Rethinking Tax Refunds and Financial Decision Making

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wendy De La Rosa, Assistant Professor of Marketing at the Wharton School, explores how people think about tax refunds and why those decisions often don’t align with their financial goals.

She explains why many treat refunds as “extra money,” leading to overspending and missed opportunities to save or pay down debt. The conversation also highlights inefficiencies in the tax system, where 20 to 30 percent of refunded dollars are lost to preparation costs, and shares practical strategies like pre-commitment and automation to improve financial outcomes.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. like 20 to 30% of every dollar uh that gets sent back uh through the tax system is being eaten up
  2. by tax preparation costs. Wow. Right. And so we have this like highly inefficient system of filing
  3. our taxes and it doesn't have to be this way. Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the podcast that
  4. takes you on a journey through the minds of Warton faculty. I'm your host Dan Looney and in each
  5. episode we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton
  6. professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today. Well, we
  7. are in the middle of one of everybody's favorite times of the year, tax season. But it is a time of
  8. the year which also gives us the opportunity to try and better understand some of the behaviors
  9. that occur by individuals at this time of the year. When you think about the preparation of
  10. your taxes, are you a procrastinator or not? When you're thinking about potential refunds
  11. or payments, how do you deal with one or the other? Lots to discuss and a pleasure to be
  12. joined by Wendy Dear Rosa, who's an assistant professor of marketing here at the Wharton School,
  13. who also focuses a lot about consumer financial decisionmaking. Hi Wendy, great to catch up again.
  14. How are you? I'm doing well. Excited to be here. Thanks for having me. Yeah, it's great to talk to
  15. you. You know, it it it is kind of an interesting component of the time of the year and I guess from
  16. a behavioral standpoint, uh it does give you the opportunity to gain a lot of information
  17. and data about how people handle these situations. It does. And what we what we know from prior work
  18. is that people tend to think about tax refunds as windfalls. We don't incorporate it into our
  19. regular budgets. We think about this money as sort of special money, which is odd, right? Because
  20. it's our money coming back to us, right? It's it's not a gift from anybody. Um, but what that
  21. means is that we treat that money differently. And often times what we find is that when people start
  22. um elaborating and deeply thinking about and anticipating a tax refund, you start to allocate
  23. that tax refund multiple times over. So, you start to tell yourself, hey, I'm going to use this to
  24. pay down debt. I'm going to use this to maybe put a little bit of money in emergency funds. Hey, I'm
  25. going to use this to uh maybe buy myself something that I've been waiting to buy, especially in this
  26. like, you know, sort of time period where prices have been rising sort of rapidly over the past
  27. couple of years. And what ends up happening is that you sort of mentally spend that money three
  28. times over. you've allocated across so many buckets um that by the time the tax refund
  29. comes in and of itself, we then don't have a real concrete plan. And so we, you know, we talked to
  30. a lot of people that sort of have a little bit of regret on how there they ended up spending
  31. the money. There was sort of this gap between how they planned to do it and how they actually did.
  32. Do you see more people focused on I'll call it a negative in terms of paying down debt more so than
  33. thinking about buying themselves something nice? Like that's the first thing they think about. If
  34. they know they have debt, they associate this as an opportunity to pay that down. Yeah. So we have
  35. sort of this like uh bias in which when we tend to think about our future selves, we tend to think
  36. about the perfect version of our future selves. So in the future you're going to work out more,
  37. you're going to save more, you're going to be a better parent, a better spouse, etc.,
  38. etc., right? Like we all turn into our individual versions of Beyonce in the future. And so today,
  39. when I'm thinking about what I'm going to do for my tax refund in a couple of months,
  40. I'm going to think about all of these things that I think my perfect self would do. paying
  41. down debt or increasing my savings and putting some money away for, you know, my child's 529
  42. account. What happens is when the future becomes the present, I realize that I'm still the same
  43. imperfect self as I was yesterday. And so all of the temptations that come into play sort of come
  44. right when the tax refund hits the account. And so that's sort of the the tension that we have.
  45. So I'll tell you a little bit of an intervention that we did with a company called Digit a couple
  46. of year now a few years ago where understanding this tension this gap between what I intend to do
  47. and what I actually do when the time comes when the rubber hits the road. We send people in this
  48. experiment one of two text messages. In one we said hey you might get a tax refund if you do what
  49. percentage of it would you like to save early in the tax season in January. So people didn't know
  50. if they were going to receive a tax refund or how much. But if they did, they could say 10%, 20%,
  51. 50%. And then if digit notice a tax refund on the account, they automatically move that money from
  52. their checking account into a savings account. In the other condition, we texted people and we said,
  53. "Hey, when they received their tax refund, when did you notice that there was a tax refund?" We
  54. texted people and said, "Hey, what percentage of it would you like to save?" and then you could
  55. tax any percentage and none then digit wouldn't lose that money. That timing difference that
  56. will almost double the amount of savings rates, right? And so here's a tool that people can use
  57. of saying let's precommit ourselves early in the tax season and have a very concrete plan about
  58. how you're going to save that money or how you're going to pay down debt and then create systems.
  59. digit is just one example where that money then automatically flows in the way that you
  60. intend to in January, not in the way that you intend to when right because you have
  61. the element of procrastination and I think sometimes procrastinators tend to be people
  62. who feel like they're going to owe money when they get their taxes done. And that dynamic
  63. then probably presents a higher level of pressure on the individual because they're concerned that
  64. they've worked hard in the last 12 months. they've done, you know, pretty much everything they can
  65. and yet they still owe when the tax return is done. Yeah. You know, 85% of tax filers get
  66. a tax refund. And so, but you are talking about sort of this 15% of the population particularly,
  67. you know, we don't tend to think about this, but gig workers, 1099 workers, so your lift drivers,
  68. your Uber drivers, um, you know, their taxes don't get withheld. And so a lot of them are sort of not
  69. just procrastinated but in shock of how much they have to pay at at towards the end. I think this
  70. year in particular is sort of this unique year in taxes because there's all of this discussion going
  71. around that people are going to see a larger than than usual tax refund as a result of uh
  72. recent regulation changes um around the order of $1,000. And what we're seeing in the data is that
  73. it's bigger, but it's not like I I want to temper expectations. It's not that people are getting
  74. uh on average a tax refund that's high that's more than $1,000 than what they used to do. You know,
  75. the the recent regulations, what they do is that they have disparit impact. So, if you're higher
  76. income, you're actually going to be a little bit more well off uh in terms of your tax refund
  77. than if you're lower income. And according to the latest stats by the IRS, tax refunds are about 10
  78. to 11% higher this year than they were last year. What does that translate to? It means like 300 an
  79. extra 300 to $400. That's not chunk change, right? The average tax refund this year is about $3,600,
  80. which if you're earning minimum wage in the United States, that's the equivalent of more than three
  81. months of your gross income, right? So these are real dollars that have real consequences and one
  82. of our largest poverty alleviation programs is created through the tax system. The component
  83. of planning when people are thinking about their taxes. Are people savvy enough to think about that
  84. this is not in many cases something that you think about after January or you know when February
  85. rolls around that there are elements of this tax preparation that are things that probably can be
  86. considered throughout the course of the year. Oh don't get me started about the inefficiencies of
  87. our tax prep program. Um, you know, I think one of the most like heartbreaking stats,
  88. um, I've come across is for our tax system is sort of the biggest tax system we have, for example,
  89. to fight poverty or to help our seniors, uh, to help working parents. And the heartbreaking stat
  90. that I read is basically like 20 to 30% of every dollar uh that gets sent back uh through the tax
  91. system um is being eaten up by tax preparation costs, right? And so we have this like highly
  92. inefficient system of filing our taxes and it doesn't have to be this way. In fact, um there
  93. are many organizations including code for America who have like helped build up like easy and free
  94. filing tax tools. But your second question comes like why is it so hard? Why is it so hard to plan?
  95. like you know one of the reasons why people are getting a higher than average tax refund this year
  96. which again people treat as a windfall but you can conceptualize this as a loss right this is money
  97. that you're not earning any interest on that it's your money you could have gotten it earlier in the
  98. year is really because the inefficiencies in the system. So for example given recent regulations
  99. there were changes to the tax code but there were no automatic updates to people's withholdings.
  100. Yeah. Yeah. like that's an inefficient system and so you're withholding more money even though you
  101. know that the regulations have changed that the system itself has changed but there was
  102. no automatic update to withholding rates and so that's part of the reason why people are getting
  103. a a higher than average refund and if we had a system in place from employers for example that
  104. really sort of put at the forefront employees financial well-being and sort of got ahead of
  105. this I think we would help in the planning process much Then I I'll ask a version of a question that
  106. I think everybody every expert's being asked right now. Do you think then that artificial
  107. intelligence will have will be able to play a role in making this better as we move forward? Listen,
  108. AI is going to touch every aspect of our society and it's already having a pretty sizable impact in
  109. the accounting field. What I will say is that even in the world before AI, we had tools available
  110. to us such as the free filing tool uh under a different administration where people could file
  111. their taxes for free directly with the IRS. It had an MPS score in the '90s. Like when was the last
  112. time you saw a government tool where people said had an NPS score in the '90s? And that was before
  113. AI. Um, and so while I think AI will be helpful in hopefully making life easier for accountants
  114. and making our lives easier as we file our taxes, a lot of the frictions, the main frictions that
  115. we're talking about, like there's no, we don't need artificial intelligence for we just need
  116. sort of will from our legislative bodies, from consumers to say it doesn't have to be this way.
  117. It doesn't have to be this hard. I don't need to get my CPA in order to file my taxes, right?
  118. Um and and we've done it. What do you think then are are there a couple of components, strategies
  119. that people should really think about? And it's probably again a a thought process that may you
  120. know pop up from time to time over the course of the year so that they can be better prepared in
  121. terms of when they get to tax time so it doesn't become this pressureful you know bomb ready to go
  122. off type of time of the year. Yeah. And so one of the things that um is fascinating is that there
  123. are very predictable patterns in tax filing rates. that you have is sort of this inverted U. Like
  124. right when people there's a bunch of people that as soon as they get their W2, they go and they
  125. like talk to their accountants and they go and they file their taxes uh because they're either
  126. liquidity constrained or they're expecting a large refund or you know what, they just want to get it
  127. out of the way and then there's a big lol um that happens basically in the first couple of weeks of
  128. March. we're in the law right now. And then you have the bunch of people who are like, it's April
  129. 14th. Oh man, I better start thinking about my taxes. Um, and so if if think about who you are
  130. and I would say create your environment in a way that makes your life easier easier for you. So as
  131. you're thinking about setting up the appointment with your tax collector, put a reminder in your
  132. phone in January to make that appointment in March. one, your tax accountant is probably
  133. going to have more time in the in early March than, you know, mid mid April. Um, but then two,
  134. you start to set structures in place of saying, "Here is my plan, you're making it more concrete."
  135. The second thing I would say is we know that when we try to reach our goals, especially our
  136. financial goals, having a buddy, having a partner, and vocalizing it really matters, right? And so
  137. think about talking to your friend and say when I get my tax refund I am going to do X. Have that
  138. accountability with your buddy. But then the third and this is where technology and again it doesn't
  139. have to be AI but just like technology it can be helpful is create a system in place where you can
  140. precommit. So there are companies and and fintech startups that just allow you to say look when
  141. there's a deposit from the IRS automatically send whatever percentage makes sense for you to either
  142. paying down debt to saving to whatever you want so that you don't have to be in the seat when you're
  143. the most tempted to spend to make these decisions. Wendy, always great to talk with you. Thanks very
  144. much for your time today. Oh, always a pleasure. Take care. Thank you. Wendy de la Rosa, assistant
  145. professor of marketing here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to the Ripple Effect. We
  146. hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave
  147. us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Wendy Dear Rosa discusses tax refund behaviors, preparation inefficiencies, and strategies for better financial planning during tax season.

Key points

  • Understanding Tax Refunds. People treat tax refunds as windfalls, leading to poor financial planning.
  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Exploring the inefficiencies of the tax system and consumer behavior during tax season.
  • The Role of AI in Tax Preparation. AI is impacting accounting, but legislative will is crucial for tax system improvements.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes