The Pain in Spain: An Economy in Crisis

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton Management Professor Mauro Guillen on Spains Economic Crisis 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] we're speaking today about the economic and financial problems in Spain with
  2. Maro Gan management professor at Wharton and also director of the Lauder Institute of international studies uh
  3. welcome good morning Steve happy to have you with us today sovereign debt is big in the news
  4. these days particularly with Greece but Spain is actually perhaps a bigger challenge for Europe because its economy
  5. is four times the size of Greece uh could you tell us about the problems in Spain and how they've developed well as
  6. far as sovereign debt is concerned uh it is true that Spain is a much bigger economy one of the largest nine or 10
  7. economies in the world however the debt burden right now is not as big as uh that of uh uh Greece or Italy uh or even
  8. the UK it's actually about the same level compared to the size of the economy as in Germany uh the problem of
  9. course looking uh towards the future is that it is growing fast because of high Unemployment uh but it is still is at
  10. manageable levels and uh that is I think reflected in the fact that the country continues to get a AAA rating uh from
  11. the agencies well it's interesting that uh Spain is actually in pretty good shape
  12. based on what you've just said um but there's a lot of concern that its debts going to go up now in the case of
  13. Greece uh it was a little bit more of a typical case where where most observers U see that as
  14. a case of government overspending uh but Spain's actually been very good in managing its debt and actually I think
  15. ran surpluses for four or five years leading up to the financial crisis yeah uh and so they were in part a victim
  16. weren't they of circumstances AB absolutely um this is not to minimize the problems that beset the country I
  17. mean the problems are serious I don't think the Deb problem is as urgent as some of the other problems and of course
  18. everything is interrelated so I I did not mean to uh minimize the uh uh you know difficulties uh lying ahead uh but
  19. I don't think the debt itself is a big problem now of course you know comparisons with Greece are easy to make
  20. but at the same time uh are uh you know difficult to justify uh because Greece is a relatively small economy uh it's
  21. not very competitive uh it has been basically you know propped up by by the by the rest of Europe uh Greece is is
  22. not a country that uh contains a lot of companies that are internationally uh you know competitive or that have a
  23. global presence um so it is a very very peculiar case now having said that it is
  24. one of the member countries of the Euro system uh and as such then uh you know anything that goes wrong with any of the
  25. members of the Euro undermines The credibility of the entire uh scheme and some people might say that Greece was
  26. kind of the can opener that opened up the problem but when you look inside um it's the bigger economies like Spain
  27. that present the challenge regardless of how they got into the problem sure sure
  28. and not only Spain also I think Italy is a is a very big uh issue so the Euro just turned uh 10 10 years old and uh of
  29. course the problem with the with the euro is like with any uh currency area that is created uh with multiple
  30. governments pursuing different kinds of policies is that that you need some measure of coordination you need some uh
  31. you know system in place for dealing with situations such as the one that we find ourselves in right now and uh that
  32. was probably the uh you know a mistake that was made 10 years ago not to put in place this mechanism so that now when we
  33. have this crisis now having said that I think the Euro has been pretty much a success and I think the the fact that a
  34. lot of countries around the world hold uh an important percentage of their reserves ranging from 20 to 30% in euros
  35. is I think a very very uh strong message uh indicating that uh you know there are
  36. people out there who actually you know like the Euro and they've been diversifying a little bit of the dollar
  37. reserves you know in and putting them into into Euros over the last uh five or seven years uh so I think that is a uh
  38. you know a signal that from the markets and from the uh Reserve holders around the world that the Euro actually is a
  39. viable currency it's just that there are some problems with it but there are also
  40. problems with the dollars there are problems with stering there are problems with all of the other currencies that
  41. are used for holding reserves let's come back to that idea of the mechanism a little bit later but I wanted to ask you
  42. about how Spain's unique problems developed it it seems as though um a real estate bubble developed and and as
  43. real estate prices increased a lot of money came pouring in from outside of Spain particularly from Germany and that
  44. that increased prices even further which created the bubble and then of course the world financial crisis led to a
  45. collapse of housing bubbles in many countries Spain was just one uh that that had a housing bubble problem um so
  46. where where does do you agree with that analysis and where does that part I think that is part of the picture I
  47. think in in Spain uh regarding the real estate sector broadly defined uh we there are several issues there one as
  48. you mentioned is the um the bubble in prices which affected certain parts of the country just as it did the United
  49. States right the coasts more than than the uh than the center and so on and so forth uh but there's also a construction
  50. bubble uh meaning a construction boom uh during the last uh six or seven years uh
  51. in Spain uh you know the construction business just building not just uh residences or houses or commercial uh
  52. real estate but also uh roads and bridges and uh railway tracks and all of that uh became a very important part of
  53. the economy to the point that uh about 45% of all new construction in Europe not just residential construction any
  54. kind of construction in all of Europe was taking place in Spain 45% when the Spanish economy is only maybe 15% of
  55. Europe right um so there was a construction boom uh which of course is very it's an industry that is very labor
  56. intensive and so when uh construction you know slows down then you have a lot of people actually going out of jobs out
  57. of their jobs and it's not only the the direct jobs in construction it's also the companies that make cement it's the
  58. companies that you know uh move around the cement and the bricks and the all of the construction materials it's all of
  59. the activities that surround construction which is a uh you know which are very very important and so you
  60. know this is having a very very important effect on unemployment but having said that there's another thing
  61. that I would like to add which is that the Spanish economy suffers and we can talk more about that from a chronic
  62. problem in terms of uh productivity sluggish productivity growth relative to its competitors and this is what is
  63. really you know causing trouble uh right now those are both interesting points uh
  64. when a country gets in the kind of trouble that Spain is in if they're not in a currency Union and don't have in
  65. effect a fixed currency one of the ways to get out of that problem is to devalue
  66. your currency your exports will increase that will help to stimulate the economy
  67. and that more or less pulls a country out over some period um Spain can't do that they're hamstrung because uh being
  68. in the European Union and and with the Euro they don't have control of their currency anymore you're absolutely so
  69. how can they get out of proof of the the the importance of uh of a an orderly currency devaluation for getting out of
  70. recessions is that uh in Spain in the 1970s there was a recession there was another one of course in the 1980s
  71. beginning of the 1980s and another one in the beginning of the 1990s and at each of those uh uh points in time Spain
  72. devalued the currency and uh uh you know subsequent to that it enjoyed relatively
  73. strong growth uh so that's the way in which traditionally uh you know the Spanish economy has gotten out of
  74. trouble it's a beggar die neighbor kind of uh way out it's the easy way out uh having a uh strong currency or being
  75. part of a strong currency such as such as the Euro also uh brings with it benefits lower interest rates uh a more
  76. stable uh economic microeconomic environment um so one should not you know deny the benefits there is this
  77. problem now and that's what I was mentioning earlier that the really the only way for the Spanish economy uh and
  78. for Spanish based businesses not just Spanish owned businesses but also foreign multinationals operating in
  79. Spain the only way to remain competitive is to increase productivity because we cannot uh lower prices artificially
  80. through the exchange rate so increasing productivity what does that mean in practice it sounds like uh deflationary
  81. policy is that right well it means uh workers and managers and uh pretty much everybody working harder uh it means
  82. doing so uh without or smarter or smarter and it means doing so working harder without necessarily getting paid
  83. more and and uh it means investing more in education uh which I think has been or continues to be the problem or part
  84. of the problem in the country and uh it essentially means also letting the market uh operate and see which kinds of
  85. activities should really be located in Spain and which ones shouldn't uh remember very few people actually know
  86. that uh in Spain the most important uh export category besides tourism right which is Big just the same way as it is
  87. big in Italy or in France uh the second most important category is automobiles export category and uh and it is the the
  88. number one uh manufacturing uh good that is exported and of course we have a uh we we're anticipating that there will be
  89. a competitiveness problem if we don't improve our productivity uh let's say in the next three to five years so these
  90. are all long-term Solutions it sounds like Spain's unemployment is 19.5% GDP fell by 3.6% in 2009 they're
  91. they offering now is there anything that can be done more immediately uh there are no Magic Bullets uh the only thing
  92. that uh you know uh uh if you cannot devalue the currency the only thing that you can do in the very short run is to
  93. uh try to reduce costs uh the easiest way of course is by not granting wage increases or by you know even if
  94. companies you know in the presence of high employment if they could reduce wages right they could negotiate with
  95. their workers the problem of course is that the labor market situation uh or institutions are not not very flexible
  96. so it's difficult to actually lower wages uh on short notice uh uh so um it's going to be a slow recovery that is
  97. that is exactly the situation uh compared to the uh recessions in the early 90s in the early 80s or the one in
  98. the 1970s this is going to be a slower recovery and by the way will depend largely on the extent to which uh
  99. particularly the rest of Europe recoveries because Spain's most important trading partners are France
  100. Germany Italy the UK switching lenses a little bit just moving out a little bit to consider more
  101. of Europe and you mentioned beggar Thy Neighbor policies so in Europe we've got this jut exporter Germany which is has
  102. for years been uh carrying a trade surplus a big Trade Surplus they're very good at creating goods and exporting
  103. them uh but if Europe's going to have uh a balance of some sort if if one country
  104. is going to be a huge exporter the by far biggest economy in the European Union then other economies are going to
  105. have a trade deficit by definition isn't that right and if you can't balance currencies among the com countries
  106. because it's essentially a fixed currency how then can these countries balance um their their fiscal spending
  107. their currencies their interest rates how how does that work in a fixed interest rate envir or fixed currency
  108. environment absolutely I mean we're going back to the issue with the Euro which is that some parts uh uh of Europe
  109. uh or the Euro zone are more competitive than others uh in the global marketplace
  110. now keep in mind that the European Union as a as a block the 27 countries uh they
  111. have more or less balanced trade with the rest of the world okay so it's equal exports and imports but of course as you
  112. just pointed out within the European Union some countries enjoy huge uh trade uh uh surpluses that's Germany and the
  113. worst the worst trade deficit by the way is Spain okay so so at one extreme you have Germany and at the other you have
  114. Spain and then the other 26 member countries uh 25 member countries uh lie somewhere in between so the issue is as
  115. usual is um you know there will be some parts of Europe as a result of that that
  116. will do better than others uh and hopefully there will be adjustments in other words uh well the Germans over the
  117. medium run and the long run uh should be paid more money for what they do because
  118. they're very good at what they're doing and the Spaniards at the other end of the spectrum will see their standards of
  119. living uh come down uh as they hopefully restructure their economy uh they will find a way in which they can
  120. compete uh globally and then they will take it from there but there's going to be right now in the next few years a big
  121. uh Readjustment a big restructuring in Europe also in the United States by the way but but for sure in Europe as a
  122. result of the big changes that are taking place in the global economy do you think this threatens the
  123. cohesiveness of the European Union well sure any restruct absolutely any restructuring any Readjustment uh uh you
  124. know causes problems uh there are elections and uh people will be unhappy uh when when election come time comes
  125. now in Europe as you know the elections that matter are the national elections and they take place at different points
  126. in time depending on the country each country is in a different electoral cycle uh so there will be tension and
  127. there will be frictions and uh I don't think the European Union as such is going to uh you know unravel I think
  128. that's Unthinkable uh but uh there will be frictions and there will be a lot of problems that will be will need to be uh
  129. uh you know ironed out and certainly uh we're getting into a situation in which uh you know I think the Moment of Truth
  130. has has come right because we do have other countries around the world that have become uh as productive and as
  131. competitive as Europe South Korea Taiwan China is you know coming close even some
  132. Latin American countries are doing exceedingly well in certain industries so the Moment of Truth has come uh it
  133. has come for Europe it has come from the United States I think the you know the first countries in the world to
  134. industrialize are facing yet again a competitive crisis right and uh they'll need to figure out uh you know what to
  135. do do you think that uh with unemployment close to 20% in Spain uh and it sounds like years of austerity of
  136. of some kind that that that political pressure that you talked about are political changes uh and social
  137. pressures could build to a point where there would be say a demand within Spain to withdraw from the the currency Union
  138. go back to the petta for example uh no I don't think so um in fact the uh support
  139. uh for monetary Union uh was highest in Spain it actually much higher than in Germany because in Germany a lot of
  140. people uh you know were reluctant because of you know they already had a strong currency uh so Spain is actually
  141. a country that from the point of view of public opinion is very pro- European and
  142. I think it's just Unthinkable but it's Unthinkable from another point of view which is that uh you have a lot of
  143. homeowners in Spain who have a mortgage and their mortgage is for the you know in most cases like 95% of the cases it's
  144. a variable adjustable interest rate and is linked to the euro uh you know interest rate uh so uh there is a very
  145. very strong reason why people would not want uh Spain to uh to get out of the EUR because suddenly you know their
  146. mortgage payments would go through the roof because once you get out of the Euro you know anything that is in Spain
  147. would actually you know revert to a higher interest rate right uh so there's absolutely no chance that
  148. Spain by itself would want to get out of the Euro so zero chance of that uh no but keep in mind one very important
  149. thing which is that the Euro could depreciate itself and that would help Spain as long as Spanish companies uh
  150. export or to the extent that Spanish companies export outside of the Euro zone right so the Euro does decline in
  151. value and has been declining in value over the last uh month uh month and a half relative to the US dollar for
  152. example uh that would help the uh the export competitiveness of of country such as Spain also Germany of course
  153. right uh so there are a lot of moving pieces here uh but there's one clarification also that I wanted to make
  154. about the 20% unemployment rate in Spain um it is 20% right and it is incredibly
  155. High uh but it affects uh for the most part the young people right uh what does this mean well this means that
  156. essentially among the younger age group we're talking about 40 45% unemployment rate that is where the problem is uh the
  157. problem is that you could lose one generation here right uh one generation that essentially would be you know
  158. outside of the labor market making some money here or there in the informal economy right because they have to leave
  159. on something and but that's not the way to start your your career that's not the
  160. way to start your sounds like a recipe for a real political problem absolutely absolutely so what's what's the answer
  161. you mentioned um earlier about a mechanism some people were talking about uh a European equivalent of say the the
  162. international monetary fund a European monetary fund that would help to sort of stabilize or bail out
  163. countries like Greece that get into trouble um is is that something that is likely to fly well uh the European Union
  164. could obviously decide to set up such a uh such an institution uh the IMF uh essentially intervenes in emergency
  165. situations that is to say when countries run out of money they don't have reserves they don't have uh you know the
  166. means to actually keep going right uh keep going in the sense of um you know uh living up to their commitments
  167. Financial commitments and being able to pay for whatever things they need to import and every country needs to import
  168. something right uh so is Greece in that situation right now well it seems that it's very close to that uh and uh of
  169. course the IMF could bail them out right uh the interesting political or image issue right now is that well no European
  170. country would want you know or or no European country would want one of their member countries of European Union to be
  171. bail out by International institutions such as the or Global institution such as the IMF so there is this idea that
  172. well maybe the solution should be a European solution right but once again we didn't think about this or they
  173. didn't think about this 10 years ago and now in the midst of a crisis uh they need to come up with a solution and they
  174. find that there's no institution right to to deal with that now of course the other way to to get it done is to just
  175. get two or three countries in Europe perhaps led by Germany and say we're going to bail them out but there are a
  176. lot of political pressures within Germany domestic political pressures not to do so because as you know the uh the
  177. ruling Coalition includes now the liberal uh party and the liberal party is very much against something like this
  178. what is Europe likely to do they don't want others coming in they they want to take care of their own situation uh but
  179. there's a lot of differences within the countries and Europe I think uh I think let's uh let's think in terms of two
  180. scenarios well the first scenario is that the crisis is just uh Greece okay there's no other country so I think
  181. probably then uh in the next uh you know few months some kind of an ad hoc solution would be quietly put in place
  182. right you know the the Greek problem will be dealt with Greece is a small economy anyway it can be easily bailed
  183. out by the rest of Europe and that will be the end of it that gives some breathing space exactly so it will be
  184. quietly put in place you know without uh you know uh with the public attentions uh you know set elsewhere and so on so
  185. forth scenario number two is that of course the crisis spreads and it's not only Greece but it's also so you know
  186. conceivably Ireland or Portugal maybe some countries in Eastern Europe let's not forget that countries in Eastern
  187. Europe are also in Dire Straits and uh perhaps Italy uh quite frankly I don't see Spain but you know if if the crisis
  188. spreads to you know like uh uh five six eight countries then maybe Spain could be part of that uh so if you put
  189. yourself in the very very pessimistic scenario then obviously an ad hoc solution wouldn't do it will need to be
  190. something more organized something more institutional it may require uh you know
  191. the IMF uh F's intervention after all MH so especially if there were some sort of
  192. outside shock like a sudden jump in oil prices for example exactly right now we something else you know comes our way if
  193. there's another typhoon right that comes our way then or Europe's way uh then that you know the situation will get
  194. much much worse and uh you know something more drastic will need to be so it it was interesting that earlier
  195. you you put your finger on increasing productivity as ultim imely the the cure for this situation but in in the short
  196. run is it going to be austerity of the kind that we we were used to the IMF imposing in the 80s and
  197. 90s on on countries uh just that just to keep things simple if you do not devalue
  198. the currency which is the initial you know question that you posed and that your productivity is growing at a slower
  199. Pace than that of Germany or that of the other people who are in your same currency area right then the is
  200. essentially you know no solution your living standards are going to come down uh it's not only that you're going to
  201. have an employment you may have more or less unemployment but just in general even those who are employed are going to
  202. be earning you know less for what they do because they're not as productive right I mean sooner or later the day of
  203. reconing kicks in and the market you know especially you know the global trading system will you know impose on
  204. you uh its conditions which is essentially well if you're not as good as the others you know you're not going
  205. to do as well in this economy uh so that's the ultimate uh you know consequence of this it's not that the
  206. country Spain in particular or any other country is just going to you know disappear it's just that its people its
  207. population are going to enjoy lower standards of living or to put in a different way they're going to be
  208. declining at least in relative terms compared to those of other countries that are more productive and again the
  209. issue is Spain's productivity is growing let's say at 1 or two% per year uh well
  210. in some East Asian countries is growing at four or five% in Germany it's growing
  211. you know somewhere in between those two numbers so uh it's not sustainable uh your standards of living will have to
  212. come down unless of course you devalue but I don't think that's going to happen I don't think uh Spain or Greece or
  213. Italy are going to leave the the Euros system and even different lands now there's other countries that were in the
  214. wings wanting to get into the EU um this is the first really major crisis that the EU has had these this is the kind of
  215. Crisis that that critics and Skeptics worried about uh and it's it it's finally here and we'll see how things
  216. get manage but will that affect I mean it seems like it's likely to affect uh other countries um Beyond Greece and so
  217. forth that are that are hoping to get into the EU like it like turkey for example right so there's turkey and
  218. there's some uh a few other Eastern European or former you know Soviet republics who might at some point want
  219. to be in now turkey I think is a uh you know it's an interesting uh uh you know situation uh they've been you know
  220. applying for membership for a very long time they have everything to gain from being members of the European Union even
  221. though they already enjoy some of the benefits because they have some free trade agreements with some of the
  222. countries uh but of course they will get a windfall from uh you know the structural funds from all of the
  223. subsidies the European Union subsidies and of course it will give foreign it would give foreign investors a great
  224. deal of confidence of confidence in Greece in in turkey and as a result of that then more foreign investment were
  225. would um pour into uh into turkey uh but I think the current crisis should in quite frankly in my view uh if I were
  226. turkey uh should not diminish uh the desire to become member of the European Union because the benefits are you know
  227. enormous and turkey is already quite integrated with uh the rest of the with some of the countries European Union
  228. especially with Germany right in terms of trade uh the other important thing here to keep in mind is that the
  229. European Union has actually enlarged uh or let me uh rephrase has entered into negotiations about
  230. enlargement during crisis uh so when Spain and Portugal and uh entered uh the negotiations were taking place in the
  231. early 1980s when you know the economy European economy wasn't doing that great uh remember also Britain and uh Ireland
  232. uh and Denmark became members in the early 1970s 1973 okay so uh so the the union has um welcomed new members during
  233. times of crisis in the past uh so I don't think turkey should give up give it up and I certainly believe strongly
  234. believe that European Union should uh get serious about admitting turkey as a as a member would it change how they how
  235. turkey might want to enter in other words uh the UK has managed to escape um turning to the euro could turkey do do
  236. something similar at least at least yes the two things are not necessarily linked to each other that is to say you
  237. could become a member as you just pointed out uh and not become uh part of the of the euro currency in fact I would
  238. strongly you know suspect that uh if Turkey were to become a member let's say in 5 years from now it would probably be
  239. you know asked to you know wait a few more years for Euro membership because that's a tighter you know degree or
  240. extent of integration and it requires you know a number of other structural reforms uh uh so you know what turkey
  241. needs to think about is uh negotiations and uh you know because there's all sorts of details that need to be uh
  242. fleshed out so maybe you could uh give us one final word on where things are heading
  243. with Spain and with the European Union what's most likely in the next critical weeks ahead well in the next weeks ahead
  244. obviously uh we're going to see uh quite a bit of uh you know turmoil and discussion and debate some of it really
  245. heated in terms of what needs to be done and one again if uh there's no uh surprise event out there like a in
  246. oil prices or whatever I think uh you know we're going to uh you know enter into a period of three or four years
  247. during which in Europe in general but I think in Spain in particular there will be very sluggish economic growth maybe
  248. you know half a percentage point maybe 1% one and a half modle through modle through uh it's very hard to reduce
  249. Unemployment uh with such a slow growth and uh it's just going to be hard uh and
  250. uh once again I think we are going to to be enter entering a period during which
  251. living standards in some parts of Europe I think that also applies to the United
  252. States by the way but certainly in certain parts of Europe including Spain uh will uh not grow as much uh and in
  253. fact they might even shrink uh so I think we are you know entering a period of uh you know just um you know not
  254. catastrophe not uh you know uh outright uh you know um decline in the economy but certainly uh you know a kind of a
  255. flat you know profile in terms of economic growth and in terms of incomes uh and people are going to wonder
  256. exactly you know after three or four years of such a situation what went wrong and perhaps
  257. engage in some serious uh reforms we talked about external shocks I saw that the latest trade figures for Germany for
  258. the latest period were down shockingly a large amount I think it was over 6% um and that's already causing some worries
  259. uh did that does that number surprise you and how could that affect the it was surprising and this is why there's now
  260. more concerned in Europe because Germany being the largest economy if it's not doing as well and for Germany obviously
  261. the export um situation is absolutely crucial so it was surprising and again I think it reminds
  262. us that Germany has not resolved all of its problems right uh but once again it's not that the country is going to
  263. you know disappear from the face of the world I mean uh you know it is a uh very
  264. competitive economy right though it has its problems they have a highly educated
  265. population and uh you know they've surmounted uh you know very very important challenges before so you know
  266. what there's also room for optimism but uh once again I don't think we're going to see a fast turnaround in Europe in
  267. the next three or four years it's going to be painful it's going to be slow it's
  268. going to be uh just uh you know very very prolonged uh you know way or Road out of this recession well not to put
  269. too much on one number but that that trade number is causing worries that there could be a double dip recession in
  270. Germany do you think that's it could be possible but at the very least I think the most likely scenario is that uh
  271. we're going to be entering a period of just you know so sluggish growth that uh uh you know unemployment is not going to
  272. come down and of course if unemployment doesn't come down then the budget deficit deficits will remain at very
  273. high levels right because of subsidies unemployment subsidies uh so it's it's going to be it's going to be tough
  274. challing be tough thanks for joining us we're out of time I appreciate it very much thank you very much okay thanks
  275. Steve

Brief Summary

Maro Gan discusses Spain's economic challenges, including debt, unemployment, and the impact of the Euro on recovery efforts.

Key points

  • Spain's Economic Challenges. Spain faces significant economic challenges, but its debt levels are manageable compared to Greece.
  • Youth Unemployment Crisis. Spain's youth unemployment rate is alarmingly high, threatening a generation's future.
  • The EU's Major Crisis. The EU faces its first major crisis, raising concerns about its future stability.
  • Turkey's EU Aspirations. Despite the crisis, Turkey's desire to join the EU remains strong due to potential benefits.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes