Searching for a Way Out of Europe's Dead-end Austerity

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A Knowledge@Wharton Today Blog piece on the situation in Spain. Commentary by Wharton Management Professor Mauro Guillen.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] when one thinks about the current situation and uh uh the problem with uh
  2. uh austerity measures that is to say you know this uh focus on on fiscal adjustment right reduction of expenses
  3. and uh uh increases in taxes in some countries uh you know what I think most governments have already realized is
  4. that this is not going to be the long-term solution the problem of course is that there's no agreement uh in
  5. Europe as to what might be an alternative uh path of action and the northern countries the Creditor
  6. countries are insisting on austerity because of course they feel that you know they they they should not pay for
  7. the excesses right of the last decade in the southern uh countries but I think uh
  8. one must uh you know step out of that uh dichotomy between either austerity or the end of the Euro right and I think
  9. there are intermediate uh Paths of action that have not been tried and I'm not the only one uh person uh proposing
  10. them but one of them is to uh ask the European Central Bank to accept a slightly higher rate of of inflation why
  11. would this work uh help well this would help because as you know inflation tends
  12. to reduce the debt burden right in real terms so if you maintain inflation let's
  13. say half a percentage Point higher than what it is now over the next three or four years that's going to help uh
  14. countries such as Spain and Italy which are really you know the countries where the future of the euro is going to be
  15. decided right uh so these two countries could benefit immensely for that but the
  16. second point that I would like to make is that uh the method by which you increase inflation right by a few you
  17. know T of a percent uh also would matter a great deal so I wouldn't do it with uh
  18. quantitative easing with another round of QE this time in Europe not here in the United States the way I would do it
  19. is by asking uh the Germans to increase wages for their workers above productivity increases right that would
  20. be inflationary that would reduce German competitiveness granted but hey you know
  21. it would also weaken the Euro a little bit and a weakening of the euro is going to help German exporters right a
  22. weakening of the euro is also going to help Spanish or Italian or Greek exporters okay so you get that benefit
  23. but you get another benefit if the Germans uh if the German population has more money right because their wages
  24. have increased right they're likely to buy more goods and services they're going to they're going to save some of
  25. that money but they're also going to consume more and of course they will consume more German Goods they will
  26. consume more Chinese Goods but they will also consume more goods and services from the European periphery they will go
  27. on vacation for a longer period of time they will spend more money they will buy
  28. more uh Spanish and Italian Goods as well uh so that that should be uh you know the second point the third point I
  29. don't think this is going to happen but the third uh uh you know action that they could uh they could take
  30. is uh a little bit of a stimulus in Germany you see right now the Germans can borrow money at negative interest
  31. rates right so you know there's things that the German government would like to do maybe they want to build some piece
  32. of infrastructure here or they would like to invest more in education or on R&D they should do it and that fiscal
  33. stimulus in Germany sure it will come with a little bit more inflation but that's going to help not just Germany
  34. but all of the other countries that trade with Germany as well uh the problem of course is a political
  35. one which is that it's very difficult to persuade the German public uh and the uh
  36. the voters in several of the other creditor countries that they should accept a higher inflation because once
  37. again inflation helps those who you know uh owe money uh but uh it does hurt uh the savors it does hurt the the people
  38. who are creditors uh so they are reluctant to go down that path and of course historically as you know uh the German
  39. voter has become very very much against uh High inflation right for for all sorts of historical reasons uh so
  40. there's a lot of uh reluctance on the part of German politicians then to go down that path uh but I think it is
  41. right now uh the only viable solution that doesn't continue this procyclical you know that doesn't contribute to this
  42. procyclical Dynamic that I described earlier [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode discusses alternative economic strategies for Europe, focusing on inflation and wage increases to support struggling economies.

Key points

  • The Austerity Debate. Exploring the ineffectiveness of austerity measures in Europe and proposing alternatives.
  • Inflation as a Solution. Discussing how a slight increase in inflation could benefit struggling economies like Spain and Italy.
  • Political Challenges. Highlighting the reluctance of German voters to accept higher inflation despite potential benefits.

Related episodes