Spain Sputters as a Bail-out Moves Closer

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton Professor Mauro Guillen talks about the situation in Spain in this Knowledge at Wharton Today blog piece.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] well I think uh it's not because uh most of the um measures that the government
  2. is implementing are procyclical that is to say they they aggravate uh you know they they
  3. accelerate the the direction in which the economy is going the economy right now is going south so it accelerates
  4. that movement right it's procyclical as opposed to anti-cyclical uh but Spain is
  5. just a microcosm of Europe I mean it's just one more instance of uh what is going on throughout the Euro Zone and
  6. again the uh the issue is that uh of course the banks are in bad shape because something happened uh you know
  7. to real estate or something happened to uh households that are too much into debt and they cannot keep up with their
  8. with their payments uh on their loans and uh so the banks uh or many of the banks are are in trouble that means that
  9. there's no credit going to companies that also means that companies don't have um you know a way of investing and
  10. creating jobs but also they don't want to do it because they don't see the demand for their goods there uh internal
  11. demand of course is depressed uh and Export let demand is also depressed because at this point in time the global
  12. economy is not doing well because the emerging economies as you know are also uh in trouble right and growth is slowly
  13. uh coming down even in China uh so there seems as if there's no way out we can talk about the possible solutions but it
  14. seems as if you know austerity measures don't work you mentioned the figure about the deficit that is getting bigger
  15. well you know uh governments in Spain in Portugal in Greece in Ireland have been
  16. announcing new austerity measures at a rate of uh you know every two months or so right or three months over the last
  17. uh couple of years and uh you know they cut this much right and what happens well interest on the debt takes like
  18. away half of the savings because the interest rates uh keep on going up right on the uh when they refinance their debt
  19. and then the other half uh uh of the savings uh go into paying the additional unemployed people uh that have been
  20. generated because the economy is not growing subsidies have to be paid and then on top of that uh tax revenue goes
  21. down uh because there's not enough economic activity right uh there's not enough uh uh you know movement in the
  22. economy that the government can tax right so it's a uh you know it's a procyclical Dynamic and uh there are
  23. ways out of it but I don't think austerity is the way out of it well no government likes to be bailed out right
  24. so this is the uh the basic thing to to keep in mind this is what's going on uh the government in Madrid doesn't want to
  25. be bailed out because that would reduce its autonomy uh and of course uh you know they will do whatever it takes
  26. right essentially to avoid a formal official bailout not that governments in Europe or in the Euro Zone have a lot of
  27. autonomy anymore uh but a bailout would reduce that autonomy especially on the fiscal front to nearly zero right so
  28. they want to avoid that and they're trying to see if uh you know uh suddenly they see the uh the light at the end of
  29. the tunnel if there there's some change in the global econ iomic or financial landscape that may give the country uh
  30. you know a ray of hope uh but unfortunately pretty much all of the news are bad right one after another and
  31. so sooner or later if this Dynamic continues um well Spain essentially will be like uh Greece and Portugal and
  32. Ireland before it uh it will be locked out of the uh debt markets it won't be able to sell as many you know as much
  33. debt uh instruments as he needs to in order to continue financing itself and at that point then there will be no
  34. other uh you know solution than to ask uh uh the European Union for a bailout well uh people have been uh uh
  35. people have been saying that a bailout might occur um you know any time uh for probably the last six months or
  36. eight months in the case of Spain uh so I guess um at the rate things are going it may not be more than two or three
  37. more months but again I mean something could happen that changes the situation uh although I I doubt that something big
  38. enough right significant enough uh uh will occur that will change the basic Dynamic right now so it seems as if it's
  39. a matter of uh a few months now uh as opposed to a year or a year and a half which was the situation you know um back
  40. at the beginning of uh of the current year 2012 [Music]

Brief Summary

Spain's economic decline worsens due to procyclical measures and high debt, risking a bailout from the EU.

Key points

  • The Austerity Debate. Austerity measures are failing to improve Spain's economy, leading to deeper issues.
  • Spain's Economic Outlook. Spain faces a dire economic future, potentially mirroring Greece's crisis.

Related episodes