Can Diversity Initiatives Break Barriers in Entertainment? Kenneth Shropshire — Opportunity Matters

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton Coalition for Equity and Opportunity's Faculty Director Kenneth L. Shropshire is joined by industry leaders Nzinga “Zing” Shaw, CEO of Attack the Glass, and sports and entertainment attorney Jaia Thomas to address pay equity and underrepresentation in entertainment.

They discuss their experiences in developing diversity initiatives, including targeted hiring practices, mentorship programs, and curating resume databases. Shah and Thomas offer insights on how to enhance visibility and opportunities for women, people of color, disabled communities, and LGBTQ+ professionals in sports and entertainment. This interview is part of a special 4-part series called “Opportunity Matters.”

#entertainmnet #entertainmentindustry #DEI #inclusion ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU 🏷️ Opportunity Matters

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. welcome to the next episode of Opportunity Matters today we're going to focus on entertainment and the issues in
  2. entertainment deal with both representation and inclusion and as we've been doing in this series what
  3. we're going to try to do is look at both the problems that exist in this industry
  4. as well as some of the solutions or prospective solutions that are out there we've got two great guests who will join
  5. me in the conversation today first is inzinga zing Shaw I'll be calling her throughout the the interview she's the
  6. president and CEO of attack the glass she's an experienced SE Suite executive with extensive hands-on experience and
  7. knowledge spanning diversity equity and inclusion change and crisis management human Capital Management employee
  8. relations Talent acquisition organizational and strategic planning branding and Community engagement
  9. previously Zing was the recording Academy's Chief Dei officer at a pivotal point in the industry and she was the
  10. first Chief inclusion and diversity officer at four blue chip organizations including Edelman Starbucks Marsh
  11. Clinton and the NBA um and I I've met her uh along the way mainly in the sports context and
  12. have enjoyed getting to know her further she's she's moved around and and now doing this great independent work Zing
  13. thanks for joining us thank you so much for having me Ken and also joining us is
  14. J Thomas she's a sports and entertainment attorney those who knew me knew I was going to get an attorney on
  15. here sooner or later with over 15 years of experience she's a founder of diverse
  16. representation a company aimed at increasing in in the hiring and exposure of black attorneys agents managers and
  17. publicists in the sports and entertainment Industries in addition to creating the first ever directory of
  18. black attorneys agents managers and publicist in sports and entainment diverse representation also curates
  19. various diversity programs and initiatives throughout the country ja thank you for joining us thank you so
  20. much for having me I'm happy to be here so so let let's let's start off um just kind of set the stage
  21. um Zing what what why you want you take us through and we were in in kind of this uh award season I guess in terms of
  22. the entertainment industry and this this has been a flas point in some ways to illustrate to
  23. those who aren't aware of the absence of diversity in the entertainment industry
  24. but why don't you give us some thoughts on some of the biggest issues that exist
  25. in entertainment in terms of um diversity Equity inclusion and the opportunities that exist to to address
  26. those it's such a great question Ken and it's really what a lot of people are talking about right now what are the
  27. challenges what are the uh things that are stopping diversity equity and inclusion from moving forward
  28. particularly in the entertainment industry and there are a couple of things at play um first and foremost
  29. there are a lot of conversations around pay Equity whether it's pay Equity regarding gender and women not receiving
  30. the same compensation as their male counterparts we hear about pay Equity across race um hearing that white uh
  31. individuals are earning more money than ethnic minorities uh there are also a lot of discussions around representation
  32. of the lgbtq community and how that shows up on the acting side if you're talking about roles or in the sports
  33. side um prominent athletes that are able to come to the Forefront there are also
  34. issues around uh ableism and people who have disabilities not being able to break through the glass and and have
  35. representation of their demographic set so there are a lot of big Equity issues in entertainment
  36. um I I want to underscore the under representation of minorities it's something that we've been hearing about
  37. a lot um this includes onscreen payals behind the scene roles whether we're talking about actors writers directors
  38. producers key decision makers and the list goes on so um we have a lot of things to Grapple with in this field
  39. right now and we've got to be very open and honest about the things that are not
  40. Equitable in this industry if we're ever going to get to a point where we're able
  41. to move the needle forward before I ask you the the same question this this is a very interesting
  42. T time where some of us are stuttering at using the the phrase Dei and where there's some even absence
  43. of people listening to what the issues actually are if you if you use that phrase so so I really appreciate the the
  44. way that you've broken down the kinds of concerns that that exist and that it's not just race it's not just gender um it
  45. it can be someone who's from a a poor setting that can't find their way into Hollywood to get get the opportunity
  46. that someone that's been raised in Hollywood is is is able to do and and that's that's a lot of what we've been
  47. trying to get people to think about across these industries and the topics that we we're talking about in in this
  48. series is that the big concern the people that do this kind of work is opportunity and making sure I mean is
  49. it's the oldest it's the oldest piece of uh of the Constitution of the United States although there were some problems
  50. in the initial document the the idea of opportunity for all the idea of of equal
  51. opportunity and and access so so G your um your your thoughts on the issues that
  52. are there and if you could you know tell us tell us some about diverse representation
  53. sure so I started diverse representation about four years ago um as a black woman
  54. attorney one of the issues I was seeing in the industry was that a lot of my clients were black and oftentimes I was
  55. the only black person on their team so whether that was an athlete a black athlete or a black entertainer you know
  56. I would be their attorney but their agent would be white their publicist white their financial advisor white
  57. their manager white their entire team would be white and I felt like this was an issue we weren't talking about um I
  58. felt like when we talked about diversity and inclusion in the entertainment industry I felt like the focus was
  59. always on the toal making sure that the faces we saw on screen were diverse but paying very little attention to the
  60. folks who were representing those people on screen because if you really started
  61. to peel back layers those spaces were not diverse at all um and so that's why I started diverse representation when I
  62. started it I didn't really have a plan for it I didn't know what it was going to turn into I really started because I
  63. wanted to get the information out there I heard a lot of black actors and a lot of black athletes say I don't know any
  64. black agents I don't know any black attorneys so I started as just a database of here are all the black
  65. attorneys here are all the black agents here are all the black publist so that that can no longer be an excuse of I
  66. can't find them well now you can and it's free um so now we're GNA have to think of a different excuse and I just
  67. wanted people to be more cognizant about the people they were hiring you know that's the other thing a lot of Black
  68. Talent you know they would get on these platforms and preach about diversity and
  69. preach about you know black this and black that but when you look at their teams there are no black people in sight
  70. so you know I just wanted everybody in these spaces to be more cognizant about the people they are hiring um and the
  71. people that were on their teams so that was the impetus behind starting the company and don't interrupt but but I'm
  72. I'm flashing on one of our first conversations our first interactions I I think I I I told you at the time that
  73. I'd written a book about sports agents in in 1989 or 1990 or so and one of the things that we did in the book was to
  74. talk about the number of black agents this in the sports business and how easy it was to count them I mean how easy how
  75. easy you know it was it wasn't problematic and and if you if you went through for example one of the big big
  76. deals in in sports is uh who's representing the the first 10 top 10 draft picks and so often then the there
  77. were no African-Americans representing any of the draft piics even though the top draft piics were largely
  78. African-American and so so there's been this and we'll talk about this there there has been this um dramatic change
  79. in some ways um and I I was asking you about how to how to keep track it was it was very easy to keep track of back then
  80. but it's it's the good thing I guess to say and part of what we want to raise too is some of the positives there it's
  81. it's not that easy to keep that track of now there there are numbers there but and and Zing you you'll probably have
  82. some reaction to this too the the age- old question from people that are hiring is is I can't
  83. find anybody I can't find anybody historically there was a little bit to that now that doesn't exist so we're at
  84. this point where diverse representation has a directory saying you can go into the
  85. places that you going to and you say well here's here's a list of people but we still can't get people to move to
  86. make make the hire and it and it works it can work in a lot of different ways too I mean it can be women won't hire
  87. women it it can be a black person won't hire a black person that that's a different kind of
  88. issue but the idea the Hollywood studio won't hire these diverse people and they can no longer say we
  89. can't find them what what kinds what kinds of steps are we taking that are are trying to get over that that barrier
  90. the barrier well here they are and you're still not hiring them well first you know we have to have a recognition
  91. that diversity does not equal deficiency I think a lot of times when corporate organizations or individuals are
  92. thinking about representation and who they're going to bring on board they believe that if you say the word
  93. diversity you're almost asking them to water down the the pipeline or the talent pool in terms of the quality that
  94. they're bringing to the table and that is just not a fact it's not true at all um diversity does not equal deficiency
  95. diversity just means that we are widening the aperture so that we can tap into a variety of talent pools and look
  96. at new and unexpected Talent you know I think one of the core issues around Innovation is ensuring that there are so
  97. many different points of view that you can really go outside of yourself and outside of the status quo and identify
  98. something that is new and unexpected and different and that's really what diversity aims to achieve and so I think
  99. Ken to answer your question when it relates to people and or organizations that say okay well you know thank you
  100. for for being able to materialize these diverse candidates however we just can't
  101. find a natural fit um what they're saying is that they're not ready to let go of the status quo they're not ready
  102. to look at a different type of leader or learn from someone who is um not a person that they're usually used to um
  103. working alongside or working under and so we've got to really peel back the layers of this onion and figure out what
  104. is the real core issue you know I've been hearing a lot of rhetoric on social media and traditional media that is very
  105. anti- Dei and you know it's it's it's interesting because you think about what Dei stands for diversity means
  106. difference um Equity is about making sure that we are providing opportunity for everyone to reach their maximum
  107. potential by giving them tools that are applicable to their needs and inclusion is making sure that we are curating
  108. spaces and environments where people feel like they can belong in their authentic way and so when we hear uh
  109. phrases like anti- Dei I like to really challenge the people who are are challenging our our our status and I say
  110. well what are are you anti the D are you anti the E are you anti the eye because
  111. when they really have to sit back and think about what they're against it's not necessarily the the things that Dei
  112. truly stand for and and it's a often a self-determined definition of what Dei means it's I'm I'm I'm actually
  113. anti- acronyms partly for what we just heard from you the idea that if you if you say it that's a lot different from
  114. this thing this Dei thing that that people have uh put a bull's eye upon J what I know one of the ways that diverse
  115. representation has has addressed some of these issues and and one of the paths to
  116. solution is that you have worked with with companies to to to help them to figure out ways to to meet these
  117. candidates to to get get to get to know them better part of the earliest of solutions that that we began to point to
  118. in the academic space thinking about this was the idea of of networking in the idea of getting to know someone and
  119. breaking down barriers in that kind of way what why don't you uh tell us some about some of the uh corporate
  120. relationships and and programming that that you've done sure so yeah we have a lot of corporate Partnerships with
  121. companies like ca WME um lioncap Warner Brothers Discovery and a lot of these companies say the same thing you know we
  122. can't find black candidates and also just as a little Aster for diverse representation I know that's our title
  123. but we're very specifically focused on black people in sports and entertainment we're not as you know maybe
  124. all-encompassing as other organizations but that was that's something we've heard from a lot of our partners we just
  125. can't black candidates um for these spaces so we've tried a couple different things to help Rectify that problem um
  126. we have a couple years ago we started an executive pipeline program because that
  127. was a big complaint we were hearing from a lot of companies you know we're able to find black candidates at the entry
  128. level but when it comes to like Executives SE Suite we just can't find them so we've created um black executive
  129. pipeline programs for various facets of the entertainment industry industry to help equip black candidates to become
  130. Executives um and work in conjunction with these Studios with these networks we've built out resume databases that
  131. housed thousands of black candidates um you know that our partners can access when they're looking to hire um we have
  132. created a Black Entertainment career Summit um where it's a three-day program and Studios production companies
  133. networks come in and talk to candidates about job opportunities how to get your foot in the door and have on-site
  134. interviews so honestly it's been a hodg podge of a lot of different things some things have worked some things haven't
  135. um but we worked with our partners to try try a lot of different things to see what's really going to move the ball
  136. forward what which of of those that you named what what kinds of programs have have seemed to work best or have had
  137. noted success for you um and what kinds of things would you or or are you tweaking is it's it's an ongoing process
  138. I know part of part of what I do a lot of work with the NFL part of part of what we found is you've got to
  139. constantly tweak these programs what whatever it is you think you had right it's not going to be right tomorrow
  140. unless unless you move forward what what what are some of the learnings that that
  141. you you've had along the way and things that you would uh would do to to try to move the needle further sure great
  142. question so I would say probably one of our takeaway ways is I think sometimes the short-term programs actually work
  143. better than the long-term programs so some of our short-term programs where it's only for like a week or even a
  144. weekend sometimes are are stronger than the ones that are six months to a year long some of our
  145. pipeline programs that we created that were three months long six months long those were a little harder to sustain um
  146. just because the interest level waned with participants kind of hard to keep up with people over the course of six
  147. months um people change jobs they move it's just a little more difficult to keep people focused for a longer period
  148. of time as opposed to kind of a short stint so we have found a lot more success with like shorter programs or
  149. events that are only for a couple days or a week as opposed to three months six months or a year um and probably our
  150. most successful program in terms of really getting black folks in the door has probably been our Black
  151. Entertainment career Summit there had never been a program specifically aimed at educating black folks on various
  152. careers in the entertainment industry and so that has been a really great program a ton of people have been hired
  153. as a result of it because we do onsite interviews all the networks production companies who participate do on-site
  154. interviews with people attending um and we've seen a lot of great success come out of that Zing if I can wi in yeah
  155. please do please really quickly because I think uh what ja is talking about is absolutely right and I just wanted to
  156. build on it when I was the global head of diversity at Starbucks we used to do a lot of work that was intersectional in
  157. nature so what I mean is that we would um cross collaborate across demographic sets and really use our employee
  158. resource groups as a a means of getting representation across the board but we would create projects for different ergs
  159. to collaborate on together so I remember one project in particular where there were three demographic sets that came to
  160. the table um it was the the black partner Network which were um employees comprised in the black um and you know
  161. African diaspora communities um the lgbtq community and also the Pan Asian community and those three groups came
  162. together around an innovation challenge that Starbucks was spearheading um as it
  163. relate to new products that they were looking to put on the shelves for customers and what I can tell you is
  164. that when the work was intersectional and people really had to um spend a lot of time with one another in communities
  165. that they were not used to collaborating in there were a lot of insights and aha
  166. moments that came out of that and and so we realize that a lot of the way that Dei is perceived um unfortunately is is
  167. perceived in U let's call it a a stereotypical fashion surrounding segreg ation because when you think about ergs
  168. the nature of ergs can feel very much like segregation you know the the blacks are going to have their group and the
  169. lgbtq will have their group and the disabled will have their group and so if we're not figuring out ways to leverage
  170. each of these demographic sets and and help them come together in ways that they can be supportive of one another
  171. while also standing proud in the skin that they were born in then we're really missing the Mar so I think a lot of
  172. times what organizations are are doing is keeping the status quo surrounding the the mindset of Dei being
  173. segregationist versus a collaborative community so have you found and the employee research group
  174. ERG topics is is certainly one that sounds like it's it crosses over but have you found anything that's really
  175. distinct about entertainment versus the other Industries you've been in yeah absolutely I mean listen I think that
  176. the entertainment industry is very unique for a variety of of reasons it's Unique because it's the one industry
  177. that we look at to glean some sense of joy and hope for a variety of communities I mean if you think about
  178. the pure nature of what entertainment sets out to do it it sets out to um keep people engage during times that are
  179. troubling it it sets out to make people laugh even when the world can um certainly throw things at us that are
  180. hard to digest um it it is it makes you know when you think about athletes and what they represent it makes us hopeful
  181. that you can you know work hard put your best foot forward collaborate with teammates and and um reach the sky sky
  182. is the limit so I think the entertainment industry is very different than a lot of Industries anytime I go to
  183. a sporting event I look across the arena and I'm always floored at how many different types of people are convening
  184. in one space excited to cheer for one entity one the home team um and so you look around and and there are black
  185. people and white people and Asian and Latino and then you have disabled and lgbtq and old and young and it really is
  186. just a beautiful array of of what Humanity looks like when you think about who is coming together to be entertained
  187. so when you think uh about your industry uh and in entertainment Collective and and who it can bring together it's
  188. very important for the industry to recognize that representation matters and having an array of people that um we
  189. can look at as an on the- field product or onscreen product is just as important
  190. as who you're attracting to your Venue you know we've got a couple minutes left and z i want to make sure I
  191. I ask you this question because I know you think about these things on on the big level from um the sea Suite kind of
  192. kind of space you know we are in this moment and and not everyone understands that this is part
  193. of the Dei space too but but what is it that that companies what kinds of conversations are taking place about uh
  194. islamophobia and anti-Semitism in the the top levels of these companies and and I guess more
  195. specifically what kinds of conversations should be taking place and what kinds of
  196. action should should they take I'm so glad you brought this topic up because it certainly is front um of mind for all
  197. of us uh that are witnessing what's happening in the world and I would just say that companies um have been
  198. addressing anti-Semitism and islamophobia particularly in the entertainment industry um by a
  199. combination of things which all involve awareness education representation also policy changes so there is progress that
  200. is being made I think there's a lot of work that can still be done but some of the things that I've seen in
  201. entertainment are um with industry stakeholders including Studios and production companies they're
  202. implementing dni initiatives to promote representation of diverse communities including Jewish and Muslim individuals
  203. and these uh some of these these efforts include targeted hiring practices mentorship programs the inclusion of
  204. diverse voices in decision-making processes so that's huge also educational programs there are a lot of
  205. efforts to educate industry professionals on the nuances and impacts of anti semitism and islamophobia and
  206. they have been implemented so training programs and workshops are addressing stereotypes cultural sensitivity the
  207. importance of accurate representation and storytelling and then last I'll just say that there have been a lot of
  208. responses to controversies that we've seen play out on social media and in traditional media and so there are
  209. instances of anti-Semitism or islamophobia in the entertainment industry um often met with a public
  210. outcry so in response industry professionals Studios networks are issuing public statements condemning
  211. this Behavior they're taking corrective action they're re-evaluating content and
  212. severing ties with individuals involved so I think this is these are topics that
  213. are going to be front um and Center for a long time well Zing J we we have run out of time as I told you told you what
  214. happened um you know the important thing I want want to close with J made a great
  215. point about every organization can't do everything and if it's it's it's the little things that can make the change
  216. come about if we have Enterprises like diverse representation working on on blacks getting access we have other
  217. organizations working on on other folks and if we have those who can take on the
  218. mega mega space that's important too so thank you to you both uh look forward to
  219. everybody joining us on our next episode of Opportunity [Music] Matters I'm farita Griffith managing
  220. director for the Wharton Coalition for equity and opportunity in partnership with Wharton Works led by Professor
  221. Damon Phillips business round table and second chance business Coalition we're bringing together Business Leaders
  222. academics State leaders and Justice impacted communities for discussions on creating Pathways to sustainable
  223. employment for individuals who are formally incarcerated to learn more and register go to
  224. ceo. won. up.edu

Brief Summary

Inzinga Shaw and J Thomas discuss diversity, equity, and inclusion challenges in entertainment, emphasizing representation and hiring practices for Black professionals.

Key points

  • Diversity in Entertainment. Exploring the pressing issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion in the entertainment industry.
  • Diverse Representation's Impact. Highlighting the importance of diverse representation in sports and entertainment.
  • Successful Programs for Inclusion. Discussing effective short-term programs for increasing diversity in the entertainment industry.
  • The Unique Role of Entertainment. Entertainment brings joy and hope, uniting diverse communities in challenging times.
  • Addressing Islamophobia and Anti-Semitism. Companies are taking action against discrimination through awareness and policy changes.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes