Leadership: Mark Shapiro, Cleveland Indians
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
๐ Leadership
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] We would love to hear for starters you to talk a little bit about the success
- you're most proud of as a leader. I would say, you know, taking a roster when I inherited the team in 2002 and
- and turning the entire roster over and getting back to the playoffs in 2005, not the logistical accomplishment of
- turning over 25 players, but of having to lead a bunch of a group of an organization, uh, having to communicate
- that externally to a public uh, with a lot of skepticism and doubt out there. uh but finding an internal group of
- people who bought into a vision, who aligned behind it, uh who were bound together by a strong set of beliefs and
- values um of what we could accomplish and not being overcome by some of the objective challenges along the way. And
- so seeing that manifest itself into a central division championship, knocking the Yankees out of the playoffs, I'm not
- sure anything could feel t you have a tang a better tangible more tangible feeling of that that satisfaction, that
- fulfillment. Mark, let me ask about the many decisions you've made over the years,
- hundreds of decisions on players and all kinds of other related issues. Looking back on your 20 plus years now at the
- Indians, what's been one of your tougher decisions? And looking back on that, what would you have done differently
- with the benefit of hindsight on that? So I have my leadership moment, you know, to reference you that I thought
- back and I had read your book and um I I inherited the team at a at a juncture that I knew was difficult uh because I
- knew the roster was aging. I knew we had some market correction, but the the magnitude of difficulty was far greater
- than any of us internally knew strategically. Um and I was staring in a decision in the face to trade our best
- player, a guy named Bartolo Cologne, a well-known pitcher, um for three minor leaguers. So externally, three people
- that would be completely unknown. Um, as a leader, I knew I'd be disappointing pretty much every contingency out there.
- You know, our fans, our market, uh, people in the office that work that weren't tied to the baseball decision-m,
- the field staff, you know, that led our team on the field and our players. Every
- constituency I had would be disappointed and they wouldn't understand the decision. Yet, it was clearly
- intellectually and strategically the right decision. Um, and it was in my mind, and this is what I communicated to
- ownership who ultimately approved the decision. It was the only opportunity we had to chart a course, a true plan or
- strategy back to contention from where we were. Um, so we basically the decision was let it naturally play out
- and make it understood by everyone what we had to do or preempt that decline with a very difficult to understand
- tough decision. And I'm curious actually just to follow up on that. So I think one of the unique things about that
- approach is being willing to make a short-term sacrifice for a long-term gain. We would love to hear a little bit
- more about your unique approach to leadership. Is there a situation that stands out similar to that where you led
- in a way that perhaps might differentiate you from other leaders? Um, I'm not sure the one situation
- stands out and I I never give much thought to trying to differentiate myself. I think what I would try to do
- is uh and the old and the older I get and the more examples I have, the more I grasp towards that idea that the only
- way to sustain leadership is is to to be authentic. And the only way to be authentic is to have your leadership
- align with your values. Otherwise, you keep trying to determine how I should act in certain situations and there's no
- way to replicate that from situation to situation. So, I think if anything, um, what may differentiate me or may make me
- similar to other effective leaders that can sustain it is that there's got to be
- some code. There's got to be some you've you've got to gone through the effort and it's not always an easy effort.
- sometimes a painful effort to be aware of the things that are important to you and you've got to articulate those
- things to the people around you. And ultimately what people buy into when they follow you uh when they join you is
- they they buy into those values. They buy into that that sense of vision of where that that articulation of your
- vision of where you're going. They don't in baseball they don't buy into the uniform. They're not buying into the
- hat, you know, they're buying into the people behind that. Mark, going back to your college days,
- my guess is you had not openly or explicitly planned to become the president of a major league baseball
- team, but but here you are. And thinking about the time since your college days to now, was there a turning point, an
- experience, was there a mentor that really had a impact or all three of those that had a major impact on who you
- are now? Yeah, I two mentors that had an impact. um no one defining moment but I think I
- can I can maybe a defining uh path. So the mentors were clearly my father um from a standpoint of those values. You
- know just watching the way he interacted with people never qualifying people. You
- know my dad in a small town of Baltimore, Maryland would walk down the street and in almost mayoral sense knew
- everyone. uh the way he talked to the you know the guy who parked the car was the identical way he did talk to the
- mayor and there was never a qualification and every human being was equally as important to him um that
- sense of you know importance compassion you know was always a core part of who I
- am um that sense of that values are intertwined and I think this is kind of going back to the authenticity you can't
- be one person as a father friend husband and a different person as a leader you don't walk through the building and
- become president of a company. You know, it's not a cape you put on. You walk through the building and you're the same
- guy you were and how you treated your wife, your kids, your brother. Imperfect certainly, but you have to be the same
- person. So, my dad, I think, did that for me. John Hart, um, you know, was the general manager when I came on as an
- entry level no titled cubicle dweller. Um, he saw something in me along with Dan Odow, who was the assistant GM at
- that time, that empowered me. um that when I look back and think what they were how much they empowered me as a
- 24year-old kid uh with relatively little experience um I'm amazed it didn't you know it was not amazing to me then um
- but it wasn't just giving me opportunity to lead it wasn't just giving me an area
- to be accountable and responsible for it was them telling me you know hey you're
- you're good you know you're a guy you know believe in what you're you what you're saying your ideas are good ideas
- now go execute them. So, how about a turning point experience, a a moment, a decision, a inflection point?
- I don't I don't know if I have one experience that that uh I can think of. I mean, I I
- think what led to me ultimately maybe having more opportunities in addition to gaining them their belief was being
- immersed in competitive environments like, you know, like this one, like Wharton, like Princeton, like the high
- school I went to, being around people that uh subconsciously had high standards uh for themselves that pulled
- me up to their level. So, I'm not sure that I was destined to do anything. I'm not sure that I know I'm not the
- smartest guy in the room now and never have been, but I know I'm a competitive guy. I know that for sure. And I know if
- you drop me into a room of a lot of really smart people that I'm going to try to figure out a way to rise to their
- level and at least hang with them. And if you do that enough, what you find is you keep asking that of yourself, you
- demand that level of excellence from yourself. And so I think not being one situation or one moment, it's it was the
- convergence of that opportunity and those people that believed in me with that approach that you know I demand a
- lot of myself. So that you know my thought coming in at 23 years old, 24 years old was you know this was a very
- simple way to approach it. Every single thing they give me to do I'm going to do
- better and faster than they expect. That was I mean that's as simple as it was. It's all I ever said. You know I'm going
- to do it better and faster. started there and what happens is the opportunity is just kind of built off
- that. Great. So I'm I'm curious then if you think about those two decades that you spent with the Indians, how has your
- view of effective leadership changed over time? That's a great question. Um I I think
- the maturity side of things like I said not to be redundant as more shifted more
- towards the authenticity side that I may have as I came in been more drawn to and
- thought more about the inspirational leader. So thought about the great speech, thought about the singular
- moment um and I and I the great idea um and not the discipline, not the consistency, not the you know uh
- continual effort, not the clarity of values, the things that lead to sustaining it. So I think as as I have
- matured uh the areas that interest me are that and then probably uh how do you lead because this is very situational
- specific for me. How do you lead when you the objective intellectual side of you understand so clearly the magnitude
- of your challenges are so great but you still have to take you still have to lead people to overcome those
- challenges. So I've got to kind of split you know understanding how the cards are
- stacked against us in our current situation. Um and you've got to design your strategy based around that. So you
- better have a strong intellectual and objective understanding of that. But at the same time, you do still have to lead
- an a very diverse group of people to overcome those challenges. And so you have to be positive. You have to be
- strong. And how do you do that? That that's probably the one that at this moment in time um as in my progression,
- that's the one that I wrestle with the most now and and you know try to try to come up with strategies to personally
- deal with. Mark, when people come into positions of responsibility like your own, you almost always arrive with a
- number of preconceptions of what it's going to take to lead well. What turns out to be a preconception that didn't
- pan out, didn't turn out to be true. Probably that you need to be strong, that you need to uh and by strong I mean
- almost intimidating. um that you need that that fear is even plays any role in leadership that uh
- that effort spent trying to act like a leader or you know becomes unauthentic and becomes artificial. It becomes
- something that people see through pretty quickly. Um so I think you know my earlier visions of leadership um
- perceptions of leadership might have been more built on some youthful understanding that it's hierarchial um
- that you know it's superior that there's some elevated stance and you know the further I go the more I understand that
- you know the humility is that is just such a important part and so I don't think I ever really understood um that
- that I do I think I heard a a a another leader talking recently about the scale of humility and confidence and I I am
- fascinated by you know being on that spectrum of humility and confidence because do I do think to effectively
- lead you can't be all the way to the humility side because then you really don't earn anyone's respect but you
- can't be too far on that confident side because then you lose all the respect so
- there is somewhere in that spectrum where I just think it has to be genuine self-confidence it can't be fabricated
- or artificial thanks yeah it's really interesting It reminds me of of a very old idea from Aristotle that you always
- wanted to be in in the mean or the midpoint between humility and arrogance. Okay. Well, that's maybe where that that
- person was speaking from. But yeah, I kind of just looked at it like there's that spectrum. And a lot of times when
- I'm sizing up, you know, potential leaders in the organization in my own mind, you know, I find myself he
- articulated or Aristotle articulated that's what I'm thinking about. I'm thinking about those things. So, how do
- you strike a a balance? I think that, you know, when when people are arriving in major leadership positions for the
- first time, you know, they often end up sort of falling off the spectrum at one end or the other and you're talking
- about sort of being in this this critical middle middle range. How do you get there? Well, humility is very easy
- to come by in my field. All you have to do is pick up a newspaper or turn on the radio and you
- can be humbled very quickly. Um, so I would just say aware, you know, that self-awareness is the key to having that
- balance. Um it's something that uh I think about all the time that we talk about internally that I think effective
- leaders have to be before anything else. If you look at you know kind of building
- um the foundation of what it takes to be an effective leader that starts with that self-awareness. You've got to be
- aware of your strengths but you've got to be keenly aware of your limitations and you've got to be aware of your
- insecurities. Every single one of us has insecurities. Every person has them. People that manage their insecurities
- prevent them from derailing them. To me, almost every single time I see someone derailed in an effort to lead,
- insecurities are at the root of that of being derailed. And so, again, we all have them, every single one of us, but
- they're easily managed if you take the time to be aware of them and then you talk yourself through them and ensure
- they don't derail your efforts. Mark, I've got a final question for you here. as you bring people into the ball club
- and mentor them, coach them, develop their leadership, what's the maybe the most important line of advice you would
- have for them? And to broaden it out a bit, speaking to undergraduate students back at your alma mater talking with MBA
- students here, what general advice would you have for people who do want to take
- responsibility for not necessarily a ball club, but working for an organization? So, what what's your
- advice? Well, the first thing I would say is to to do the work to take the time to get to know themselves. Um to
- you can call it whatever you want. You know, you can call it, you know, to understand what values are important to
- you. To me, it's defining the things that, you know, going back and searching for when they're in the cultures, when
- they're in the environments that they're happiest and most fulfilled. Why is that? And when there's a dissonance,
- when they're not happy, when they're finding that something's not correct, you know, what are the things that are
- not present? Because I think if they really do the work and it's not easy work, but if they take the time to to
- establish, understand and identify and and have a clarity to their value system that they'll be surprised how many more
- things are out there that are opportunities to lead that allows them to align themsel with the right leader
- and the right culture. And I think that path to development is going to come from being aligned with the right leader
- and in the right culture. The right culture and the right leaders are going to be obsessed with development. We
- obsess about developing our people. If you're in the wrong culture and and you're not aligned, then ultimately
- you're going to be exe, you know, you're going to be asked to execute a task or a
- role and there's not going to be much concern about your development. And I think, you know, to me personally, I
- think that's what I'd say is do the work to to really identify the things that are important to you. You'll be amazed.
- Open your mind up to the number of people you could be you could learn from and work with that you're aligned with.
- And uh it all starts there. That's great. Mark, we thank you for joining Knowledge of Wharton today. Thank you
- very much. Thank you guys. Thanks. Thank you. [Music]
Brief Summary
Mark Shapiro discusses leadership lessons, tough decisions, and the importance of authenticity and self-awareness in his career with the Cleveland Indians.
Key points
- Turning the Team Around. Mark shares his proudest leadership moment: transforming a struggling team into playoff contenders.
- The Tough Decision. Mark reflects on a difficult trade decision that disappointed many but was strategically necessary.
- The Importance of Values. Mark emphasizes the significance of aligning leadership with personal values for effective guidance.
- Advice for Future Leaders. Mark advises aspiring leaders to understand their values and seek alignment with the right culture.
Episode highlights
- Turning the Team AroundMark shares his proudest leadership moment: transforming a struggling team into playoff contenders.โSeeing that manifest itself into a central division championship...โ1:08Apr 10, 2013
- The Tough DecisionMark reflects on a difficult trade decision that disappointed many but was strategically necessary.โIt was the only opportunity we had to chart a course back to contention.โ2:29Apr 10, 2013
- The Importance of ValuesMark emphasizes the significance of aligning leadership with personal values for effective guidance.โWhat people buy into when they follow you is your values.โ4:05Apr 10, 2013
- Advice for Future LeadersMark advises aspiring leaders to understand their values and seek alignment with the right culture.โDo the work to really identify the things that are important to you.โ14:50Apr 10, 2013
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





