Jeremy Siegel on Bear Stearns, the Rate Cuts and Inflation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The ongoing credit crisis in U.S. financial markets has claimed a huge and high-profile victim: Bear Stearns. After being slammed by what amounted to a run on the bank during the week of March 10, the Wall Street firm agreed to be acquired -- for $2 a share -- by JP Morgan Chase over the weekend in a deal overseen by Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson. The Federal Reserve lowered interest rates the same day -- and did so again on March 18, by three-quarters of a percentage point. Are other Wall Street firms likely to follow Bear Stearns into oblivion? Will the Federal Reserve's efforts help to boost confidence in the financial system? Finance professor Jeremy Siegel, author of The Future for Investors, discussed these questions and more with Knowledge@Wharton. 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at Warton please visit knowledge. won. up.edu for more
  2. information the ongoing credit crisis in US financial markets has claimed a huge
  3. and high-profile victim Bear Sterns the Wall Street Investment Bank and securities brokerage firm after being
  4. slammed by what amounted to a run on the bank during the week of March 10th be Sterns was pushed to the brink of Bank
  5. repy and then acquired for $2 a share by JP Morgan Chase over the weekend Federal
  6. Reserve chairman Ben Bernan and treasury secretary Henry Paulson played an active
  7. role in the transaction largely because of the potential impact that a major bankruptcy might have on confidence in
  8. the financial markets that same day the Federal Reserve lowered interest rates as it did again on March 18th by 3/4 of
  9. a percentage Point as the credit crisis shows no signs of easing our other wall Street firms likely to follow bare
  10. Sterns into Oblivion will the federal reserve's efforts help to boost confidence in the financial system Among
  11. Us and international investors Finance Professor Jeremy seagull author of the feature for investors discussed these
  12. questions and more with knowledge award Professor seagull thanks for joining us happy to be here Steve well the FED just
  13. lowered the interest rate by 34 of a point what effect do you think that that will have yeah that was right in the
  14. middle of of expectations what I thought they would do um there were two dissents this time
  15. which is is quite a lot uh Charlie pler joined Richard friser from the Dallas fed Charlie pler is here from the
  16. Philadelphia fed I know him very well he's actually a student of mine at uh uh when I Tau at the University of Chicago
  17. um and uh what concerns me and and I on the whole I think what Bernan is doing is is very good he's being aggressive
  18. where he has to be uh but but as I mentioned last time in the podcast I I I'm concerned that the FED is not acting
  19. as concerned about inflation as it should it did in its statement acknowledge that there were inflationary
  20. pressures uh but it did not Elevate inflation as a problem equal to the uh problem of of growth and I think both of
  21. them are problems at the present time so we're going to have to see how that plays out and whether Commodities are
  22. going to continue their ride upward it was broken yesterday uh but uh without coming out strongly against inflation
  23. we're going to be watching those commodity prices that's going to be important if they go back down it's
  24. going to be all right but if they continue up it's it's a threat let's turn to the other big story
  25. that's been playing out this week uh why did be Sterns implode so quickly it's like a run in the bank uh we don't have
  26. runs on banks anymore because we have we have Deposit Insurance we had the FED explicitly standing behind all the
  27. deposits but basically what happens is rumors start your your you know your money isn't isn't good and then you know
  28. you lose Nothing by getting it out uh uh so you you you run to the bank and and get it out now in in this case it's not
  29. a bank in in a formal sense but it's lenders that have been lending um uh Bear Sterns money against their
  30. portfolio against their purchases and all of a sudden they were worried about whether they would be repaid because
  31. this is very short-term Landing they all yanked their lending uh and this caused
  32. a tremendous cash squeeze because they didn't have enough cash and and and that's when the real problem started was
  33. the weekend sale at $2 a share to JP Morgan Chase the right move for the markets that that surprised me um uh a
  34. lot a lot uh I wasn't uh when they announced on Friday that they uh that the Fed was giving a 30 billion doll U
  35. uh credit or or or guaranteed to P Morgan I thought that that was a good move they said that it was going to be
  36. 28 days and I thought that they would auction take four weeks and and auction off uh uh Bear Sterns or or tell them to
  37. find other financing I mean that they didn't have to sell themselves uh I was I was very surprised that it was done so
  38. quickly and I'm and quite puzzled at it and um I don't know whether $2 is a is a
  39. is a good price I think there's going to be a lot of controversy about this issue
  40. uh going forward in terms of what in terms of the fact that the shareholders of Bear
  41. Sterns this is a stock that was selling at 160 less than a year ago even after all the problems were announced last
  42. Friday it closed at $30 a share No One dreamed that it should be two and to sell it out at two um uh you know next
  43. we get all the facts uh seems to me to be uh too extreme and and I don't understand why it had to be done so
  44. quickly maybe there will be information forthcoming about that maybe the management did think that they were
  45. bankrupt then rather sell it out at two rather than go through bankruptcy uh we'll have to see what the results are
  46. but it it it was a pretty shocking um price right what impact would a Bear Sterns bankruptcy have had on other
  47. financial institutions well you know you want to ask question is there much difference
  48. between $2 and and a bankruptcy uh I mean that's one reason why I I think that the 28 day loan that the the FED
  49. made last Friday was very appropriate in other words let let's give us time to to
  50. sort this out and make a uh you know a a a reasonable uh attempt at getting other
  51. financing find out what the assets are um and and and that's why it surprised me that a sale was pushed through so
  52. very very quickly here so I liked what the FED did on Friday I'm not quite certain about why it then uh had pushed
  53. through as the word has it an sort of an emergency um uh sale at at at a fire sale price right
  54. the timing was supposed to uh happen prior to the opening of the asan markets on on Monday correct right the
  55. interesting thing is that um the markets were actually going to be opening better
  56. uh if when they learned of the $2 price that that that panicked the market it wasn't uh that was a very bad piece of
  57. news um actually when they announced that they were cutting the discount rate uh as they did before the markets open
  58. good move when they announced the sale when they heard the word sale good move and then they announced the price $2 and
  59. bang everything fell apart so it was the price uh more than anything else that uh
  60. that shocked the market I certainly support the move of lowering the discount rate as they did a quarter a
  61. point um is is is Layman Brothers vulnerable um certainly when you looked at the market yesterday uh they were it
  62. it sold as low as 20 now today a lot of confidence come back and selling at 40 um I think they're I they are vulnerable
  63. everyone is quote vulnerable to a certain extent of a run uh however uh uh the financial status from everything we
  64. know about Lan is is far better than be Sterns bar stern was first of all far more involved in the mortgage back
  65. Market far levered I mean listen they thought this stuff was great they were buying it all the way down and uh with
  66. leverage and um uh although many Wall Street Banks ended up owning some of it they didn't keep on piling up it looked
  67. like a kind of a double down strategy on the part of Bear Sterns I mean look at this stuff is is is not worth as little
  68. the truth is had they had the liquidity uh to hold on um the be Stern's positions might have turned out to be
  69. very profitable just like long-term Capital Management 10 years ago had they been able to hold on uh those positions
  70. became profitable but um they weren't in both these institutions and um uh as a result without liquidity uh this this is
  71. this is a major risk you mentioned your surprised at the fed's move in all of this are are you uh what's your take on
  72. the fed's role uh it is it is it is playing a a proper role one has to realize when the when the Fed was was
  73. founded uh you know nearly 100 years ago um there was just the banking system I mean there really wasn't as much
  74. investment Banks and all the markets that we have today and and and everything else so all the lending
  75. functions were defined in terms of the banking system our financial system is so much bigger today I mean it covers i
  76. banks as well as commercial Banks and all sorts of markets uh that that did not really exist before so I think it is
  77. very proper for Bernan to now say let me extend credit to primary dealers they don't have to be dealing just with the
  78. commercial banks in other words we have to recognize the uh the um extensions of
  79. of the credit markets and the financial markets and I think that that he's doing
  80. so I think the as I say my at this point the only quibble I have with his policy
  81. uh is not coming out a little stronger on I'm worried about uh inflation because I think this is what's driving
  82. commodity prices and the dollar all his other moves I think have been very well thought of and uh certainly even the
  83. declines and interest rates if he had put a sufficient caveat on that I think I would I would uh approve of that also
  84. um uh on the whole though the FED is doing really just about everything in its power now to to keep the situation
  85. from uh developing worse and you know people say can get any worse when we look at the effects on the real economy
  86. so far um uh yes home prices are falling yes the home building industry is has turned negative as it has for the last
  87. year uh the amazing thing is is that the best estimate of Economist is that GDP growth in this first quarter just like
  88. the fourth quarter of of last year will again be positive and as we know unemployment rate has just ticked up a
  89. few T of 1% there has been um out a tremendous uh disturbances um and turmoil in the
  90. financial and credit markets but in the real economy um at this particular point
  91. we would have to say uh the effects are relatively mild okay what about the issue of moral hazard some critics have
  92. said that the FED inserting themselves in this situation other words yeah and I think one thing Steve and I I I think we
  93. all heard that as we're listening on on news reports this was not a bailout um by the FED I mean when the price of the
  94. stock goes down 99% virtually wiping out every uh share uh owner um and in fact I'm shocked they
  95. they did the price so low I really think the intrinsic work was was was probably
  96. a bit higher one-third of these were bears and employees that held the stock in one form or another I mean it the
  97. firm's Equity was virtually uh was virtually wiped out so I mean uh you know the people say always this is
  98. encouraging this type of behavior before you wipe out 99% of the value that's not
  99. going to encourage uh that sort of behavior for it also one has to realize that this was actually a loan to JP
  100. Morgan um uh uh and they are intending to unwind that loan my prediction is by the way that the FED will not take any
  101. loss on those guarantees because I think when uh you know when everything is sorted out there will be enough to cover
  102. that and there won't be any loss and so I I don't believe believe that this will
  103. encourage similar if they had you know said we're buying out a Bear Sterns at you know $100 a share that would be a
  104. whole different but not at $2 a year so they're not laying out a safety net there is really no safety wet I mean
  105. basically uh you know Bear Sterns went all the way down it just didn't technically go into the bankruptcy right
  106. right are the the recent interest rate Cuts likely to restore confidence in the financial markets do that's more than
  107. just the interest rate Cuts it's all these actions to extend credit beyond the uh traditional Commercial Banking
  108. areas into other Financial uh areas um and and the process of lowering it my feeling is that we're going to get
  109. through this and I think that the FED uh you know by late summer will emerg as wow it went through a really difficult
  110. time and saved the economy maybe not from a recession but from something much worse and we know what it could have
  111. been because the 19 30s were a similar sort of situation um but the FED did not stand behind the financial institutions
  112. and then they were Banks let them all fail and we had the the worst economy in history uh I I think when we look back
  113. we'll say we he put everything he could reasonably at it um and um we're going to have a maybe a mild recession but
  114. we're going to avoid anything worse and uh we banki may very well easily turn out to be a hero here um when when
  115. everything is said and done and the recovery comes if not a recession are we likely to have a longer and deeper
  116. slowdown than we've had at least in recent times well you know actually the interesting thing is that slowdowns have
  117. been a little longer but much shallower um the Deep downward Spike that we used to get like particularly in
  118. manufacturing you know suddenly down and then up spikes of unemployment have given way in a more service oriented
  119. economy and in uh in in a slower a much more muted behavior of of unemployment and employment and and a a little longer
  120. in other words remember the sluggishness coming out of the 2001 recession uh you
  121. know prompted Greenspan to keep rates down for a long period of time um uh so my feeling is we may not pick up until
  122. 2009 although I think 2008 might surprise us in the second second half but uh I certainly think it's going to
  123. be a very very mild recession if we do have one what are the implications for international markets well uh the the
  124. the the falling dollar is is a concern I voiced that uh at our last podcast that
  125. um I I worry that the International Community has uh not lost faith in in the Federal Reserve or in benan in terms
  126. of fighting the down term but in terms of fighting uh the uh inflation um and giving up on the uh International value
  127. of the dollar and I think that that's driving I mean since we talked you know a couple weeks ago the dollar has gone
  128. down even much further commodity prices have risen more oil is now you know back
  129. at 110 and going higher that is my my primary concern I think personally that is a bigger concern than you know Bear
  130. Sterns and the others those hit the headlines but you know what is happening to the dollar what's happening commodity
  131. prices um has has deep meaning in there and I'm afraid it's just going to give upward a pop of inflation which means
  132. that Bernan will then have to uh turn back from these cuts and in fact raise rates uh later on so if he comes against
  133. inflation now I don't think you would have to raise rates as much later on if he voices his concern he can break the
  134. commodity bubble and um and uh and save higher rates later on at this particular
  135. juncture I'm waiting for the market I mean we just got these Cuts uh you know today we'll see what happens on the
  136. commodi markets but if they continue to rise and the dollar continues to fall um
  137. uh Bernan is going to have to say we we uh we we now don't believe any more cuts
  138. are are needed or or desirable for our economy so Professor seagull what should investors be thinking about doing now
  139. well you know it's interesting in terms of uh you know when should you sell Market's gone down a little bit since
  140. then we've had a you know very good day today so far um one thing that I look at is Market
  141. sentiment um and uh we we've had I won't go into the details but we had some indicators that were very very negative
  142. um on the part of individual investors and newsletters and that is a contrary indicator in the sense that when
  143. everyone gets barrass and everyone throws in the town of the you know it's it's just horrible that's usually where
  144. the market turns around and I'm beginning to see a lot of that negative sentiment move into the market I'm
  145. seeing spikes of of of volatility I'm seeing um uh all sorts of indices flashing high anxiety and those indices
  146. are are are pretty reliable at bottoms uh in terms of of picking it I won't say we're at the bottom right now I think
  147. we're very close to the bottom uh don't get scared and sell anything out this is
  148. not going to be a Great Depression I know some people are talking about it um but uh if you see the way the FED is
  149. moving and making sure liquidity is in the system when you look at what happening in the real economy and
  150. believe it or not it's still moving along with very few people n have lost their jobs I think you'll see that
  151. there's a lot of reason to be confident about the future thanks very much for joining us today thanks for having
  152. me for more information please visit knowledge. won. up.edu [Music]

Brief Summary

Bear Stearns collapses, Fed intervenes, markets react to crisis.

Key points

  • Bear Sterns' Collapse. Bear Sterns faced a run on the bank and was sold for $2 a share.
  • Federal Reserve's Actions. The Fed lowered interest rates to combat the ongoing credit crisis.

Tension

60/ 100Some tension

Related episodes