Aniruddha Joshi: Knowledge at Wharton Real Estate Forum
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Aniruddha Joshi, executive director of U.K.-based Hirco Group, discusses changes in the Indian real estate market over the past year and the outlook for 2010.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- you joined us last year at the real estate forum what changes in the global real estate market of surprised the most
- over the past year well let me restrict my comment to India I know more about India than I do about the global real
- estate market but if you recall last year's podcast I had actually expressed a fairly high level of confidence in how
- I saw the Indian economy in general and indian real estate market coming out of the recession I think in fact one of the
- the visitors to your website had written some comments about my broadcast which you know I think he had some doubts
- about the the confidence that I had but I think looking back on the past year certainly you know I think a number of
- comments that I made a year ago have fortuitously you know proved to be correct recently the Indian government
- announced the the last quarter GDP growth which came in at seven point nine percent which certainly was a very
- pleasant surprise i think people are not expecting the economy to come out or so
- fast and at such a fast pace I think that the other thing about global real estate markets that has been a surprise
- has been you know this I anticipated crisis like the commercial real estate market which we haven't yet seen I mean
- people have referred to it as the other shoe dropping even in the conference this morning they've been references to
- the whole commercial real estate situation and I certainly don't think we're out of the woods I'm and I think
- we are we may yet faced some issues then but I was expecting that to happen yeah
- much earlier than it was hmm on the whole what do you think has buffered the Indian market the most well you know a
- friend of mine who's as a mechanical bent of mine you know he was saying to me once 10-15 years ago you looked under
- the hood of a car and he knew pretty much how everything worked and how you could fix it and but now of course if
- you look under the bonnet it's all microprocessor controlled and software control etc so it's very hard to
- to make out words in some ways you know the Indian economy is like the car from 15 years ago that you can look under the
- hood and fix it doesn't have the complexity if you like that that the US or European markets have we didn't have
- mortgage securitization within a mortgage-backed securities we didn't have any kind of asset securitization
- you know mortgages account for maybe six percent to the GDP so very small proportion so you know let's in terms of
- complexity it was probably a much easier economy to manage to steer through this
- this storm but of course you need the political will to do that and the knowledge to fix the problems we've been
- very lucky that we actually had a government come in with a clear mandate we've gone through a period of
- coalition's but the last election saw a clear majority for the Congress party which meant that you had the political
- will to address the issues and we saw that with the SAT them fraud case where the government acted very swiftly and
- fix the issues and the other the other side of it of course is the the knowledge so I think a lot of credit
- must go to the way the financial market regulators and the government have steered the economy through the crisis
- the other thing I think is that the Indian economy is much more dependent on private consumption private domestic
- consumption if you think about you know the the contrast with China I mean I I like to say that when I when an American
- man American consumer walks into walmart and buy something the Chinese economy benefits whereas when an Indian consumer
- walks into a shop in in Mumbai or in Delhi and buy something that's where the Indian economy is growth comes from so
- having that major driver with in control private domestic consumption as opposed
- to depending on exports depending on services unlike you know has has also helped the economy substantially so if
- in fact you see a kind of D linking between the stock market and the real economy because the stock market
- obviously depends a lot on capita flows in and out portfolio investments etc so the stock market was was affected
- but the real economy was was was shielded by these two factors good management and basically a strong
- domestic demand base would you say that there are still some lingering risks for
- investors in the market certainly I think that the risks in India are probably very similar to the risks in
- the US and that we are also faced with very high budget deficits you know which is a which is a major challenge now we
- are susceptible to because we're a net oil importer we are susceptible to what happens to gas prices energy prices and
- the growth has to be fueled by energy imports by and large so I think those two things are key you know they're
- potentially issues to worry about the other I think area that investors need to be cautious about is obviously what
- is happening with with the regulation regulatory changes the country is becoming more transparent in fact the
- new Companies Act is coming in very soon replacing something that goes back to the British times the government is also
- put forward a model bill for real estate regulation which is long awaited and would introduce transparency into the
- market and much more much more certainty but on the other hand one hopes that it
- doesn't simply just introduce additional bureaucracy as far as the real estate firms and developers attention a number
- of investors global real estate investors talk about the red tape that's involved when entering a market like
- India is that changing it all in your opinion well I think yes you know I mean I think one has to realize that India is
- a very large country and it has a federal structure which is very similar to the US so therefore you're subject to
- federal laws or what we would call union laws you're subject to state laws and you're of course subject to the local
- municipality parity laws you know in that of course leads to a lot of complexity and a lot of red tape
- but that's just a you know a reality of the geography it's not like investing in
- Ireland or Belgium or something like that which is a much much smaller you know smaller countries Molly economy
- certainly the bureaucracy faces you know it poses a challenge not just for foreign investors it poses a challenge
- for Indian investors also but I think the advantage that Indian investors have is that they know they know how to
- navigate through the system you know what is required to be done and I think that's where the value of a local
- partner for a foreign investor becomes critical right and what would you what advice would you give to to investors
- looking to to move into the Indian market what sort of key things they need to keep in mind what are critical the
- age-old rule of location location location applies to Indian real estate as much as it does to any other in fact
- because India is so large the rates of growth are diverse I mean if you look at a state like Gujarat in India for
- example Gujarat has been growing for the past ten years at a rate of twelve percent per annum the GDP of that state
- that's a faster pace of growth than than China on the other hand there are parts
- of India where growth rates have been much low so you know the the country the selection the area that you focus on is
- is critical you know you have to choose strongly growing micro markets you also have to look at states which have more
- transparent regulation more understandable processes so some of the states in the South in the West have
- much higher quality regulation in much higher quality processes and I think you have to focus on finding a local partner
- who's both experienced has a track record has a brand name because Indians of a brain conscious and in a foreign
- company enters India they do not have a brain presence so partnering with a local strong local brand is critical so
- I'd say these are these are three things to look at you know the location the choice of state and the choice of a
- partner and then lastly obviously the asset class I mean there are investment opportunities in India in a variety of
- asset classes residential commercial hotels hospitals in the area which is which is growing educational
- establishments service apartments so the opportunities are many and depends on the investors appetite and his
- investment thesis you know there are a lot of government programs right now they're helping regular citizens to
- afford housing and home ownership yes the government has done quite a few things first of all a large chunk of the
- banking industry in India is actually owned by the government so the major banks in there owned by the government
- and these banks typically have targets given to them by the government as to how much they must advance by way of
- mortgages to home borrows so if you look at state bank of india which is the largest bank their current target for
- mortgages is monthly 20 billion rupees so that almost half a half a billion dollars every month they're expected to
- lend in mortgages the government is making credit available easily the government has also come up with schemes
- for allowing mortgage interest to be written off of taxes the government has also come up with schemes which allowed
- developers certain benefits when they build affordable housing in other are there are certain other certain patterns
- of behavior in Indian consumers you think that are changing that are enabling homeownership that might may
- not have been present in the past different ways of spending I know that Indians are you know they save they tend
- to save so the question is I you know how are how is the government and how is the industry convincing people to put
- their money into home ownership as opposed to renting for instance well I I don't think that's such a challenge in
- India because traditionally Indians are viewed property and gold as two key investment asset classes and they've
- always had them in their portfolio if anything you know it's only recently that Indians are getting used to the
- idea of buying stocks or buying bonds so property and and gold have always been very important investment avenues but
- there are certain trends you know especially the develop into the nuclear family because traditionally
- Indian families have you know clustered together in large groups aren't uncles grandparents etc but increasingly with
- the urbanization you get the husband and wife and two kids type of family setting
- where you do need a home of your own and I think that is driving quite a lot of the the growth the development of the
- nuclear family and the migration to the city's Indian cities are growing growing
- rapidly and of course people when they move from the villages to the city and they want to buy a place to sleep place
- to stick now what about in the reverse direction I know that there are some programs that are working towards
- affordable housing in rural areas as well as hirako involved in any of those kinds of projects or are you interested
- in developing housing in rural areas at all or do you mostly stick to the metro areas into the large cities well here go
- actually is focused in what I would call an area in between rural and urban because you know we try to be near the
- urban metros simply because we want to leverage our customers want to leverage the existing connectivity that the urban
- centers have for example airports railway stations roads sea ports etc but at the same time we tend to stay away
- from the city centers or the city proper because obviously we can do large greenfield projects well outside the
- city limits so if you look at our project in Chennai for example it's about 60 kilometers from downtown
- Chennai it's a non-virgin green area 500 acres but it has the advantage of being
- able to leverage the existing infrastructure of Chennai the second Airport that's coming up the national
- highway network if you go right out into you know with the country obviously the
- you've you're faced with challenges of infrastructure so infrastructure would be the major where the infrastructure
- stops sort of the development stops in the sense you fake degree I mean that's I think that's probably the biggest
- bottleneck as far as the Indian economy is concerned the quality and the availability of public infrastructure
- that is everyone recognizes that as the major challenge even in the major Indian cities roads power sewage all our
- follow challenges and aside from infrastructure there any other major challenges you've received for the
- industry and uh i think you know there's one area that needs to be addressed which is that the recognition by the
- government of real estate as a as an industry which would make things much easier the recession ironically has
- actually helped the real estate industry in india because it has brought down the
- prices of cement steel and are the essential commodities that that go into the the construction business i think
- that's that's going to be a key area you know what happens to oil prices and what
- happens to the prices of these commodities and any thoughts on the outlook for 2010 for the industry in
- general well you know I came back from mumbai on tuesday and on sunday night i was at dinner at a restaurant and i
- actually had someone come up to my table and say you know are you guys done because we're waiting for a table you
- know that tells you about the state of the economy when you're in mumbai you feel what recession you know traffic is
- is bad people are out buying stuff everyone feels very confident the stock market is booming companies are lining
- up for IPOs so I'm very very positive as far as 2010 is concerned I mean I think
- as long as something doesn't happen on the international front such as with the oil prices I think certainly the
- domestic economy is position very well to continue on its path of growth great thanks very much be nice to check in
- with you again next year thank you thank you thank you you
Brief Summary
The episode covers India's real estate market, economic growth, investment risks, and government support for home ownership.
Key points
- Surprising GDP Growth in India. India's GDP growth came in at 7.9%, surprising many who didn't expect such a quick recovery.
- Navigating India's Complex Real Estate Market. Investors face challenges due to India's federal structure and regulatory complexities.
- The Importance of Location in Indian Real Estate. Choosing the right location is critical for real estate success in India, with diverse growth rates.
- Government Support for Homeownership. The Indian government is making credit available easily to promote homeownership.
- Positive Outlook for 2010. Despite challenges, the speaker expresses optimism for the Indian economy's growth in 2010.
Episode highlights
- Surprising GDP Growth in IndiaIndia's GDP growth came in at 7.9%, surprising many who didn't expect such a quick recovery.“People were not expecting the economy to come out so fast.”1:15Feb 10, 2010
- Navigating India's Complex Real Estate MarketInvestors face challenges due to India's federal structure and regulatory complexities.“India is a very large country with a federal structure, leading to complexity.”6:30Feb 10, 2010
- The Importance of Location in Indian Real EstateChoosing the right location is critical for real estate success in India, with diverse growth rates.“The age-old rule of location applies to Indian real estate as much as anywhere else.”7:42Feb 10, 2010
- Government Support for HomeownershipThe Indian government is making credit available easily to promote homeownership.“The government has done quite a few things to help citizens afford housing.”9:30Feb 10, 2010
- Positive Outlook for 2010Despite challenges, the speaker expresses optimism for the Indian economy's growth in 2010.“I'm very positive as far as 2010 is concerned.”14:59Feb 10, 2010
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





