In What Form Will the Eurozone Emerge from the Crisis?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Wharton finance professor Franklin Allen delivers a keynote address on the uncertain future of the eurozone at the Wharton Global Alumni Forum held in Milan, Italy on May 17 and 18.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- it's a great honor for me to speak after Mr Perera I think that the change in government last November in Italy was a
- tremendously positive development was extremely positive for Italy Mr Pacer outlined the policies that they're
- going to follow which are a big improvement over the ones previously because there wasn't much growth
- previously and hopefully we will now get that I think also though it was a tremendous positive development for the
- Euro Zone and the EU as a whole because the government now in Italy brings a sense of sanity and
- discourse which is much better than it was before in the whole European union now I'm going to talk about the
- crisis uh this is a based on work with Victor ngi who graduated last Monday from
- Wharton and the t is in what form will the EUR Zone emerge from the crisis now the headline story in the
- internet version of uh the European edition of the financial times this morning is about a speech that the
- British Prime Minister David Cameron is going to give this afternoon and apparently what he's going
- to say is that the Euro zone is heading for disaster unless it makes a move to quickly go
- towards full political and economic union now my own view is that I don't think we're ready for a full economic
- and political union in Europe yet people still think of them first and themselves first and foremost as being
- French or Italian or Spanish or whatever country they come from now I think maybe
- 20 to 30 years time people may start thinking of themselves as being Europeans first and then the country
- that they come from as their second identity but I'm much more optimistic than Mr Cameron about the survival of
- the Euro Zone I think though the way that events are developing the Euro zone is changing
- in a very positive way and it's putting in place the mechanisms it needs to survive in the long run until in 20 to
- 30 years time we can fully Implement a complete fiscal and monetary union now when they originally designed
- the Eurozone they realized that there would be an issue about fiscal responsibility and so they put in place
- the stability and growth PCT which had rules about what governments could and couldn't
- do now the two major rules were to do with government finance and they required that the deficit to GDP ratio
- must be close or under 3% except for crises times government debt the ratio that they
- allowed for that was 60% now they also had a number of other restrictions on inflation rates exchange
- rates and long-term interest rates which countries had to satisfy in order to join the
- Euro but it's those two that are the most important now what this graph shows is
- the three years prior to the start of the Euro Zone and it's the government surplus or deficit for those three years
- the blue is 1996 the red is 1997 and the green is 1998 now you can see that countries made
- big efforts to get their deficits under the limit Greece moved down Italy also and
- Belgium too by the time we got there countries were either very close to the 3% or
- underneath now what this shows is the gross government debt to GDP for again the three years prior to the entry of
- the Euro zone now three countries stand out as not satisfying it there Belgium which at
- that time had over 120% to start with Greece around 100% and Italy also at around
- 120% clearly they weren't satisfying the obligations of the stability and growth
- pact so what they did was to change it so as long as you were moving in the right direction then things would be
- okay and you could join now Greece because of of the problems it had the notion was that they would have to delay
- so instead of joining in 1999 they joined in 2001 now if we take a longer term view
- what what was happening well these are three countries that are the poster Childs for fiscal rectitude in the
- current environment at that time and we can see that Ireland Luxembourg and Finland all
- went from to to strong surpluses as the date of the start of the Euro occurred now Luxembourg we won't talk
- much about them again they have fantastic record and have always satisfied the stability and growth
- pact here we have Belgium Germany Spain Netherlands and Austria now you can see that Belgium
- they had a deficit and they got it in in in under control and most of the countries did
- now the interesting one is Germany Germany is the red line because of the reunification they
- had to run deficits in the 1990s they got that under control and got to a surplus by
- 2000 but then you can see that their deficit went went below the minus 3% so they were in violation of the stability
- and growth pact if we look Greece France Italy and Portugal Greece clearly has a problem
- it's been in violation most of that period up to 2007 the other interesting one here is
- France which also violated the Surplus restriction of three minus 3% they also went to 4% we'll come back
- to that in a minute if we look at government debt over this period this is Belgium Greece
- and Italy you can see that Belgium did a very good job of bringing its debt down
- Greece did not do such a good job Italy like Belgium brought it down here we see Ireland Spain
- Netherlands and Finland they did a good job of coming below the the 60% now here we see Germany and France
- again and what you can see is that they were under the 60% to start with and they drifted up and then as we went into
- the early 2000s they went farther above that's when they were running these deficits so again France and Germany
- broke the rules now as they broke the rules the commission started to implement the
- procedures in the stability and growth pack and they started to ask them to make
- adjustments now Germany avoided a formal excessive deposit procedure by making an
- agreement with the commission but the commission did bring an action against France now November
- 2003 they presented the evidence to the Council of um Finance ministers and at that point the French
- and the Germans undertook political moves to persuade the other members of the council not to impose penalties on
- them and that was really a a in my view a big mistake because it reduced the effectiveness of the stability and
- growth pact so they in fact ended up suspending The Pact and no country was penalized France and Germany weren't
- penalizing none of the other countries that had violated temporarily 2005 they reformed the pack
- they loosened the Escape causes they lengthened the deadlines and they ex allowed longer adjustment
- periods now if we go back before the 2007 crisis is all the countries except Luxembourg
- and Ireland VI violated the 3% deficit Rule now a number of countries as we saw including France and Germany also
- violated the 60% but again no countries were penalized for violations now clearly the convergence
- criteria the fact you had to meet them to get into the Euro meant that countries did change their fiscal acts
- and they got much better situations but once the Euro was established that pressure effectively diminished and
- there are studies which show that there doesn't seem to be any marginal effect of the stability and growth pact if you
- compare these countries with other oecd countries now once the crisis started then of course we were in exceptional
- circumstances and most countries violated both rules now interestingly there are
- currently only four countries in the EU that fully satisfy the stability and growth pact
- criteria Estonia is one of them Luxembourg is another Finland and Sweden now of course Sweden isn't a member of
- the Euro zone so we just have those three two other countries current ly satisfy the criteria they didn't until
- recently and so they're still under excessive deficit procedures and that's Bulgaria and
- Denmark so it seems that you either have to be a rich Scandinavian country or you
- have to be a former communist country if you're going to satisfy these criteria the important point though is
- hardly any of the countries satisfy it and yet no countries have been penalized so just to summarize the
- stability and growth pact I think is a very good idea the political mechanisms haven't worked very well and I think you
- know it's important to have them there but I don't think we can rely completely on
- that now what about the market so economists love the market and and how did it do in this
- period well here we see the period leading up to the euro Zone and you can see that there was tremendous variation
- in interest rates across Europe now by the time we got to 1999 they had pretty much
- converged now from 1999 with the exception of Greece which is the red line remember they didn't
- join until 2001 because they didn't satisfy the criteria well enough in 1999 but since that period what we've
- seen is very tight spreads 20 30 40 basis points was the biggest spread between the different Count's
- bonds now we often talk about efficient markets and how good markets are at predicting the future but one of the
- very interesting things is they didn't predict the future in this case many people remarked on the fact that it was
- quite interesting that Greece had a 20 or 30 basis point differential to German BNS but the belief was that that was
- okay now as we can see what's happened since 2009 is we've seen a big Divergence not quite as much as we had
- before but a significant difference so the market did didn't work and I think one of the issues there is why not I
- think what happened is that they believed the official sector that there was no chance that anything bad could
- happen and also this was a very much of this was what the period the economists call the great moderation and things
- were working fairly well for much of it now 201 they introduced some more reforms
- this is colloquially known known as the sixpack I'm not sure how many Europeans know exactly what a sixpack is but
- nevertheless that's what it's called and this is EU secondary law so it's law that they pass in Brussels which applies
- to the uh EU EU and this has various components of fiscal policy so they strengthened the budgetary surveillance
- they speeded up and clarified the implementation of the excessive death procedure and so on they also were
- worried about macroeconomic imbalances because it isn't just fiscal Pro profac that's the problem arguably
- in Greece that's the issue but if you think about Ireland and Spain these are countries which were extremely good in
- terms of the stability and growth PCT and yet they had these big shocks and got into
- trouble so the part of the six-pack is to monitor macroeconomic imbalances they also introduced
- sanctions and penalties that were larger than before they changed the way the decisions were
- made about that so before the council ecoin had to vote positively to impose sanctions
- now if the commission recommends sanctions they have to vote it down so it goes ahead unless there's a majority
- against it that's called this reverse qualified majority voting and we'll see how that
- works the macroeconomic imbalance procedure unfortunately it's taking something of a long time they introduced
- this mechanism they just released few weeks ago the first alert mechanism report based on 2010 indicators
- unfortunately the crisis move much faster than this then we have the fiscal compact
- treaty and what that is again is more of the same now what countries have to do is to put a balanced budget rule in
- their constitution they have to then if they go above 60% start moving towards the
- 60% at 12th per year and then if you're in excessive deficit procedure you have to put in a
- plan with with the commission now the problem is that the stability and growth pact didn't work no countries
- were penalized and what the current strategy is is to do more of the same but have
- more penalties and so on but I think we need more than that as I say I think these are good moves but they clearly
- aren't enough on their own and I think the basic problem is that the shocks are much much larger than people expected
- when they designed the Euro Zone as I said we were going through a period known as by macroeconomists as the great
- moderation we didn't see big recessions we didn't see big macroeconomic problems
- and so the kind of things that happened in Ireland and Spain with massive Bubbles and then fiscal problems were
- not anticipated and the problem is that the adjustment within the Euro Zone particularly for many countries which
- have wage adjustment which isn't very fast which have income distributions determined in a in a fairly centralized
- manner they don't adjust quickly and that's what's caused a lot of the problems that Mr pacero was talking
- about earlier and you know Spain is is one example here it has got this very high
- 24.4% unemployment rate and perhaps most distressing of all 51.1% among youths and that is the real
- problem I think that we face in Europe that we need to do something about that now what alternative strategies are
- there out there what else can we do now one of the things that we could do is to have transfers between
- countries now at the moment what we have is loans the bailouts are loans they are
- expected to be paid back with interest but one way of doing things would be to have
- transfers Spain for example through no fault of its own had this massive bubble I don't think people there were doing
- anything that was wrong it just got caught up in an economic tsunami so maybe we could have a transfer from
- countries which weren't as badly caught up and help Spain through it now the problem is that we don't have full
- political and economic Union we aren't willing particularly in the AAA countries to have transfers of that kind
- so I think that will come in 20 to 30 years and that would be a good thing it's a way of ensuring against these
- very extreme shocks and of course we have that somewhat in the US we do have a federal system which transfers across
- States if California ever goes bankrupt though I will never vote for a government that transfers money from the
- federal government to California if it's Mississippi or arkans thought that's fine but the rich ones we don't
- shouldn't be transferring to them now what are the Alternatives well Victor and I suggest is we need two
- mechanisms which when countries get into very desperate trouble will help them get out of
- these now it's interesting because I think both of these mechanisms are beginning to come about the two are s
- devault within the Euro Zone we've seen that we had that in March with Greece contrary to many people's
- predictions it wasn't a catastrophe in fact it went through very smoothly there wasn't much drama and the reason for
- that I think was it was widely anticipated and I think the second one which is also important is to have
- temporary and I want to stress the word temporary exit from the Euro Zone and then once a country has recovered
- economically started growing it can re-enter when it satisfies the stability and growth pact
- criteria and I think what this would do would be to add to what the official sector has come up with the treaties and
- so on and it would allow the market to provide incentives to countries although markets haven't done a great job in the
- last 10 years in predicting what what's happened I think they're very quick Learners and people will start to
- monitor the fiscal policies and the macroeconomic balances much more carefully so as I said Sovereign default
- worked pretty well with Greece the unfortunate thing was they didn't do it soon enough if in May
- 2010 they defaulted the same way on the private sector they would have limitated
- about 75% of the debt burden they would have had a real chance of growing out of
- the problem now that's what the IMF usually does unfortunately I think the politics dsk was already thinking about
- the French election and so they didn't force that on the EU and I think that's a Pity but I think this is a useful
- mechanism to have if a country has a big shock through no fault of its own then this is one way of getting back to a
- growth situation more quickly so for example at the moment I think Ireland will get
- through this but it would be a help if they could default on the senior Bank debt at the beginning the ECB said no no
- don't do that it's going to cause catastrophe but these defaults in Greece haven't done that and I think it would
- be the same in Ireland they wouldn't and Ireland would have a lower debt and would have a a somewhat better chance of
- of getting out but as I say I think they have a very good chance of emerging now temporary exit from the
- Euro Zone I think that in some countries we have this desperate problem of unemployment and particularly youth
- unemployment and the wages aren't adjusting if anything wages in many of these countries with high unemployment
- are still going up and creating less competitiveness now I think the initial view was that austerity problem
- austerity policies would solve the problem because if you cut government spending increase taxes to put
- governments Back in Balance then that would show that the longterm was okay and the country would start growing and
- the economists the macroeconomists had models which had market clearing which showed that that would be happening
- unfortunately that's not the way it's turned out in some of these countries in Greece is the the most prominent example
- the austerity is simply making things worse as you cut government expenditure the economy shrinks and government
- revenues go down and so on now it's very interesting there are many growth strategies
- and these are structural forms of the kind that that we've been discussing in Europe for a while they tend to take a
- while though things like Market reforms take a few years educ uh labor reforms take a bit longer education takes even
- longer than that now the one policy which does usually provide growth is a long change to the exchange rate Argentina is
- the classic example of this Argentina had a fixed exchange rate with regard to the dollar and you can
- see that they started to go into a recession in the late '90s and that got pretty bad in '
- 01 they then dropped the peg to the dollar they shrunk for a few more months but then they started growing and
- growing very quickly and they've grown at about 8% since then they're now up to about 60% above where they were a decade
- to go and they soon passed where they started so in the two or three years they were above where they
- started now you may say but don't they fix the inflation numbers in in Argentina well my understanding is they
- do at least a little bit but even if you measure in terms of US Dollars using market exchange rates you get a similar
- kind of phenomenon now people say well Argentina was different it was a growing World
- economy so what are some other examples well if you compare South Korea and Japan what you see is that South Korea
- with an exchange rate adjustment during the crisis despite having an economy very much like Japan managed to start
- growing pretty quickly Japan because it's a safe haven currency didn't have that luxury and they aren't above where
- they were in 2007 they're still about 3 or 4% below so this is South Korea you can see the
- blue line is GDP they got badly hit after Leman but the exchange rate adjusted then they started growing
- they're now about 15% above Japan if you look they're still not where they were as I say they're about 97
- 98% even today 5 years later what are some of the other countries well if you go back to the 199
- 90s and look at the crisis then many countries followed this strategy of default and depreciation of the exchange
- rate and had long periods of high growth South Korea at that stage did the same thing they had a very sharp recession
- that lasted for about a year or two one to two years and they started growing they've grown at 6% a year since
- then Indonesia its banking syst system was devastated most banks basically collapsed they then defaulted and had an
- exchange rate adjustment they started growing at 5% for about the same for nine years or
- so Russia same kind of thing 7% now people often say that for example if Greece was to follow this strategy
- then it wouldn't be as successful because it has a low GDP to uh sorry low exports to GDP p ratio but
- many countries have expanded that and been very successful so for example India even without an exchange rate had
- its exports to GDP ratio double in the 1990s and then again in the 2000s it started from a place not that different
- from gree's the gold standard there's a nice paper by Barry ier green and Jeffrey saxs in the mid
- 80s and what they argued was that in fact fact the countries that left the gold standard in the 1930s did pretty
- well it's the same effect they were able to get over the effects of the Great Depression and start growing now the
- popular wisdom is that they was a begger Thy Neighbor policy but that what they argue is that although there was a
- negative effect on those countries around them it may well have been worse if they hadn't done the exchange rate
- trange and their conclusion is that more devaluation would have helped us get it
- through the Great Depression more easily my view on this is the basic problem is that relative prices are
- wrong if we can adjust those then we can do much better and we can improve things
- substantially contagion this is the big problem this is what the official sector
- says you know if we do these changes we're going to have these terrible problems of contagion with the Greek
- default we didn't because people anticipated it I think the same thing is true currently with
- the possible exit of Greece from the Euro Zone Investment Bank reports are putting about a 75% probability on that
- everybody's beginning to take actions to hedge against those kinds of risks if Greece leaves it will be somewhat
- chaotic but just like countri leaving the gold standard in the 1930s we can cope with that and the big thing is that
- within a year or two I believe Greece would start to grow again and it was the best and most effective policy for
- solving these terrible unemployment problems particularly among youths and as I say
- it's temporary there's no reason why they can't go out in 5 10 years whatever time it takes them to get back to
- economic health to rejoin Jo so let me conclude I think the moves that we've seen are very
- positive but they're not enough we need to go farther and in particular when we have very large shocks we need to have a
- mechanism that allows countries to start growing again quickly and I think with those we will
- see the Euro survive as I say they're coming about and I am very optimistic about the future of the year I think
- that we can keep it on track and in 20 to 30 years we can go towards the full political and economic Union but at the
- moment it's a little premature to do that let me stop [Applause] there
Brief Summary
The episode discusses Italy's new government, Euro Zone challenges, and the need for reforms in economic policies and the Stability and Growth Pact.
Key points
- Positive Developments in Italy. The change in government last November is seen as a tremendously positive development for Italy and the Euro Zone.
- Cameron's Warning. British Prime Minister David Cameron warns that the Euro zone is heading for disaster without urgent reforms.
- Youth Unemployment Crisis. Spain faces a staggering youth unemployment rate of 51.1%, highlighting a major issue in Europe.
- Greece's Economic Recovery. Despite chaos, Greece could see growth again after leaving the Euro Zone.
- Optimism for the Euro's Future. A call for action to ensure the Euro's survival and growth.
Episode highlights
- Positive Developments in ItalyThe change in government last November is seen as a tremendously positive development for Italy and the Euro Zone.“It was a tremendously positive development for the Euro Zone and the EU as a whole.”0:28Jun 4, 2012
- Cameron's WarningBritish Prime Minister David Cameron warns that the Euro zone is heading for disaster without urgent reforms.“The Euro zone is heading for disaster unless it makes a move.”1:54Jun 4, 2012
- Youth Unemployment CrisisSpain faces a staggering youth unemployment rate of 51.1%, highlighting a major issue in Europe.“51.1% among youths is the real problem we face in Europe.”19:16Jun 4, 2012
- Greece's Economic RecoveryDespite chaos, Greece could see growth again after leaving the Euro Zone.“Greece would start to grow again.”31:06Jun 4, 2012
- Optimism for the Euro's FutureA call for action to ensure the Euro's survival and growth.“I'm very optimistic about the future of the Euro.”31:57Jun 4, 2012
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





