Europe: The Problems are "Deeper than We Fully Realize"

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

An interview with Jon Huntsman, Jr, former U.S. Presidential candidate.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] not at all optimistic I think it's a lot deeper than we fully realize you've got
  2. sovereign debt problems that are on top of uh traditional banking problems that are on top of serious growth problems
  3. and you're not going to solve the former two until you figure out how to grow and
  4. growth is not going to occur until such time as governments promulgate some progrowth policies which are a ways off
  5. so I would say this year probably is as Bleak as we've seen in a very long time but we're going to have to figure out
  6. how deep the crisis is and whether it's Greece or Greece and Spain Spain and Italy you know the third and fourth
  7. largest econ iies of the Euro Zone whether or not that impacts France for example what in other words the metastas
  8. is ultimately uh but I think we're a long ways off from being able to make any real sense of
  9. it well I think there has to be a sense of predictability going forward from a regulatory standpoint from a tax policy
  10. standpoint uh from an overall long-term austerity uh standpoint in other words it's one thing to have a certain at A-
  11. kilter debt to GDP ratio but beyond that what is your investment regime going to
  12. look like is it going to stay consistent uh and bankable investable for more than
  13. just a year I think all these things are going to be terribly important to the investor Community going forward and
  14. with uh the unpredictable nature of where some of the economies are in the Euro Zone getting any of those longer
  15. term policies in place that will really give the sense of confidence to the investor Community really is almost
  16. impossible how do you stimulate investment you stimulate investment by creating an economy that is conducive to
  17. investment and Capital's a coward let's face it and it's going to flee wherever it perceives you're to be risk in the
  18. marketplace and find a safe haven so how do you make your economy a safe haven it's generally done by uh tax policy uh
  19. by investment regimes that are uh improved either through transparency or trade and investment facilitation
  20. measures so all of those are things that can be looked at and implemented but again the marketplace is going to say
  21. that may be a quick fix and it may be something that I can't Bank on longer term and I think that really is the
  22. problem in the Euro zone right now is how do you promote enough in the way of confidence in your longer Term Policy
  23. policy making so that it isn't one regime overtaken by another a year or two from now who will come in with
  24. completely different policies that's that's the fix that they're in that's another side of the equation
  25. the whole demand side of of of the economy and the high levels of of unemployment and the missed
  26. opportunities on the human capital side so it's a it's a serious serious set of circumstances right now and I think
  27. we're years away from any kind of settle settling out or ultimately a calming effect that would provide enough in the
  28. way of confidence and longer term policymaking uh transparency where investment is going
  29. to be attracted in any serious way I'd have to say the high levels of unemployment and the displacement on the
  30. social side because that leads to what I would consider to be unpredictable outcomes in terms of social unrest it's
  31. one thing to deal with the economic side numbers that just aren't looking good it's another to look at the social
  32. implications of high unemployment like we're seeing in in Greece and Spain and the unrest the unrest that that could
  33. very well trigger boy farbe it for me to Advocate anything in in Europe Beyond which
  34. they're already uh looking at but clearly you've got to attack debt you've got to figure out how to get your debt
  35. to GDP into some sort of manageable number that speaks to longer term confidence then you've got to attract
  36. investment you've got to have Seed corn with which to build your economic base and change the fundamentals and put
  37. people back to work and investment isn't coming in until there's a clearer picture of where the economies are going
  38. longer term and again that gets right back to debt uh with a higher debt to GDP ratio the longer term Outlook is
  39. very very Bleak so I think I would attack the debt side first knowing full well that that could boost a little bit
  40. in the way of longer term confidence bringing an investment that could ultimately settle out the unemployment
  41. problem I think you've got a broader uh architectural overlay that is altogether
  42. problematic that we aren't even talking about and and that is what about the Euro Zone what about the fiscal and
  43. monetary Union what about the Euro these are all issues beyond the individual economies that have to do with the
  44. regional architecture uh that have got to be resolved and many say today well it was a failed start you know was okay
  45. to call it a failed start today but what do you do about it so before you really
  46. start drilling down on the individual member states and some of their problems you got to deal with the problem of
  47. Europe and what it means to be managed economically within a common market or a common framework that doesn't seem to be
  48. working out so well so who do you call do you call Brussels do you call the nation's capital that you have queries
  49. about uh you've got the overlay of 27 countries in the EU to say nothing of the 17 member Euro Zone that each has
  50. you know bureaucrats in Brussels that handle the various aspects of economic trade and foreign policy and so they're
  51. it's a topheavy system and it's really difficult to talk about how you bring back to life an individual nation state
  52. when you've got this architectural overlay that really is failing the region in a very serious
  53. way well to have a successful fiscal Union like the United States has a fiscal Union for
  54. example you have to have Labor Mobility just to begin the conversation I don't think Europe has anywhere near the labor
  55. Mobility that you need to make it work you've got to have some recognition that the wealthier states are willing to
  56. somehow subsidize the weaker States we do in the United States without really calling at that but you know that's kind
  57. of how our system of subsidies out of Washington taxation to watch and then payments back to the States really
  58. really works in order for all of this to work you've got to have a stronger political union uh to back everything up
  59. so it's as if you had uh a couple going off to be married not yet uh finalized yet you take out a joint checking
  60. account and You Begin transacting business with all the uncertainty that that would then uh entail uh you can't
  61. you can only go so far with a fiscal and monetary Union without uh a strong political union to provide the
  62. cohesiveness and that's where the card has been put before the horse so to speak and I'm not sure longer term that
  63. a political union the kind that would be necessary in terms of the innate inherent cohesiveness is going to be
  64. there to support uh uh an economic or a fiscal Union longer term I think that that that's exactly right
  65. and I'm not sure that a 70-year experiment uh you know let's just take it from Post World War II from the
  66. Breton Woods period right through to the Accords of the early 1990s the master master treaty uh and then take that
  67. through to today I'm not sure that the leaders of Europe are going to easily dismiss what has been the most important
  68. experiment economically and politically uh uh uh in Europe since World War II and maybe in maybe in 100 to 200 years I
  69. think they will endeavor to make it work so that you don't end up with a two-tiered system I think that's
  70. terribly problematic from a currency standpoint from a trade and investment standpoint but then they're going to
  71. have to deal with Greece and in order to deal with Greece so that they don't fall
  72. out of the Euro Zone uh someone's going to have to back stop the the numbers and
  73. there's only one country that can do that and uh and that's Germany and then in Germany you have to conclude that
  74. what is an economic problem for most others becomes a political problem for Angela Merkel she can't very well make
  75. the sale on the streets of Berlin when they say well gee in 2000 we were the problem economy and we did what needed
  76. to be done in the interim in terms of austerity in terms of getting our balances back in working order and you
  77. want us to do what you want us to subsidize those who aren't willing to step up and and uh Embrace those
  78. difficult measures that are needed uh such as we did that becomes politically untenable and so that's kind of where we
  79. find ourselves today is an economic problem that fundamentally becomes a political problem for Germany uh and a
  80. relative stalemate and the European Central Bank trying to create a wall uh a back stop uh to the best of its
  81. ability with certain member states playing a supporting role to ensure that or to try to keep contagion from from
  82. breaking out maybe some the Asian Cris crisis was followed by some pretty serious
  83. austerity and uh getting their balances back in in working order very aggressively might add to the point
  84. where for example the South Koreans you know were very angry at the IMF and the United States for the tough medicine
  85. that they advocated but they got through it and I would say they probably got through it better because relatively
  86. speaking many affected were smaller economies they're also newer economies uh they didn't have much as much drag uh
  87. uh in their systems as you find over uh in Europe it's also a more buoyant region in terms of uh inner Asian trade
  88. and investment flows uh so to some extent I think you could say they had imbalances they addressed
  89. the imbalances uh they took some really tough steps that were advocated by the IMF the United States and others and
  90. they got back in the game uh but there were also some factors that would would have made them a different set of
  91. circumstances in Europe well you have to ask yourself the question where are the engines of growth
  92. the global economy has always had in recent years some reliable engines of growth to pull
  93. those economies who were performing at lesser levels along but you're hard pressed to see any
  94. entrance of growth today uh China will remain reasonably strong they may not put in an 8% number or % number but
  95. certainly probably a seven or a seven plus perc number which is way down historically from where they've been
  96. over the last 30 years uh India is down probably by a factor of 30 to 40% in terms of their own growth numbers so
  97. where where are the engines of growth and I think that's bad news for the global economy and so you
  98. may get by with you know one and a half maybe 2% if you're lucky uh waiting for the traditional engines of growth to
  99. refire themselves and uh and get moving again but I think the next year or two are going to be very tough for the
  100. global economy uh and uh I think the I think a lot of it will depend on how quickly the
  101. United States gets back in the game I I would say streamline uh investment regimes uh introduce greater
  102. transparency into the system open Financial Services markets Insurance markets do a better job protection
  103. protecting intellectual property rights I think these are all probably quit manipulating your currency
  104. to the extent that you do uh these are all probably steps that would uh enhance the prospects of both countries China
  105. and India longer term they're hard to do uh particularly during periods of uncertainty when your export markets are
  106. uh less Reliant today than they were just uh a few short months ago even uh you're going to think Inward and you're
  107. going to Resort more to uh protectionist measures and you're going to be more inclined to manipulate your currency and
  108. to keep closed some of those markets that even under uh WTO agreements you uh you agree to open it it uh at some point
  109. so this we're we're at an important uh time uh in terms of whether or not some of the newer emerging economies are
  110. really willing to step up and show their commitment to to growth and to reform and to economic
  111. openness well the evidence is there that they're in that transition to some degree um when they announced stimulus
  112. measures as they did about 3 weeks ago to uh incentivize consumers to buy more in the way of household appliances
  113. televisions big screens consumer goods you know they're taking this transition seriously and
  114. they have to because the math just doesn't work for them any other way you can't maintain their current trajectory
  115. as just an export power uh and expect to deal with the demographic changes that lie on the horizon when you've got
  116. more people leaving the workforce and you have entering the workforce uh your costs are going to increase and labor
  117. rates and indeed in the southern manufacturing zones around Guang Joo and Beyond we're seeing prices escalate and
  118. I think that's because of the upside down demographics that China is just on the front end of
  119. experiencing and so you've got longer term four grandparents two parents one wager
  120. you got an upside down pyramid essentially uh and so how do you make the numbers work longer term how do you
  121. deal with health care costs Social Security costs and uh an affordable housing cost when you get real estate
  122. bubbles every now and again they want certainty and uh certainty is tough to achieve when once you've started that
  123. transition from an export Le economy to more of a consumption economy but they they've taken that risk flexibility is
  124. driven by necessity uh because they can't go back to their old form of managing the
  125. economy and expect to survive longer term they're in unchartered territory right now and but it's all that's also
  126. by necessity [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode analyzes the bleak economic outlook for the Euro Zone and global markets, emphasizing debt issues and the need for pro-growth policies.

Key points

  • Economic Bleakness. This year is predicted to be one of the bleakest in recent history.
  • Investment Confidence. Investment won't return until there's clarity in economic policies.
  • Unchartered Territory. China is navigating unchartered territory in its economic transition.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes