How To Turn Online Data Into a Pricing Strategy That Works

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Recent Wharton research examines how retailers can use online data to create effective pricing policies. More: http://knlg.net/2iFse5x 📂 Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. We're here today with Ken Moon, a Wharton professor of operations, information, and decision, and he's here
  2. to talk to us about some of his recent research. Ken, thanks for being with us. Oh, thank you so much. So, first of all,
  3. could you give us kind of a short summary of what you looked at, what you're trying to find out? Um, so I I do
  4. research in empirical operations. So, um, basically that means two things. One, I I work with data. Um, typically
  5. sometimes in collaboration with uh companies, hospitals, marketplaces. Um, and second, I'm really trying to be uh
  6. prescriptive about decision- making in my research. Um, in this particular project, uh, we work with an a retailer
  7. that's active online. Um, it was a very, uh, detailed customer level data set. Uh, what's kind of interesting about it
  8. is that you can track a single customer um, both online and offline. So, for instance, if the customer today were to
  9. um go on their phone, look at a product, go to their computer tomorrow, look at that, and then walk into a store on
  10. another day and actually buy it, we would be able to track all of those things. Um, so it really opened up a lot
  11. of avenues to explore there. And um I think uh one thing that's very interesting about uh this particular
  12. project was that we were able to look at a very information-rich environment in a
  13. way that I think um we see in our everyday lives. So, not only can we browse in that way and have a lot more
  14. information, say we think a product that we're interested in might drop in price,
  15. we can check our smartphone. Um, it's also the case now that uh these companies can actually track all of this
  16. information um at a very individual level. Um, so for both sides, it's a very information-rich environment. And
  17. so it's very interesting um to think about how does that affect uh the decisions of say companies that are
  18. active in this sort of space but also um how does that affect outcomes for for customers and consumers right I mean
  19. price monitoring has really become kind of a daily part at least of my life I know so when you were looking at this
  20. data set what did you find about price monitoring um I think one uh sort of broad takeaway
  21. is that information seems to matter um so you do have customers who are very intensive in their monitoring. Um
  22. they're typically the more price sensitive customers actually, but also their opportunity cost to be doing this
  23. sort of monitoring is very low. So they're going to be checking very often. Um and your most price insensitive
  24. customers actually uh they're not checking very often. It's about every 20 days on average between uh visits. Um so
  25. it's a very big difference in terms of how these uh consumers are able to access information even from this very
  26. ubiquitous channel. Um, and it makes a big difference in terms of outcomes as well. Now, is there a clear indication
  27. of how companies should be doing this? Like how they should be playing with price based on how someone's looking at
  28. and monitoring price? Should we be doing one thing or does it depend on the customer or No, that's it's it's very
  29. interesting. It was it was that's exactly uh those are exactly some of the issues that we wanted to explore in this
  30. research. And um uh one of the interesting things that we found is that even in this very uh rich
  31. informationally rich space um sometimes very simple uh policies and very simple decisions can be very
  32. effective. You can capture most of the value as a firm. Um so to give you two examples um the retailer that we worked
  33. with follows a very simple pricing policy for each product. You're going to start at a certain price, a list price,
  34. and then at a certain point in time during its season, you drop uh the price down to its sale price, which is a very
  35. predictable percentage of that initial list price. And then finally, you move to another predictable price, a
  36. clearance price, where you're trying to just get the products out of the off the
  37. shelves. And um what's interesting there is that the consumers understand what prices they'll see. Um it's very
  38. predictable. Um but all that the retailer did is to make the timing of those markdowns unpredictable.
  39. And by doing something very simple like that um it really uh uh uh exacerbated theformational
  40. uh asymmetry in terms of the cost of monitoring. So those customers who were price insensitive who um it was very
  41. costly for them to be monitoring often they were the ones who couldn't take advantage of a markdown when it happened
  42. and they understood that. So then um they would buy earlier. So there's an interesting aspect there where um this
  43. sort of pricing has an allocative role. You're deciding who buys at what price because it seems like I mean it seems
  44. like more companies and maybe correct me if I'm wrong that more companies have moved towards more unpredictable
  45. pricing. I mean, it used to be it seems like that, you know, there was there was
  46. the price, then it went on sale, then it went on clearance, and now it seems to be like, you know, one day it could be
  47. 50% off, one day it could be 30, the next day it could be full price, and then it could be 50 again. I mean, it
  48. seems like companies are actually moving towards that as opposed to predictability. And is that hurting
  49. them? I think it depends on the market. And an interesting thing is that um in this sort of setting, we find that being
  50. predictable, being simple, but also having this um uh some degree of flexibility is actually the right way to
  51. go. So um you are capturing from the firm's perspective uh most of that value. An interesting thing there I
  52. think that you're sort of mentioning is that um uh if you think about an industry where that sort of uh quickly
  53. changing pricing has been very successful. An example would be the airline industry where you might be on a
  54. plane and you sit next to someone who's paid a very different price for for the same ticket. U for in I'm pretty price
  55. sensitive so I might have bought a cheaper ticket. Um and the other thing in that setting is when they do that
  56. very successfully um the plane tends to be full. So they tend to be able to allocate all of um the seats that they
  57. have. So that's sort of the price I think you pay for having that cheaper ticket. But the same message carries
  58. over into this setting. We find that when you do this sort of pricing correctly um with these um simple sort
  59. of policies, you're actually able to sell a lot more units. you're actually able to put more products profitably in
  60. the hands of more people who want uh those products and also um with these simple uh policies you're actually able
  61. to get more of those products into the hands of uh the consumers who want them the most. Um so there's an allocative uh
  62. role there. So uh I think an important message here is that um from a consumer welfare standpoint uh this sort of uh
  63. pricing um can have um ripple effects that have positive implications. So if I'm a retailer and looking at this
  64. research, what are some ways that practical ways that retailers could kind of apply this or some sort of advice or
  65. takeaways that they could have from it that they could use in their business? Uh I I think one is um to uh to be able
  66. to understand why certain price uh policies might work including ones that you're using already. So in this case um
  67. our retailer one thing that was interesting is we asked them why are you using this type of policy and they
  68. almost think of the customer sort of like a pet or a dog where if you train them the wrong way they'll just start
  69. expecting to wait for a markdown. Um so this was their way actually um heristically of uh sort of uh not
  70. training the customer by introducing this uncertainty making them unsure but actually what we found is you have
  71. different types of customers who have these different costs of monitoring this channel and that's really what's driving
  72. um what was good about this way of pricing. Um so one is to um if you have a lot of data be able to understand even
  73. with a simple policy why is it effective. Um and the second message there was that um again going to the
  74. sort of uh simplicity um that simple the message that simple works um in this setting where you were
  75. trying to say give coupons to your most price sensitive uh customers identify who they are and you have this mountain
  76. of data recording all of their behavior online. Um what we find is that uh there's some very strong signals from
  77. that data. So you only need a few things. Um if you look at how people monitor online the frequency with with
  78. which they monitor that's a very strong signal of their price elasticity. So um you actually don't need to take you
  79. don't need to always be using all of that information. Tracking something very simple like the ratio of purchases
  80. to visits online is actually a very strong signal and captures almost all of that value um that you would have from
  81. uh sophist a sophisticated analysis of all the data. And so what's next for this research or
  82. what are you planning on looking at next? Um I I think directly um there uh the most related thing would be looking
  83. at these sort of informationational costs, these frictions um in a number of other settings. Um uh I'm I'm doing some
  84. work in online marketplaces and and other places where you can get very interesting data um at the sort of
  85. granular level. Um but more broadly I think there are a lot of settings that are becoming much more informationally
  86. rich whether it's um firms that are able to track you online or um uh as a patient or in a marketplace or or even
  87. in the workplace. And I think um an important aspect of these changes is to be able to understand how does it affect
  88. um firms who are sort of experimenting to see what can they do with this sort of data but also how should consumers
  89. and workers feel about um uh how comfortable should they feel about these changes. So I think it's a very
  90. interesting space from a research standpoint. You get lots of data so it's very interesting as well and uh um I'm
  91. I'm excited about it. Great. Thanks Ken. Thanks so much for being here. Oh, thank
  92. you. [Music]

Brief Summary

Ken Moon discusses consumer behavior and effective pricing strategies in retail based on his research with detailed customer data.

Key points

  • The Role of Information in Pricing. Ken Moon explores how information affects consumer decision-making and pricing strategies.
  • Simplicity in Pricing Policies. Ken discusses how simple pricing strategies can effectively capture consumer value.
  • Consumer Welfare and Pricing. The implications of pricing strategies on consumer welfare are examined by Ken.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes