How Investor Learning Affects Firm Behavior

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Recent Wharton research illustrates the need for managers to understand where investor beliefs are when disclosing information. More: http://knlg.net/2iWDMRO 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today was Wharton accounting professor Frank Joe who's going to talk to us about someone who's recent
  2. research Frank thanks for being here thank you for inviting me and could you first give us kind of a short summary of
  3. the paper what question you were trying to answer okay so in my job market paper
  4. I basic look at how does investor learning affect firms voluntary disclosure decisions and by voluntary
  5. disclosure decision and mean management annual earnings forecast decisions we know that management and the earnings
  6. work as a very prevalent so it's an important question to ask what are the forces that shape management earnings
  7. pork at decisions and empirically there is a very interesting phenomenon which is that earnings forecasts decision tend
  8. to be sticky over time and I basically build a model trying to explain why this thickness occurs and try to empirically
  9. quantify this mechanism that I proposed and the mechanism is basically is that the learning about unknown firm
  10. profitability we know that investor they don't know everything so is a reasonable
  11. assumption that inverted they don't know from profitability and just by taking this simple premise I show that in such
  12. a learning leads to sticky disclosure incentives and the mechanism is very simple basically investors they have
  13. their prior information so that's you investing Apple and you think that Apple is a pretty good firm just by observing
  14. that ad post performance and drops a little bit in one time doesn't mean that Apple is about firm for you so in other
  15. words in that church beliefs are speaking over time and I show that investors build if in turn affect
  16. managers voluntary disclosure decisions and that would in turn lead to sticky disclosure incentives and my structural
  17. estimation shows that investor learning leads to very sticky disclosure incentives so that there is 10% increase
  18. in the likelihood of disclosure in one year caused by investor learning that would in turn lead to about 10% increase
  19. in the likelihood of disclosure in the next year so basically I mean for investors it's the more they learn the
  20. more they kind of confirm their beliefs about the firm yes and then the more they confirm their beliefs the more of
  21. the firm wants to disclose information about itself okay so the set of the investors
  22. believes on firm disclosure choice depends on whether the beliefs are optimistic or pessimistic if investors
  23. believe you're optimistic relative the actual firm profitability and that in turn leaves less room for the manager to
  24. convey good news and therefore the disclosure probability would go down and this basic dis research shows that it's
  25. important for the manager to take into account where investors beliefs are when they the manager decides whether to
  26. disclose information or not so basically to be to teach it about disclosure versus where investors are with the firm
  27. at that interview time yeah and so Charlie kind of going further with that and if I'm a firm or if I'm an investor
  28. how could I practically apply this research either to my firm decisions or how I act on my activity as an investor
  29. okay so this research is more from the managers perspective to tell the manager to pay attention to where investors are
  30. and often you empirically we see that you know some firms release some information which is not like a big
  31. surprise but there's a very large market reaction versus other times and when man
  32. like the manager really some information that is like basically in you know there's a very large surprise but
  33. there's very little stock price movements and my rates of basic tells manager to pay attention to where
  34. investors beliefs are and how uncertain they are investors are about their beliefs when manager decides whether to
  35. disclose information or not now are there key indicators in terms of where what investors beliefs are in a given
  36. time it is it just stock price or there are other things that they would be looking at to kind of stage back so the
  37. key component would be the stock price audited wasn't manager he or herself believes where the firm fundamentals are
  38. yeah so that's a key in because the manager knows about a company but investor they don't know so they have
  39. some valuation about the firm but manager probably knows whether in my firm is good or not so based on that
  40. that's a key indicator of investors belief and of course in my research I structurally so using a model to buy all
  41. the investors believe so potentially my model can be useful because I show that the model actually
  42. states the data pretty well right and so what would next for this research are you gonna follow decide so currently has
  43. a working paper on how investors process information that is was held from them about 50% of the time management does
  44. not issue earnings guidance and typically when this happens it indicates bad news and the investor kind of know
  45. it's bad news but surprisingly what investor when you better prize the firm it actually over prizes it and when the
  46. earnings are announced there's a subsequent decline in firm value so this is potentially both important to
  47. investors and to managers because on the one hand manager they're supposed to inform investors about what's going on
  48. or the manager could statistically take advantage of the investors inability to process the lack of disclosure and from
  49. the investors perspective they need to understand what the implication of firm strategic decisions in this case is
  50. disclosure choice and firm makes all kinds of strategic decisions and it's probably true that investor have a hard
  51. time understanding them too so this is the follow-up research great Frank thanks for being with us today okay
  52. thank you [Music] you [Music]

Brief Summary

Frank Joe discusses how investor learning affects firms' disclosure decisions and the implications for management and investors.

Key points

  • Investor Learning and Disclosure. Frank Joe discusses how investor learning affects firms' voluntary disclosure decisions.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes