Is Dynamic Pricing a Hit?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Despite the customer dislike for dynamic pricing, researchers are finding out that it can be an effective tool for many businesses that do not experience equilibrium when it comes to demand. More: http://knlg.net/29korRy 📂 Finance & Accounting;Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton marketing professor peter fader and wharton professor of operations information and
  2. decisions senthil Vera Gavin to talk about their new paper which discusses dynamic pricing of major league baseball
  3. tickets thanks for being here great to be with you Rachel so first off could you guys talk to us a little bit give us
  4. a brief summary of the paper what did you study and what were you looking at so in a major league baseball in
  5. professional sports in the entertainment world in general there's been this this
  6. Great Awakening that the action take care about the business side of the business it's not just a matter putting
  7. the best players on the field or the best performers on stage and of course a big part of that is pricing so for years
  8. and years again all these different kinds of companies have just come up with arbitrary prices and they've kind
  9. of relied on secondary markets in order to kind of reach the white the right equilibrium well it's great to see that
  10. a lot of major league baseball clubs among others in this this general area are finally getting smart and saying we
  11. want to take control of this we want to set the right prices and part of that means dynamic pricing part of that means
  12. adjusting the price is over time some charging different prices different people depending on the nature of the
  13. game and so on so a lot of clubs have been just trying it out but not a lot of them have actually stepped back to say
  14. is it working can we do it better what's the incremental impact of one kind of pricing policy or another so we were
  15. very fortunate to be able to work with a club that was asking those kinds of questions and through it just a really
  16. clever data set and some pretty clever modeling I think we came up with some pretty good answers and some tell you
  17. everything dad it's a it's a very interesting problem it's a confluence of exciting cutting-edge research with a
  18. practical application that goes directly onto the field literally in this case right so and now so can you guys talk to
  19. us a little bit about you found some interesting key takeaways from this paper a bit might surprise a lot of
  20. people who are out there buying baseball tickets or maybe not one of the things that we found out is people talk a lot
  21. about dynamic pricing it has a lot of customer response to dynamic pricing a well-chosen price even if it's static
  22. just as well that's one thing we learned from this project which we had some inkling about but we
  23. were really surprised how well a well-chosen static price dead that's one of our surprising findings and of course
  24. there's the flip side to it as well which is dynamic pricing isn't a panacea just because you're varying the prices
  25. doesn't mean you're necessarily making more money and in fact in this particular case if we look at the
  26. dynamic pricing policy at this one club followed over this one portion of a season they actually they actually lost
  27. money I relative to to the the static policy that they had at the beginning so it's it's funny that just right balance
  28. between what should be dynamic and essential said in some cases we can pick the just right prices why even bother
  29. changing things at all now but i would think that picking the just right price is easier said than done that is true if
  30. if there is a magic bullet so to speak that's distributable we would be able to do that right I think context specific
  31. application is very important here it's it's a relationship as bit often talks about between the customers you want to
  32. serve and the team you wanna run and the organization one around and in this case
  33. that data is useful to understand what kind of policies would work yeah we can improve but it's very specific data has
  34. that information they can convert the data into good pricing policies and I think that's why it's such a great
  35. collaboration over here because I do spend my time thinking about the relationships and thinking about all the
  36. nuances of where demand comes from and sentio and his colleagues in our oh I d department it's been about I'm thinking
  37. about optimizing and very often each of us doesn't do justice to the other side so our build these really great
  38. descriptive models but I fall short on the so what and very often folks in the optimization world will build overly
  39. simplistic models because it enhances the optimization part this is that just right combination we have a really rich
  40. description of how people are buying tickets when and for what sections and what are they willing to pay for so it's
  41. a nice story about customer behavior but it lends itself pretty well to the optimization as well that's right as I
  42. said it's a confluence of how people behave and what models you can run in the background and how we can bring it to
  43. business applications today yeah and now you guys had some pretty interesting ways like one thing that I think really
  44. comes out in the papers there's lots of different ways that a baseball team in particular and probably really anyone
  45. that wants to do this good dynamic price I mean so you talked about the seat and
  46. you talked about how well the team is doing and a bunch of different ways to do this so we talked about it a couple
  47. of different levels so as you just mentioned Rachel a lot of it would be the factors that should be taken into
  48. account when deriving a dynamic pricing policy and you just mentioned a few of them there and it's great that and
  49. that's not an academic exercise that a lot of professional sports teams and and and other kinds of businesses are
  50. starting to take those factors into account so one is on the input side what factors should we be looking at and how
  51. to adjust for them but then there's on the kind of on the output side in terms of setting the policies and again this
  52. is sent those expertise about you know should we be looking ahead or not well anyway you can talk more about the
  53. nature of the different kinds of pricing policies and to me it's been an education just to think about the
  54. different ways that we can go out there with policies I mean we're we're all learning different things from this
  55. problem as we talked about it's very class disciplinary and one of the things is how far do you look ahead when you
  56. said your dynamic pricing policies do you look ahead ten games three games how often do you change how do you
  57. communicate that and these things matter and these things are just customer responses and that's going to feed back
  58. into the policies that you're going to come up with so people think of dynamic pricing as an evil or a panacea we
  59. talked about it the truth is somewhere in the middle it's you can go to the same solution and do it poorly because
  60. of how you use the information so in this case before example found out if there is more people in the group that's
  61. buying tickets they are more likely to buy from certain sections of the stadium and in my batter sections of this cherry
  62. that are surprising to me as a marketing person maybe that's not immediately surprising but that's not what the
  63. models usually assume so it becomes relevant to understand your customers to take the data from your from your
  64. understanding of the problem and apply it and start thinking about dynamic pricing so how many games you should
  65. look at should you look at your opponents should you look at the day of the game the weather all these things
  66. models did you revisit if they go into a bad streak yeah when you go into a bad streak then you cannot be charging too
  67. high so you have to think about revising prices downloads I mean just kind of think about sometimes there's a team
  68. that could be you know they could tell they could say in April well this is the team that's going to the World Series or
  69. the Super Bowl or whatever you want to say but then by September they've tanked well that's actually one of the issues
  70. that happened in this case so actually the whole setting of the model is kind of interesting that this particular
  71. major league baseball team didn't use dynamic pricing for the first half of the season so we were able to calibrate
  72. all of our demand and response models based on what we see for you know the first 40 games or so and then we can
  73. project what would happen in the latter part of the season if they didn't introduce dynamic pricing so we have
  74. this really good baseline about what sales would have been and we look at the difference in order to say how well did
  75. the dynamic pricing work well we didn't know it at the time but the team did not
  76. do well in the second part of the season they they went way way way down and so it's not so much that we can blame the
  77. dynamic pricing policy but the team went into an area that we hadn't observed in
  78. the first part of the data set so you know that's just the nature of building a model and kind of rolling with it that
  79. sometimes things will happen out there that you can control you can anticipate right now tell me a little bit so if im
  80. a im another major league baseball team or even a minor league baseball team or anyone where this could be anytime soon
  81. this could be applied any number of ways i know you've done something with some things with like concert tickets things
  82. like that Peter my boys are now nonprofits which I looked at it too that's exactly I mean you you are a
  83. baseball team you know mindedly clean you're an international team you know a soccer team cricket team or or even a
  84. non-profit arts organization you have already the data that can tell you what how you can think about this problem
  85. where we come in and tell you is this information is very key it's important and this is how we can use this
  86. information and I just shared policies so on one hand the I think the the framework that
  87. we've built is fairly general because we're using pretty common set of factors and data structures and so on but the
  88. specific results I'm not sure that we'd want to generalize from those I think the particular weight that different
  89. factors might have the relative differences between different kinds of pricing policies that is going to be
  90. context specific but I am pretty confident that if we took the overall model and then recalibrate it in another
  91. setting it would continue to work well maybe with just slightly different results what I'm wondering so if I'm REE
  92. if I'm an organization i'm looking at this how might i practically apply the research part of it is just gaining the
  93. overall understanding so before we even worry about specific estimated coefficients or any of the numbers that
  94. are in the paper as we've said before just thinking about what are the factors that you'd want to take into account and
  95. operationally can you create a situation again that we were fortunate to have here where we have this control
  96. condition where there was no dynamic pricing going on so we get a clean read so once we kind of press that button and
  97. start it we can understand what's happening what's attributable to it so there's things both in terms of what we
  98. put into the model as well as just the overall way that it played out in practice that that can be generalized
  99. and I hope that folks would focus more on on those kind of operational factors more than specific results arising from
  100. it that's very important point actually a lot of times people say yeah you could
  101. do this but what if it happens what if something else happens and by doing this kind of experimental data base study
  102. you're able to answer those questions using counterfactual ti what if the team got on a hot streak this is what you
  103. should be doing what if the show is so successful or what if the lead actor leaves what do you do and we can have
  104. answers to these kind of questions using the model applications and as pitted the
  105. actual results may vary from case to case but the fundamental application remains the same now is there a story in
  106. the media that you guys think really relates to this research that really kind of puts it into a new light door
  107. relates to it in general I think there's a not only a current story but an ongoing
  108. story as I said at the outset justice all this this consternation among professional sports organizations about
  109. the existence of and the profitability of secondary markets so a lot of this project arose from a large-scale project
  110. I had done with Major League Baseball I was very pleased that one of the clubs wanted to go further with it in that
  111. project with MLB the questioners should they continue to use stubhub as their exclusive secondary ticket provider and
  112. most of the teams agree to do so some of the teams opted out including the New York Yankees and just this week the
  113. Yankees change their policy on that and they're they're coming back to step up albeit with conditions but it's but the
  114. point is that if this this whole situation is far from settled so you have a lot of teams that are doing the
  115. kinds of modeling experiments like we see going on over here and as a whole it's it's going to be just a lot more
  116. changes taking place we hope that it's not just trial and error we hope that it's going to be the club's include and
  117. the secondary ticket providers are just getting smarter and and and actually in some sense reducing the opportunities
  118. for arbitrage and some of the game playing that goes on just by anticipating what the right prices will
  119. be and hallo very under different kinds of circumstances yeah pretty much an ugly bunted that I mean do you feel like
  120. the secondary markets have really put a lot of pressure on the teams or on concert I Ranh Bay Aaron concert
  121. promoters or anybody just to really look more closely at this from their perspective just because they know the
  122. secondary market is out there and it's something that's very relevant to anyone who's buying tickets in a way the
  123. existence of the secondary markets has and the success of them has been a great wake-up call to these organizations the
  124. fact that they're now putting so many resources internally into doing the kind of modeling and experimentation that
  125. were endorsing here it used to be that they would take all the analytic talent and save it for the money ball people
  126. let's go out there and just find the best players but now they want to find the best analysts who can help them sell
  127. tickets at the right prices to the right people it's good to see that there dare
  128. I say leveling the playing field exactly i mean at some level they owned the content as we speak right
  129. they own the content they can control the content they can they understood that concert better so who else right
  130. can benefit more from these kind of pricing adjustments than the content providers themselves right i mean you
  131. can you can get the best players but you still have to get butts on the seat now
  132. do you feel like there are i think i mean i think there's a lot of views about Dana epidemic pricing out there
  133. you've got people to think it's the worst thing in the world and people think that's the best thing ever I mean
  134. do you think there's other misconceptions that this research kind of dispels one of the things that again
  135. we going back to what we got surprised by is you could do very well with the well set static pricing again well set
  136. that is a hard problem so dynamic pricing gives you flexibility to adjust and this is very important it'll
  137. actually can help a team to reach out as fans and consumers to it's not necessarily the bad thing for both the
  138. team and the facts under consider that might be the biggest revelation not just from this one study but from this this
  139. broader project that I was involved with and when I first started talking to Major League Baseball they were very
  140. reluctant a lot of clouds are very reluctant to try dynamic pricing it seemed first of all scary it's unknown a
  141. second they worried about some kind of backlash that fans would feel that they're being gouged and so on it's been
  142. great to see how well-received dynamic pricing has been the clubs have been careful about it and so they have an
  143. overreach there's been very few stories about any kind of backlash and from the fan side we're getting used to it we're
  144. understanding that the what we see whether it's with with airplanes now with professional sports when it comes
  145. to a ride-sharing services that that dynamic pricing is here to stay and as long as companies are doing it in a
  146. smart way and as long as they have the long run in mind and not trying to squeeze as many dollars they can right
  147. now it really can be in everywhere in everybody's best interest now what's next for this research where are you
  148. going to go next with it lots of direction is actually I mean we we have interest from many places so we're
  149. actually we just hope there is more time to do all this stuff and and better data too we were very
  150. fortunate to get that the data that this one club provided but there's so much more than they could provide so there's
  151. other sources of revenue such as concessions and merchandise that they're selling there can be other sources of
  152. customer behavior in this case we didn't have full granularity to track exactly which household was buying which ticket
  153. at which time so we could link that together to come up with a better notion of what the true demand is so in many
  154. ways this is the this is the tip of the iceberg this is the top of the first inning I think it's going to be a long
  155. game ahead for understanding the role of dynamic pricing in this setting and so many others well I guess we'll see you
  156. back for your next to your next base hit so sex L Peter thank for thank you so much for being to Magnus
  157. you

Brief Summary

Wharton professors discuss dynamic pricing for MLB tickets, revealing static pricing can be equally effective and sometimes more profitable.

Key points

  • Surprising Findings on Static Pricing. Research reveals that well-chosen static prices can perform just as well as dynamic pricing.
  • Dynamic Pricing in Major League Baseball. A discussion on how dynamic pricing affects ticket sales and customer behavior in MLB.
  • The Future of Dynamic Pricing. Experts discuss the ongoing evolution of dynamic pricing strategies in sports and entertainment.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes