How Goodwill's Dual Model Succeeds

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

There’s a lot more to Goodwill’s charitable model than is obvious from its ubiquitous thrift stores. Jim Gibbons, head of Goodwill Industries International, explains. More: http://knlg.net/1WCbMet 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Hello, I'm Sheryl Coulman, Managing Director of the Wharton Social Impact Initiative. We're being joined here by
  2. Jim Gibbons, President and CEO of Goodwill Industries International, and we're going to talk about their their
  3. really successful hybrid model for their business. So, welcome, Jim. It's great to be here. Good to have you here.
  4. I know you're you're talking to a lot of folks about Goodwill, and and one of the
  5. things that I think is really interesting for our audience to hear about is Goodwill is one of those sort
  6. of highly recognized brands. So, you guys have been around a while doing great work, but why don't you, for the
  7. audience, tell us a little bit about the core of your work? Cuz I think a lot of
  8. people may know the name more than they understand what your business is. You know, it's great. It It's great to be a
  9. part of Goodwill. It is a household name. Uh, there are more than 3,200 Goodwill stores throughout communities
  10. all over the place. Uh, and a lot of people do know the mission. More importantly, they know
  11. that it's a brand that they can trust. Uh, but our real focus is not uh, the thrift industry. Our focus is really
  12. revolves around job creation and job training and working with individuals and families uh, so that they can
  13. achieve their own personal economic success. And I think that's an interesting point, cuz I think for most
  14. people when they're they're aware of Goodwill in the the stores, um, the thrift stores, and they probably have
  15. this tendency to see those as an end in themselves, that you have the store so you can have money. Tell the how tell
  16. the audience how the the stores help you do your mission. Oh, well, the that's it's really
  17. twofold. So, we have this network of Goodwill stores. Each are community-based organizations
  18. uh, that provide a wide range of other community services. Uh, but the the retail store model uh,
  19. serves two functions. One, that entire business infrastructure to the tune of about $4 billion
  20. is an infrastructure that's fully leveraged uh to create job opportunities for people
  21. with disadvantage and conditions. So, it could be transitional employment, it could be first-time opportunities, it
  22. could be job training programs, uh but really working to create an inclusive uh work environment so that uh
  23. individuals with barriers to employment get a shot. And we are just as happy when we have a talented team member
  24. leave us for a new and a bigger and a better opportunity uh as we are to have them on the team in
  25. the first place. Uh and then secondly, uh if uh those Goodwill stores are run successfully, and they are for the most
  26. part, uh all of the earnings before incremental mission activity uh are then plowed back into that community
  27. uh for other programs and services uh to sustain that organization and to meet the specific needs of the community
  28. where that Goodwill is. Yeah. And you, you know, you mentioned that that word sustainability. And I know for many
  29. social enterprises, either for-profit or or nonprofit, they really are trying to
  30. focus on sustainability. How do I How do I make sure that I can keep doing the mission that I want to do?
  31. Mhm. And how do I get the capital and resources to do that? So, your thrift stores provide a really uh successful
  32. example of how that happens. Yeah, we um you know, we're fortunate in many ways that the model has been able to uh
  33. create resources to support and fund some incremental growth. But, still uh capital for anybody in the
  34. not-for-profit space is always a difficult thing to come by. We've got an innovative initiative uh
  35. that we call the Goodwill Job Creation Fund right now that has been launched by Goodwill Industries International in
  36. partnership uh with three founding investors, the Kresge Foundation, the Casey Foundation uh and the Ford
  37. Foundation. And what's really exciting about it is it's it's a loan fund to Goodwills to build out the social
  38. enterprise. But its measure of success certainly uh calls for repayment of the loans,
  39. which happens 100% of the time. Mhm. Uh but more importantly has a very social impact-oriented scorecard uh so
  40. that we can connect the dots uh between uh the economic or capital outlay and the
  41. social impact that's derived from that very specific investment. So let's help uh talk about this a little bit and and
  42. bring it down to example. So if I'm a uh local community uh CEO of my local Goodwill Mhm. I can
  43. go to this fund if I want to sort of make a bigger store. I can go to this fund and get uh money to make an
  44. investment that way. Is that how I use it? So for expansion Mhm. uh you know, and it's got it's a you know,
  45. we uh currently have one kind of product offering uh in the mix, but we're looking to expand that cuz like you said
  46. earlier, uh right now we haven't fully demonstrated the the full sustainability of this process. It's working
  47. economically, but is it going to bring enough value from a capitalization perspective
  48. uh uh to make it sustainable, but we we have uh we're very optimistic about it and it looks as if the model's going to
  49. work really well. Yeah, and I think that this this kind of innovative financing is so um
  50. important for the nonprofit approach because even if you're even if you've got a strong steady donor base, there's
  51. so much fluctuation and change in the nonprofit industry that looking for different revenue streams becomes
  52. increasingly important. So, it's I think it's great to see good you know, brand names like Goodwill figuring out how
  53. they can be innovative around this. Yeah, it's great. so are you loaning money out of there
  54. yet or is it just are. It started with about a 10 10 million-dollar initial round
  55. and almost the entire amount has been uh has been committed at this point. You know, the the most interesting thing
  56. about this whole sector is when you have levels of economic stability, you can actually focus on the
  57. community needs and then put plans in place to meet them. And that's really the key to a social
  58. enterprise model or a sustainability model. Yeah, and I I think that it's impossible to you know, under
  59. overestimate how important that is cuz for many nonprofits, there isn't that kind of stability and they're really you
  60. know, having to scrape by each year. So, anytime you can get some stability and get some vision into the future, you're
  61. able to do things a lot a lot more effectively. Yeah, interesting enough our founder from 1902
  62. uh many of the words uh he said in his time are words that we are all using today whether that's
  63. really the importance of reclaiming the value of both lives and of things uh all the way to this notion of being
  64. dissatisfied with the status quo. So, he's and he was quite an environmentalist uh
  65. then too and we're really connecting the dots between our model and environmental
  66. impact now as well. So, in that not being satisfied with the status quo, how does an organization like yours
  67. established great brand name, you want to protect the brand and make sure that you're, you know, really doing the good
  68. work that you've continued to do it. How do you get innovation going? You've done
  69. it obviously in the financing area, but how do you get new ideas happening? Are you top-down kind of guy? Yeah, well,
  70. you know, you know, there are moments that sometimes it'd be nice to be top-down, but we're not.
  71. Uh so, we actually are designed and structured uh as a networked organization of 165
  72. uh independent community-based organizations uh in the United States and Canada and then 14 other countries.
  73. Uh but what that actually results in is 165 plus innovation labs, test laboratories,
  74. where Goodwills will try new things and if they work, we share. And then it's really about rapid replication. Mhm. Uh
  75. so, it's innovate and replicate. Uh and then, you know, there's never been a replication where you don't have to
  76. customize that innovation to your own community needs uh because we're in the human services business. So, you kind of
  77. got to you got to make it work within your community. Uh but that that's one big one, but the other one is we have to
  78. have a real open mind up for self-disruption right now. Uh Those are words business students love.
  79. Yeah, well, the competitive the competitive landscape, technology, new markets uh all are things that we're uh staying
  80. right on top of. Uh eBay. eBay? Is eBay a disruptor to the Goodwill model? Probably.
  81. But Goodwill embraced that and that we have our we have uh not only a great partnership with eBay, but we also have
  82. a ShopGoodwill uh auction site that has grown rapidly over these last several years. Uh so,
  83. innovating uh embracing those disruptions is really key to everything that we try to do.
  84. And when you're thinking about how you're going to, you know, uh expand these these disruptions in your ability
  85. to respond to them. What role do corporate partnerships play in this? Well, corporate partnerships are really
  86. important. Uh they're important both from a cause marketing perspective and a building the
  87. brand, but they're also important from a uh acquiring uh resource and energy within community.
  88. Uh and so as as corporations are trying to build more substance more substance, so moving beyond the PR
  89. component of corporate social responsibility, uh and really trying to have impact for
  90. the uh investment they make, whether that's economic or talent or uh their own team members volunteerism,
  91. uh they want to know that they're they're having an impact. And so for Goodwill,
  92. we have that like great model that allows our partners to have great employee engagement,
  93. uh have a great cause, and then, you know, at the end of the day, benefit an entire community by strengthening the
  94. workforce that that those corporate partners work in. That sounds great. So, we've covered a little bit around
  95. financial innovation. We've covered a bit around, you know, innovation and and new models and new approaches. We hit a
  96. little bit on on the kind of corporate angle. So, let's turn quickly to things around HR, you know, because I think
  97. that one of the things for for those of us who have worked in the in the nonprofit sector, there's always tension
  98. around wanting to get really great employees and give them a career path, right? Have them find a way to not just
  99. be good in the job that they have, but to be groomed for the other job. How do you think the either Goodwill itself or
  100. the nonprofit sector has to get better at doing that? What are some ways? You know, I think talent
  101. acquisition in the not-for-profit space is, you know, is a top three challenge. Uh
  102. so, acquiring top talent uh is is an area that I think everybody across the sector has to pay attention to.
  103. What we try to do uh is bring in talent at Goodwill Industries International by uh really
  104. affecting a culture within Goodwill. Uh that is a culture that people want to be a part of.
  105. Uh an interesting thing uh that people always ask me is, you know, can you bring people who want to, you
  106. know, give back? And, you know, we really want to hire people who want to engage
  107. and bring their talents, their skills, and their willingness to work hard to make a difference.
  108. So, if it's a mindset of just kind of doing a favor, it's probably not a great teammate.
  109. Mhm. But, if it's a mindset of working hard and bringing your full intellectual and work ethic fortitude forward, then
  110. you'll probably work real well in our culture. Uh and we try to be very uh uh very excited and clear about the kind of
  111. work uh that we do and the kind of culture that we try to create and hold each other accountable for. Sounds good. Are
  112. you able to um work with the local affiliates? Do you promote people up through the local affiliate into the
  113. into the uh international? You know, across the national kind of network organizations, we probably have
  114. uh I've not actually not benchmarked it, but I would say that we have one of the
  115. more comprehensive uh leadership development and management training programs. So, we have
  116. um management training that we use a train-the-trainer model with, so with local affiliates to help
  117. their workforce grow. We have a social enterprise certificate program so that all employees have an opportunity to
  118. build a stackable credential. We have retail 101 train-the-trainer programs. But most most uh uh
  119. excitingly, we have opportunities for people to go into uh senior leaders programs so that they can grow into more
  120. senior positions uh as well as a executive development programs for people to uh strive to to lead a
  121. to lead a a Goodwill. Great. So, we're nearing the end of our our segment. Be a little visionary. What do you see
  122. going on for the the nonprofit sector? Well, I think that, you know, we have a uh a society
  123. where uh many people of wealth want to create their own not-for-profit. And they want to do it to have impact,
  124. but also control. Mhm. And what I see happening across the not-for-profit spectrum
  125. uh sector, as well as with uh business and government is we've got to get better in the world of collaboration.
  126. So, we got to get clear on roles and responsibilities. We've got to get better at measuring. We
  127. got to stand tall on common goals and objectives. And when we get all of that done we'll
  128. be able to drive collaborations in a way that have the impact that we're all striving for. But I think uh I think
  129. it's going to be a balancing act between control and collaboration. Uh and finding that sweet spot is where
  130. we're going to find the impact. That's great. Thank you so much. This is talking to Jim Gibbons, president and
  131. CEO of Goodwill Industries International. Thank you, Jim. Thank you. Hey.

Brief Summary

Jim Gibbons discusses Goodwill's mission, innovative financing, and the importance of collaboration in the nonprofit sector.

Key points

  • Goodwill's Mission. Jim Gibbons explains how Goodwill focuses on job creation and training.
  • Innovative Financing at Goodwill. Sheryl Coulman discusses Goodwill's innovative financing model for sustainability.
  • The Importance of Corporate Partnerships. Jim Gibbons emphasizes the role of corporate partnerships in community impact.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes