Internal Mobility or External Mobility

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Many of us job-hop through our careers. But research by Wharton professors Matthew Bidwell and Ethan Mollick shows that the grass is not necessarily greener on the other side. More: http://knlg.net/1kH7KFo 📂 Management;Human Resources 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so the paper is about the different kinds of moves that people make in their careers and trying to understand the
  2. differences between them so obviously these days most people in their careers sometimes they move jobs inside firms
  3. they get a promotion maybe they move to different function a lot of times obviously people move across firms as
  4. well and so what we look at is do those moves have different kinds of effects it
  5. pretty much the same so you move to a job doesn't really matter if it's in the same company or a different one or is it
  6. that you're really doing quite different things when you move jobs inside firms versus across them um and so that's the
  7. basic goal of the paper we looked at it so we did a survey a few years ago of our alumni here at Warton and ask them
  8. about all of the jobs that they had held and we use that to kind of disentangle which are the jobs that have to
  9. disentangle when did they move jobs inside organizations when did they move across and what happened to them when
  10. they made those moves so we found quite big differences between the moves that took place inside
  11. the firms and the moves that took place across the firms um when people were moving inside firms we saw they got a
  12. pay raise um they also CAU quite big increase in responsibilities so they tended to rise up in terms of their
  13. title and they pretty much doubled the number of people that they were managing when people moved um jobs across firms
  14. they also got a pay raise but it didn't tend to come with an increase in responsibilities instead they were
  15. moving to a job with often a similar title and usually with the same number of subordinates managing the same number
  16. of people and so they weren't necessarily getting a promotion in the same way so we saw you know kind of
  17. talks to different move different reasons for moving so when people are moving inside it's you know they're
  18. moving up the ladder when people are moving to jobs in other terms they're getting a pay raise they get paid to
  19. move but they're not making the same kind of move up the ladder they're moving to a similar rung orbe it in a
  20. different organization I think I was impressed by how Stark the differences were between
  21. um the internal and the external move so I had a sense from prior um prior research that probably you know a
  22. reasonable proportion of um moves between firms are in effect lateral the idea there being
  23. that employers know the people who work for them and so they have a sense that they're doing good work and they're
  24. prepared to promote them if they're doing well obviously we don't know the people in other organizations and so it
  25. may often be that we feel a lot more comfortable bringing somebody who's really shown they can do that job
  26. somewhere else and so there was a sense that we'd see quite a lot of hiring being lateral the extent to which those
  27. moves were kind of overwhelmingly lateral I think surprised me so kind of just the sheer scale of the differences
  28. between internal and external you know I think they have implications on both the part of
  29. obviously people pursuing their careers and certainly employers I mean one of the things we found so like I said when
  30. people move jobs they get a pay raise we also looked at how much people were being paid at the time of the survey and
  31. how that related to the kinds of moves they've made we found that the more times that somebody had moved inside an
  32. organization the more pay they were receiving that kind of makes sense these ly promotions you're getting up to the
  33. next ladder the more promotions you've had yeah we expect the more you should be paid it turned out the number of
  34. times have moved across firms um didn't predict pay at all so it wasn't that they were bad moves but they weren't
  35. good either and I think what's going on there is you know when you move across firms you get a pay rise maybe 20%
  36. something like that but what you do is you delay your time often to the next promotion um and so the tradeoff there
  37. is a little more complicated and so you know it does suggest that internal moves
  38. are quite important in moving ahead in your career so that's not saying don't move externally we don't see a penalty
  39. for moving externally but it does say I think as people think about their careers they want at various stages to
  40. be able to kind of be promoted to move up the ladder inside organizations and so I get a bit nervous when people tell
  41. me about their career plan I'm going to go to this job you know there's not a lot of head room but I'll get great
  42. experience and I'll use that experience to get hired into a higher level job somewhere else that turns out to be
  43. quite a hard transition to make and so I think finding a job where there is room
  44. to grow inside the organization you may not want to stay at that organization forever but at least get a rung or two
  45. up the ladder enabling you to move out to a higher rung elsewhere I think that seems like a smarter career strategy um
  46. on the employer side again they're kind of you know I think it reiterated something I found in my prior work which
  47. was that when you're hiring from outside you have to pay a lot right because you
  48. have to pay whatever somebody was getting doing the same job somewhere else plus maybe 20% in order to get them
  49. to move and so again that makes moving people internally seem a lot cheaper I mean I don't think there's
  50. been a great deal of work really trying to evaluate these kind of internal and external moves um you know I think two
  51. or three things that were nice um about what we were able to do with this survey
  52. um we were able to capture all the times people have moved inside organizations I
  53. think a lot of times when people have tried to look at in this in the past using some of the kind of big survey
  54. data they've had to use fairly weak measures of Moves Like if somebody changed occupation or something like
  55. that were able to just ask them about all of the job moves that they had um second nice thing I think often in these
  56. surveys particular when people are trying to understand the extent of external Mobility you know there's
  57. always a question about we know that being laid off is very bad and so you really have to
  58. untangle voluntary moves from the involuntary we were able to do that reasonably well um in a way that other
  59. research probably had I think the biggest difference or the the one that I found most valuable was really getting a
  60. good measure of what people were doing in each of these jobs so particularly like you knowing these managerial jobs
  61. how many people you manage is a reasonable measure of responsibility so having that in each job and really being
  62. able to look at how that changed as people move jobs I think you know gave us an ability to really Advance on PRI
  63. literature by understanding what's going on during these moves I think one of the areas that
  64. we're looking at in detail is trying to get a sense of um some of the more specific paths that people follow as
  65. they move across organizations and so one of the things that I've been very interested in is where do people start
  66. their careers and where do they move to subsequently and one of the interesting things you see with this population is
  67. there's a fairly small group of organizations that people tend to move into for their first jobs limited number
  68. of investment Banks consulting firms big corporates they hire a lot of these mbas
  69. and then afterwards the mbas go off to a wide variety y of um different organizations and so getting a better
  70. sense on why they're doing that how that um fits in with firm strategies is something I'm very interested in you
  71. know another thing I think that a lot of people as have asked me about this study
  72. is about the differences between men and women somewhat surprisingly we actually
  73. see kind of similar effects in terms of internal and external moves for both men
  74. and women so there's not that doesn't seem to be generating differences in how men and women do in this sample
  75. nonetheless there are big differences and so women end up earning substantially less and I think one of
  76. the other questions were interesting what are some of the industries that are more female friendly and why and what
  77. are some of the places and career PS that particularly seem to penalize women in the sample
  78. [Music]

Brief Summary

Internal job moves lead to promotions, while external moves yield pay raises without increased responsibilities.

Key points

  • Internal vs. External Job Moves. The study reveals significant differences in career advancement between internal and external job moves.
  • Pay Raises and Responsibilities. Employees moving internally often receive pay raises and increased responsibilities, unlike those moving externally.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes