Adam Grant on 'Give and Take: The Surprising Truth about Who Gets Ahead'

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

KNOWLEDGE AT WHARTON ARCHIVES: A colleague asks you for feedback on a report. A LinkedIn connection requests an introduction to one of your key contacts. A recent graduate would like an informational interview. New research from Wharton management professor Adam Grant reveals that how you respond to these requests may be a decisive indicator of where you'll end up on the ladder of professional success. Grant recently spoke with Knowledge at Wharton for an interview about his findings, which are explored in his new book, Give and Take: A Revolutionary Approach to Success.

More on this interview: https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/podcast/knowledge-at-wharton-podcast/givers-vs-takers-the-surprising-truth-about-who-gets-ahead/

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Adam thank you so much for joining us today thank you for having me so would
  2. love to talk to you about your uh book give and take uh now you write in your book that uh people differ in their
  3. preferences for reciprocity and you divide them into givers takers and matchers uh could you
  4. perhaps Begin by explaining the difference sure so I I was really struck going into this process by the fact that
  5. people have different motives when they walk into workplace interactions and I think you could sort of anchor this at
  6. you know at two extremes the takers and the givers so the takers are people who when they walk into an interaction with
  7. another person they're trying to get as much as possible from that person and contribute
  8. as little as they can in return thinking that's sort of the shortest and most direct path to achieving their own goals
  9. on the other end of the spectrum we have this strange breed of people that I call
  10. givers um not about donating money or volunteering necessarily but looking to help others Maybe by making an
  11. introduction or giving advice or providing mentoring or sharing knowledge without many strings attached and these
  12. givers actually prefer to be on the the contributing end of an interaction now I
  13. think very few of us are purely takers or purely givers most of us hover somewhere in between and that brings us
  14. really to the third group of people who are matchers um a matcher is basically somebody who tries to maintain an even
  15. balance of give and take so if I help you I expect you to help me in return um you know I'll sort of keep score of
  16. exchanges so that everything is fair and really just right now uh so so it seems
  17. logical enough based on what you said that research shows that in fields like engineering and medicine that give us
  18. end up at the bottom of the Heap because obviously if you have a if you are focused on giving more to others than
  19. taking back uh then then it's quite likely that you'll end up at the bottom of the Heap but who ends up at the top
  20. of the Heap and why yeah that that was one of the most fascinating questions that I got into when I started doing the
  21. research for the book is you know you look across a wide range of of Industries and even countries and you
  22. find these three Styles exist everywhere and indeed the the givers are over represented at the bottom um putting
  23. other people first they often put themselves at risk for burning out or being exploited by takers and so a lot
  24. of people look at that and they'll say well it's hard for a taker to rise consistently to the top because you know
  25. often times takers burn Bridges and so it must be the matchers you know who are who are more generous than takers but
  26. also protect their own interests and when I looked at the data I was really surprised to see that both of those
  27. answers were wrong it's actually the givers again givers are over represented at the top as well as the bottom of most
  28. success metrics um I found that in sales that the most productive sales people are actually those who put their
  29. customers interest first and you know I think a lot of that comes from the trust
  30. and the good will that they build but also the reputations that they create and I guess one of the the ways that I
  31. would play this out is to say the the success of givers and the the follow of takers is is often driven by matchers so
  32. a match is somebody who who really believes in a just world and of course a taker violates that belief in a just
  33. world matchers cannot see stand to see Takers get ahead you know by by taking advantage of other people and so the
  34. data on this suggests that that matchers will often go around trying to punish them um Often by gossiping and and
  35. spreading negative reputational information and just as as matchers hate seeing takers get away with exploitation
  36. they also hate to see people act really generously and not get rewarded for it and so matchers will often go out of
  37. their way to promote and help and support givers to make sure they actually do get rewarded for their
  38. generosity and I I think that's one of the most powerful Dynamics behind the rise of
  39. givers that's great and one of the things I found Most Fascinating about your book is the combination of of very
  40. rigorous research uh with some really compelling stories of both givers and takers uh and and so uh among the
  41. various stories you tell there is one about a person called Peter odet uh could you tell us that story and did
  42. being a giver help him or HT Hur him and what are some of the lessons to be learned yeah absolutely so I would I
  43. would say yes to all of the above um so so Peter adet is is one of my my favorite people that I met when I was
  44. doing research for the book He's a financial adviser and he's the kind of guy who goes out of his way to help
  45. everyone that he meets so for years he would interview job candidates and he would only be able to hire one and have
  46. to turn everybody else down and he would often give up his entire afternoon just
  47. trying to find jobs for the other people that he couldn't hire himself and you know really opening up his personal
  48. Network to do that um a lot of times this this orientation toward helping others sort of got him in trouble um in
  49. one particular case he had a a colleague um who ended up calling Brad in the book
  50. who essentially was was getting out of the business and he needed somebody to to buy his CL clients quickly and Peter
  51. said sure I'll do it and you know he basically paid about $10,000 for Brad's clients on the spot just to help him out
  52. and then a couple months later Peter started losing his clients and they disappeared and he discovered that all
  53. of those clients that he was losing were former clients of Brad's that he had bought and he did a little bit of
  54. homework and found out that Brad was back in the business and he was basically taking his clients back and
  55. not paying Peter a dime for them and it cost Peter a ton of money and he really got I think burned by a taker in that
  56. situation and yet Peter will tell you if you talk to him he's been enormously successful in his career um he runs a a
  57. financial advisor firm that's uh well well over 7 figures in terms of annual revenue and he will tell you that being
  58. a giver is how he has gotten ahead it's how he wins business it's why people go to him and I think what happens is often
  59. times givers put themselves at risk in the short run but in the long run they end up building the kind of Social
  60. Capital that's really important for success in a very connected world and you know you can see this play out in
  61. many many different situations in his career uh one of my favorites was when he actually drove out to visit a client
  62. in the scrap metal business who was the tiniest of clients worth very very little money and Peter's colleagues
  63. actually said don't bother it's a waste of your time um the drive out there alone is not worth your your hourly fee
  64. and Peter said you know you can't just ignore somebody because they're not worth your time I I really want to help
  65. in any way I can and you know the client turns out not to be a a scrap metal worker but the owner of a lucrative
  66. scrap metal business and he multiplies his fees by a factor of a 100 once he sees what a generous Guy Peter is and I
  67. think that that's one of the things that that we learned from Peter is that givers do in the short run sometimes
  68. lose and Peter has gotten better at protecting himself and and screening to say you know is this person a taker a
  69. giver or a matcher before he determines how much he'll help them um but at the end of the day he also ends up helping
  70. people who he would never expect to be able to help him back and yet sometimes they do that's very interesting that
  71. just an act of kindness in going out to see somebody who needed his help uh multiplied his business manif that's a
  72. very very really very inspiring story um how do successful givers approach networking uh and how does that their
  73. approach differ from say takers or matchers so takers tend to actually have incredibly broad networks in part
  74. because when they burn one Bridge they have to go and find new people to exploit in order to get sort of keep the
  75. the network going um what you find is matchers tend to have much narrower networks because they will typically
  76. only exchange with people who have helped them in the past or they who they expect to be able to help them in the
  77. future and so they end up restricting their their Universe of opportunities um givers tend to build much broader
  78. networks than matchers but in a very different way than takers um what givers will typically do when when they meet
  79. somebody new is try to figure out how can I add value to this person's life and what could I possibly contribute
  80. that might benefit this person um and what that typically means is they end up creating a lot of Goodwill in the
  81. relationships that they build that that often lies dormant until they may actually need
  82. it how do you spot a faker or a taker and givers clothing H that that was one of my favorite bodies of research that I
  83. looked into when writing the book so I think there are a couple powerful ways to to spot a taker um one let's start
  84. with the corner office there's a phenomenal study by chatter G and hamri that looked at over a 100 computer
  85. companies and actually downloaded the annual reports of each company and tried to figure figure out could you identify
  86. the taker CEOs without ever meeting them so they got Wall Street analysts to rate
  87. how much is each CEO a taker and these analysts who knew the CEOs and interacted with them you know rated the
  88. extent to which they were entitled and narcissistic and self-serving and the first factor that
  89. really correlated highly with those ratings was the Gap in compensation between the the CEO and the next highest
  90. paid executive so typical computer industry CEO makes about two to two and a half times as much annual compens
  91. ation as the next highest paid executive in that company the typical taker CEO had about seven times more annual
  92. compensation than the next highest paid executive in that company so literally taking more in terms of compensation the
  93. second cue was looking at their speech so the takers tended to use first- person singular pronouns like I and me
  94. as opposed to us and we when talking about the company and then the third my favorite was the takers literally felt
  95. it's all about me I am the most important and central figure in this company and when you looked at their photos in
  96. the company's annual reports they actually had larger photos and they were more likely to be pictured alone and I
  97. think that was a third signal so those signals don't just show up in the corner office right there's new research by
  98. Keith Campbell and his colleagues suggesting even you can spot these cues on Facebook and one of the easiest ways
  99. that you can look for a taker is to look for a pattern that translates from Dutch
  100. as basically kissing up kicking down so takers tend to be very careful at impression management and great ration
  101. when they're dealing with someone Superior or more influential but it's hard to keep up the facade in every
  102. interaction and so it's often peers and subordinates who have a more direct window into what are this person's true
  103. motives really like you know what you just said reminds me of a of a story I read many years ago uh when Mahatma
  104. Gandhi you know when he when he edited a magazine he would receive all kinds of letters and one letter was from a young
  105. young woman who was about to get engaged uh and uh she was going to meet her you know
  106. prospective uh fiance for the first time and she wanted to know how she could judge this person and the advice that
  107. Mahatma Gandhi gave her in The Columns of the the magazine that he edited was don't look at how he treats you look at
  108. how he treats his servants uh and and and I think that's very very telling in terms of because
  109. with with somebody whom he was trying to impress obviously he would uh you know he would be very well behaved but a true
  110. sign of character is how you treat people who are vulnerable I I think that's a really profound observation and
  111. you know I think there's a famous quote attributed to Samuel Johnson that the the true measure of a person is how he
  112. treats someone who can do him or her no good exactly exactly now I you also point out that givers and takers are
  113. very differ quite a bit in the way they approach collaboration uh and and sharing credit
  114. uh can you give any examples of how how this works out yeah so I think this is one of the most interesting Dynamics you
  115. could you could really look at so in in doing the research for the book I used some historical examples here that I
  116. found fascinating uh one was Frank Lloyd Wright who at one point discovered as an
  117. architect that his uh his draftsmen were essentially getting more commissions and
  118. more work than he was because essentially customers and clients found easier to work with and every bit as
  119. talented and he was offended by this and and felt that you know they should be subservient to him so he actually set a
  120. policy that they were not allowed to accept independent commissions and if while working in his Studio they did any
  121. work even if he never touched it his name had to be signed first and you know I think that obviously that cost him a
  122. lot of very very talented drafts people and if you look at his legacy he really mentored and championed far fewer great
  123. AR Architects than than most who achieve similar stature did another example that
  124. I think really stands out from history is is Jonas sulk who's really remembered as as a hero uh for discovering and and
  125. sort of commercializing a polio vaccine but if you look at suk's Behavior really
  126. closely one of the things you'll see is he never gave credit to any of the the people in his lab who helped him
  127. discover the vaccine and actually caused the the team to fracture and Splinter um
  128. so sulk never made a discovery that was nearly as as influential again and I think this is one of the costs of
  129. appearing like a taker in a collaboration right is slighting other people who might deserve credit what
  130. givers tend to do in collaboration is assume that credit is not zero some and if I give you credit for your
  131. contributions that doesn't necessarily take away from my contribution and that makes it a lot easier to keep people on
  132. board in a team over time it means typically that if you're a leader or manager people will follow you if you
  133. rotate to a different organization or a different job and I think that that's that's really powerful but often harder
  134. to do great no you also have a very interesting reason you give why s didn't give credit to his team uh and and and
  135. there was a certain bias at work could could you explain that that's very fascinating yeah so this this comes out
  136. of Social and cognitive psychology so the the immediate thinking is well you know if if sulk were a taker he would be
  137. motivated to put best foot forward and so he would trumpet his accomplishments and really dismiss those of of people
  138. around him and yet Ross and colleagues have shown consistently that these kinds of biases are less about our desires to
  139. paint ourselves in the most flattering light and actually more about information that there's a discrepancy
  140. between what we know about our own contributions and those of others so in suk's case he remembered the Blood The
  141. Sweat The Tears that he put in Moment by moment when he was working toward creating that that polio vaccine that
  142. saved thousands and possibly millions of lives he literally couldn't remember the
  143. contributions of his colleagues because he wasn't there a lot of the time right he he didn't actually experience them
  144. and this is really the discrepancy that exists um Eugene Caruso and his colleagues have done some really
  145. powerful research showing that when people are just asked to list the contributions of their team members and
  146. their own they're literally more able to remember their own contributions and I think that's one of the big factors that
  147. drives credit biases in collaboration uh one of the biggest challenges for any manager or even a
  148. teacher is identifying the so-called Diamonds in the Rough you know people who have the potential uh to to to
  149. become to do great things as they go forward uh how can you tell us a little bit about how a legendary teacher uh uh
  150. does this in in your book absolutely so there's an accounting professor at the University of North Carolina and Duke by
  151. the name of CJ skender um the man is taught over 35,000 students in his career he's won every teaching award on
  152. the planet and he has a remarkable gift for bringing out the best in his students he's had many many students win
  153. gold medals both in his State and nationally for their accounting achievements he's had more than three
  154. dozen students follow him to become professors of accounting and when you look at his approach the question is how
  155. does he do it a lot of people assume that he's got a great eye for talent and that he's immediately able to spot the
  156. quantitative Vance and then basically work with them and CJ says no it's the exact opposite he sees every student who
  157. walks into his classroom as a diamond in the rough waiting to be polished and then what he does is he tries to make
  158. his classes as interesting as possible to bring out the best in those students now of course it doesn't work with every
  159. student but what he finds over time is by making his material interesting that he does shift some people toward
  160. becoming more motivated and more hardworking and this is true I think of of coaches and leaders and managers
  161. everywhere if you look at at research by Benjamin Bloom and his colleagues of what made somebody a worldclass tennis
  162. player or a world-class musician or even a mathematician or a scientist of of great acclaim very rarely were those
  163. worldclass candidates Superior early on in their careers um they looked pretty average when you started with them but
  164. what they had in common was a coach a teacher or a manager who believed in them and set their aspirations very high
  165. and then that often created a self fulfilling prophecy by inspiring them to to engage in more deliberate practice
  166. and to put in the 10,000 hours that we all know are critical to achieving expertise you know one other really
  167. fascinating part of your book deals with what you call powerless communication what does that what does exactly what
  168. does that mean and how is it useful in persuading and influencing others so I'll give you my own personal example of
  169. this um when I was 25 and I had first started teaching I was asked to to teach a leadership and motivation course uh
  170. for uh for senior leaders in the US Air Force and I was about half their age and
  171. I had just finished my doctorate and I had relatively little experience and I felt like what I had to
  172. do was speak in you know the most confident possible tone to really establish my credibility and so I came
  173. in and I I walked through all my credentials and describe sort of what my training was and then we we went through
  174. the session and and afterward I got the the course feedback and you know it was pretty depressing to say the least uh
  175. one of the comments that that really got burned into my brain was that there was
  176. more knowledge uh in the audience than on the podium and there were other people who made comments like you know
  177. gosh the professors get younger every year and you know how could this guy really teach us to lead he's never been
  178. a leader and you know I sat back and thought about that and realized that perhaps the The Confident dominant
  179. powerful approach was not the best path to influence and I decided to open up with a slightly different approach which
  180. is I walked into the next class that I had to teach for that same audience in the Air Force and I said okay my name's
  181. Adam Grant I know what all of you are thinking right now what can I possibly learn from a professor who's 12 years
  182. old and then I just waited and you know after a few seconds everybody started laughing and and one of the Air Force
  183. Colonels said no no no no that's way off I'm sure you're at least 13 and you know that became sort of a
  184. running joke throughout the session and I I think what I I guess what I what I learned from that experience was that
  185. sometimes humility and vulnerability in communication um what you might think of
  186. as powerless communication is actually a stronger way to connect with your audience and there's a lot of research
  187. on this there's a classic study by Elliot arenson on the pratfall effect where um quizbowl uh competitors are
  188. recorded and you get to listen to them and you hear an expert and when the expert spills coffee all over himself
  189. you actually like him more it humanizes him it gives you an authentic connection
  190. with him and I think that's a lot of the power of powerless communication uh what
  191. can givers do to avoid burnout and also to avoid becoming dmats it seems those are two pretty big risks for people who
  192. see themselves as givers yeah I think that's right I think in a way being a matcher is a safer strategy I think that
  193. you know knowing the givers end up at the bottom and the top means there are some risks associated with it but I
  194. think that those risks actually can be mitigated with with careful strategies so I think a lot of it comes down to
  195. setting boundaries so many givers can confused being helpful or being generous with being available for every person
  196. and every Quest request all the time um there other givers who confuse perhaps you know being generous with empathizing
  197. and dropping everything that you're doing to help others um and I think there are also plenty of givers out
  198. there this is something I found over and over in my research who feel like it's uncomfortable able or inappropriate to
  199. advocate for their own interests and I think that we need to we need to work with with people who sort of fall in the
  200. giving end of the spectrum to help them set clear boundaries and determine okay how am I going to help most of the
  201. people most of the time uh one of my favorite Concepts that I I came across when doing the background research for
  202. the book is is What's called the five minute favor uh which is basically instead of just helping everyone all the
  203. time thinking about okay can I offer something of unique value to this other person that will take me 5 minutes or
  204. less and you know I think it's it's basically about finding High benefit to others but
  205. low cost to the self ways of contributing you know normally people believe that the alternative to being
  206. selfish which is what uh you know the trait that takers usually have is being selfless but you've come up with a
  207. another term called uish could you explain the difference yeah so when I first started studying give and take I
  208. thought that that basically self-interest versus sort of selflessness were on one spectrum and
  209. you had takers over here who are very you know very selfish you had givers who are very selfless and it actually turns
  210. out if you look at the data on this that you can more effectively draw a 2 by two
  211. and say concern for your own interests and concern for other people's interests are actually independent motivations so
  212. you could score low and high on one or on both so the takers tend to be purely selfish um there's one group of givers
  213. who's purely selfless who constantly put other people's interests ahead of their
  214. own but there's this other group of givers that I call other who are concerned about benefiting others but
  215. they also keep their own interest in the rearview mirror and so they will look for ways to help others that are either
  216. low cost to themselves or even high benefit to themselves I.E win-win as opposed to win lose here's the irony the
  217. selfless givers might be more altruistic in principle right because they're they're constantly elevating other
  218. people's interests ahead of their own but my data and and research by lots of others show that they're actually less
  219. generous because they run out of energy they run out of time and they lose their
  220. resources because they don't basically take enough care of themselves the others givers are able to sustain their
  221. giving by looking for ways that giving can hurt them less or benefit them more so the the vulnerabilities that you
  222. identified earlier of burnout and being a dmat are actually uh something that affects selfless givers more than others
  223. that's right yeah selfless givers are at much greater risk of burnout and exploitation are the other is givers
  224. right well uh one final question Adam uh what practical advice apart from reading
  225. your book uh could you offer people who want to start applying the these principles to their own lives so I think
  226. there there's lots of advice sort of peppered throughout the book in different chapters but when I take a
  227. step back I think the first question is what is your own style um if you go to the the give and take website give
  228. take.com there's a self assessment that you can take there there's also a 360 assessment both available for free where
  229. you can get other people to rate you and I think that's really the first step is
  230. to hold up a mirror and figure out okay what is my default um I may act more like a taker when I'm negotiating a big
  231. contract I may act more like a giver when I'm in a mentoring role and I'm probably a matcher when a colleague from
  232. another organization approaches me for some specialized knowledge but how do I treat most of the people most of the
  233. time I think as the first step and then I think you know the second step is there are some surprising opportunities
  234. both for success and for meaning in operating like a giver and so I would ask okay what are the types of giving
  235. that you find most energizing or most consistent with your skills um for some people it's making introductions for
  236. others it's sharing credit for others it's stepping up as a mentor and I think finding your own sort of Giver style is
  237. really powerful and you know I think the the real meaning and purpose associated
  238. with that is that you know even if givers don't always do better than takers or matchers they manage to
  239. succeed in ways that make others better and lift others up instead of cutting them down and I think looking for ways
  240. to do that is probably the the most sustainable path to success in the long term both for individuals and
  241. organizations Adam thank you so much for speaking with knowledge at Wharton my pleasure thanks for having me
  242. [Music]

Brief Summary

Adam Grant discusses givers, takers, and matchers in workplace dynamics, highlighting their impact on success and networking strategies.

Key points

  • The Dynamics of Givers and Takers. Givers often end up at both the bottom and top of success metrics, driven by their altruism and the support of matchers.
  • Peter Adet's Generosity Pays Off. Peter Adet, a financial adviser, exemplifies how being a giver can lead to long-term success despite short-term risks.
  • The Power of Vulnerability. Humility in communication can strengthen connections with your audience.
  • Risks of Selfless Giving. Selfless givers face higher risks of burnout and exploitation compared to others.
  • Understanding Giver Styles. Identifying your own giving style can lead to greater success and meaning.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes