Saatchi & Saatchi's Roberts: Getting to the Future First

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Kevin Roberts has been CEO Worldwide of Saatchi & Saatchi since 1997, and in the space of 11 years has cemented the ad agency's reputation as one of the most successful and creative companies in the industry. Among Saatchi & Saatchi's clients are Procter & Gamble, General Mills, Novartis, Toyota, JC Penney and the New York State Department of Economic Development. Roberts, who travels the world for the New York based company, is perhaps most well known for an idea he came up with called "lovemarks" -- which means creating a brand for which the consumer has "loyalty beyond reason." Before joining Saatchi & Saatchi, Roberts worked for Mary Quant Cosmetics, Gillette, Procter & Gamble and Pepsi-Cola. An edited version of the conversation follows.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at Warton please visit knowledge. won. up.edu for more
  2. information Kevin Roberts has been CEO worldwide of Sachi and sa since 1997 and in the space of 11 years has cemented
  3. the ad agency's reputation as one of the most successful and creative companies in the industry among Sachi and sa's
  4. clients are Proctor and Gamble General Mills nartis Toyota JC Penney and the New York State Department of Economic
  5. Development Roberts who travels the world for a new york-based company is perhaps most well known for an idea he
  6. came up with called love marks which means creating a brand for which the consumer has quote loyalty Beyond Reason
  7. end quote before joining Sachi and Sai Roberts worked for Mary Quant Cosmetics Gillette Proctor and Gamble and
  8. pepsicola Kevin thanks for joining us can you tell us tell us a little bit more about your love Mark idea and why
  9. it's been such a hit I it started about eight nine years ago when I was growing very concerned
  10. that mass marketing and commodification was going to put companies like mine out
  11. of business I thought Brands were getting strangled by assistant brand managers and by promotion budgets and by
  12. retailers so I started to think about what was the future Beyond brands um and I had a conversation with a guy
  13. called Alan Weber who at the time was the editor of Fast Company when the Fast Company was very hot and Allan said well
  14. it's time we did have some new thinking on Brands what do you got and I said well I think it's all about trust and
  15. you may recall the literature was very based on respect and Trust about a decade ago and he said that's not very
  16. exciting and it's not very fast company it's kind of business weeky but you know
  17. we really wanten be on the Leading Edge not behind it go away and think again so
  18. I went home pretty disconsolate you know despondent when you're in the ideas business and people stomp on your ideas
  19. it's not a great night so I went home and I live in tricker in New York and uh my wife's in New Zealand they're kind of
  20. a long way apart so I was there unloved my wife wasn't there Allan didn't like my idea so I opened a couple of bottles
  21. of red wine and was doodling around as you do at 2:30 in the morning and instead of trust marks I started to draw
  22. a little heart okay and I saw heart and marks and then love marks I thought man I got it this is so simple what's the
  23. deepest emotion of all so I went to bed 8:30 in the morning passed the 8:30 test
  24. called up Alan said man you got to come back he wrote a cover story about 3 weeks later on love marks and that how
  25. it was born it was then tested we proved it we researched it we figured it we kind of backfilled all the data into the
  26. concept which wouldn't you wouldn't do it knowledge Warton but it's what we did and we found out that yes indeed there
  27. was an incredible year learning for an emotional connection from consumers and about that time a lot of the thinking
  28. moved to emotional marketing so love marks was born really out of desperation and fear all right you have said in the
  29. past that one of the most successful examples of this is Michael Jordan when Nike hired him for their company people
  30. just absolutely established this incredible emotional connection with him somehow the company was able to start
  31. selling $70 shoes for2 $ he was a phenomenal success but then he retired what happens when your love Mark
  32. brand or your love Mark representative retires or goes into drug rehab or whatever how do you how do you keep that
  33. momentum up uh you've got to be authentic right and I think Nike had a very authentic position in you know
  34. they'd come from they started Life as a product which was very Innovative when bman introduced that the University of
  35. Oregon it was a waffle sold shoe that had benefit and attribute and it was lighter so it actually helped you run
  36. you know perform better right so it started Life classically as a product then when Phil Knight really got his
  37. juices flowing he turned it into a massively successful brand with all the brand iconography that we all familiar
  38. with the swoosh the just do it idea the kind of advertising approach that they took it took Jordan to move Nike from
  39. being if you like Irreplaceable to becoming irresistible because Jordan gave it aspiration he
  40. gave it emotional connectivity the whole idea was you know if you wear Nikes you
  41. can be like Mike which was a very aspirational thing for many people that's how the love Mark started for
  42. Nike and of course Nike the only purpose to create a love Mark is to charge a premium Brands were invented to charge
  43. premiums the premium went out of Brands she had to move into love marks Jordan went from $ sneakers as you said to
  44. selling $200 um Air Jordans then what happened two things Jordan retired and the sweat shop crisis right
  45. got really a big public heiring right it's very hard to love a company or a brand that is seen to be or perceived to
  46. be exploiting other humans right right because you know that's really tough thing Knight and the company then took a
  47. look at that and said whoa you know we got to go back to our roots so what did Nike do they went more and more local
  48. they sponsor every local college team every local soccer team every local athlete they continued with their Heroes
  49. Lance Armstrong and and Co but they moved right back into local Grass Roots they also addressed their sweat shop
  50. issue by a coming clean and B fixing it so love is something as it is in real life that you can win and you can lose
  51. it's certainly something you've got to earn every day and you can't take it for granted you've really got to get deep
  52. into the Grassroots of your consumer love marks are different to brands in one other key key way I think really
  53. brands are owned by brand managers and by companies okay and the biggest problem in business today is persuading
  54. companies to give up control because we've seen power shift you know when I grew up Brans had the power when I was
  55. at gillet or Proctor and Gamble man you know when I walked into to a store with Tide or Crest you were the King right I
  56. was the king okay and then we saw the the rise and Rise of Walmart you know the world's biggest company and we saw
  57. private label and we saw Aldi and we saw all the price guys and we saw Tesco in the UK kakur in France and we saw power
  58. switch from Brands to retailers that power has now gone forever Walmart has as little power as
  59. you can see from recent events as Proctor and Gamble as little or as much now power is switched to the consumer
  60. the consumer is boss and the consumer really will not be talked to or controlled she's in control so what we
  61. have to do is to give up control Nike had a hard time doing that had a hard time doing that now they've been able to
  62. do it they've been able to welcome the bloggers they've been able to welcome the interactivity so people are falling
  63. in love again what companies besides Nike have been able to establish this connection kind of to move Beyond that
  64. that yeah love marks are very personal right so they're personal to me and to you I mean the brands I love may not be
  65. the brands that you love but I mean Steve Jobs at Apple would be a classic example I mean you can buy any MP3
  66. player in the world that is cheaper than an iPod you know kind of the batteries will work it won't give you as much
  67. frustration and you wouldn't dream of doing that right because you're in love with the iPod it's got a 75 share it's
  68. trebled the profits of the company and it's allowed him to restage the music industry right because
  69. iPods there are three things that we think make a love Mark they are mystery sensuality and intimacy words that are
  70. never used on your MBA program okay and these words are at the heart of today's consumer choice and you know un lever
  71. don't use them very much but you can see with Dove that they are starting to understand that intimacy PNG on Pampers
  72. are starting to understand the whole sensuality area even on tide they've now got smell and all this kind of stuff
  73. really deep into the brand so it's those three words and and apple really really
  74. drip with that Toyota has had a recent uh ad campaign on YouTube that was actually
  75. the creative people were from Sachi and sa La I believe um what is that say about how how big companies are now
  76. using social uh networking sites to promote their products and is this going to kind of change the way that that you
  77. work with companies the consumer's boss so we shouldn't really be thinking about
  78. companies anymore or Brands anymore you're spot on so companies like mine have got to re-calibrate away from being
  79. brand Centric or company Centric or client Centric or service Centric and be consumer Centric Yoshi ishisaka who ran
  80. Toyota for a decade said to me 10 years ago Kevin you will never know more about
  81. cars than Toyota and we will never know more about the people who buy them than Sachi and Sai
  82. our companies like us now have got to become very very close to Consumers that's complex because every
  83. consumer is different so the whole Mass reach and scale thing has gone it's complex because information
  84. and knowledge are now pure and simple table Stakes you will send you know the NBAs
  85. out of here they'll be fully equipped with information they'll be very knowledgeable how to use
  86. it you know Harvard will do the same Stanford will do the same not as well as you guys but they will in all or own
  87. their little way Focus very hard on information and knowledge what will win in our world is using those vital table
  88. Stakes quickly but then developing insight and foresight now you can't get insight and
  89. foresight from data and from analysis okay you've got to get it you know if you want to know a hell of a lot about
  90. lions you better go to the Jungle not to the zoo so you've got to figure out how
  91. you can empathetically now have the insight into a consumer behavior and then have the creative
  92. foresight to do something about that before the competition jobs and his folks are very empathetic I remember you
  93. also said recently that uh while other people are saying that that that television and newspapers are dead that
  94. actually the television is the most important medium and will be the most important medium for the next 20 years
  95. because a people have them including come people abroad and B people know how to use them it's pretty important and
  96. you've also said that stores are the second most important medium the actual going into stores shopping experience as
  97. opposed to online shopping do you still feel that way yeah I I I I feel that we live first of all in the screen age
  98. right and I've written a book called siso which is provides sight Sound and Motion none of us now are ever ever ever
  99. more than a few inches away from a screen because we all carry the mobile phone in our pocket we all have a
  100. computer at work or at home we all have five or six TV screens at home we have our iPod with us we're constantly in a
  101. world of the screen more and more that screen will be as it is in in many cases already it will be interactive and it
  102. will be social and it will be networked and it will be mobile so the screen is going to be the the first place we all
  103. go TV will be the absolute dominant screen in the world just look at China look at Russia look at India look at
  104. Brazil look at Indonesia and look at the way TVs are absolutely going crazy even
  105. in the US people still spend two and a half hours a day in front of a television screen and you know you're
  106. not going to watch a game of football on a 3X3 in iPod you're going to watch it on a 48 in high tech High digital TV
  107. screen right the way you watch it will differ because you will want to have control you will want to be interactive
  108. you will want to be working with the screen so the screen's vital for all of us and it's a great Communications
  109. medium because you can hear it you can see it you can touch it you can interact with it you should be able to smell it
  110. but you can't yet but you can on some sites you know you can smell smell of a pizza and so on it drives you crazy and
  111. then in the store 85% of decisions are made in store that store can be an online store or it can be a physical
  112. store but that's where the decision making is being made today because we live in a world
  113. where pretty much all products are parity right all products do as build anti- dandruff shampoos get rid of
  114. dandruff okay moisturizers help make your skin soft beer tastes good you know so it's not the differences that they
  115. used to be in quality or Price they're not there anymore so there's going to be an emotional connection for you that
  116. makes you select one shampoo versus another 85% of the time that decision takes place in store in less than 3
  117. seconds boom most store experiences are revolting MH just terrible particularly supermarkets right right the idea now is
  118. creatively our creatives instead of now just focusing on a 60c 30 second TV spot
  119. boy they should start with an idea they should start with a consumer and they should start in store because if we can
  120. turn that store into a the of Dreams the the biggest thing that Apple did was stop selling in Best Stop relying on
  121. Best Buy and Walmart and open their own Store where the experience became an apple experience but how can you do that
  122. in a supermarket sure you can you can just take a fixture and you can instead of at the moment it's all
  123. fixtured um by product category instead of by consumer experience when you're in
  124. the cold season there are about 116 products that you need if you're if you think you're going to get a cold well
  125. they're never merchandised together in fact it's just 87 cough you know medicines oh so we're trying to bore the
  126. consumer into submission okay uh is this I'm going to switch gears here is this truth or or is
  127. this legend that when you were the CEO of Pepsi Cola Canada during a presentation you actually had a Coke
  128. vending machine brought onto the stage and you took out a machine gun and you blasted away at it and I hid it and you
  129. hit it that's important part of that story I'm assuming they were blanks and I'm assuming that there was actually no
  130. one seriously hurt and I'm assuming you did that as a business you made a business decision
  131. when you did that so I'm wondering what your think I wasn't just pissed you know
  132. trying to blast a Coke but but the other question related to that is I know that
  133. that that must have totally energized your audience which included employees and it must have energized you how do
  134. you keep up that that pumped up energy that you need for the kind of job that you have we'll start with the truth
  135. behind the story the story yeah it's it's true it was I was the CEO of Canada and we were number two to Coke and we'd
  136. been number two to Coke for5 years and we were by neelon share indices about 0 five of a point behind
  137. them that period And I figured if we could take our guys over the edge we could get
  138. leadership the time it was the nor uh the na agreement the North American free trade agreement was the big big kind of
  139. thing and the Canadians were very frightened of it because they thought they would be swallowed by uh America
  140. because America have scale and you know blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah and the guy called Brian Mone at
  141. the time was a prime minister of Canada and M had asked me to speak at some Pro because he was very Pro free trade and I
  142. was very pro- free trade would I speak at this big black tide dinner in Toronto and I said yes I would so we had the TV
  143. cameras there because because morone was there and because he was giving a speech
  144. suppor of free trade and I was opening the thing from from the role of business okay so I brought in a load of our big
  145. retail customers all of whom were very worried about free trade because they thought that Walmart were going to swamp
  146. lob laws and so on plus we had a load of so a lot of our customers there and a lot of key Pepsi people there a bunch of
  147. them and I made the point in my speech okay that competition was the way to go and that in this kind of free trade
  148. battle Canada would become stronger because we were fast we were flexible we could move quicker you know and all this
  149. kind of stuff and that we would be made better by the American competitors they would lift our game etc etc and I talked
  150. about how Pepsi in Canada was a company driven by all local bottlers and no local entrepreneurs whereas Coke was
  151. owned by the US company and I said so here we are right and here's what's going to happen to us and we're going to
  152. go with all my Canadian Vancouver botler and Kea bottlers we're going to go past them man
  153. I'm telling you and at that time I opened the the the theater curtains and brought on
  154. a big Coca-Cola vending machine bent down put on a a safety goggles picked up a machine gun and blew
  155. the thing into pieces everybody hit the deck they were you know ball gowns going
  156. all over the places handbags going we' of course told the Royal Canadian man police so they didn't shoot me cuz I was
  157. kind of nervous that somebody was going to pull a I would never have done it in Detroit or anything like that so and yes
  158. it was blank what it was I had all the vending machine lit up electronically so all I had to do was to hit it with a
  159. rubber bullet and the explosives inside of course what happened for the next three weeks the whole media was all over
  160. this thing it was shot across every piece of television and it was always with the line here's Pepsi going to go
  161. past coke blowing this every sales call my guys meant start started off with you
  162. work for that crazy guy who shot up the machine instant it's fantastic and we went past them right that so it was just
  163. that momentum theater to tip up over the edge and I think how do you keep yourself going I mean I'm if you're in a
  164. creative industry I'm in the ideas business right you know we live in the age of the idea Walton's in the ideas
  165. business right you're in the Innovation Business Without that you die I'm in the
  166. same business it's pretty exciting you know I'm not into process or routine or bureaucracy or what went before it's all
  167. about getting to the Future first um so if you can't get excited you know I'm surrounded by 5,000 creative people and
  168. you can never get those Eagles to fly in formation so you better enjoy it you I also read that that one of that your
  169. favorite job on the way up to the top or up on the way up to the current job you
  170. have now was as a brand manager for PNG in the 1970s what was so special about that learning you know I was kicked out
  171. of school when I was 17 so I wasn't able to do an NBA at Wharton so at the age of
  172. 25 I realized that my peers were simply smarter than me I was faster tougher more aggressive whatever else but they
  173. were smarter and in the end I thought you know what you you can't you can have as much EQ as you want but if you've got
  174. an IQ Gap it's not going to be very helpful I better fill that Gap and uh at the time I was working for the Gillette
  175. company and PNG never ever hired from other companies and I persuaded them that with me I was still only 25 they
  176. should make an exception so they started me at they punished me obviously being Proctor right as the lowest assistant on
  177. the on on the totem pole and uh I learned there for seven or eight years I must have learned 30 things a day and
  178. everything I now know about marketing pretty much was founded then right and when you went to when you went to Sachi
  179. and sa in 1997 I understand you were brought in to kind of revive was somewhat of a
  180. flagging company bad morale Etc and you're expected to bring in a whole team of people but you made a conscious
  181. decision not to let any of the old team go for two years now that's kind of counterintuitive to what we hear when
  182. they bring in new CEOs they they rush into bring their new team they get rid of all the dead word that they perceive
  183. as there why did you make that decision and did it work um I'd never worked in advertising before so I didn't really
  184. know much about advertising so I thought it would be kind of better if I if I work with the people that didn't know
  185. about advertising cuz I really didn't know anything about it I had no idea how an advertising agency worked cuz i' only
  186. worked on the other side I also think zigging when other zag is is kind of where I'd like to start so the very fact
  187. that everybody did it the other way around made me think well that usually doesn't work so let me have a another
  188. think about it and then I met the people in the first three days and I thought you know they're okay all that you're
  189. suffering from is a leadership vacuum you don't have a purpose you don't have a dream you don't have a framework
  190. you've been let down by the the two Sai brothers who led the company in typical style from a great entrepreneurial
  191. company to the biggest in the world and couldn't keep up so then it you know collapsed financially not not through
  192. functionally everybody's morale was battered and heaved but from a capability point of view I thought they
  193. were all still top talent M uh and it were I mean we've grown yeah you know our business 11 years out of 11 Revenue
  194. 11 years out of 11 margin top in the world creatively and got rid of the $2 billion debt and didn't um go into
  195. bankruptcy which is where we were heading right what's the best ad campaign you've ever
  196. seen uh the best ad campaign I've ever seen uh I don't spend a lot of time on ad campaign say the truth I think it was
  197. for Castleman Forex a beerer that you would never have heard of um in Australia and so the brand was Forex is
  198. like doseki in in Mexico so we had four cuz everything in Australia is bigger it's a bit like Texas so we had four and
  199. and the campaign was run to launch the Aussie logger in the UK and the campaign line was Aussies don't give up
  200. XXX for any other logger right and every execution was around that you know and uh it was it was it was absolutely
  201. absolutely Dynamic yeah one final question you were born in in England you live in Tribeca but actually your family
  202. and your your wife and children are in New Zealand where your home is why New Zealand uh I went there in 1989 head
  203. hunted to run the what was then the biggest company in New Zealand two companies merged together lion a big
  204. Brewer soft drink manufacturer and Nathan a big retailer that had the equivalent of Target and woolest and all
  205. those franchises they put these two companies together and had no idea how to run them or what to do with them once
  206. they would come together they wanted someone with International experience because they knew the future was outside
  207. of New Zealand cuz we only have 4 million people mhm and yes there are 25 million sheep there so we can move
  208. forward on that which would be good if they had purchasing power but they don't so so there's 4 million uh people and
  209. the businesses had nothing to do with each other at all right so we had to strategically decide how to go offshore
  210. what businesses to keep which businesses to sell and they wanted a someone from outside of both companies right to sit
  211. on top of it again and not a not a typical solution typically one guy would have won and one guy would have lost so
  212. I sat just on the top and they wanted someone who was not an American because I felt that Americans in New Zealand
  213. would probably not necessarily understand I'd been working in Canada I was born in England and they found that
  214. culture closer to New Zealand but you could have settled your family in any country you you probably been to what 90
  215. countries in the world you could have settled in any one have you been to New Zealand no well that would answer the
  216. question yeah it's Paradise I became in New Zealand within two years it's a value driven Society a value driven on
  217. egalitarianism on social equality on environmental issues and on great education for all so I'm from
  218. workingclass England it was like being transplanted into a place that the southern upper class hadn't ruined oh
  219. great thank you for joining us thank you very much for more information please visit
  220. knowledge. . up.edu [Music]

Brief Summary

Kevin Roberts discusses love marks, emotional branding, and marketing strategies in this episode.

Key points

  • The Birth of Love Marks. Kevin Roberts shares how the concept of love marks emerged from a moment of desperation.
  • The Consumer is Boss. Roberts discusses the shift in power from brands to consumers, emphasizing the need for companies to adapt.
  • A Bold Marketing Stunt. Kevin Roberts recounts a dramatic presentation where he shot a Coke vending machine to energize his team.
  • Reviving a Flagging Company. The decision to keep the old team for two years was counterintuitive but strategic.
  • The Best Ad Campaign. Aussies don’t give up was a dynamic campaign that resonated.
  • Why New Zealand?. The cultural fit and values of New Zealand appealed to the speaker.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes