Small Actions, Big Difference
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) and sustainability need to be strategic in order to benefit firms and society, says C. B. Bhattacharya, author of 'Small Actions, Big Difference.'
Small Actions, Big Difference: https://smallactionsbigdifference.net/ https://twitter.com/CBsuite https://www.facebook.com/CBsmallactionsbigdifference https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/46433107-small-actions-big-difference
University of Pittsburgh Center for Sustainable Business: https://www.sustainablebusiness.pitt.edu/ https://twitter.com/PittCSB https://www.facebook.com/PittCenterforSustainableBusiness http://linkedin.com/company/pittcsb https://www.instagram.com/pittcsb/ 📂 ESG
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- good afternoon I'm sandy hunt managing director of the wharton and social impact initiative and i'm delighted to
- welcome you to our conversation today with cv Bhattacharya CB is the H J's offer chair of sustainability ethics at
- the University of Pittsburgh's Katz Graduate School of Business and the author of the great new book small
- actions big difference welcome to Wharton CB thank you for having me so you have a rich career in
- this space tell us a little bit about how you got interested in this topic well I'm actually back at my alma mater
- so my PhD was from Wharton and it was in marketing which doesn't have a direct link to what I do today but as I was an
- assistant professor back in the day at Emory University during that time I met a gentleman by the name of Ben Cohen and
- he was the CEO of this company called Ben & Jerry's so he was the Ben of Ben & Jerry's and he asked me kind of an
- interesting question he said you know we do a lot for the environment and we do a
- lot for society can you help me understand if what we do for the environment and for society does it help
- us sell ice cream and I found that to be a fascinating question and this is the mid-1990s mind you I found it a
- fascinating question on multiple fronts first he was talking about sales and how
- to increase sales and as marketing people we are always talking about how to increase sales on the other hand he
- was talking about environmental attributes and social attributes of a product kind of driving sales and nobody
- was looking at that at that point in time and so I said ok I don't know the answer to this question but I'm gonna
- you know think about it and so that really started my transition to the field of what we now call corporate
- social responsibility or our CSR and that proved to be kind of the turning point for my for my career and then one
- thing led to another you know there were several articles to be to be written several questions to be explored and I
- started down that path and as I was searching for my last book leveraging corporate responsibility I made an
- interesting observation and the observation was that these corporate responsibility managers or
- sustainability managers in companies companies like P&G General Mills Timberland I you know research all these
- companies they were all very smart very good people but they were kind of lonely
- and what I mean by that is that they did not have a seat at the strategy table of
- the company and to me this truck as as odd and not something good for the field because in my research I had found that
- it's only when CSR is treated as a strategy only then does it benefit the firm and benefit society and so on and
- so forth so I started thinking about my next book which now comes out as small actions big difference means how can we
- you know on board the entire organization into this journey of making our companies more more sustainable so
- that in short is kind of how I get here excellent and before we go into the solutions the book outlines let's talk
- about the problem you say this isn't working at companies for two reasons one is that bosses delegate the task to a
- single unit rather than integrating it throughout the entire corporate strategy and two is that boards believe
- unsustainable practices can be solved by a change in management let's talk about
- how those show up and and and really illustrate those problems what does it look like in the first case how do you
- how would you know gosh that's that's my company we need to change right so there
- is this mistaken conception in the field in in large parts of the corporate field
- I would say that sustainability the well-being of our planet and its people is the next iteration of CSR or
- corporate social responsibility in fact I'm going to India next week to speak at
- a conference which is called CSR 3.0 so it's it's like you know goes higher and higher now this is this is wrong
- because sustainability has to do with the survival of the company and as such it deals with every organizational
- function you know starting from procurement where do our materials come from to disposal kind of where do our
- products kind of end up and as you can imagine every part of the organization is touched by the concept and actions
- that have to do with sustainability so the lens yeah so that's why I call conducting business through the
- sustainability lens so everybody has to be on board and just relegating it to one unit so that you produce a
- sustainability report in which you just kind of note what all you've done as a company in insuring yourself as a good
- corporate citizen is necessary but nearly not sufficient so when a company is doing it right is there someone in
- each division or sector that is sort of a part of the sustainability team how do
- you make sure it's not siloed yes that that happens first of all oftentimes there are no sustainability teams as
- such because sustainability is fully integrated into product development in you know into into R&D into branding
- into human resource management into procurement all of that and any team that you will find is we has what's
- called sustainability generalists multiple people working in that who may not have a very deep knowledge of the
- science of sustainability or whatever but who know enough so as to make those business decisions with that lens of
- sustainability priority and they're making sure that it's just that it's always integrated into every business
- decision made from the mailroom to the boardroom that's that's how it happens in certain
- companies in other companies you're absolutely right I mean there will be somebody from marketing somebody from HR
- somebody from procurement and they will be kind of the ambassadors if you will to the overall kind of corporate
- sustainability leadership leadership team and then they in turn kind of cascade stuff
- through their respective departments so I have seen both of those happening so that's the first way you see it not
- working and a little bit on the solution the second challenge you raise is that it's not about a change in management or
- change management it's really about changing how a company philosophically thinks about sustainability tell me more
- in our field in the corporate world we have this belief that change management can pretty much fix everything so the
- lean manufacturing and all those change management you know quality move consulting so and that's the bread and
- butter of consultants so I have seen several organizations who will say well we can get in a McKinsey or an Accenture
- to kind of you know launch our sustainability program it that's all very good except sustainability speaks
- to the very philosophy of business and to the philosophy of the corporation and change management does not do that so
- traditional change management initiatives are still focused on how to increase profit whereas when it comes to
- sustainability the first thing we're saying is that we have to go beyond profit to think about purpose what is
- the purpose of the organization and the purpose of the organization really is to
- play a role in society and and to be helpful towards the environment to serve customers so it's a multi-stakeholder
- kind of a concept and as you know the Business Roundtable recently came out and said that you know we need to go
- beyond profits Larry Fink has been writing his letters and so on so it's when we think that you know a chain
- management exercise can fix sustainability again I think we are kind of ignoring some very important
- underpinnings of the concept particularly when it comes to kind of convincing your employee basis that this
- is something worthwhile kind of engaging in rather than kind of being being being
- bystanders so so rather than change in management I would just cut out the end it was more about kind of thinking that
- change management is gonna be able to fix it and that's wrong it won't excellent for companies that don't have
- the expertise in-house you're speaking to why bringing someone in from the outside may
- not be the solution what would your advice be if they are looking into to bring in insight or some valuable
- perspectives about how to be a more sustainable company yeah so I'm not saying don't bring someone from the
- outside I mean if you don't know what to do you need you need help and there are
- you know commercial consulting organizations there are also people like myself and others who work in the field
- who might be able to help so that's all fine and good but I think what is important is for whoever kind of comes
- in to help to understand this concept of kind of it's it's just different from it's somewhat sustainability is a
- different kind of an animal and and let's try to understand kind of you know go take a step back and see why business
- exists in the first place and why is it important that's really important because if we don't ask that question
- why do we do what we do as an energy company I mean my job literally is not to sell electricity but it is to keep
- people comfortably warm or cold or help them do whatever they want to do with electricity and that's a huge mindset
- shift and when you when you define your purpose any company they will always find that sustainability kind of is
- inherently built-in into that definition and so anyone who comes in to help you out help any company out as long as they
- have the right kind of perspective on what sustainability entails and what it would take to change an organization to
- transition its business model to be more sustainable I think you're fine excellent let's get into the solutions
- because I bet viewers are watching this and saying gosh this seems like a hard nut to crack so your book outlines three
- steps can you summarize them for us sure yeah so the three steps are incubate we're by and large it's the leadership
- team and who gets together to define that all-important purpose that I talked about what's the company's purpose and
- then they come up with of concrete goals so the issues that are material for their company because a
- cement company could be very different from kind of a a consulting company or a financial services company or what have
- you everybody doesn't have to solve all the problems in the world so the second phase is launch and that's when we kind
- of unfold that program for the employee base of the company and potentially other stakeholders as well like you know
- community members supply chain members even customers and so on and the third phase is called entrench where you
- undertake a set of practices that makes acting sustainably are doing business so
- that lens of sustainable sustainability kind of like second nature you know and and there we talk about kind of you know
- providing feedback on progress you know through metrics and KPIs we talked about creating this vibrant
- culture of sustainability in the organization so that it's kept fresh and it doesn't become another flavor of the
- month and then I talked about expanding your sense of kind of ownership so that it's not just about me anymore my
- company but it's about the planet and that's where we see traditional competitors collaborating you know to
- solve what I call the tragedy of the Commons problems like kind of deforestation or we eat waste
- that no one company can solve by itself so those incubate launch and entrench are the three steps of my model
- excellent let's dig in a little bit on the incubation step you're setting that mission that purpose is that unique for
- each company or do you see companies within a particular sector all sort of having the same mission and purpose I'm
- asking as I think about leaders who are going to watch this interview read your book by and read your book and then sit
- down at the right board and say how do I know I've landed at the the real purpose
- statement or mission statement of this company right so it's a two-fold answer to that any purpose I believe would have
- to have some kind of a normative component so I'm not just doing or defining the purpose of the four
- so that it resonates with my stakeholders it also has to be is this really what we are trying to trying to
- accomplish or or or not what comes from our hearts and minds as leaders and and a leadership team and then I can check
- to see is this something that that gets buy-in from my employees first and foremost but out of all the stakeholder
- groups that I have if it does if employees seem to understand that this is what we are trying to do it should be
- reasonably easy to communicate otherwise purpose gets gets very very can get lost
- and then you know it's defeated but if it if it is something that's true to who you are as a company and this is what
- you're really trying to do and you know it it has buy-in your employees say yes I mean this is this is a good goal for
- us you know this is this is indeed why we exist as a company then then I think you're you're alright and every company
- does not have to even within the same industry every company does not have to have the same exact same purpose I mean
- so the purpose of all car companies might be to provide mobility which is in fact the basic purpose the reason I
- think that they're trying to do this but that does not mean that somebody cannot
- add comfort to it or somebody else cannot add you know speed or the experience or you know or a rush or
- whatever you call it so there are definitely ways to kind of you know change your purpose to to give it a
- certain uniqueness relative to others you talked about checking it with your employees as the first stakeholder group
- what does that process look like so you come up with a purpose statement and you
- want to see if it resonates with your employees that's a way to test if it's the right statement for your company
- what do you do you can do a town hall meeting you know so we're you it's an open forum where employees come and you
- know you can just have a Q&A session I've seen CEOs lead this kind of a process and it can be quite energizing
- for for the employees employees can provide feedback it can also be done kind of
- the departmental kind of level so if the CEO and his or her leadership team have
- defined the purpose they can you know you have these different ambassadors who can go out to their respective kind of
- reports and can find out what what what people are thinking about it the main thing is that it has to have
- buy-in both externally and internally and by gauging the energy or the resonance with what you're talking about
- kind of you know that's the surest way to know if you if you're on the right path or not so that one's a little R in
- a little science or a lot of it is a little art a little science excellent so let's go into the second step where
- you're making your goals more concrete sort of how I you know took that away when it comes to social impact issues
- sometimes you have blurry edges we'll go back to your car example you know it's to get people places is it to get them
- there safely is it to do it with the smallest you know environmental footprint is it to do so building
- community is it to do so safely for children pets so on and so on how do you know how do companies draw the right
- line around those sort of specific dimensions of impact so that they aren't trying to boil the ocean and target 100
- impact dimensions because it can get really tricky to know when to say when sure that's a great question so what
- companies typically do is something called a materiality analysis which in very simple terms is kind of what do our
- stakeholders think are the most important issues kind of facing the company and what do our managers think
- are the most important issues facing the company and so stakeholders rate all these different issues that you talked
- about kind of you know I've participated as a stakeholder in several companies surveys in terms of their materiality
- surveys and and B just from our knowledge of the industry from the knowledge of the company we say ok I
- know these kinds of things are really important and then the company you know chooses a set of employees as well too
- to rate the same universe of issues in terms of how important is it for the company and then the the materiality
- matrix is simply kind of you know plotting those on a two-dimensional access kind of you know and so the
- importance according to the employees and the importance according to the stakeholders and then we choose
- typically the company will choose those issues which are deemed important not only by the company itself but also by
- the marketplace of of stakeholders and more than three or four issues can make it or seven let's say in the case of
- Unilever it can you know it can get very very complicated now the question is why
- is this step important you don't want to boil the ocean because if you if you don't focus on anything this is a quote
- in my book if you don't focus on something then nothing gets done so you know you got to prioritize you've got a
- pick I mean let's talk of carbon carbon is extremely important for let's say Lafarge wholesome this large cement the
- largest cement produce in the world but it is much less important for let's say a company like ing financial services
- you know for whom something like cybersecurity may be much more important so it's - materiality is one way that we
- can boil down and distill our our goals and and into into concrete bite-sized kind of chunks and it's easier to
- disseminate this goals and the priorities to kind of the employee base and to the stakeholder base I mean I
- mean think of companies like La Farge or Unilever are IBM they have hundreds of thousands of employees and you know to
- get into their heads kind of okay these are the three things that are important that makes progress much much easier
- down the road absolutely especially to consumers I'm imagining the effort it takes for companies to say this is what
- we care about you want to keep that list yeah mm-hmm not not limitless so then as
- we go to the end you and to the third step you talked a lot about employee ownership really getting this to be
- something that every single employee at the company sees as a part of their job as a priority of theirs
- you talk about the heart and the head both being necessary can you tell us a little bit more about that yeah so so
- ownership is really kind of the centerpiece I think of this whole thing I mean there are companies who are
- giving directives to their to their employees kind of okay we need to be more sustainable we need to do this we
- need to do that but what's happening if you do not go through this process of instilling the sense of ownership then
- it becomes like you know going to the gym because I have to go to the gym and and my heart is not in in this thing
- what ownership does and psychology this is a psychological ownership you're not owning something physical but what
- ownership does it makes the individual employee take responsibility you know for sustainability regardless of whether
- he or she is in the mailroom or whether he or she is in the boardroom like everybody can make make a difference and
- so to to instill that sense of ownership I have to make an appeal and I call this
- enticing employees to kind of on board and it's different strokes for different folks so the right thing to do this is
- the right thing to do it's the right thing to do for our planet it's the right thing to do for our children we
- will be extinct I mean all of these things are are going you know people are reading about in the newspapers so
- several employees will resonate with this right thing to do kind of argument the other argument is well this is not
- only the right thing to do but it's also the smart thing to do because this look
- this is saving you money so I spoke to Lisa Jackson who's the top sustainability person at Apple and she
- said that the most fun part or one of the most fun parts of her job is to actually go into businesses and say you
- know look this is going to not only going to save you the amount of metals in you use in these
- products but it's also saving you money at the same time but it's a nicer saving
- because it's also helping the planet so the head and the heart kind of work in tandem you know and therefore you know
- companies oftentimes will use one or the other but very often a mix above yeah let's talk a
- little bit about that you said sustainable investment takes time to pay off you will have to spend money to get
- your house in order but once the returns start coming in then there's no conflict
- between the sustainability and the profitability let's talk a little bit about that timeline because I think this
- is a concept most everyone can get excited about but often what comes into play is how much do I need to invest and
- when will I see those returns returns in terms of profits returns in terms of employee engagement and environmental
- impact can you talk about what you've learned about those timelines sure another great question
- there is not I would start by saying that there is not kind of one timeline and it depends on the kinds of
- initiatives you undertake in almost every organization I've studied it seems like there there's low-hanging fruit and
- the low-hanging fruit really does not take long to to fix unless you're overly bureaucratic and
- the low-hanging fruit oftentimes is as well kind of you know things that have high symbolic value high signaling value
- even if they are not the one that's kind of the the most intense sustainability activity that you could undertake what
- would an example there so an example of low-hanging fruit would be to basically say kind of this is this is a plastic
- freeze you know a single plastic use free zone in our office we do not bring single plastic use bottles you know if
- we each have our respective coffee cups or mugs and water water bottles and so on and so forth and that's not that
- difficult to do but it has a tremendous impact on just the employees kind of you
- know light bulbs going off hey I mean you know my company is taking this seriously I mean you know so no more
- companies go to the next step and say we will not have individual waste paper baskets in every office you know you
- will need to go to the common area and segregate your wastes into you know what's recyclable what's compostable etc
- etc and you know what not having your own waste paper basket actually makes you produce less waste really
- bitter on because a huge behavior driver that's that's that's absolutely correct
- so these initiatives can can literally be done kind of you know in that three to six months time visibility quick wins
- now then though you know if you want to change your entire procurement system you want to like install audits at your
- suppliers which you should be doing those take a little bit longer to kind of pay off you want to build a factory
- which is going to be completely modernistic and and up to code and so on that's those those take a little bit
- longer to pay off but it's a journey and the most important thing is to get started you've got to get started with
- something that's noticeable and kind of you know becomes the cooler top you know
- so people congregate around the water cooler and actually start chatting about it but their reusable water bottle you
- know there's the a lot of snowball philosophies and it sounds like what you've seen is that when you do get
- these processes implemented they begin to start to snowball have you seen any cases where companies have had success
- jumping right to big things as their first investment and sort of making a seismic shift and how they do business
- and capturing that transformative energy simultaneously simultaneously yes so once company I studied was was Marks and
- Spencer for example this large retail organization across the world and they took a very deliberate stand by the said
- that kind of you know it should not be that if we are going to open a new retail store that someone has to decide
- individually kind of what kinds of lights to order and what kinds of insulation to have said their plan is
- called plan a because there is no plan B so that's what it says on the thing and
- and in and it's I spoke to the chief sustainability officer there and he told me that you know plan a just happens at
- the push of a button I mean you know it's not that somebody actually has default it's the default is the default
- option so they've tackled some some big things in the in in in the in in in those kinds of spaces in the operation
- spaces where actually you do save a lot of energy and you know and save a lot of
- emissions and so on but they've also at the same time kind of worked with their employees to say look we're a retailer
- so if we exist in communities that community is not gonna be happy or satisfied to know that our store is kind
- of you know has the latest technology you sustainable technologies kind of embedded into it the community will
- actually want to see some outreach from the stores to work with them I mean employ disabled people in there in the
- store or kind of you know help out with with some charitable work or something so that in a kind of there is that
- feeling that you are you are one of us so that was that's one example I can give you where they're tackling kind of
- multiple things and and at the same at the same front excellent doing this right
- sounds like a competitive advantage right you are getting high sort of customer engagement high employee
- engagement saving money are you seeing companies share what they've learned about how to be more sustainable or are
- they kind of keeping it a secret sauce because it is a competitive advantage these technologies and these processes I
- mean what I treasure trove of information but it's also it's a competitive landscape so what are you
- seeing this that's that's also a very very good question it's again I mean it's it's a it's it's
- a mix what you see out there is a mix I mean there are companies that firmly believe that sustainability needs to be
- put in the pre-competitive space so you know that's not something we we fight about let's fight about who's whose
- product does better in the in the marketplace and so on and so forth but they will collaborate on on technologies
- and they will collaborate on kind you know difficult problems like deforestation how to be solved before a
- station no one company can go it alone when it comes to that so that's where again collaboration is necessary
- Unilever for example you know they had a compressed canned deodorant and they made the technology open-source NL which
- is a very very large Italian electricity company they have made much of their technologies kind of also open to to
- someone else so it depends on on the company I know in the chemical industry as well and if there are collaborations
- that we don't see it's behind the scenes in R&D and so on and so forth all with the view to kind to make you know a host
- of companies sustainable at the same time conflict murals issue which came up with this digital devices with the kids
- in the Congo or mining these minerals and they were coming into our phones so there was this plea to kind of you know
- clean up the supply chain a bunch of organizations like Apple and Samsung and Nokia they got together to clean up that
- supply chain so I think I'm sure companies do have secrets and they're keeping some of them to themselves to be
- able to play the competitive advantage game but there's in the in the kind of higher consciousness of things it's also
- emerging that okay I mean you know this is germane for us also so let's work on it together
- excellent well that's good to hear to write this book you conducted over 25 interviews with multinational companies
- over a hundred over hundred individuals at those companies and what I thought was interesting is those individuals
- were sort of across the leadership spectrum so you said mailroom to boardroom type of thing was there
- anything that everyone commented on any Universal trends no matter the sector role level yes that this is truly
- important and we must be doing something about this and it's high time and all that kind of stuff everybody shares that
- was there anything that surprised from those interviews yes of course you know it's it's it's interesting that
- more than the interviews or the content of the interviews what is surprising is what you learn about organizations and
- and how they operate so there are organizations where kind of you know you where they are happy to
- have you videotape the interview for example you know and there are organizations where you cannot even
- audiotape an interview right now that says something I don't know what it is but it says that companies operate kind
- of companies operate differently there's a company where the CEO might come outside to to greet you and and and and
- you know kind of sit you down and so on and there are companies where you might have to go through three or four levels
- of admin assistants and so on to finally get into the CEOs room so these are things that you notice and you know
- that's that you find kind of surprising as well one thing I learned is that you know the real stories really come out
- when you move away from the c-suite which is why I always made sure that I spoke with some middle managers and
- wherever possible I visited factories and I spoke with the factory workers and I just went to branch offices and so
- just to see kind of is this ownership concept that I'm proposing this buy into sustainability wholesale employee
- engagement is this real or is this something that's just kind of you know in the head office because that happens
- that head offices are more but there there's some very very interesting kind of variations as you move across
- different parts of of a giant of a giant company well as we come to the end of the interview if someone doesn't read
- your book or doesn't even have time to finish watching our interview here today what are in a couple sentences the main
- takeaway is that you would like anyone who you know catches this interview reads the blogpost about it what are the
- couple things you'd really want them to take away the first thing I would say is
- that you know the cost of inaction is higher than the cost of action I think a lot of folks don't realize that not
- reading the scientific news that is coming out and the second thing I would say is that you know you just can always
- do something whether you work at a company whether you are the CEO of a company whether you aspire to work for a
- company all of the even just even leaving the consumer side aside for now just thinking about the workforce and
- the numbers we have in the workforce if we can mobilize a significant portion of
- that workforce we get something called the million-man effect which is kind of you know together we are stronger so I
- want to leave everybody with the sense that you know together we are stronger and that small actions can make a big
- difference and that no no no action is small enough you know starting from the mundane off kind of you know putting the
- lights out to kind of figuring out perhaps a way to suck carbon out of the air or to kind of you know alternative
- to plastic packaging or plant-based burgers or whatever it is whatever is in your realm of influence you have to do
- it being a bystander is not an option anymore you've got to lean in and be an owner yeah well that could I don't think
- would be a better way to end that call to action for all of our viewers and listeners that being a bystander is not
- an option CB bhattacharya thank you for not being a bystander for putting this book and your work out into the world
- the book is small actions big difference and it is available now CB thank you for
- your time thank you for having me for more insight from knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton
- UPenn edu [Music]
Brief Summary
CB Bhattacharya discusses integrating sustainability into business strategy and outlines steps for companies to enhance their corporate social responsibility efforts.
Key points
- Small Actions, Big Difference. CB Bhattacharya discusses his journey into corporate social responsibility and its importance.
- Three Steps to Sustainability. Bhattacharya outlines a three-step model for integrating sustainability into corporate strategy.
- The Cost of Inaction. The cost of inaction is higher than the cost of action. It's crucial to act now.
- Mobilizing the Workforce. Mobilizing a significant portion of the workforce can lead to impactful change.
Episode highlights
- Small Actions, Big DifferenceCB Bhattacharya discusses his journey into corporate social responsibility and its importance.“This is the turning point for my career.”1:57Jan 6, 2020
- Three Steps to SustainabilityBhattacharya outlines a three-step model for integrating sustainability into corporate strategy.“Incubate, launch, and entrench are the three steps of my model.”12:39Jan 6, 2020
- The Cost of InactionThe cost of inaction is higher than the cost of action. It's crucial to act now.“The cost of inaction is higher than the cost of action.”33:30Jan 6, 2020
- Mobilizing the WorkforceMobilizing a significant portion of the workforce can lead to impactful change.“Together we are stronger.”34:22Jan 6, 2020





