Franklin Allen on Past Crises

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Credit Crisis Interview: Franklin Allen on Past Crises

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] this knowledge at Wharton podcast and videoast is brought to you by Wharton
  2. Executive Education for more information on Wharton's executive programs such as
  3. the executive development program leading and managing people or the new high potential leaders course please
  4. visit executive education. won. up.edu [Music] although the subprime crisis seems to be
  5. showing some signs of easing debate over what caused it whether it could have been prevented and how long it might
  6. last will continue for some time to come knowledge at Wharton asked Wharton Finance Professor Franklin Allen for his
  7. perspective on the latest economic developments welcome Professor Allen you've studied financial crisis all over
  8. the world and uh Through Time how does this one in the US stack up compar to the others I think it's too soon to tell
  9. at the moment we're not through it yet and it it it may end fairly soon but it may get worse if there are significant
  10. feedback effects in the real economy I think though that the one that has the closest parallels is the crisis
  11. that Japan went through in the 199s and in the early part of this Century so so how was the situation in Japan similar
  12. to that here the situation is similar in that one of the fundamental problems in
  13. Japan was was that property prices got out of line there was a huge bubble in Japan they fell 70 75% over 15 years and
  14. that wreak havoc on the financial system in particular the banks had enormous problems and that spilled over into the
  15. real economy and their growth rate went from being one of the highest in the world up until that time to being one of
  16. the lowest and they're still in some ways not out of it now the US I think the basic problem that caused this was
  17. that property prices got too high we had a bubble again it's an interesting question as to
  18. how big that bubble is some people say it's around 25% because property prices at the peak were about for the us as a
  19. whole about 25% higher than the long run Trend growth line and and if that's the
  20. case we what sort of Midway through the uh uh the pullback in prices yeah so they're down about uh 12 13% at the
  21. moment so if that was the correct diagnosis then it would be about another 12% to go but the interesting question
  22. is whether we will have feedback effects on the real economy unemployment will go
  23. up and those kinds of things and that will cause them to go down below their Trend rate so they may go down
  24. significantly further than that and over what period do you think that might happen if it does if you look at the
  25. people who are experts in the real estate market they they typically tending to say one two two more years or
  26. maybe a little bit longer than that but again it depends on the feedback effects
  27. because as one thing collapses that causes other things which feed back into property prices and so on we're
  28. certainly seeing a kind of contagion that's spreading I mean at first it was fairly easy to understand why investors
  29. would be nervous about Securities backed by subprime mortgages but we've also seen a kind of freezing of of debt
  30. markets for Securities on which there really haven't been large defaults uh and yet people are having a hard time
  31. pricing them and a very hard time selling them now what's caused that I think there's a great deal of
  32. uncertainty about what's going to happen going forward we don't really know what
  33. the feedback effects are going to be and we have very little idea of if if there is Contagion how serious that's
  34. going to be we don't really understand how the Federal Reserve will intervene so it's kind of a fear factor that just
  35. prevents people from doing anything that they think might be risky I think that's
  36. a large part of it that that there's great uncertainty now uh looking around the world there are there are various
  37. economies that are showing some signs of stress these days uh is it true that some of that is has Ripple effects from
  38. these problems in the US or are these just other economic factors uh taking over if you look at different parts of
  39. the world so I think it depends exactly where in the world one is looking at so um Japan is clearly having big problems
  40. I think that's somewhat related to this but it's more related to exchange rate issues Europe is also having problems uh
  41. some of that is direct but again I think a of that particularly going forward will be exchange rate issues so one of
  42. one of the problems here is that the central Bankers don't agree on what's going on
  43. and they've had different responses so the European Central Bank has kept interest rates fixed and the FED has cut
  44. them dramatically and that's led to a big difference which has caused the euro to go to record levels and that's going
  45. to hurt European exporters in a big way going forward I think so the fed's response to the problem here has had a
  46. ripple effect then in Europe with the it has skyrocketing Euro it it has it's been Amplified by the fact that the ECB
  47. has taken a very different position and you mentioned also that there there's been a certain amount of uh ripple
  48. effect from the US to Japan how how has that worked so again there's an exchange
  49. rate Factor so they they can't really change their exch their interest rate um and the yen is strengthened against the
  50. dollar not by as much as the Euro but that is also causing them problems but they have
  51. longer seated problems which we talked about a few minutes ago and they really still haven't recovered from those
  52. problems back in the early '90s now uh the dollar of course has been in the news a lot for for having fallen so
  53. much Al it's recovered a little bit just recently uh but is the is the the falling dollar is related in part to the
  54. Fed rate cuts that are response to the economic slowdown here so I think that's a large part of it but there's also a
  55. longer term problem which is we still have these big imbalances Global imbalances that people have been talking
  56. about for many years now we still run a huge deficit with the rest of the world and I think part of the response is is
  57. to that long long-term problem but it's definitely accentuated by the interest rate differences now there's uh been a
  58. lot of talk in recent years about the the booming economies in China and India and uh this changing the nature of of
  59. the international economy uh how do you see that evolving and and is that affected At All by these events in the
  60. US so I think that's a very important factor in what's happening in in the global economy in terms of higher
  61. commodity prices and higher oil oil prices so it's certainly playing into the inflation which we haven't talked
  62. about yet but is an important contributing factor to what's going on and and that and what is the mechanism
  63. the falling dollar again or so that's part of it but it basically there's a a greater Global demand for oil
  64. Commodities and for for food and that's driven up the prices of all these things
  65. and China and India are a large part of that that extra demand now their economies are continuing to do well uh
  66. the stock markets have actually dropped a fair bit more than most of the developed countries but their economies
  67. are actually much stronger and they're likely to remain strong in my view a lot of what's happening in China is is still
  68. demand for building infrastructure and so on and that's likely to continue now demand is is very high in those two
  69. countries China and India for Commodities and we've seen commodity prices uh go up quite a bit oil is and gasoline
  70. are certainly a of real concern to Americans and and some of that this I take it is due to the falling dollar and
  71. and and uh in addition to the demand issue yes I think it's both those factors I see and the falling dollar
  72. part of that can be traced to this subprime yes crisis as and so these different in interest rates that we
  73. talked about now uh you mentioned inflation you know how is inflation uh of course Commodities as as we just
  74. mentioned are a factor in inflation but uh what has been driving the uptick in inflation
  75. in the US recently so Commodities and oil have had a big impact on the headline number
  76. which is the total and the problem I think is that traditionally the the FED has not worried too much about the
  77. headline number they've looked at core inflation but it's been so big the rise in commodity prices and oil prices that
  78. it's now having a big impact and it's not clear that these things will be temporary I think some analysts are
  79. predicting oil will go to $200 a bar Barrel from its current level of around 120 and that may well happen and so
  80. these things can get worse rather than what usually happens which is that they're just quite volatile and go up
  81. and down but because of this long run situation of increased demand they may stay up now the Federal Reserve is
  82. always an a balancing act uh with interest rates if it it can reduce interest rates to stimulate the economy
  83. but cutting them too much stimulates inflation so it it has cut rates uh in recent months uh how do you assess its
  84. response in the in the rate cutting area I think they're engaged in a very interesting experiment I I I think we're
  85. in territory which we have very little idea of how things are going to play out going forward
  86. so they've cut rates to try and save the real economy and stop us going into recession and stopping what happened in
  87. Japan that that's often uh discussed as the rationale but as I say no one's really
  88. tried this in this way and it may well be it works out in which case maybe a year two years from now things will be
  89. fine everything will be back to normal but it may also be that things get worse and they being exacerbated by this
  90. cutting rates when inflation is at levels that we haven't seen for some time and the problem is if it gets
  91. embedded into people's expectations then it may start to take off again like it did in the
  92. 1970s well the 1970s were a period of horrific inflation as I recall being right out of college at the time and
  93. double digits mortgages were double digits during some of that period do you really think we're in for something like
  94. that I certainly hope not but uh you know it's already up to to over 4% in China it's running at
  95. 8% so I that's the sense in which I think we're into the unknown uh if you look in Europe it's also running high
  96. and there I think there is a a lot of evidence that is beginning to be built into the wage expectations and so on and
  97. the problem is once it gets into a spiral it's difficult to deal with particularly if the FED is cutting
  98. interest rates at the same time and you mentioned that the central banks in Europe have not responded with the same
  99. kinds of rate cuts that we've seen with the Federal Reserve why not part of is it is it that it they're
  100. in a different situation so they they don't perceive the risk of recession as being the same as here but also I think
  101. part of it is very much a difference in beliefs about what's important and what's going
  102. on so the European Central Bank they have one mandate which is to fight inflation and that's the result of long
  103. historical process from the 1923 inflation in in in Germany and so they even talking about raising rates in in
  104. in the Euro Zone and uh so I think it's a combination of different situation but
  105. also different philosophy the UK is a little bit mixed so they've done some Cuts but nothing like what the US has
  106. done now one of the things you said kind of surprised me because we we think back
  107. to uh there have been some changes in Germany and there were certainly changes in uh uh in Britain in the in the
  108. Thatcher era that but but you mentioned that the expectations of wage increases you think is is embedded or is that
  109. re-embedded uh didn't that used to be the problem they used to be the problem but the problem is that they're also
  110. running around you know these high levels around 4% three and a half% those kinds of numbers
  111. and there that's much more unionized in in many countries than we are here and so for example in recent trips to
  112. Germany one of the things one has to start worrying about is are the trains going to be on strike who's going to be
  113. on strike those those are things that haven't been that prevalent in Europe but they they've begun to happen again
  114. because of this inflation and demand for higher higher wages now coming back to the Federal Reserve another of the
  115. things it did uh in in response to the credit crunch was uh we don't know what term to use
  116. properly because bailout seems to be uh uh not approved of but they did something to help be Sterns or to ease
  117. that problem uh the transition to the purchase of JP Morgan what what was your feeling about that that
  118. maneuver so I think there are two issues here one is did they deal with the shareholders
  119. of be STS in the correct way and the second one is the more General one is should they have done uh the
  120. intervention at all so the reason they did the intervention was to prevent contag best ear's important counterparty
  121. in many transactions so I think one can debate that but probably they did the right thing there I think where they I
  122. would disagree with what they did is in providing a guarantee and at least as I understanding understand it not charging
  123. for it and that allowed the shareholders to walk walk away with substantial amounts of money not not large compared
  124. to what they would have had a year ago but nevertheless you know the the head of bur STS had sold his stake for $61
  125. million and if they charged for the guarantee in the way that uh the bank of England had talked about charging for
  126. the guarantee that Northern Rock got then it's not clear that they would have got very much at all if anything well we
  127. hear the term moral hazard in this context do you think that they've created a moral hazard I think they have
  128. I think as I said I think if if uh you know the the employees held large portions of the shares of best earns I
  129. think if going forward we get into similar situations if people think that they're going to be able to walk away
  130. with some money as opposed to nothing then that will make a big difference to the way they behave so Mr Kay may have
  131. behaved very differently if he thought that he would get zero with certainty if there were problems as
  132. opposed to walking away with 60 million which for most people is a a fairly comfortable retirement so I think it
  133. will change and hopefully next time they'll charge for the guarantee if they provide one and in addition to that the
  134. federal has the Federal Reserve has done some things like um in order to to improve liquidity uh like lending out
  135. treasury uh bonds and taking mortgage obligations that are much riskier as collateral and other types of things
  136. that that is done to make sure that there is money available to financial institutions uh have these been a good
  137. strategy so I think we're gaining we're in the unknown we don't we haven't done this before uh on the face of it it
  138. looks as though it helps the markets but I think we have to wait and see I think
  139. there are some aspects of it which are unfortunate so one of the things that financial institutions such as mutual
  140. funds have to do is to report their Holdings at end of quarter what they try and do is to get as high quality
  141. Securities on their books as possible and by the FED providing treasuries in exchange for Le low low quality
  142. Securities what they're doing is essentially helping financial institutions to make their books look
  143. better than they are in fact are so they hold high quality Securities provided by
  144. the FED for a day or two and then the rest of the time they're holding lower quality Securities and investors don't
  145. know about that because the FED is helping this lack of transparency this is what's called window dressing I think
  146. and it's because the financial reports are just a snapshot of that day exactly so you may not have owned it the day
  147. before you may get rid of it the day after but your investors think you loaded up on all this healthy stuff and
  148. they won't know the difference for 6 months exactly and that's that's a problem and what they should do instead
  149. is change it so that it's a random day sometime in the qu so people can't plan as you described all unfolds thank you
  150. very much thank you

Brief Summary

Wharton Professor Franklin Allen discusses the subprime crisis, its parallels to Japan's past, and global economic implications.

Key points

  • The Uncertainty of the Crisis. Professor Allen reflects on the current economic crisis and its unpredictable future.
  • Contagion in the Financial Markets. Discussion on the spreading effects of the financial crisis and investor nervousness.
  • Fear in the Market. Exploring how fear affects investor behavior during economic uncertainty.
  • The Fed's Experiment. Professor Allen analyzes the Federal Reserve's approach to rate cuts amid uncertainty.
  • Inflation Concerns. A warning about the potential for inflation to spiral out of control.

Tension

65/ 100Some tension

Related episodes