics 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'd like to welcome Derek Pensler who is a professor of Israel studies at Oxford
  2. University and also a professor of Jewish history at the University of Toronto. Welcome to Knowledge at
  3. Wharton. Thank you. Thank you for joining us today. Um I want to ask you uh what are the features of a Jewish
  4. approach to economics and uh and how that differs from other approaches. But before I get to that, uh, I wanted to
  5. start with this idea of what do you think of pairing ethnicity with economics? Uh, and looking at the two
  6. together because that can be a controversial idea just starting off. It can be very controversial. No matter how
  7. you approach it, it it is sensitive. The fact is that until the 1930s, 1940s, it
  8. was very common for scholars, including Jewish scholars, who were really embedded in their communities, to write
  9. about the uh the relationship between the Jewish religion or Jewish nationality and Jewish economic
  10. behavior. Nothing wrong really was attributed to it. Anti-semites were making outrageous comments about Jewish
  11. economic behavior or domination, but but Jews considered it a completely acceptable thing to do. And then came
  12. the horrors of the 1930s4s, Nazism, the Holocaust. And in the wake of that, a lot of the language
  13. that had been used to talk about Jews as a kind of an ethnic unit and an economic
  14. unit was discredited. It was considered no longer appropriate to talk about Jews
  15. that way. Even by Jews, even by Jews. And so Jewish scholarship, scholarship on the history of the Jews tended to
  16. focus on anything but economics, religion was okay, politics was okay, culture was okay, but economics was
  17. taboo. Very few people wrote on economics every every now and then. And just in the last, I'd say decade, decade
  18. and a half, we now see young scholars who are now, you know, two generations removed away from from the Holocaust who
  19. are beginning to take this subject up again. And after all, you can't understand any kind of group behavior
  20. without e without without economics. So, enough time has passed, it would seem. I
  21. think enough time has passed, although there are people who still are um nervous about it because of the way that
  22. anti-semites have made use of economic arguments to demean the Jews. Well, let's get into what some of these
  23. characteristics or features of the Jewish approach are and and how they may differ from other cultures, other
  24. countries, other nations. Well, one thing I I would say there's there's not some a monolithic thing called the
  25. Jewish economy that sort of marches across space and time. It's just that there seem to be certain forms of
  26. economic behavior or or economic culture throughout much of the Jewish world that
  27. seem to repeat themselves in in many different circumstances and it's hard to know how far back to go. But certainly
  28. by the time we get into the later middle ages up through early modern times, 20th
  29. century, the most important thing really is just one sentence, which is that Jews
  30. throughout most of history have not been peasants or aristocrats. Throughout most
  31. of human history, most people until recently were peasants. They worked the land. They often couldn't leave the
  32. land. And that doesn't encourage economic innovation. It doesn't encourage literacy. It doesn't encourage
  33. numeracy. It doesn't encourage entrepreneurship. And aristocrats are lords of the land and they tend to be a
  34. warrior elite and that also does not encourage innovation. So who innovates in the society? The middle classes, the
  35. towns people, the bourgeoa or the burgers. Well, Jews have been for millennia primarily a people of
  36. townsmen. It might be a small town, it might be a large one. And they've worked in a mixture of crafts, but also in in
  37. commerce. When people are doing that generation after generation, they develop certain comparative advantages
  38. whether it's literacy or numeracy. And let's not forget the fact that Jews are connected with each other across space.
  39. The Jew in one town in Poland has Jewish distant family from another part of Poland or from somewhere in Germany and
  40. so on. So uh but the Israeli economy as you alluded to in your last answer has changed a lot over the last 30 years.
  41. let's say without going back centuries just look at the last 30 years and it's gone from largely a social socialistic
  42. approach to the economy to a much more capitalistic approach can you talk about that change and how it came about why it
  43. came about sure and I can do it by actually bridging a little bit from you know the 16 1700s I was talking about a
  44. second ago into into directly into your question which is the Jewish world in central eastern Europe primarily was
  45. just overwhelmed by the possibility of revolution in the 19th century, capitalist revolution, transformation of
  46. economic relations, but also socialism, communism, various movements on the left
  47. and national movements. Zionism is after all a classic form of of Jewish nationalism were caught up with this
  48. idea of of a revolutionary change in the Jewish people. So Zionism when it realized itself in the state of Israel
  49. in 1948 was very strongly dominated by I wouldn't say a socialist ideology as such but one that had had
  50. socialist elements where the state played a very major role in the development of the country in the
  51. promotion of the nation. There was a lot of state-owned industry there were severe limits on wages. So for example,
  52. wage differentials between workers and say physicians or professors in the early state of Israel were quite
  53. minimal. So there was this kind of egalitarian ethos, not socialism per se, but kind of social democracy. And that
  54. was one kind of Jewish I would say economy in that it was influenced by the very strong role Jews had played in the
  55. revolutionary movements in the early 20th century. But that was Israel of one era, 1950s,60s.
  56. It already begins to loosen up in the 70s and the 80s. Israel becomes an industrial powerhouse
  57. manufacturing textiles, medical technology. It's no longer making money selling oranges and oranges and
  58. grapefruit alone. There's a lot more to the Israeli economy. And then comes the great uh privatization wave that begins
  59. in the 1980s and has really continued to our own day. stateowned industries are sold off. Um, and there's a kind of
  60. neoliberal economy where now Israel is one of the world centers really for investment from abroad and of economic
  61. innovation. It's seen uh as a world center for high-tech innovation in particular, but all kinds of innovation,
  62. right? Um, and uh I'm wondering to what extent uh the military in Israel has has
  63. played a role in that development of high-tech. How closely related are those two? They're very closely related now.
  64. They are in pretty much any country. So take aerospace and develops in California and you know the United
  65. States from uh World War II on. So clearly high-tech innovation in the United States, the internet came after
  66. all out of the US military. So that kind of connection is not unique to Israel. The difference is that the United States
  67. has this massive economy and as big as the military is in the US, there's an enormous consumer-driven business-driven
  68. economy. Israel is a smaller country with a smaller economy and the military is far more pervasive. So there's a lot
  69. more direct applications of military technology to the private sector. So it can be that some kind of programming
  70. that was developed let's say to help provide directional assistance to fighter aircraft might then become used
  71. in GPS um for for civilian automobiles. This sort of thing the much more direct transfer of technology. So uh over over
  72. history there's been other groups that have had um prominent merchant classes that also uh went to other parts of the
  73. world and established beach heads. I'm thinking of particularly the the Chinese throughout Southeast Asia uh where um
  74. they are often some of the chief merchant classes in some of the big cities in Southeast Asia even today
  75. although they are a a tiny percentage of the population. uh and India is another
  76. example where uh there's there's been a lot of merchant activity many much of which has or some of which has gone
  77. overseas. So there's a diaspora for from India of business people. How do those groups uh how are they similar to what's
  78. happened in Israel and to Jews over the years and how how do they differ? Well, there's there's two different ways of
  79. answering the question. One is that Jews until really 1948 were almost like a a periphery or a diaspora without a
  80. center. That is spiritually they had this notion of the land of Israel as their center. But that wasn't really
  81. their physical demographic home. So they were like a donut as it were, but there's no center in the donut. And they
  82. dealt with each other throughout the Jewish world. So you've got that Jewish merchant in New York who's got the
  83. colleague or the relative in Cleveland and someone in Los Angeles. So there's a lot of horizontal integration. And
  84. something similar happened of course with let's say Indian merchants throughout um much of Africa throughout
  85. British Africa. The difference is that there was a homeland. There was a homeland and although some of these
  86. Indian merchants never saw that homeland some of them did uh you know you have Mahandas Gandhi for example who's in his
  87. case an attorney from Gujarat in India but then he winds up making his career partially in South Africa and then comes
  88. back to India. there is a center, there's a place to go back to for Israel, for the state of Israel, that
  89. only happens in 1948. Then you have a state. But until really the 1970s, you don't have lots and lots of Israelis
  90. living abroad as you do now. Now there's an Israeli diaspora of who knows half a
  91. million, as many as a million living in the United States. They have very close ties, including economic ties with the
  92. state of Israel. So I'd say now the Israeli diaspora relates to Israel economically the way that the Indian
  93. diaspora or the Chinese diaspora of the past may have dealt with their homelands. So it's become more similar
  94. since it's becoming more similar because Israel is a normal state in that sense and the Israeli diaspora is a normal
  95. diaspora. Uh Israel as as I mentioned is well known for being innovative for being
  96. innovative in high-tech in particular. Are are there attributes of the Israeli economy related to that that can be
  97. adopted or adapted by other countries that see that success and and you know just as they would look at Silicon
  98. Valley and say how can we develop something like that in our country? Well, theoretically, yes, but it might
  99. be difficult because there are national cultures. There are ways of behaving. And if you look at Israel and the way,
  100. for example, the high-tech sector works in Israel, there's tremendous informality. There are authority
  101. structures, but they're very loose and you can challenge authority. You can challenge your boss and things uh are
  102. are much less well organized. There's a lot more improvisation. So the question is whether these corporate cultures in
  103. other parts of the world are frankly willing to loosen up uh the way that Israel has uh Israelis also they bring
  104. into the project a lot of intellectual independence um and one has to be willing to listen to a lot of that and
  105. so it has to be much more of a group sort of decision-making process than an individualistic one. Uh what I don't
  106. know if it can be translated as easily is the sense Israelis have of a very strong solidarity which keeps them
  107. united despite the often lack of the the lack of strong authority structures. Israel has a sense of common threat
  108. whether it's real or perceived is not the issue. There's that sense and uh there's a sense of sort of Jewish
  109. solidarity. Whether one can replicate that in other parts of the world, I'm not sure. But the actual chain of
  110. command, the way decisions are taken on a daily basis, the way brainstorming takes place. Yes, of course, one could
  111. try to replicate that. Uh, one last question. Any idea what the next iteration of the Israeli economy might
  112. look like? Are you seeing anything today that's moving on? That's that's a departure from what we tend to think
  113. about or or think we know about the Israeli economy today. Well, one thing's for sure. uh Israel shows every sign of
  114. continuing to be uh a world leader in many aspects of uh of high-tech but it's it's not just that and the fact is
  115. Israel does have competition and it's not just the United States and Canada there's the European Union and I mean
  116. Israel is not alone in this and there is a concern in Israel that uh inadequate government funding uh if the startup
  117. funding for example the investment funding that comes from venture capital uh capitalists all over the world if
  118. this were to dry up then the Israeli startup economy would dry up. So, Israel in some ways is very vulnerable. What I
  119. think might begin to happen is that Israel will become not only a leader in the development of new technologies, but
  120. the adaption of existing ones, the exist, for example, desalination, which 30 years ago was considered outrageously
  121. expensive and simply impracticable. But Israel is now uh adopting desalination that I think is providing up to 70% of
  122. the country's drinking water. the country will actually have a water surplus in a few years. This would have
  123. been absolutely unheard of. They're using technology which is in part homegrown. A lot of it's come from from
  124. elsewhere. So Israel's innovation isn't simply that they're developing things at
  125. home. It's also what they make use of comes from what comes from the outside. So a second last question which is um
  126. what haven't I asked you that would be interesting for viewers to understand about the Israeli economy? I think what
  127. would be really interesting to understand I guess two things. One is similarities and differences between the
  128. Israeli economy and its Jewishness, however we can define that, and American Jews because American Jews by and large
  129. are is a very successful ethnic religious minority. Uh but it does not display as an aggregate it seems the
  130. same kind of thirst for innovation that one finds in the state of Israel. American Jews are by and large a
  131. comfortable and successful minority. And if anything, the innovative aspects of that community are being bled away by
  132. success. You know, 50, 60 years ago, American Jews, the first generations to go to university, they worked very hard.
  133. They had to be innovative to to make it in the world. Whereas now, they're more comfortable and they can trod in, you
  134. know, wellestablished paths in business, in the professions. Whereas in Israel, there still is this still is this kind
  135. of thirst to to succeed. And the other thing I would sort of want to mention gets back to where we started
  136. is is it even appropriate to ask these questions about the Jewishness of an Israeli economy. So um I would just say
  137. that in other parts of the world in China and in India there's much less embarrassment about talking about the
  138. relationship between culture and economics. Scholars of Indian studies simply do this all the time. What
  139. they're careful about and I would finish with this. There's a difference between
  140. saying that there can be a cultural influence behind economic behavior and some sort of determinant that people
  141. because they belong to a certain ethnic community or identify with it that they are automatically blessed or cursed or
  142. you know predetermined to succeed or to fail economically. There's enormous parameters, enormous spectrum of
  143. possibilities. This is not an issue of race. This is not an issue of uh genetics. This is an issue of culture.
  144. culture is fluid and organic and all we're talking about is a field of possibilities which in the case of
  145. Israel they've managed to realize. Thanks very much for joining us. You're welcome.
  146. [Music]

Brief Summary

Derek Pensler discusses Jewish economic behavior and the evolution of the Israeli economy from socialism to capitalism.

Key points

  • The Jewish Approach to Economics. Exploring the unique features of Jewish economic behavior and its historical context.
  • Transformation of the Israeli Economy. A look at how Israel's economy shifted from socialism to capitalism over the decades.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes