Did Japan Just Spark a Currency War?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] we're speaking today with Wharton Finance Professor Franklin Allen about
  2. the falling Yen and how that seems to have kicked off talk of occurrent War um one immediate reaction to Japan's New
  3. stimulative Economic policies has been a sharp drop in the Yen that's led to talk
  4. of beggar Thy Neighbor policies and a currency War among a number of global officials including people in Russia uh
  5. and Europe now most recently um Europe is increasingly worried that in addition to Japan the US and the UK and even
  6. Switzerland have policies that are holding down their currency and that's making the Euro stronger than it
  7. otherwise might be um and I think that Japan's policies have focused attention on that in a way that that was not
  8. happening just a few weeks ago um how serious are these concerns and and what can you tell us about them well this
  9. whole issue of currency Wars goes back quite a while now when Brazil's Finance Minister coined the phrase for for this
  10. issue and I think in a number of emerging econ economies and in uh places like Switzerland and Norway and and uh
  11. Sweden what we've seen is uh inflows of money and strengthening of exchange rates and in some places like Brazil
  12. this has caused real problems for their manufacturing sector in Switzerland I I think the government put the cap on
  13. because they were also worried that their manufacturing sector would be significantly hit
  14. Japan is the first large economy to try to I think manage its exchange rate they they may may not
  15. be doing that explicitly but one of the major effects of the policies that prime
  16. minister AB has said he's will introduce and and he is introducing is to try and
  17. weaken the exchange rate I think one of the things that has really hampered Japan a great deal over the last few
  18. years since the default of lhan is that they have been regarded as a safe haven currency and this has really hurt their
  19. industry a great deal so if you compare Korea and Japan they have similar kinds of industrial structures but Korea which
  20. allowed its exchange rate to drop a significant amount after the lman default has done much much better than
  21. Japan and I think the Japanese want to try and prevent their economy being stalled
  22. by this very strong exchange rate now the question is whether they'll go too far and they'll see an exodus of the
  23. money out of Japan and one of the big issues is why are people keeping money in Japan given that it's exchange rate
  24. may well weaken it's gone down significantly already but it may go down much much more if you look at the
  25. Historical even over the last decade movement in in the Yen it's ranged from 80 to 110 120 depending on the time
  26. period you choose but it could well weaken considerably more and one wonders when people will start pulling
  27. their money out there's a large proportion of the Japanese stock markets held by foreigners uh a small but now
  28. significant 9 10% of the bond market is held by foreigners but the real question
  29. is what did Japanese investors see do they fully comprehend that their currency May weaken dramatically and it
  30. might be good idea from Individual perspective not from necessarily from the nation's perspective to take some of
  31. their money and put it overseas and if we see that then we could see some real instability in in Japan I I think one of
  32. the other big issues is how other countries will react I think the Germans are particularly worried Japanese car
  33. companies have not been as competitive because they've had to cut back R&D and all those kinds of things and so if they
  34. start making more profits which they are doing with these weaker Yen they may be
  35. able to start competing more effectively with the German car manufacturers and I
  36. think that's why we've seen various German politicians and uh Jen vman of the of the bundas bank start worrying
  37. about the the overall effects of this and uh I I believe uh dragi has now come out and made some at least failed
  38. references to um concerns about the level of the Euro yes he he made some comments yesterday of about
  39. uh that they would look and see what the long run effects on the on the current were because of course the Euro has
  40. strengthened significantly it then fell back a fair amount so we'll see what happens but that's kind of a warning
  41. shot isn't it that you know more than three can play at this game or however many are playing at it yes although I'd
  42. be surprised if if the uh the ECB got into that but they may Doh and um how big are the dangers that um you know the
  43. currency War could erupt into the equivalent of a shooting War well it's an interesting in question
  44. whether this is such a bad thing that the the the folklore from the 1930s that we had these beggar Thy Neighbor
  45. policies that when Britain went off the gold standard then many other countries followed and this led to a deflation was
  46. very bad I I think the historical record is not so clear and there are a number of papers that argue that in fact it
  47. would have been better if we'd had these realignments of exchange rates in that it would have have led to relative
  48. prices being much better and that that can benefit countries so I think we'll see how it plays out this time
  49. [Music]

Brief Summary

Wharton Professor Franklin Allen discusses the implications of Japan's falling Yen and potential currency wars among global economies.

Key points

  • Currency Wars and Economic Policies. Finance Professor Franklin Allen discusses the implications of Japan's economic policies on global currencies.
  • Japan's Currency Management. Japan's efforts to manage its exchange rate could lead to significant economic shifts.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes