Frank Quattrone: Business Exits in the Current Economic Environment

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

During a recent panel discussion on venture capital at Whartons San Francisco campus, Frank Quattrone, co-founder and CEO of Qatalyst Partners, a technology-focused investment bank, spoke about how the recovery from the recent economic downturn will be different from what took place following the dotcom bust. πŸ“‚ Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. In your view, are there any difference that we can expect in terms of the recovery if we compare the post uh 2000
  2. bust of the dot-com to what we can expect moving forward at this particular time given changes in
  3. the marketplace, regulatory changes, and perhaps changes in investor psychology as well.
  4. Happy to answer that. Um just a little bit of historical perspective in the technology IPO market, which has been my
  5. privilege to uh participate in since the early 1980s. Uh it's been a market that was in the
  6. '70s kind of a backwater. It was kind of a buy exception market. That was the time when company great companies like
  7. Intel and Rome and Tandem went public. But back then, there was only about maybe five companies a year that came
  8. public. The average deal size was maybe 10 million. It was really Apple's IPO and Genentech's IPO in 1980 that started
  9. to institutionalize the market. And so, in the '80s uh that that decade that was um
  10. uh a personified by Apple there were 32 uh IPOs a year in technology. Um if you look at the the time frame where
  11. Cisco and Netscape and the internet started to be formed the first half of the '90s there were over 100 IPOs per
  12. year in the technology sector. Uh the first wave of the internet uh which captured Amazon's IPO, which I had the
  13. privilege of leading uh there were 240 deals a year. And in the crazy years of 1990 and 2000, there were almost 400
  14. deals per year. Uh now, after that bubble burst uh there was there were a couple of years where
  15. it was really lean, but for 2001 through 2007 there were 62 deals per year and 80
  16. billion dollars of proceeds were raised, about 11 billion a year. Um in the last 2 years, just to put that in
  17. perspective, there my numbers are different because I'm dealing with global uh tech IPOs and not just venture
  18. back, but there are only 18 a year. Um and the market is uh is about 3 and 1/2 billion per year. Those statistics are
  19. lower than the 1980s. Uh sort of puts you between the '70s and '80s. And so, it's really very very
  20. dramatically different. And and will it recover to the same extent? I'd say no. And I think some of the key
  21. differences this time are the fact that in the uh '99 2000 bubble, it was really
  22. focused on uh internet and telecom. And it was mostly a US kind of phenomenon. And the
  23. broader S&P, the broader industries, they didn't go down nearly as much. NASDAQ down
  24. over the 2000 to 2003 time frame was down 80%. I don't think the S&P got down more than 30% during that period of
  25. time. This time, it's been uh much more deep, much more broad, much more global. Uh
  26. the the bust this year I'm sorry, this this time uh took 17 months to reach down 50%. It was down
  27. 50% not just in NASDAQ, but in S&P, in the Dow, and the financial services industry, which is the real big change
  28. this time, was down 83% during that that period of time from uh from October 2007
  29. to March of 2009 when things bottomed out. The thing that brought the market back
  30. last time were big IPOs for Google and VMware, but also the fact that there was a lot of credit flowing through the
  31. markets. The LBO firms started to become a big part of both um the M&A market as well as the IPO
  32. market. Uh in technology, that was unheard of. About 25% of the market during that mid-2000s time frame both
  33. the M&A market and the IPO market came from LBO firms buying big technology companies and taking them private and
  34. then taking them back public again. This time, there's really no credit. It's it's really a have and have not
  35. market. The top dozen tech companies that have 5 to 30 billion of cash have a big advantage over the others, but
  36. credit is largely unavailable to uh to the mid-sized companies. And so, that's one of the main changes. Also, the the
  37. number of suppliers of the service underwriting taking companies public has shrunk dramatically due to companies
  38. going out of business, companies merging, and such. And then the big companies now sort of have a chokehold
  39. on the distribution and they're not letting companies come public unless they have very very large revenues and
  40. prospects for uh for big market caps. So, I think it's different. I think it's going to take a
  41. longer time to to come back. Uh I think we're going to need to get the credit flowing in the economy again before
  42. things really open up again. Meanwhile, we live in a world where M&A transactions are the dominant form
  43. of uh exit. If I look back to 2009, in Q3 of 2009 uh 11 out of the 22 disclosed deals were
  44. transactions that were valued at less than investment. Only two of the 22 disclosed deals had a
  45. 10x or higher return. So, Frank, you're an investment banker, prominent investment banker
  46. would you offer any thoughts on your views on whether the M&A market in 2010 is likely to recover? We have had a slow
  47. January. Most of the indices are down. What's your view? So, I I want to emphasize and agree with
  48. what Ted said. It's a fallacy that when stock prices go down, M&A activity goes up because when stock prices go down,
  49. the buyers have lost confidence. And you need the CEOs of the big companies to have confidence, predictability,
  50. visibility into their own businesses before they're willing to pay imaginative prices. So, if you're in the
  51. middle of a credit crisis when there's maybe only 10 technology companies that could buy properties for cash, but
  52. they're worried, you know, are they going to have earnings in the next quarter and are they going to have
  53. customers because all their customers can't afford to buy the products anymore, they're not going to be
  54. thinking too much about M&A. So, my statistics showed that uh in the the fourth quarter of uh
  55. of last year, of '08 um rather What improvement? In the fourth quarter of '08, the annualized M&A volume in tech
  56. was only 13 billion. And that was our brokerage foundry deal times four. And uh there wasn't a whole lot of of of
  57. deals happening. In '08 as a whole, it was 77 billion. And last year, we we track it at 90 billion. So, there was a
  58. slight increase year to year, but most of that activity took place in the second year
  59. in the second half of the year. So, we we think that that activity is in fact accelerating. And there is a variety of
  60. reasons. One is interest rates remain low. Uh so, the opportunity cost of taking
  61. cash off your balance sheet and buying earnings is it's it's a good deal. Secondly, confidence is returning. Uh we
  62. think that we've bottomed. March of '09 is generally what people think was the bottom of the
  63. uh stock market and the economic problem. Now, we're not recovering as fast as people would hope, but I think
  64. people are now saying, "Okay, it the worst is over. Now, I need to go take a look at what's happening." Do you
  65. believe in that? Yes. Well, I do. I also think, however, that stocks are way ahead of where the actual economic
  66. recovery pace is going to be. So, I think that we're, you know, if things don't really start growing, there's risk
  67. in PE levels right now in the marketplace. But getting back to why M&A is going to improve, there are some
  68. structural things going on in technology. Some industry trends that are really really much more powerful than stock
  69. market fluctuations that are driving it. We're going from a world where there were horizontal specialists, you know,
  70. Oracle in database, Intel in chips, HP in servers, Cisco in networking, EMC in storage uh
  71. to one where now a few very large companies want to control it all, back to the mini
  72. computing mini computer and mainframe days. So, Cisco is in the computer business, slapping HP and IBM and Dell
  73. in the face. Uh HP's bought 3Com, they're redoubling their efforts in networking to compete
  74. against Cisco. Dell bought Perot Systems to be in the system integration business
  75. when all they've got to sell is servers, but they're going to probably want to flesh out their technology stack. Oracle
  76. bought Sun, they're in the hardware business now. Um they can control everything from
  77. servers through applications. And Oracle's now controlling the agenda in the industry. And so, before when you
  78. were a networking startup, the only company really that could pay a big price for you was Cisco. Now, you've got
  79. six companies, all of whom came from it from a different perspective, hardware, software, internet, you know, whatever,
  80. and they all want to buy a networking company. So, we think that the buyers for individual technology components
  81. uh are broadening. And so, that's creating competition. And you're seeing even some public bidding wars like our
  82. Data Domain deal with EMC and NetApp. You're also seeing some trends in in mobility such as, you know, Apple
  83. getting into the cell phone business. Apple and Google's in the cell phone business. Apple and Google used to have
  84. common board members. And so, now these two are competing for mobile advertising
  85. properties. Apple hasn't bought anything historically. They've got three, five, 40 billion dollars of cash on their
  86. balance sheet. Apple getting into the acquisition business is the best thing I've seen happen in a long time.
  87. Uh so, uh and then you see you see this new world called software as a service in the cloud. That's a new area where
  88. there's no ground rules and where these former partnerships that governed, you know, this Cold War, it's it's like the
  89. wild wild west again. So, we think there's a lot of structural change going on in the technology industry across all
  90. of sectors. And that 5 years from now, you won't be able to tell a storage company from a networking company from a
  91. software company from an internet company. Everybody's going to try to do everything and grab that land again. So,
  92. I think it bodes well for for strong M&A activity going forward. Mhm.

Brief Summary

The episode analyzes the current tech IPO landscape and M&A activity compared to the post-2000 market, highlighting significant changes and challenges.

Key points

  • Historical Perspective on Tech IPOs. A look back at the evolution of technology IPOs from the 1980s to now.
  • M&A Market Recovery Insights. Discussion on whether the M&A market is likely to recover in 2010.

Related episodes