A Wake-up Call on Water Scarcity
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Part II of this Israel Knowledge@Wharton interview with Israeli water experts considers the successful technologies and water management techniques that have been pioneered in Israel, and how they might aid others in coping with the world's quickly rising problem of water scarcity. Members of the panel include Eilon M. Adar, director of the Institute for Water Research and Avigad Vonshak, director of desert research, at Ben Gurion University. Joining the discussion is Noam Lior, professor of mechanical engineering and applied mechanics at the University of Pennsylvania.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] would you give an overview uh of the kinds of Technologies ideas Innovations
- in Israel today that would apply very well to other countries that are that may be facing problems soon I would I
- would try and divide them into two and maybe aan will elaborate on the technology of reclaiming and producing
- water but there is the other part and this is the consumer and the understanding that it's not enough to
- produce more water you have to use it in a more efficient way and even the term of efficiency or what is sustainability
- is getting to be controversial so if you come to a farmer and ask him what is water use efficiency his answer will be
- very simple how much money do I make from a unit of water and this is the advantage of the relatively educated
- Israeli farmer he can adapt diverse and change whatever he's doing with the water based on Market needs and price of
- the market of the product uh the best example is as I usually say and this is something that we developed in our
- institutes is aquaculture in dry lands growing fish in the desert which seems to be a crazy idea makes a lot of sense
- if you measure the efficiency by the amount of protein you are producing per unit of water and then you realize that
- fish as I say live in water but they don't consume the water so the challenge is intensive f of aquaculture recycling
- of water using the water after it in order to have another product like growing dates for suddenly from one unit
- of water you actually have two products you have fish and you have dates you increase the well-being and the income
- of a farmer and you utilize the water in a very smart way it will be there is a need to associate it with the
- understanding of people that they at a certain stage they'll be Achi change in the diet of what we are
- eating and this is just one example and there's many others growing uh vegetables that not only Thrive of
- celline water but actually take up the salt all the way to Growing algae and microalgae that again can the water can
- be recycled and the product that you are producing as a very high value in the market this of course depends on the
- ability of the technology to provide us with more good quality water and I think
- Alon is the right person to elaborate on this one do we have the Technologies we
- need right now or we're going to be having to develop more we do have Technologies however the question is
- whether these Technologies are adequate for the future but before that to continue with what avad
- said the question is whether it will be sufficient to dwell on you know increasing water use efficiency to solve
- the problem globally and the example from Israel is that it's not in Israel we reached High use
- efficiency by all means by all standards but it's not enough definitely not enough in spite of the fact that
- agricultural sector in Israel is now getting only 25% of the water consumed by the agriculture sector
- is fresh water 47 years ago the agricultural sector consumed 1.1 billion cubic meter of
- water at that time 100% fresh water slowly but surely in 45 47 years they moved to
- 68% treated reclaimed sewage water only 24% fresh water the rest is fresh breish
- water and Sopris they consume the same amount of water today 0.998 billion and a big surprise
- the cultural production was not negatively affected they produced 10 times more to be accurate 10.2 times
- more than 47 years ago and bear in mind the Israeli GDP during that time is 9 Times Higher and the population at that
- time was 3.2 million people and now we are 7.6 million people so you know it can be done however the question is and
- I coming back to the issue whether that will be sufficient to solve the problem and the answer is
- no we reached the almost the highest efficiency and we still have a gap between what is available and and the
- demand now demand is a relative term but the so-called the motto in our country is that the fact that water is a scarce
- commodity should not have a negative impact on our economy on our society so to close the gap we had to come with
- Novelties and Technologies to treat Water by desalination of breish Water by desalination of sea water there are many
- ways to go we finally went for those Mega plants when we reached the solution that we can produce 1 cubic
- of meter from seawater designation utilizing 3.75 Kow hour of energy at the cost of not energy the global cost of
- between 656 56 to 66 us cents per cubic meter and it's affordable so that I think the way to go
- and I don't say which way it will be developed we have to get our science you know full clearance to get wild and come
- up with different different ideas and in the water Institute at the benon University we actually explore several
- Avenues I cannot tell which will finally be materialized and that will be of course the most efficient one regarding
- money wise yes I'd just like to add some qualification to what avard said maybe it will lead the discussion uh to a
- little uh different direction uh having been a farmer in Israel uh the cost the the the value of water is how much money
- you can make from your product not per unit of water but per unit cost of water so uh so uh the the cost of water is a
- very important ingredient and maybe the dominant one in the situation also we also talked a lot about food and
- agriculture but in fact in Israel as far as I have seen uh industry uses uh at least as much War you know globally as
- as agriculture in Israel yeah no no no no Statics no you totally wrong I mean the is the the industry is consuming
- about 10% of what the of what the agricultural sector very low amount whatever the industry is described as in
- the statistics that I got from the uh Israeli literature where this may be when the time when we had a huge textile
- industry which is which is not anymore they cannot afford uh the prices uh you have to realize that this brings us back
- to cost of of War and pricing and and policies and politics well industry includes cooling water for power plants
- and for desination plant and so on but anyway we'll take whatever they say as the truth but they uh fact in fact the
- industry does use water and there is a need to reduce the uh consumption and improve the quality of the water that
- comes out of out of there too and that's you know improve this quality of the affluence is really you know you're
- really a challenge and as you probably realized we don't see affluence as waste effluence is another resource that has
- to be treated and you know later on reclaimed and uh uh reclaiming effluence from the industry
- is very challenging uh process and we try very hard to come up with Solutions not because it will provide us with
- additional significant amount of water but it because of protecting the environment we are we signed the
- Barcelona treaty for not contaminating the Mediterranean Sea and uh we are very much concerned of that uh a lot of this
- uh a lot of the Innovation then that you've you've undergone in Israel has been driven by constraints by price um
- that price constraint hasn't hasn't bit down in places like the us yet where where water's mostly very cheap uh you
- would probably say very underpriced can you talk about the importance of price and how that may be that really the
- mechanism that that that changes or forces change I think that we have to understand that uh the Water issue is
- not just availability of water for consumption and Agriculture and indust industry we have to realize that water
- has an impact on every facet of our life and this is why water research if you want and and developing it is something
- that requires an interdisciplinary approach from as I mentioned before the social problems the education problems
- the energy consumption the technology itself and finally food production so all of it has to be put in a basket
- if you want and then it's up to the leadership and the politicians if you want to put a real price T not of how
- much does it require to produce a unit of water but what is the contribution to society in large of this unit of water
- and it's okay to say to a country we subsidize our water so that we can develop a region in the
- country in Israel if I live in the desert I pay the same amount of water as someone who lives in the North and
- someone can claim that it's not fair but this is a kind of a social uh political issue that is confined to the
- policies of a country and this is why there is no need to have a global price for water and every country has the
- right to do it as long as the decisions are really driven by the understanding that there are many inputs into it and
- unfortunately sometimes this is not the case which leads to wasting of water we discussed before of our farmer and sou
- part of France is basically using water in a very wasteful way because C of politics and policies that have nothing
- to do with the national contribution of this particular agriculture in in the country and one can go side by side your
- geographically regions and find this kind of if you want stupid decisions we get cannot be
- explained there is a flat price all over the country in Israel as a got mentioned
- but different pricing for treated water breish fresh breish you know natural water and blue So-Cal fresh water for
- the for the agricultural sector as long you use the qu allocated by the way it changed every year according to the
- situation as long you use the quarter or within the quarter it's flat constant price if you exceed the quarter
- sometimes they cut the because there is no water or the price is elevated dramatically the same for domestic use
- the same there is a quarter per family with reasonable cost it's still expensive but if you exceed the quarter
- if I want to water my garden I want to see some green in front of my eyes I have to pay it's a matter of
- priority ex yeah exactly I mean it's the pricing can be used by the government as
- a way of implement policies if you get a farmer to pay a more much more real price for the water he will be driven to
- use it more efficiently the best example is from the farmers you see many farmers
- especially in the netive desert they get three types of three types of water at the gate the blue fresh more expensive
- the green braish quite cheap and in the middle is the red water the treated sewage water and every farmer has its
- own tanks in the farm and he makes them aun based on you know the growing season
- germination the crop you know pricing he has to make it you know he makes the decision but he
- knows as aad said he knows a priori how much he pays for every cubic meter he takes from each of these colored lines
- so so being so close to this um as you are and having live through the development of these pretty
- extraordinary Technologies are you hopeful about how the world will handle water in the future in other words do
- you is it your view that well eventually water is going to get expensive the price will go up to a point where people
- will have to adopt new Behaviors new technologies and thank goodness that Technologies are there or are you less
- optimistic for reasons you can explain to me I like to just add one thing which will maybe also direct the the answer in
- addition to what vard Alon said there should be in uh the sense of sustainable development some depletion allowance in
- the price okay so because uh water gives us some things now but we have to take into account uh the price of it being uh
- lowered in quantity in the future okay and uh there are depletion allowances in some areas not in not in water but in
- some other uh resources and uh until the world agrees that uh this kind of depletion allowance
- should be included in the price uh in addition to all of the other costs you know we we are going to be in in
- trouble we are in troubles yeah and uh the reason I am optimistic is that there is no other choice so the question is
- why just when are we going to wake up early enough or will it have to go to a much worse situation and this can be
- Carri the way up to issues of else in Africa or just the need to dry out our golf courses God
- forbid uh I follow avard I'm also Optimist uh and I I think that by just reviewing the
- scientific Community we are driven by the market so-called and I see among my my
- colleagues researchers in different institutes we the scientific Community work very hard to come up with more
- novel methods and later on Technologies I hope to be able to produce more water more adequate water in a more efficient
- way however we have to take the holistic approach here don't forget for every cubic of meter now with the current
- technology available we need 3.75 kilow hour just in the Middle East this year we desalinate 400 million next year
- December 2013 it will be 505 million cubic meters a year half a billion just for Israel
- what about Palestine they need about 300 million what about Hashim Kingdom of Jordan what about D Syria so then the
- amount of fossile oil becomes significant with all the consequences so we have to look for as I
- said holistic approach and look for alternative methods with maybe cleaner energy associated with desalination
- whether it's wind driven desalination or solar energy driven discernation and is
- not just you know to create electricity from solar panels and plug your donation
- plan to that it's more sophisticated but we have to be concerned we shall be able and and I'm
- Optimist we shall be able to meet the demand for water definitely the question is whether it will be affordable to the
- entire population or only to spe very special segments or sections and what will be the toll on the
- environment and but we better take think about it right now and develop it together not come later you know in 15
- years from now coming with the technology then we say okay yes but it has a very significant impact negative
- impact on the environment then it will be too late um people might have thought and it
- still may be the case that the Middle East would be the test case for all of this but we've seen this year with the
- severe droughts in the United States and the effects on Lower production therefore the effects on prices the real
- spike in in food prices food shortages that sort of thing um and um depending on one's view on climate change you know
- one view is that that's going to become the norm um and so that is that the beginning of a wakeup call for the rest
- of the world you in the Middle East have faced this for a long time and have had
- a lot of time to think about it the rest of the world has not we don't have that
- much of dry farming in the Middle East ah so what I mean the So-Cal annual fluctuations has more impact on die
- farming rather than on irrigated land so well maybe it might be a wakeup call it's too early to say but you know at
- least we we can hear the the Bell okay um any final words before we stop here no I just to the wakeup call I mean
- there are so many wakeup calls that uh human uh nature tendency is to ignore them all uh there's a wakeup call on
- energy there is a wake up call on food there is wake up call on on environment and what we as scientist what we are
- trying to say is the same wake up call by the time you exaggerate on one end you causing a problem in the other one
- and it's a longside it's the holistic approach we have to understand and this goes all the way even to the way we
- educate our students the understanding that the need to be a good scientist requires a background in an
- interdisciplinary the ability to tackle an issue on an interdisciplinary approach and this is again if I may go
- back to our backyard to the desert research institutes this is why you have this kind of diversity of people dealing
- with issues all the way from Desert architecture how are you going to build you houses you cities and this is true
- not only for Israel Phoenix in Arizona is facing the same problem as a small settlement in the Israeli netive it's
- even blown up and the bigger problem in F next Arizona so it's desert architecture it is energy it is
- education it is social issues and everything if you want it's the same wakeup call we are going to face and we
- are actually facing a problem and the wakeup call is not only for the scientific Community but also for the
- politicians and the leaders because finally scientists don't make decisions thanks God they don't finally they
- finally may be able to provide a good advice yeah I think this is the m very important point you know we should make
- the advice but you know we have to educate the politicians as well yeah I think that uh demand and pricing uh seem
- to be U more dominant than the scientific inventions unfortunately and uh policy and uh and
- you know we can blame the quote unquote politicians but we elect them usually so
- uh you know if the people don't understand uh the problems then we like the wrong people so it's again put the
- blame on me yeah put the blame on us and just not to leave that global warming uh
- uh issue uh uh open um there was some brief comments made but whether you believe in global warming or not there
- are two in in incontrovertible uh uh facts one is we're doing our best to increase global
- warming uh so uh there's no question about it the emissions of greenhouse gases are increasing and their effect on
- global warming is absolutely true and the second thing that is also in controvertible is that we see the
- massive melting of the icebergs this is not the question of the snow caps so uh something is creating it and to ignore
- it and to say that there's no global warming and will continue I think is a very bad mistake absolutely it's uh the
- lowest level of ice cover for summer yeah as far as we know as far as we know uh in in the north correct also in the
- South even in there's a very interesting study just published about the mount Kia
- in Africa the eyes disappeared no snow anymore in the summer time in the sum time for the first time
- ever and they're talking about an ice free uh North Pole area perhaps in as little as 10 years in the summer
- disappear so ignoring climate change is is up to the stage of being ridiculous but on the other hand you see
- if we follow the Russians you know they are very Optimist you know because they claim more land in Siberia will join the
- productive land because of the you know yeah ating yeah it's a joke yeah but you
- know they claim that more land will be able to be cultivated now in Siberia we should see and they're selling cruises
- in the bearing the sea already so there is an upside yeah yeah thank you very much for joining us our
- pleasure thank you very interesting [Music]
Brief Summary
Israeli experts discuss innovative water technologies and efficiency in agriculture, emphasizing the need for holistic approaches to global water challenges.
Key points
- Innovative Water Solutions in Israel. Israel's advancements in water technology include aquaculture and efficient water use strategies.
- Water Scarcity and Economic Impact. The scarcity of water should not negatively impact society or the economy.
- The Global Wake-Up Call. Severe droughts and food shortages signal a global need for better water management.
Episode highlights
- Innovative Water Solutions in IsraelIsrael's advancements in water technology include aquaculture and efficient water use strategies.“Growing fish in the desert seems crazy, but it makes sense for efficiency.”1:39Nov 1, 2012
- Water Scarcity and Economic ImpactThe scarcity of water should not negatively impact society or the economy.“Water is a scarce commodity, but it shouldn't harm our economy.”5:28Nov 1, 2012
- The Global Wake-Up CallSevere droughts and food shortages signal a global need for better water management.“This can be a wake-up call for the rest of the world.”19:11Nov 1, 2012
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





