Guy Langford: Knowledge at Wharton Real Estate Forum

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A Knowledge at Wharton Interview, from the recent K@W Real Estate Forum in New York, with Guy Langford, Real Estate M&A Transaction Services Leader for Deloitte & Touche LLP.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. tell me about the problems that banks have that people aren't taking a close look at what are the
  2. skeletons in the closets that that don't get talked about usually when we talk with
  3. professionals who sometimes have an interest in in presenting let's say the best foot
  4. forward sure uh steve you know i think i think it's well known that they're somewhere in the
  5. range of 1.5 to 1.8 trillion dollars worth of commercial real estate loans that are coming due over the course the
  6. next year four to five years um during 2009 it was about 200 million and a lot of that was extended i think
  7. you've heard the phrase coined extend or pretend um at some point the banking community
  8. is going to have to deal with uh these maturities if there's not a refinancing market
  9. how is it going to be dealt with is it a modification is it a foreclosure reo real estate owned taking back the
  10. keys to the property or is there going to be some other solution i think a lot of the banks
  11. right now have not taken what people refer to as the mark and writing those to assets down to the
  12. level that perhaps folks think the market value is today now we heard on the panel this morning that very few
  13. banks want to do that because they don't have to do it at least right now because
  14. of the low interest rate environment and should interest rates change then we've
  15. got an entirely different environment of course is so can how long can this extend and pretend
  16. go on is that the same thing as asking how long are we going to have interest rates this low
  17. uh interesting question i i think at some point um for the origination markets to really
  18. open up uh people the banks are going to have to deal with these issues so a lot of people say there's a stoma
  19. right now between the equity that's sitting on the sidelines that looks to to potentially buy these assets and then
  20. the banks themselves who are holding these these mortgage loans that's the bid ask spread uh in terms of
  21. you know when they're going to deal with it um it's going to take one of several things uh it's going to take a
  22. government action for example what kind of action um in terms of you know for for example um setting a set of
  23. guidelines that actually prescribes how banks are supposed to specifically mark these items
  24. uh it could be a regulatory angle it could be an accounting standard change there's been a lot of that already had
  25. some of those had some of that yes and they've had their fair share of controversy
  26. my sense is and then you've also had some transactions which have occurred albeit in a world of
  27. distress my sense is that we're getting closer to a point where people are getting ready
  28. to transact and absent any more intervention or changes at either a regulatory or a an accounting policy level
  29. at some point in the next 12 to 18 months you're going to see a lot more transacting with these loans
  30. um larger banks will have the benefit of multiple other income streams and and trading operations being able to cover
  31. if you will um the need to make large write-downs on these assets smaller regional and community banks will be
  32. subject to a different set of dynamics and then you have you know banks that are on fdic watch lists right now
  33. uh which desperately need capital um and it's interesting that they need capital to survive and yet we have this
  34. capital that's on the sideline and we're still not getting to a point where there is a flow of activity what do you
  35. think is the ideal solution do you think that there's something positive the government could offer here
  36. um you know it's interesting uh you've got a lot of industry observers commenting on what
  37. they believe uh needs to happen um my lens talking to my clients some of them are a private equity
  38. and uh institutional investors uh some of them are banks and then also talking to you know folks
  39. who have dealt uh frequently and recently with with government agencies is it actually needs to involve a
  40. cooperation of of multiple parties it might be a situation where we have private equity comes into part of the
  41. equation um existing healthy banks are also part of the solution and then perhaps you've got fdic as a
  42. backstop um even for commercial property you're suggesting uh that even for commercial property so
  43. after after the bank bailouts that we've had and the sentiment out there um do you really think there's going to
  44. be much appetite for public money to be used for commercial i think it's a backstop
  45. you know i think the the bailout of the big banks has been just that it's been a
  46. bailout of the big banks and i think samsel made the comment today is like a lot of
  47. folks out there don't realize that bailing out the big banks on wall street is bailing out what
  48. uh main street as well because those banks and those institutions are critical to main street right that gets
  49. translated differently through the politics of course it does of course um however i think a
  50. lot of the regional and community banks have not been recipients of that funding but they're actually the
  51. ones who have a fairly large exposure to lending on the commercial real estate side so that's interesting because i
  52. i've read someplace that the top 20 banks basically have very little exposure to commercial real estate
  53. and it's it's the big regional banks and the small banks big regional and community banks
  54. community banks with construction loans and so forth the construction loans are challenging
  55. uh just lack of cash flow and i think a stabilized asset is an easier one to deal with from a loan perspective and
  56. then to the actual underlying asset but a non-cash flowing asset one that needs continued investment or
  57. incremental investment is more challenging to work through you know whichever way you look at it steve
  58. it's going to require participation from multiple constitu constituents and so you know i'd like to think that
  59. you know given given my my lens on in the world right now that the um regional community banks
  60. uh some of them will be healthier than others and and have an opportunity to participate in this process to expand
  61. their footprint i'd like to think that the fdic or other government agencies will be there to endorse or bless a
  62. transaction i'd like to think that the private equity participants can also play an important role of recapitalizing
  63. some of those institutions into a healthier state is that something like what was done
  64. with the snls in the late 80s early 90s in other words you had institutions flat on their back
  65. you had government come in and at least propped them up to the extent that they they didn't go out which they would have
  66. without the propping up and then you had bottom feeders come in and buy them up at
  67. prices and that were very attractive if you had confidence in the market and of course they made a killing by the mid
  68. 90s some of these these players that had consolidated a lot of these little banks were were big
  69. regional players themselves and they had done exceptionally well yeah uh different
  70. world today obviously um and i have heard people reflect upon you know why aren't we
  71. doing an rtc type structure today there's definitely a different political landscape right now
  72. and there's also a very large volume if you look back to the rtc days or the savings and loans and you compare it to
  73. the volume of distress out there today so there's already been more money far more money lend to aig alone
  74. than there was the entire snl industry at that time absolutely um and i think back in in the
  75. snl uh um crisis or if you will um you also had a much different array of loan product
  76. um and you know since the snl crisis uh you really had proliferation and new sorts of
  77. sources of capital one of them was cmbs and so that was kind of post snl and i'd
  78. say that that has added to the complexity and then you add to that as well multiple participations by different
  79. banking institutions in the site in the one loan um and you have various forms whether it's
  80. syndication or uh or going out there and secured as a securitizing product that basically makes for a much more
  81. complicated capital stack in some instances uh we've seen a couple of examples already
  82. with the the complexity within the capital stacks today is such that folks are saying the only
  83. way to deal with this is through some kind of cleansing process whether it be a foreclosure or more
  84. pointedly a bankruptcy and we have seen examples of that so given that commercial real estate is a lagging
  85. indicator and what you're suggesting is that things are coming to a head as it were
  86. that some of the problems are that have been able to be extended and pretending that that
  87. payments were being made when in fact a lot of concessions were were being made behind the scenes that
  88. that peers going to be forced to come to an end uh the kinds of changes you're talking
  89. about may be starting to begin how long of a process is it until the market sort of washed out and and
  90. ready to look ahead to more normal times i'm assuming we're talking years here steve i wouldn't be
  91. here if i knew the answer to that uh you know crystal ball aside you know there's a lot of
  92. a lot of issues that need to be worked through the good news is there's a lot of
  93. capital on the sideline it's and they are patient pools of capital and they want to deploy but they also want to
  94. deploy in an environment in which they have a little bit of certainty around the investment
  95. parameters uh there's been a lot of concern about the uh the bow out of big banks and the
  96. impact that that's had on you know compensation and other areas of scrutiny from the investing public
  97. um so that's created a little bit of angst um i think there's also a little bit of
  98. angst in the system right now in terms of people that do participate in the like a
  99. loan sale program or process uh that is being run are frustrated at the number of other
  100. bidders that are coming in and bidding up the price of the assets or the underlying quality of the
  101. information so systemically there are a number of things uh that are little that are roadblocks
  102. to an efficient recovery if you will what are some or who are some of those investors
  103. we're talking about u.s commercial property here i assume uh and who are some of these investors that uh
  104. that are crowding out the field is it are the overseas investors for example sovereign wealth funds perhaps uh yeah
  105. there's there's an array of different investors and you you're obviously familiar with
  106. the private equity capital i think uh one of our panelists today talked about the 78 billion
  107. dollars sitting there on the sidelines ready to deploy into commercial real estate
  108. majority of that is looking at paper and not the underlying assets so you've got that pool of capital
  109. you've got the pool of capital with uh in the public markets in the last eight months nine months
  110. the public markets have been very uh positive towards real estate whether it be newly formed reits that
  111. are going out there to pursue a mandate in distress buying distressed opportunities or originating
  112. or alternatively recently we've had a number of blind pool reits going after specific asset classes like
  113. hotels so there's been 30 plus billion raised in that area and then for the so so reits are very
  114. positive and bullish yeah and the public markets have have provided some liquidity there and it's
  115. interesting that that that source of capital the public markets provides an interesting vehicle
  116. for real estate because it gives people the exposure the asset class but it also gives them liquidity uh
  117. so you can sell down a portion of your holding whereas it's it's tough to sell down a porsche
  118. an office building so how interest rate dependent is all this and then continue can i come back to the
  119. interest rate dependency okay and then add category number three is is you've got you know large pools of
  120. these um reits that are non-traded and i think that's about 70 billion dollars year-to-date and then you have
  121. individuals high net worth individuals domestically who are looking at this as rtc2 saying this is
  122. how all the big guys today uh got to where they are they made some prudent purchases during the
  123. last down cycle and and were able to you know come out of that cycle you know very strong and then you've got
  124. offshore capital and with exchange rates where they are right now you've got offshore private equity also
  125. looking at the u.s saying risk adjusted this is a good place to be given asset prices right now
  126. sovereign wealth even though some sovereign wealth have got their own share of issues
  127. i think there's still a huge pool of capital out there looking for an allocation towards u.s
  128. commercial real estate i mean that's very the very group that can afford to to buy and sit and wait i would think uh
  129. they're long-term players without a doubt and a lot of them are looking to put commercial real estate into their
  130. portfolios as a tool for for diversification sorry i i went on there that's okay do you
  131. want me to address the uh the interest rate issue please yes because can you repeat the question the
  132. question is isn't all this in interest rate dependent in other words um at some point interest rates are going
  133. to have to rise and the timing is everything and if it if if rates rose sooner rather than later that could
  134. throw pretty big monkey wrench in some of these scenarios couldn't it uh without doubt without doubt i mean i
  135. think if we listen to some of the panels this morning uh i would say there was a consensus
  136. view that rates need to start being ratcheted up now um you know to curb fears of
  137. of you know high or hyperinflation down the track and so you know right now you look at the lending environment and
  138. the cost of funds is very low um but there isn't a lot of lending going on um you know it does dampen as interest
  139. rates go up i think what we did here however steve is that you could still you go up a a a couple
  140. of percentage points and that the dampening effect on investment and commercial real estate
  141. would be not so significant but yet it would have a moderating impact you know in the macro economy and then
  142. there's the question of really whether folks may be advocating slightly higher rates but whether the economy
  143. or the authorities would actually do that given the fragility of the economy right now
  144. that's absolutely true so another question uh dubai world we have to ask you about
  145. that and even though it looks as i guess we're about two weeks since that's happened it's been
  146. announced um the the the waiting to to pay back debt uh at first there was a big reaction now
  147. there's less of one what kind of an effect does that have on u.s investors just in terms of thinking
  148. about uh investing in projects in in real estate in general making them more cautious or or in what
  149. other ways might it affect uh investor psychology yeah all of these uh items impact investor
  150. psychology um seeing a large public rate um file for bankruptcy protection investor sentiment it impacts a segment
  151. that they're in seeing another privately held company file for bankruptcy as well in the you
  152. know extended hotel segment also creates um an impact on investors sentiment you
  153. know similarly dubai world um you know has an impact on the investor sentiment i don't think it's any different to
  154. other investors who in this last cycle invested in commercial real estate and employed leverage
  155. i know some participants right now look at that set of factors as being creating conditions that that might be
  156. appealing to an investor i see other folks looking at that saying well that creates a lot of distress
  157. and dampens you know investor sentiment i think it depends which lens you're coming from
  158. um you know i i you know in many instances given my role i'm subject to limitations
  159. on what i can share but i think it does obviously have an impact on investor sentiment
  160. um what i would say though is yeah overall um i would expect over the next you know
  161. three to five years time to see a broader deleveraging of the commercial real estate markets
  162. perhaps back to more sustainable levels i've heard a lot of people you know touting somewhere between 60 to 70
  163. percent ltv the question is what is v and i think that's driven to some extent by leverage
  164. my expectation is that that the public markets the private capital the offshore capital
  165. um and the banking you know sector as well as the government are all going to be part of this uh you
  166. know solution if you will to have a broader deleveraging of real estate you know commercial real estate
  167. in the u.s and that will happen over roughly what kind of period three to five year period
  168. of time three to five years yeah okay let's switch topics quickly to uh distressed debt
  169. sure give me your sense of what the contours are of distressed debt in the u.s and then in europe it seems
  170. to me from what i'm reading that in in the u.s the amount of distressed debt has come down quite a bit in the last
  171. year where it looks like europe may be just about to ratchet up what's your view uh
  172. yeah my lens to you know lens on the u.s is a lot sharper than it is in in europe and i would probably
  173. contend your view that uh things in the us have been dealt with i'm not sure what your
  174. exact words were there but uh i think there's still a huge amount of distress in the system in the u.s
  175. for debt underlying commercial real estate there's a huge amount that's coming up over the next five years that
  176. has to be dealt with i think similarly but on a lesser scale in europe the issue has to be dealt with
  177. in in some respects some of the marks have been taken in europe under ifrs or under the u.s
  178. accounting models some of those marks to mark the loans down in market value have not occurred
  179. so you know in terms of scale the us market has a huge nut to deal with in in that regard let
  180. me just read you something from the ft because this is what i was referring to the
  181. rating agency talking about moody's here now forecast that default rates for us jonker's
  182. speculative grade debt will peak near 14 in november before falling back swiftly to four
  183. percent in a year's time that's that sounds like a big change that is a big change and you know to be
  184. honest it's probably one that i don't want to comment on just because you know the speculative
  185. nature is is there more you can you can offer though on your views of distressed debt
  186. yeah it's interesting we you know we work um as a practice with a number of different
  187. constituents within the distressed the world of distressed debt we work with debtors who are trying to deal with
  188. banks modify their loans see if they can extract um alternate scenarios with their
  189. current borrowings and we have the lenders who are dealing with who are trying to work out what's this
  190. loan really worth what are my options do i take the keys back do i extend to pretend do i modify it
  191. or do i sell that loan to somebody else and make it somebody else's problem or does the government come in and then
  192. i'm dealing with the investors as well um who are trying to work out how they can play
  193. effectively in this in this space and be part of the solution so you look at those three constituents
  194. um and there's a lot of different you can come in at different lenses um interestingly enough you know we have
  195. the benefit of working with different clients across that kind of cycle and provide
  196. a lot of that uh you know perspective to different clients you know based on what we see in the
  197. marketplace i would tell you there's a lot of distress to go around right now and and my view is is that it is going
  198. to take a diligent period of time to work through the distress it's certainly encouraging that the the
  199. capital markets on the public side for public reits and new pools of capital are being
  200. raised that's a positive it's a absolute positive right now that the markets have been able to absorb
  201. uh and over-subscribe a couple of recent cmbs offerings some of which are tough backed and some
  202. of which are non-talf-backed so you know i see those as two positive signs and we see that you know one or two
  203. transactions have occurred uh with with you know fdic-sponsored deals so you look in the world of distress and
  204. you say there are some positive signs um you know we'll get through this and it will result in a de-leveraging of
  205. real estate is also going to result in a shift if you will of of real estate wealth from
  206. one set of hands to another set of hands and there might be some folks who are on
  207. both sides of the table might be thanks for joining us my pleasure you

Brief Summary

Banks face challenges with $1.5 trillion in commercial real estate loans due, requiring potential government intervention and collaboration with private equity.

Key points

  • The Banking Crisis Looms. Banks face a looming crisis with trillions in commercial real estate loans due soon.
  • Extend or Pretend. The banking community is caught in a cycle of extending loans instead of addressing defaults.
  • Capital on the Sidelines. A significant amount of capital is waiting to be deployed in commercial real estate.
  • The Future of Interest Rates. The timing of interest rate changes could significantly affect the market.
  • Investor Sentiment Shifts. Investor psychology is impacted by major bankruptcies and market conditions.
  • Navigating Distressed Debt. Exploring the complexities of distressed debt and the various stakeholders involved.

Tension

55/ 100Some tension

Related episodes