How Financial Literacy Affects Household Debt and Bankruptcy

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Economist Sasha Indarte talks about her research into the effect of social safety net programs on household debt and creditworthiness, and bias in the bankruptcy process. This episode is part of a series on “Financial Literacy.”

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. now inflation is kind of special because one of the economic effects of inflation
  2. is that it tends to make people less averse to taking on debt the idea is if you have a fixed amount that you're
  3. promising to repay in the future and you expect more inflation going forward then
  4. the real value of what you promised to repay it's not going to be quite so large because in the future $1,000 isn't
  5. going to have the same purchasing power as it does today easy to say that when you have that feeling of being able to
  6. spend more that's when the potential for the concern around higher levels of debt
  7. and potential bankruptcy pops up welcome to the ripple effect the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds
  8. of Wharton faculty I'm your host Dan Looney and in each episode we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind
  9. the groundbreaking research that whon professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the
  10. world today well programs like Social Security Medicare unemployment insurance and others provide an important safety
  11. net for families but how do these programs impact the concern around household debt having those programs May
  12. deter people from savings as much as they probably should Sasha and darte is an assistant professor of Finance here
  13. at the waren school she has taking a deeper dive into this and she joins us here in studio nice to see you thanks
  14. for a few moments today thanks for having me you know this is an interesting topic I guess especially
  15. because people don't necessarily associate the availability of these types of programs
  16. to still being able to put away savings I agree I think uh it's not usually the first thing that comes to people's mind
  17. when you think about the social safety net how is that going to impact people's borrowing but it turns out from my
  18. research it looks like those programs can have uh really large interaction with credit markets and actually a
  19. really big part of the social welfare benefits from these programs can actually work through credit markets so
  20. take us through the research because part of it you did some research about the impact of Medicaid and the number of
  21. people eligible in a particular area can have a direct impact on the usage of things like like credit cards right so
  22. in a recent working paper with my co-author fellow Wharton Professor Gideon Borstein we study the impact of
  23. expanding Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act on consumers use of credit card
  24. debt in particular now it's not obvious from economic theory what you would expect you could get less credit card
  25. debt less debt overall and perhaps even more safe if for example people when they fall
  26. sick if they now have insurance they might not need to borrow or to draw down their Savings in order to afford the
  27. cost of that care now on the other hand people might have a less of a what we would call in economics a precautionary
  28. savings motive this is the idea that you use your own savings you build up wealth
  29. in order to ensure yourself against Adverse Events like job loss or or illness in this case and then finally
  30. credit Supply might also react to how people's behavior changes after Medicaid expands in particular if people now have
  31. insurance and they default less often they're in a sense more financially resilient and creditors might be more
  32. willing to lend to them in terms of you know people feeling like Medicaid it helps them feel like they're probably
  33. more free to be able to spend in other areas right exactly so this is uh this precautionary savings piece of people's
  34. behavior if you're going to be able to rely on Medicaid when you become sick you might have a little bit more leeway
  35. to spend even outside of times when you're not necessarily sick because you don't need to self-insure that much with
  36. your own savings and then so also speak to the component about how social insurance programs can actually help
  37. creditors as well exactly so when people get access to insurance we see for example in our own research people
  38. become less likely to default overall in particular they are less likely to have
  39. debt and collections which is one of the worst things that you can have on your credit report report so this reduction
  40. in default that's going to make creditors more likely we find to approve requests for credit cards people will
  41. see an increase in their credit limits essentially the supply of credit is reacting to people's improved Financial
  42. resilience so those creditors feel more amenable to being able to provide these assets to those members of the public
  43. that's exactly the idea that's because doesn't that kind of open a door they're basically open the opening the door to
  44. the potential problems that we're talking about here with some of the issues of household Deb yes so in our
  45. paper we see things running in one particular direction overall we see that Medicaid expands it's overall reducing
  46. default people's credit scores improve and despite taking on more debt their financial capacity their ability to
  47. tolerate having a lot of debt that's also improving as a result but if you did have an expansion in credit without
  48. these improvements to people's Financial resilience that's when I would be especially worried about the burden that
  49. that debt imposes so is this somewhat similar to maybe what we're hearing now about people relying on their credit
  50. cards in some cases because of the level of inflation they may not have as much money in the bank as they would like to
  51. so they're using credit cards to replace that this could be part of what we're seeing recently with credit cards now
  52. inflation is kind of special because one of the economic effects of inflation is
  53. that it tends to make people less averse to taking on debt the idea is if you have a fixed amount that you're
  54. promising to repay in the future and you expect more inflation going forward then
  55. the real value of what you promis to repay it's not going to be quite so large because in the future $1,000 isn't
  56. going to have the same purchasing power as it does today easy to say that when you have that feeling of being able to
  57. spend more that's when the potential for the concern around higher levels of debt
  58. and potential bankruptcy pops up it's hard to say whether people's Financial resilience is necessarily going to be
  59. worse overall that's really the key thing to understand whether or not an expansion of credit is going to be a
  60. good or bad thing so is inflation really helping people to the extent that they maybe anticipate that that it will in
  61. terms of making their debt affordable how much is the burden of debt that that people carry directly tied to not having
  62. the cash on hand that can be an enormous uh burden so if you do not have the cash
  63. to afford your debt payments typically people they then go delinquent so they start to miss some of their payments and
  64. that that debt it can continue to build up over time uh some types of debt it continue it can for example like credit
  65. card debt it can continue to build interest so the overall burden can grow and then when people are finding
  66. themselves with a overwhelming amount of debt that's when they might seek something like debt relief through
  67. bankruptcy but I also notice you have looked at in the past uh the level of bankruptcy and how it's tied to bias
  68. within the within the public as well yes so I have some ongoing research that tries to uh both document and understand
  69. the reason behind racial disparities and the access to the debt relief that bankruptcy provides where did that start
  70. from where did that Genesis start from in terms of wanting to look at that so there were really two big motivating
  71. factors the first is that bankruptcy is an important source of debt relief for us households in fact if you actually
  72. compare the scale of the wealth transfers uh in terms of the debt forgiveness that bankruptcy gives people
  73. if you compare that to other social insurance programs it's bigger than a lot of them it's on car with programs
  74. like unemployment insurance or even larger uh in most of the years of unemployment insurance the second
  75. motivating factor beyond the importance of bankruptcy is that there's a big body
  76. of financial research that finds that there's a lot of racial disparities in financial Market outcomes so we wanted
  77. to see is bankruptcy also one of these areas where you also see racial disparities and there was more of an
  78. impact on black Americans than there would be in regards to white Americans as well correct exactly so we found for
  79. example that uh now there's two different types of bankruptcy chapters about 70% of people file Chapter 7 now
  80. in that chapter black filers are about three percentage points more likely to be dismissed that might not sound like a
  81. lot but there's uh not a lot of uh dismissal that means uh getting uh you go through all the trouble of the
  82. bankruptcy process but then you don't get the your cases thrown out you don't get the one good part of the bankruptcy
  83. which is the debt relief and that's about double uh the Baseline rate for for nonblack filers now in Chapter 13 we
  84. see an even larger and absolute term disparity in Chapter 13 black filers are about 16 to 17 percentage points more
  85. likely to have their case dismissed which gives them about a 20% relatively higher rate of dismissal but can we
  86. determine why the numbers are the way they are in terms of black filers versus white filers it's really difficult to to
  87. get at this so we have to use a a clever bit of econometrics in order to try and
  88. say something about bias now the reason that it's challenging is when you see a disparity this could be due due to
  89. unobserved variables that we're not controlling for for example if black filers have a greater risk of losing
  90. their job in the future uh that could make it hard for them to complete some of the requirements in Chapter 13 and
  91. that might explain some of the disparities so it could just be these unobservable non-controlled for
  92. characteristics versus actual bias so the Crux of our approach to overcome this is we look at differences in the
  93. black white dismissal Gap among black decision makers in the bankruptcy process these would be the bankruptcy
  94. trustees versus white decision makers in the process and the idea is when we do this differencing and comparing we can
  95. kind of net out these omitted factors and what we're left with is how these two groups make decisions differently
  96. right but for blacks that uh either file for uh chapter 7 or chapter 13 and they
  97. don't get approved to the level that they want to that just adds another layer of angst for them in terms of
  98. trying to get out from under that level of debt exactly so when these black filers are not getting access to
  99. bankruptcy this can have uh really negative uh economic and even Health consequences there's work by uh will
  100. Doby and his co-authors for example that finds that uh in a they exploit a really
  101. nice uh nice in a statistical sense uh a natural experiment uh that led to some people receiving chapter 13 debt relief
  102. some people didn't get it and what they found is that the ones who got the debt relief they were more likely to be
  103. employed they had higher income in the future they were more more likely to be homeowners in the future and they even
  104. had improved mortality in the future so if there's a disparity a racial disparity in access to debt relief there
  105. could be pretty far-reaching consequences from this suffice it to say that the research that you've done on
  106. the on this topic shows that there are probably quite a few adjustments that could be made in terms of how this
  107. process goes the structure of it in order to kind of improve the process for all Americans correct I I see that I
  108. think our research what it does is it helps illuminate uh some areas where there's more room for investigation I
  109. think it highlights possible Avenues of policies or other changes that we could make if we want to improve and give more
  110. equal access to bankruptcy this could be things like uh for example in Chapter 13
  111. there's a lot more subjective decision-making on the part of the chapter 13 bankruptcy trustees they have
  112. a really hard mathematical problem where they have to try and forecast a person's
  113. income over the next five years so that's a that can be a difficult task and when there's subjectivity there's
  114. more scope for bias potentially to influence how they handle cases so trying to remove some of that
  115. subjectivity and Sh maybe automating uh more parts of the bankruptcy process that's one Avenue that I can say for
  116. sure it would work but it would be useful for researchers to explore so is there a next natural step that you want
  117. to investigate in this process yeah I think uh uh one I think investigating uh ways that uh introduce the use of
  118. algorithms for example to maybe Aid in the decision-making process this is something that's been done in other more
  119. of the uh criminal areas of the law where for example with respect to sentencing and things like that and
  120. seeing if this is something that can reduce bias in bankruptcy that would be useful for researchers to investigate
  121. Sasha great to meet you thanks very much for coming in appreciate your time today
  122. thank you thank you Sasha and darte who is assistant professor of Finance here at the Wharton School thank you for
  123. listening to the ripple effect we hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and
  124. leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the warden
  125. School

Brief Summary

Sasha Andarte discusses inflation's impact on debt and racial disparities in bankruptcy access in this episode.

Key points

  • Inflation's Impact on Debt. Inflation can reduce the real value of debt, making borrowing more appealing.
  • Medicaid and Financial Resilience. Medicaid expansion can lead to less credit card debt and improved financial behavior.
  • Racial Disparities in Bankruptcy. Research shows significant racial disparities in bankruptcy dismissal rates.
  • Improving Bankruptcy Access. Research highlights the need for policy changes to ensure equal access to bankruptcy.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes