Franklin Allen on Past Crises
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Credit Crisis Interview: Franklin Allen on Past Crises
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] this knowledge at Wharton podcast and videoast is brought to you by Wharton
- Executive Education for more information on Wharton's executive programs such as
- the executive development program leading and managing people or the new high potential leaders course please
- visit executive education. won. up.edu [Music] although the subprime crisis seems to be
- showing some signs of easing debate over what caused it whether it could have been prevented and how long it might
- last will continue for some time to come knowledge at Wharton asked Wharton Finance Professor Franklin Allen for his
- perspective on the latest economic developments welcome Professor Allen you've studied financial crisis all over
- the world and uh Through Time how does this one in the US stack up compar to the others I think it's too soon to tell
- at the moment we're not through it yet and it it it may end fairly soon but it may get worse if there are significant
- feedback effects in the real economy I think though that the one that has the closest parallels is the crisis
- that Japan went through in the 199s and in the early part of this Century so so how was the situation in Japan similar
- to that here the situation is similar in that one of the fundamental problems in
- Japan was was that property prices got out of line there was a huge bubble in Japan they fell 70 75% over 15 years and
- that wreak havoc on the financial system in particular the banks had enormous problems and that spilled over into the
- real economy and their growth rate went from being one of the highest in the world up until that time to being one of
- the lowest and they're still in some ways not out of it now the US I think the basic problem that caused this was
- that property prices got too high we had a bubble again it's an interesting question as to
- how big that bubble is some people say it's around 25% because property prices at the peak were about for the us as a
- whole about 25% higher than the long run Trend growth line and and if that's the
- case we what sort of Midway through the uh uh the pullback in prices yeah so they're down about uh 12 13% at the
- moment so if that was the correct diagnosis then it would be about another 12% to go but the interesting question
- is whether we will have feedback effects on the real economy unemployment will go
- up and those kinds of things and that will cause them to go down below their Trend rate so they may go down
- significantly further than that and over what period do you think that might happen if it does if you look at the
- people who are experts in the real estate market they they typically tending to say one two two more years or
- maybe a little bit longer than that but again it depends on the feedback effects
- because as one thing collapses that causes other things which feed back into property prices and so on we're
- certainly seeing a kind of contagion that's spreading I mean at first it was fairly easy to understand why investors
- would be nervous about Securities backed by subprime mortgages but we've also seen a kind of freezing of of debt
- markets for Securities on which there really haven't been large defaults uh and yet people are having a hard time
- pricing them and a very hard time selling them now what's caused that I think there's a great deal of
- uncertainty about what's going to happen going forward we don't really know what
- the feedback effects are going to be and we have very little idea of if if there is Contagion how serious that's
- going to be we don't really understand how the Federal Reserve will intervene so it's kind of a fear factor that just
- prevents people from doing anything that they think might be risky I think that's
- a large part of it that that there's great uncertainty now uh looking around the world there are there are various
- economies that are showing some signs of stress these days uh is it true that some of that is has Ripple effects from
- these problems in the US or are these just other economic factors uh taking over if you look at different parts of
- the world so I think it depends exactly where in the world one is looking at so um Japan is clearly having big problems
- I think that's somewhat related to this but it's more related to exchange rate issues Europe is also having problems uh
- some of that is direct but again I think a of that particularly going forward will be exchange rate issues so one of
- one of the problems here is that the central Bankers don't agree on what's going on
- and they've had different responses so the European Central Bank has kept interest rates fixed and the FED has cut
- them dramatically and that's led to a big difference which has caused the euro to go to record levels and that's going
- to hurt European exporters in a big way going forward I think so the fed's response to the problem here has had a
- ripple effect then in Europe with the it has skyrocketing Euro it it has it's been Amplified by the fact that the ECB
- has taken a very different position and you mentioned also that there there's been a certain amount of uh ripple
- effect from the US to Japan how how has that worked so again there's an exchange
- rate Factor so they they can't really change their exch their interest rate um and the yen is strengthened against the
- dollar not by as much as the Euro but that is also causing them problems but they have
- longer seated problems which we talked about a few minutes ago and they really still haven't recovered from those
- problems back in the early '90s now uh the dollar of course has been in the news a lot for for having fallen so
- much Al it's recovered a little bit just recently uh but is the is the the falling dollar is related in part to the
- Fed rate cuts that are response to the economic slowdown here so I think that's a large part of it but there's also a
- longer term problem which is we still have these big imbalances Global imbalances that people have been talking
- about for many years now we still run a huge deficit with the rest of the world and I think part of the response is is
- to that long long-term problem but it's definitely accentuated by the interest rate differences now there's uh been a
- lot of talk in recent years about the the booming economies in China and India and uh this changing the nature of of
- the international economy uh how do you see that evolving and and is that affected At All by these events in the
- US so I think that's a very important factor in what's happening in in the global economy in terms of higher
- commodity prices and higher oil oil prices so it's certainly playing into the inflation which we haven't talked
- about yet but is an important contributing factor to what's going on and and that and what is the mechanism
- the falling dollar again or so that's part of it but it basically there's a a greater Global demand for oil
- Commodities and for for food and that's driven up the prices of all these things
- and China and India are a large part of that that extra demand now their economies are continuing to do well uh
- the stock markets have actually dropped a fair bit more than most of the developed countries but their economies
- are actually much stronger and they're likely to remain strong in my view a lot of what's happening in China is is still
- demand for building infrastructure and so on and that's likely to continue now demand is is very high in those two
- countries China and India for Commodities and we've seen commodity prices uh go up quite a bit oil is and gasoline
- are certainly a of real concern to Americans and and some of that this I take it is due to the falling dollar and
- and and uh in addition to the demand issue yes I think it's both those factors I see and the falling dollar
- part of that can be traced to this subprime yes crisis as and so these different in interest rates that we
- talked about now uh you mentioned inflation you know how is inflation uh of course Commodities as as we just
- mentioned are a factor in inflation but uh what has been driving the uptick in inflation
- in the US recently so Commodities and oil have had a big impact on the headline number
- which is the total and the problem I think is that traditionally the the FED has not worried too much about the
- headline number they've looked at core inflation but it's been so big the rise in commodity prices and oil prices that
- it's now having a big impact and it's not clear that these things will be temporary I think some analysts are
- predicting oil will go to $200 a bar Barrel from its current level of around 120 and that may well happen and so
- these things can get worse rather than what usually happens which is that they're just quite volatile and go up
- and down but because of this long run situation of increased demand they may stay up now the Federal Reserve is
- always an a balancing act uh with interest rates if it it can reduce interest rates to stimulate the economy
- but cutting them too much stimulates inflation so it it has cut rates uh in recent months uh how do you assess its
- response in the in the rate cutting area I think they're engaged in a very interesting experiment I I I think we're
- in territory which we have very little idea of how things are going to play out going forward
- so they've cut rates to try and save the real economy and stop us going into recession and stopping what happened in
- Japan that that's often uh discussed as the rationale but as I say no one's really
- tried this in this way and it may well be it works out in which case maybe a year two years from now things will be
- fine everything will be back to normal but it may also be that things get worse and they being exacerbated by this
- cutting rates when inflation is at levels that we haven't seen for some time and the problem is if it gets
- embedded into people's expectations then it may start to take off again like it did in the
- 1970s well the 1970s were a period of horrific inflation as I recall being right out of college at the time and
- double digits mortgages were double digits during some of that period do you really think we're in for something like
- that I certainly hope not but uh you know it's already up to to over 4% in China it's running at
- 8% so I that's the sense in which I think we're into the unknown uh if you look in Europe it's also running high
- and there I think there is a a lot of evidence that is beginning to be built into the wage expectations and so on and
- the problem is once it gets into a spiral it's difficult to deal with particularly if the FED is cutting
- interest rates at the same time and you mentioned that the central banks in Europe have not responded with the same
- kinds of rate cuts that we've seen with the Federal Reserve why not part of is it is it that it they're
- in a different situation so they they don't perceive the risk of recession as being the same as here but also I think
- part of it is very much a difference in beliefs about what's important and what's going
- on so the European Central Bank they have one mandate which is to fight inflation and that's the result of long
- historical process from the 1923 inflation in in in Germany and so they even talking about raising rates in in
- in the Euro Zone and uh so I think it's a combination of different situation but
- also different philosophy the UK is a little bit mixed so they've done some Cuts but nothing like what the US has
- done now one of the things you said kind of surprised me because we we think back
- to uh there have been some changes in Germany and there were certainly changes in uh uh in Britain in the in the
- Thatcher era that but but you mentioned that the expectations of wage increases you think is is embedded or is that
- re-embedded uh didn't that used to be the problem they used to be the problem but the problem is that they're also
- running around you know these high levels around 4% three and a half% those kinds of numbers
- and there that's much more unionized in in many countries than we are here and so for example in recent trips to
- Germany one of the things one has to start worrying about is are the trains going to be on strike who's going to be
- on strike those those are things that haven't been that prevalent in Europe but they they've begun to happen again
- because of this inflation and demand for higher higher wages now coming back to the Federal Reserve another of the
- things it did uh in in response to the credit crunch was uh we don't know what term to use
- properly because bailout seems to be uh uh not approved of but they did something to help be Sterns or to ease
- that problem uh the transition to the purchase of JP Morgan what what was your feeling about that that
- maneuver so I think there are two issues here one is did they deal with the shareholders
- of be STS in the correct way and the second one is the more General one is should they have done uh the
- intervention at all so the reason they did the intervention was to prevent contag best ear's important counterparty
- in many transactions so I think one can debate that but probably they did the right thing there I think where they I
- would disagree with what they did is in providing a guarantee and at least as I understanding understand it not charging
- for it and that allowed the shareholders to walk walk away with substantial amounts of money not not large compared
- to what they would have had a year ago but nevertheless you know the the head of bur STS had sold his stake for $61
- million and if they charged for the guarantee in the way that uh the bank of England had talked about charging for
- the guarantee that Northern Rock got then it's not clear that they would have got very much at all if anything well we
- hear the term moral hazard in this context do you think that they've created a moral hazard I think they have
- I think as I said I think if if uh you know the the employees held large portions of the shares of best earns I
- think if going forward we get into similar situations if people think that they're going to be able to walk away
- with some money as opposed to nothing then that will make a big difference to the way they behave so Mr Kay may have
- behaved very differently if he thought that he would get zero with certainty if there were problems as
- opposed to walking away with 60 million which for most people is a a fairly comfortable retirement so I think it
- will change and hopefully next time they'll charge for the guarantee if they provide one and in addition to that the
- federal has the Federal Reserve has done some things like um in order to to improve liquidity uh like lending out
- treasury uh bonds and taking mortgage obligations that are much riskier as collateral and other types of things
- that that is done to make sure that there is money available to financial institutions uh have these been a good
- strategy so I think we're gaining we're in the unknown we don't we haven't done this before uh on the face of it it
- looks as though it helps the markets but I think we have to wait and see I think
- there are some aspects of it which are unfortunate so one of the things that financial institutions such as mutual
- funds have to do is to report their Holdings at end of quarter what they try and do is to get as high quality
- Securities on their books as possible and by the FED providing treasuries in exchange for Le low low quality
- Securities what they're doing is essentially helping financial institutions to make their books look
- better than they are in fact are so they hold high quality Securities provided by
- the FED for a day or two and then the rest of the time they're holding lower quality Securities and investors don't
- know about that because the FED is helping this lack of transparency this is what's called window dressing I think
- and it's because the financial reports are just a snapshot of that day exactly so you may not have owned it the day
- before you may get rid of it the day after but your investors think you loaded up on all this healthy stuff and
- they won't know the difference for 6 months exactly and that's that's a problem and what they should do instead
- is change it so that it's a random day sometime in the qu so people can't plan as you described all unfolds thank you
- very much thank you
Brief Summary
Wharton Professor Franklin Allen discusses the subprime crisis, its parallels to Japan's past, and global economic implications.
Key points
- The Uncertainty of the Crisis. Professor Allen reflects on the current economic crisis and its unpredictable future.
- Contagion in the Financial Markets. Discussion on the spreading effects of the financial crisis and investor nervousness.
- Fear in the Market. Exploring how fear affects investor behavior during economic uncertainty.
- The Fed's Experiment. Professor Allen analyzes the Federal Reserve's approach to rate cuts amid uncertainty.
- Inflation Concerns. A warning about the potential for inflation to spiral out of control.
Episode highlights
- The Uncertainty of the CrisisProfessor Allen reflects on the current economic crisis and its unpredictable future.“It's too soon to tell how this crisis will play out.”0:58Jun 18, 2008
- Contagion in the Financial MarketsDiscussion on the spreading effects of the financial crisis and investor nervousness.“We're certainly seeing a kind of contagion that's spreading.”3:27Jun 18, 2008
- Fear in the MarketExploring how fear affects investor behavior during economic uncertainty.“This is a fear factor that prevents people from doing anything risky.”4:12Jun 18, 2008
- The Fed's ExperimentProfessor Allen analyzes the Federal Reserve's approach to rate cuts amid uncertainty.“The Federal Reserve is engaged in a very interesting experiment.”10:20Jun 18, 2008
- Inflation ConcernsA warning about the potential for inflation to spiral out of control.“If inflation gets embedded into people's expectations, it may take off again.”11:10Jun 18, 2008
Tension
65/ 100Some tension





