Microfinance and Gender: Why All Inequality Is Not Created Equal

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Microfinance programs aim to reduce poverty by making loans available to poor people who, more often than not, are women. But the relative local power of the patriarchy can affect how those programs work in surprising ways, Wharton's Tyler Wry says. 📂 ESG 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. the research looks at the lending practices of global microfinance organizations microfinance organizations
  2. are small financial institutions that make loans to poor people in the developing world
  3. the idea behind these organizations is that by extending financial products to poor people you can actually help them
  4. disrupt cycles of poverty so lots of people are really really excited about these organizations and in particular
  5. because they lend to women at a high rate and this is important because women tend to be poor both around the world
  6. and within every country they're in so the research that I'm doing here starts to look at the relationship between
  7. patriarchy and the lending practices of these microfinance organizations and what we do in the paper is start to look
  8. at different ways that patriarchy manifests in a society and how it effects these practices in some
  9. counterintuitive ways so the baseline finding is that when you have a high level of patriarchy in the stage in
  10. religion in the professions and in the family so really suppressing women that makes it harder for microfinance
  11. organizations to lend to them for a number of different reasons mostly due to a difficulty in attracting resources
  12. so it's tough to attract money tough to attract actually female customers and it
  13. can also be tough to attract female employees through actually the people who had make and monitor the loans now
  14. what's interesting is we see some countries where patriarchy is stronger in some sectors than others so you see
  15. women being particularly disadvantaged in religion in the family but they have a more equal influence a greater
  16. presence in government and in the professions and what we see in these countries is we actually see the
  17. greatest outreach to women and it seems to be that this contrast between high levels of gender and equality in some
  18. sectors and lower in others actually creates awareness of women's issues and a motivation to do something about them
  19. so we see lots more local funding support for these microfinance organizations we also see many more
  20. women employees in these organizations as well as women loan officers and this appears to be driving the effect of
  21. higher levels of lending to women so the key takeaways from this are one that if you're in the microfinance
  22. industry it's not enough to pay attention just to economic factors we have a lot of research that looks at the
  23. business environment and the quality of internal practices and microfinance organizations and how this affects their
  24. operations in their outreach but I think what this research really shows is that
  25. if you're not taking into account things like patriarchy and other sources of inequality in a society you're really
  26. missing half of the picture and particularly in these countries where there's either high levels of gender
  27. inequality across sectors or low levels where it actually seems to mask inequality in some ways you need to do
  28. different things to actually ensure you're getting the outreach that you want so when patriarchy is high across the
  29. board probably important for these organizations to start looking at foreign sources of funding because the
  30. local support just isn't there now on the flip side in countries that are more equal across the board the research
  31. really implies that you know there's probably a need for some awareness and some outreach efforts to actually
  32. educate people that women's issues and women's poverty is still important to address now in addition to that there's
  33. a broader implication in terms of thinking about the cultural environment of business and social outreach so the
  34. research that's out there right now tends to focus on cultural or institutional pressures as things that
  35. lead business to do good in society and the rationale is the business is profit seeking it's instrumental and it would
  36. not do good things if it were not for external pressures with people saying we will reward you for doing this or punish
  37. you if you don't now what we show in this paper is that's part of the story sure but if you really want to
  38. understand social outreach of organizations like microfinance or theoretically any kind of organization
  39. you need to understand the sources of the problem that is trying to address so if it's trying to address poverty you
  40. need to understand where poverty comes from if it's trying to address women's issues you need to understand how these
  41. are rooted in society and the different ways that this pushes back against the efforts that actually do good in the
  42. world so the most surprising thing for us when we started to look at this data was the
  43. observation of countries that have this more mixed profile of gender inequality the assumption in the literature to date
  44. has been that gender inequality is pervasive in society and it is to a certain extent but this has led to an
  45. empirical strategy where people are measuring patriarchy with a single measure or an index measure and the
  46. assumption is you know the stronger page the patriarchy is in society the greater
  47. effect that's gonna have so when we started to decompose this and look at different indicators and see how they
  48. didn't always cluster together this was really surprising it's a different way of modeling gender inequality in a
  49. society and we were surprised not only to see it in existence but also to see the kinds of effects that drove in terms
  50. of the local support for microfinance so I mean by far the most surprising thing
  51. about the paper so I think an interesting story in the news that's relevant to this research is
  52. the the new government in Canada so the Liberal Party came in after 12 years of conservative rule and Prime Minister
  53. Trudeau he has decided that half of his cabinet ministers are gonna be women now
  54. I personally think this is a great thing but it initiated a lot of pushback a lot
  55. of consternation of people saying well we need to just have the most qualified people and this is discrimination
  56. against men and this really gets it one of the things in the paper which is when
  57. you have a society that is more egalitarian at least ostensibly even though women are so systematically
  58. disadvantaged in these countries I mean including Canada which you know you think of Canada this great progressive
  59. place but women still are more likely to be poor and more likely to live in extreme poverty but it gets masked and
  60. so you get this pushback when someone like Trudeau comes in and says you know we need to have more women represented
  61. in our cabinet with people thinking well wait no this is discriminating against men when an actual fact you know women
  62. still are disadvantaged so this is something that we were picking up at our paper as well as it relates the
  63. microfinance and I think the example of the Canadian government nicely illustrates how it applies in something
  64. and even as contemporary as you know Canadian democracy so I think one misperception this might
  65. dispel is you can understand gender inequality as a single thing so the common perception is that gender
  66. inequality ranges from strong to weak in a society and we really start to unpack
  67. that and show that it's not always the case and that when you start to get into this deeper level of analysis you can
  68. actually see some things work and that wouldn't be apparent otherwise in addition to that and you know consistent
  69. with my last answer you know I think that we really show that you know it's not enough to just assume that because a
  70. marginalized group has made advances in society that there aren't still marginalized in deeper more fundamental
  71. ways so you know even in Canada women are still poor even the United States Sweden you know in this perception that
  72. you know just because there's been advances doesn't mean there's still not work to do you know I think we nicely
  73. push back against that and show no you know there is stuff you need to do and you know especially in microfinance in
  74. the developing world there is a big need even in ostensibly more egalitarian societies and if we're not paying
  75. attention to this we're really missing one of the fundamental things that microfinance er any other similar
  76. poverty reduction intervention is trying to accomplish so one of the things that really sets a
  77. study apart from existing research that's been done is it's the first that's looked at the influence of
  78. patriarchy on the lending practices of these organizations research to date at least the big large-scale empirical
  79. research has tended to use an economic or finance perspective and they look at all sorts of great things and they drive
  80. all sorts of important insight but it misses this cultural dimension and so by bringing this to the table we're giving
  81. a richer picture of the environment these organizations work in and some of the contextual features that affect the
  82. prospects or their success or failure as it relates the social outreach now in addition to that our study as it relates
  83. to gender inequality goes well beyond what's been done so far so instead of looking at gender inequality with a
  84. single variable we're decomposing it into multiple measures and showing that when you do
  85. this one you get a more fine-grained understand you know some of the mechanisms that are driving the effects
  86. that we're interested in but also you see things that wouldn't be apparent at all with a single indicator so all of
  87. the stuff about this contrast between high levels of gender equality in some parts of society and lower in others you
  88. know this is really the action in our paper it's really what drives the effect and if you looked at it the way that
  89. people have been so far and studies of gender and gender inequality you'd miss this entirely
  90. we plan to follow up on this by looking at different dimensions of outreach by microfinance as well as some different
  91. forms of poverty and how these work in similar or different ways to gender inequality and what this means for the
  92. actual internal operations of these microfinance organizations so we've started to expand the analysis beyond
  93. just gender inequality to look at other institutionalized forms of inequality in
  94. poverty in society so things based on religious ethnic linguistic fractionalization and what this does the
  95. outreach of these organizations and we're also starting to look at how the nature of poverty be it rooted in gender
  96. or other forms of systematic discrimination affect the balance between social outreach and financial
  97. performance of these microfinance organizations and what's interesting is we're starting to see that the level at
  98. which the social and the financial performance has become compatible versus pulling apart from each other has really
  99. systematically affected not only by the quality of market institutions in a country but also the nature of poverty
  100. so in poverty is categorical so it's based in gender other forms of categorical inequality the transaction
  101. costs are higher for these organizations in terms of the outreach that they're doing and this makes it much more
  102. expensive to try and address poverty and really starts to tweak the level at which you can do sustainable outreach so
  103. that's where it's going be interesting to see you know what comes next after that
  104. you

Brief Summary

Microfinance practices are influenced by patriarchy, affecting women's access to loans and outreach efforts.

Key points

  • Microfinance and Gender Inequality. Research shows that patriarchy affects lending practices in microfinance organizations, impacting women's access to loans.
  • Surprising Findings on Gender Inequality. The study reveals that gender inequality is not a single measure but a complex issue with mixed profiles.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes