Jeffrey Schwartz: Knowledge at Wharton Real Estate Forum

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A Knowledge at Wharton Interview, from the recent K@W Real Estate Forum in New York, with Jeffrey Schwartz, Chairman and Co-Founder of Global Logistic Properties.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. jeffrey thanks for joining us today oh it's my pleasure steve tell me about your plans
  2. in the u.s uh well in the u.s well we'll start take a step one step back as you know we started the company
  3. with an asia focused put together a platform that is the largest owner largest developer of
  4. logistics facilities in china largest owner logistics facilities in japan largest overall in asia
  5. and but with the customer concentration we have in asia those customers both non-asian
  6. companies you know companies like dhl companies like unilever companies like adidas
  7. that have requirements elsewhere in the world it makes sense to help serve their
  8. requirements in other major markets obviously the us being a very very large market
  9. so we see that opportunities there we think it's part of a long-term global footprint and
  10. intend to execute on that as it makes sense and what about in china that's that's an area that's
  11. got a growing real estate market particularly commercial real estate some would say
  12. even looking bubble-like what's your opinion on that the bubble that people talk
  13. about is really focused on residential more particularly high-end residential in very limited markets it's shanghai
  14. it's potentially beijing clearly hong kong worries me from a bubble standpoint and there's been some
  15. articles about that recently that's where people really talk about a bubble in valuations
  16. within the industrial sector we see no signs of a bubble in fact our leasing velocity is the strongest
  17. it's ever been we're 150 percent above our previous records prior to this year over the last few months
  18. so it's very very strong uh we're seeing good customer demand we're seeing a limited amount of
  19. competition uh rising occupancy rates um it's a it's a real real strong market there really is strong
  20. gdp growth and more importantly within our sector domestic with the warehouse sector domestic
  21. distribution is really what drives demand 86 of our product is focused on domestic
  22. distribution and that's what the chinese government is really trying to foster and grow
  23. that's very interesting now so in china would that suggest that commercial real estate
  24. prices are rising versus the case in the u.s where things are contracting could you
  25. compare the two i'd say over the last 18 months they've been relatively stable to up slightly
  26. very market contrast but then again you have a market contrast between a country where you have eight and a
  27. half percent gdp growth in a country where you've had significant negative gdp growth for
  28. almost two years and finally potentially coming out of the the deepest recession since the great
  29. depression so it makes sense you also have the difference where there was much more speculation
  30. from a commercial development standpoint save for a couple of major cities where
  31. you do have like beijing some over building in the office sector and and high-end res
  32. high-end hotel sector or lodging sector um you've had you know and you know a difference in the credit
  33. markets with the amount of securitization the cmbs that was done the 85 90 percent the mez loans
  34. the level of sophistication that you know created problems um because people had were buying buildings
  35. financing buildings on the expectation that rents would continue to rise and eventually they'd be able to make their
  36. debt service obviously that's a game front would risk that's not turning out very well
  37. and today that creates opportunities is that one reason why you're timing for looking at the us uh well it's so
  38. there's a business drive there's an overall business reason to be in the u.s and be
  39. in western europe to serve customers on a global basis think about our customer sets very very different
  40. far different than residential if you're multi-family developer or owner the chances of leasing an apartment to
  41. someone in paris and shanghai are very very small the chances of leasing to dhl in both
  42. those markets are extremely high if you serve them well or a unilever or a png or you
  43. can go on and on the nippon expresses the world so we do have global customers which is
  44. even different than retail retail you have zara and h m that are kind of have a global
  45. footprint our customers are really all truly global players major manufacturers major logistics companies so it does
  46. make sense then from a timing standpoint if you have an opportunity to buy in when things are
  47. distressed when you buy at good pricing clearly far far better pricing than you would have seen two
  48. three years ago the opportunity could be tremendous well well let's talk about that pricing
  49. i think it was in september you were quoted as saying that you thought prices had further to fall in commercial
  50. real estate still feel that way or still feel that way uh if you look at the wall of debt you know the 1.4 trillion
  51. 1.3 trillion of cmbs coming to in the next three and a half years if you look at you know the amount of
  52. loans on the bank you know mid-size banks books i mean anything below the top 10
  53. banks or so that has been extended and you know with the you know the the expectation that someday it'll
  54. be a performing loan again it's making debt service extend and pretend exactly i was trying
  55. to not to say that but that's exactly right um you know there's more pain to come
  56. in that regard there has there's been more support on pricing because there's been
  57. so few transactions and you've got this wall of private equity capital that was raised that has subscription agreements
  58. that are expiring that people want to get out so when a good asset comes on the market
  59. with decent term on it so you have some cash flow going out four years five years six years seven years there's more
  60. bidders that you know there's more buyers and there are sellers right now so it's
  61. artificially kept pricing at us at a certain level but i think there there is further to
  62. fall with those with the debt situation the way it is and you know just the overall loss of jobs i
  63. mean you've lost seven million jobs nobody talks about that coming back even the most optimistic politicians
  64. don't talk about bringing those jobs back very fast so you've got you know an inherently
  65. weak job situation i don't know how that could bode well the fundamentals aren't good
  66. that's for sure let me just put it under the microscope a little bit more uh moody's crp index is down somewhere
  67. around 40 i haven't seen the latest but that you know within the last six weeks or so
  68. since you know 2008 i guess right or maybe that's over two years but in any case
  69. um where do you think that index would be six months from now i think most of the fall has happened
  70. you know you know can it go down a little bit you know maybe i'm overly optimistic you know i
  71. try you know i don't by nature not draconian and you know the sky's falling and you know the world's
  72. coming to an end um it's hard to survive long-term being that way but it's you know i think you've seen
  73. most of the value fall but there may be a little bit left so it's not a bad time now and for the
  74. right opportunities it could make sense but you could see some continued weakness
  75. so when it comes to opportunities is there a way to slice and dice that by geographic or region or by industry
  76. how how do you when you say industry right around they talk uh i guess uh you know geographically
  77. you're in the logistics business so i would say i would guess that new york and and newark and la would be very
  78. interesting too exactly um but industry-wise i don't know if you're all over the map or where you
  79. think the opportunities might be i think you know there's going to be opportunities to buy
  80. geographically on a very diverse basis within the u.s and within europe for that
  81. matter uh but in my mind if things if you believe that values are attractive you m when everything's on sale you
  82. might as well buy the best kind of like walking into um department store and they're having a 70 80
  83. off sale you it's not that values are down 70 80 percent right don't take it that way but you
  84. might as well look at the better markets look at the la the southern california's the northern
  85. california's the seattle's really the coastal markets um you know i kind of went through the
  86. strategy with somebody and after i drew on a map they said you just drew a circle around the
  87. outside of the u.s i said i looked and said yeah i guess my seven-year-old daughter could have done that because
  88. you kind of went around and went new york business yeah new york new jersey went down to washington you know dc
  89. baltimore corridor came down to atlanta because atlanta really is a proxy for the port of savannah which i think is
  90. the winner with the panama canal being widened you bring it into event savannah but why keep anything in
  91. savannah nobody you know you don't have any population density you got good great trail can you
  92. create great rail connections and trucking connections by almost um taking you up to atlanta so you might
  93. as well take your containers off in savannah drop them on rail cars take them up to atlanta distribute out
  94. there then getting down to florida coming across to potentially houston market again to
  95. port market and coming back in around the la so you've drawn a circle around the us
  96. and again it's the port markets port and population densities the bargains that you're talking about
  97. would you describe them as a perhaps once in a generation opportunity would you would you would you go that
  98. strong would you there were some great bargains in the early 90s whether the bargains will reach that
  99. level again or not i'm not certain um you know it will take further price destruction or you know price you know
  100. value destruction to get to those kind of levels or those kind of values again but let's hope that we don't see
  101. anything this bad again in our careers and let's hope that we have very long lives and very long
  102. careers but it doesn't get this bad again how's the refinancing situation changing
  103. that is a great question because it's shocked me in the last three weeks how much better the debt markets have
  104. gotten whereas it was difficult to do anything above 50 leverage uh three months ago now you're starting
  105. to see lenders with very competitive pricing at 65 leverage um and you're seeing spreads
  106. come in dramatically i mean right now you could do unstabilized assets 60 65 percent
  107. financing at six to seven percent fixed for ten years which in my career is historically low
  108. rates i mean what do you attribute that to well one you have very very low base rates
  109. i mean the treasuries are extremely low so the spreads are still high on historical basis but they're much lower
  110. than they were three four months ago i think actually what the treasurer did with tauf
  111. has helped um i know they got criticized i know it took him a long time to get anything done
  112. but they've broken seemingly broken somewhat of a log jam by supporting some tough issuances and it's
  113. helped out in the it seemingly has helped out in the real estate credit markets now i've had friends that complained
  114. that there's still no debt available at 85 leverage levels and that's what they're
  115. used to getting but i'm not sure that that's the way real estate really should be played i mean that's
  116. there's inherent risk in that you know there was a lot of 85 90 95 percent leverage deals in the past
  117. and that's you know i don't know that the government should support that or i don't know that you know
  118. really we want the public sector to find ways to replace that debt if there's readily available data 50 60
  119. leverage levels what we need to find is equity to bridge the gap you know two problems at play here one you have
  120. 85 leveraged assets that have fallen 35 percent value so you're negative 20 on your equity to begin with
  121. now you have this new value the 65 cents of the dollar and people are only willing to
  122. lend you 60 cents on that so you get 40 cents of of debt versus your 100 before so you're
  123. at 40 percent on the original there's an equity gap one thing that we spent some time on is ferpta
  124. talking to people in washington we've seen a lot of receptivity on ferpa relief and ferpa is the foreign investment real
  125. property tax act which was passed in the 1980s when there were a few senators that were scared the
  126. japanese were going to buy all the farmland in the u.s didn't happen wasn't going to happen but
  127. it was a little xenophobia and now it's onerous for foreigners to buy real estate
  128. and they're treated differently if they own reit stock than they are if they own
  129. ge stock it's tax wars why should that be if they want to buy you know my friend steve frost vernado
  130. stock why should that be taxed any different than buying ge stock it shouldn't be
  131. if they want to own real estate in a fund that's put together by blackstone or put together by me or
  132. by anyone else why should that be taxed differently we need that equity in the u.s desperately
  133. in the real estate markets to help out the markets to bridge that gap to make real estate
  134. less leveraged and to bridge the pain and i think we're getting you know they're getting it in washington and
  135. hopefully we'll get some relief there just to go back to one thing you mentioned at the beginning of your last
  136. answer um you talked about leverage now at 65 percent people complain some friends are
  137. complaining that it's not 85 isn't it those upper levels that help to contribute to the problem to begin with
  138. oh it is too liquid too much leveraging i don't think that we should have 85 percent
  139. debt out there that i don't think clearly i don't think the government should do anything to support
  140. the return of 85 leverage you know if we've helped the credit markets reestablish themselves at the 50-60
  141. percent level now we need to help bring more equity into the market one last question
  142. you talked about what's happened to interest rates at least in the last three weeks we'll see if it lasts but
  143. i find it interesting that that happened despite dubai world not that dubai world is a neutron bomb but
  144. certainly you think that would have something uh you would think in the market it
  145. hasn't had you know within you know debt rates or real estate uh debt capital marks the usage has little
  146. effect obviously it's had a massive effect on greece and the sovereign bonds there i think
  147. people's perception of risk has changed a little bit but you know you know dubai bought some great assets but there
  148. was a lot a lot of leverage involved in it but they do have some great assets so
  149. and you know some smart people there so hopefully they'll work their way out of it
  150. thanks very much for joining us thank you i appreciate it thank you you

Brief Summary

Jeffrey discusses logistics growth, U.S. commercial real estate trends, and market comparisons with China.

Key points

  • Comparing Real Estate Markets. Discussing the differences in commercial real estate prices between China and the U.S.
  • Opportunities in Distressed Markets. Exploring the potential for investment in distressed real estate markets.
  • Leverage Levels in Real Estate. Analyzing current leverage levels and their implications for the market.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes