Emerging Markets Lose Their Punch

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

It's been a good 10-year run for fast-growing emerging markets. But now many of them face severe economic imbalances and slowing growth. 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're meeting today with Mauro Guillen a management professor at Wharton to talk
  2. about what's happening in emerging economies thanks for joining us thank you for having me can you discuss what's
  3. been happening very recently in emerging economies a lot of money has been flowing out there growth rates look like
  4. they're slowing down I realize it's hard to generalize but it's how it is happening to a lot of countries perhaps
  5. for different reasons and one of the explanations for this at least a partial explanation is that the Fed so called
  6. tapering off is a worry because that may mean that US interest rates would go up
  7. and look relatively more interesting than then the returns that investors are getting on their so-called hot money in
  8. these emerging economies so it's about these these financial flows rather than foreign direct investments in bricks and
  9. mortar and that sort of you're absolutely right I mean the fact that investors are anticipating that the
  10. Federal Reserve will change its policy in the near future it's obviously putting some pressure on those
  11. short-term hot money flows right into emerging economies and people of course don't want to be caught in the middle
  12. right of all of this and they tend to move their money to where it can get the highest possible yield I think that's a
  13. very important background factor I don't think it's the only one I mean what we see in many emerging economies just
  14. speaking broadly about them is that the current model of growth is kind of a coming exhausted right which is has been
  15. in many of these emerging economies export-led right so we've seen very little progress in most of these
  16. countries China India Brazil in terms of the development of a domestic market that would compensate for slower growth
  17. in terms of exports there's been some progress but not enough to essentially keep the economy going at you know very
  18. fast pace you know which is what happened throughout the last few years now we shouldn't forget it's remarkable
  19. that even during 2008 2009 2010 the financial crisis emerging economies continued growing as they did but now
  20. there are the crossroads and of course these backups have a very bad moment and there is also political turmoil in
  21. several of them as you know there are street protests in many of these economies Brazil most recently this
  22. rising income inequality which also adds to the to the problems and more broadly
  23. I think there are bubbles you know there's clearly a real estate bubble in several of the markets in Brazil there's
  24. clearly a real estate bubble in several areas in China or perhaps all over the country and so on and so forth so there
  25. are many imbalances that have been building up in several markets over the last ten years of rapid growth and then
  26. as you can imagine of course to just make things even worse the banking system always always suffers from the
  27. build-up of these bubbles and we're starting to see some in some of these markets that the percentage of
  28. non-performing loans it's also starting to increase and bad assets on the balance sheets of banks so yes we are at
  29. a crossroads there's a lot of uncertainty and I think right now right now I guess one of the biggest problems
  30. for emerging economies is that neither the u.s. nor europe which are traditionally the most important export
  31. markets are growing that much so this comes at a bad moment comes of a bad moment for everybody u.s. GDP growth was
  32. just upgraded from 1.72 2.54 i guess the second quarter so that's that's one hopeful sign who knows what will happen
  33. in Japan though there is an effort there to crank up the economy in ways that haven't been done in the last 20 years
  34. or so the so-called lost decades but and Europe is struggling just with its nose
  35. above the water so is there perhaps a grand shift even if it's a mild one happening where the emerging economies
  36. which had been sort of carrying the world economy or at least preventing a you know something worse than what
  37. happened are now sort of passing the baton to the developed countries where exactly the Pathan seems to be passing
  38. not perhaps fast enough because the u.s. that you just said is enjoying a little
  39. bit faster growth but not the kind of growth that we would like to have here in order to reduce unemployment and then
  40. Europe of course is just not enough so yes I mean this is much better from the point
  41. view of emerging economies than the situation a year ago or two years ago but I think the big question mark is
  42. whether it's big enough and I think it is very clear that all of the debate about the development of the domestic
  43. market domestic consumption market in the bricks in Mexico I think now has become very relevant because I don't
  44. think that these economies can continue enjoying high growth rates let's say into the next five or 10 or 15 years
  45. unless the domestic market in these countries become so much more important in other words that they switch away
  46. from an export-led model of growth to one that is more balanced between exports and domestic consumption which
  47. of the emerging economies would you worry about the most under the circumstances you've been talking about
  48. well I think there are reasons to be worried in each of the large emerging economies I think Brazil probably right
  49. now stands out as being the biggest underperformer Brazil was growing at you know six seven eight percent just a few
  50. years ago and now it's barely growing and we see over there many of these tensions and the overheating and I worry
  51. about Brazil also because Brazil is more vulnerable than the others because it is
  52. highly dependent on the hot money that has been coming into the country to cover the deficit that they have in
  53. their current account in their relationship in terms of trade and other kinds of flows I mean Brazil in spite of
  54. being a major export power it is still a country that imports more than what it is exports so they need money capital
  55. flows to come in and bridge the gap so I worry about Brazil and I think I worry about Brazil also because Brazil is
  56. forty percent of Latin America and if something bad happens in Brazil then that's going to have a big impact on on
  57. the region but having said that I think there's plenty to worry about in China these days and also in India India with
  58. all of its poverty and all of the need for more growth it's now very clearly very clearly under
  59. forming as well I don't worry that much about Russia quite frankly I think Russia it's you know to a very large
  60. extent shielded from much of these because well it is a you know an economy that generates enough export earnings
  61. and it is an economy that has such you know natural wealth vast natural wealth that unless they grossly mismanaged they
  62. will probably whether any kind of storm what about places like Indonesia and say
  63. Thailand those kinds of countries are they they go as China goes so go those countries is that what's most likely to
  64. happen well that's part of it but more importantly is the US and Europe because those are there more important most
  65. important export markets I mean Thailand and Indonesia Vietnam Malaysia these are
  66. countries that very much depend on the US market and also european markets for their exports having said that I think
  67. they have one advantage which is that I don't think you are seeing in those economies the kinds of bubbles that have
  68. emerged in places like Brazil or China thank you very much for joining us today thank
  69. you

Brief Summary

Mauro Guillen discusses emerging economies' challenges, including capital outflows, slowing growth, and the need for stronger domestic markets.

Key points

  • Emerging Economies at a Crossroads. Emerging economies face significant challenges as growth slows and political turmoil rises.
  • Brazil's Economic Struggles. Brazil is highlighted as the biggest underperformer among emerging economies.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes