Retrain Your Brain

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Stephen Dubner, co-author of Think Like a Freak, discusses how to challenge conventional thinking and improve your decision-making. More: http://knlg.net/1vEIz42 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Adam Grant I'm here with Steven Dubner the author of The Freakonomics Enterprise along with Steven levit
  2. Stephen welcome thanks Adam uh your books have been fascinating to read they've obviously created an
  3. international explosion your latest is Think Like a Freak what motivated you to write this one well boredom no um
  4. honestly after so we wrote the first one together which was an accident I was a I
  5. am a journalist I hadd written an article about Steve levit and his strange brand of um e economics economic
  6. research and I was working on a totally separate book about the psychology of money I was really was and remain really
  7. interested in that so I was interested in behavioral economics what we now call that so I wrote about Lev then we
  8. decided after this article uh someone decided it would be a good idea if we teamed up and we did and wrote free
  9. economics which was very successful we didn't plan on it being successful we didn't plan on working together even
  10. once then we thought do we want to do another and we took about two years to to decide if we did and if we had if we
  11. could come up with enough good material for a second one which we did then for a
  12. third one we were pretty sure we weren't going to do another because we just didn't want to you know milk it um
  13. Contra the wishes of our publisher an agent you know you have to anytime someone sees a franchise presented to
  14. them they want to take it and exploit it and we just you know we had slightly different incentives we felt like we'd
  15. profited and been really lucky to get to that point and we didn't want to exploit
  16. it uh unless we had material that we were really proud of so again it took us a couple years to come up with a
  17. framework for a different book and that's this this third book Think Like a Freak and basically what what happened
  18. is we hear from people a lot emails mostly which is great I mean you know of all the things that the digital
  19. revolution has produced one of the coolest simplest ones is you can now contact people who write books that you
  20. read which used to be you used to have to write a letter to the publisher and hope they pass along which they never
  21. did so we hear from people with all these problems and questions and queries about the way the world works and we
  22. couldn't answer them all it's hard you know to answer one email well could take forget about one day could take months
  23. of research so rather than trying and failing to answer A Shard of those questions we thought what if we could
  24. write a book that basically deputizes the entire world or whoever wants to to think like we do to to kind of develop a
  25. set of rules a kind of blueprint for for essentially problem solving um it's not
  26. always problem solving but mostly that's what we try to do and that's what this book is it's meant to be a fun engaging
  27. practical way to think about the way the world really works think about the way incentives really work the way that
  28. people really respond to incentives rather than how they say they might and then if you're trying to solve a problem
  29. big or small in business or government or in your own family you know how you can maybe slightly increase your chances
  30. to actually solve it that's the idea well you you certainly accomplish those goals and you start with the premise
  31. that there are three words that all of us should probably utter more often than we do which are I don't know yeah where
  32. did that come from um well I think that came primarily from the fact that levit and I Le Steve levit
  33. my co-author you know he lives in a world of in the world of Academia where you are I'm a writer I've been a
  34. journalist you know for my whole adult life and both of us wouldn't have a job if we pretended we knew all the answers
  35. all the time the whole premise of what I do as a journalist is go find people who
  36. know things that are interesting or worthwhile or hidden and ask them about it try to find out so you have to
  37. acknowledge what you don't know levit in Academia and you in Academia you know what academic what good academic
  38. research is like good medical research like good uh physics or engineering research is trying to Sol trying to
  39. figure out questions um where you don't yet know the answers so once you come in
  40. with that mindset you're going to have a different approach you're going to acknowledge what you know which may not
  41. be very much and what you don't know and then you're going to in order to try to
  42. figure out what you need to know you're going to develop a framework for experimentation Gathering feedback and
  43. so on now as totally ridiculously obvious as that sounds what I just said there are huge quadrants of modern
  44. society particularly in business and in government where people are constantly pretending they know the answer to a
  45. question or the solution to a problem and I get it I understand the way the incentives work I understand that
  46. reputational you know reputation Works nobody wants to be the ignoramus or the dummy so if I'm a politician and someone
  47. says you know Governor blah blah Senator blah blah you know we just had this terrible mass shooting at a school if
  48. you could do anything if if all options were available to you what would you do to prevent that fut in the future the
  49. way the world works is I'm I'm going to tell you I'm going to tell you I'm going
  50. to do these three things and that's what'll do it do you have any evidence is there any empirical reason to think
  51. that that actually would work often I hate to say it no and so you see that in certain Realms politics and in business
  52. where the incentives are different there's a big incentive to get it right in business but there's also a lot of
  53. you know for lack of a a more sophisticated term peer pressure to be the gal or guy who knows who has the
  54. plan so you know a really basic um you know rule of thumb is uh um you know or a basic Mo that happens very frequently
  55. now is a firm will say we need to come up with a plan or a solution let's get our 20 top people get together in a room
  56. for an hour that's 20 person hours and let's come up with the best one the best idea and then put all our resources into
  57. that and go what are the odds I mean if this were science what are the odds that
  58. that would bear a good result almost none so then there's the counter example of Someone Like A Google who lets its
  59. Engineers take 20% of their time and work on their projects on the side the idea being you know have a lot of ideas
  60. most of them will be bad but let the triage process work and let people figure out through scientific or
  61. empirical ways how they can really learn stuff and then once you've done some experimentation and some small scale
  62. work then maybe put some resources behind it so that's something that I think business needs to do
  63. much better but I think many businesses are moving in the right direction and the digital Revolution helps that so
  64. much because it's now so easy and cheap to gather data and do AB testing or a through z testing to tell you what's
  65. actually working do you have favorite tests that you're seeing recently that kind of represent this revolution in a
  66. positive direction as opposed to you know we can all name bad decisions that should have been based on evidence but
  67. weren't are there are there any standout examples for you I'll tell you one example Le I don't know how well it's
  68. working out I did some reporting on it a few years ago I have no idea how well it's working out I like the idea because
  69. it's uh the federal government doing it and the federal government has typically
  70. been really bad I mean they're the worst and if you think about it it makes sense
  71. why they are on the top theoretically in some ways of 50 state governments and all those Municipal governments under
  72. them so they're not in a position really to go micro um and I I understand that but what they did with this race to the
  73. toop program and education I thought was a really good idea and again I don't know how well it's going to work out but
  74. basically they set up first of all a contest which means that there are incentives that presumably are going to
  75. work better than no incentives or then than there's or better than some kind of negative reinforcement that we're used
  76. to and basically uh you know Arie Duncan Secretary of Education the president said to all the states hey we need to
  77. think of ways to improve or rethink our education system and believe me you know
  78. I could talk about that for years because education is such a complicated box with so many inputs and so many
  79. outputs it's it's really easy to look for Magic Bullets you know hire Pay Teachers more or get rid of the unions
  80. or smaller class size everybody likes those Magic Bullets but it's a very complicated scenario so basically the
  81. Department of Education said we go to all 50 states each of you we want you to try to come up with a good program a
  82. good idea a good solution that works and if works we'll pay you for it and there's a good chance then we'll run it
  83. up and we'll kind of you know standardize it that's the right kind of thinking um think
  84. small don't pretend you know the answers um experiment get feedback these are all
  85. the premises of Think Like a Freak really and and there's one example where even the federal government which we're
  86. not used to thinking that empirically I think you know gave it a good shot you have some fascinating examples of the
  87. book uh that probably stretch beyond what most readers would themselves be willing to do uh one of which is you
  88. actually got people to agree to let you randomly assign them to do things like ask for a raise or quit their job or
  89. even break up with their significant other uh what was the logic behind that what you learn so this came about
  90. because of a uh a podcast episode we do free economics Radio podcast and public radio show and we did an episode that I
  91. I love it was just to me this was a great topic because it's a blend of data and empirical thinking with narrative
  92. storytelling which is my tradition um so it was called the upside of quitting and
  93. it was basically making an economic argument to some degree which is um considering that most of us have been
  94. conditioned to not quit we've been conditioned to think that quitting is an equivalent of fail is a failure a form
  95. of failure um how do we know that that's true and how much of the counter might be opposite so um you know if you think
  96. about a project a job a war you know all a relationship all these things that you
  97. might could quit but because of sunk costs and because of peer pressure and because of um you know your own moral
  98. position you might not want to quit we tried to look at you know what is the upside of quitting and we we argued that
  99. there's a significant upside that people are really bad at um estimating um opportunity cost what they could be
  100. doing if they could quit and so on so but the fact is it's really hard to get data on this because it's not like
  101. you can go into you know one big school district and say you know I'm going to take a thousand kids and I'm going to
  102. totally mix them so their grades are you know equivalent on either side and I'm going to randomly Force half of them to
  103. quit school uh don't allow them to go back to school and then 10 and 20 and 30 years later see how their lives turned
  104. out that's one way to you might do that experiment but of course we couldn't do that the people who tend to quit school
  105. tend to be a very different population than the people who don't quit school so to compare them after is not equivalent
  106. so what we came up with was a website called free economics experiments where we offered that if people had a decision
  107. to make it wasn't necessarily something to quit although usually it was if they had a decision to make um should I quit
  108. my job and go back to grad school should I join the military or stick with my job
  109. should I leave my boyfriend or girlfriend or husband or wife uh all different kinds of things should I get a
  110. tattoo or not and if they had a decision and they couldn't and they really were on the really truly on the fence then we
  111. offered to help him out and flip a coin for him and we asked all we asked is that they fill out a survey beforehand
  112. telling us about it and that then they tell us whether or not they followed the coin because we have no power to make
  113. them follow the coin and then we would follow up with them and and do research later to find out uh what their outcomes
  114. were and so to many different categories a variety of outcomes and the research isn't done yet but the short short
  115. answer is that when people quit something that they were generally really worried about quitting their
  116. lives tend to get a little bit better so even if they didn't get a lot worse you
  117. might argue that it's a a pretty good uh a pretty good bet so basically I think we should all consider
  118. quitting as a really good option um but you know it's hard when you have the words of Vince Lombardi you know a
  119. quitter never wins and a winner never quits which was wasn't Lombardi originally and Winston Churchill telling
  120. people never never never never never give up in anything large or small greater Petty you know you have these
  121. great people and that gets in your ear and it convinces you that oh man if I start a project I have to see it through
  122. but if you just for five minutes spend some time thinking about the sunk cost and thinking about opportunity cost then
  123. you can really get to different places so that's what we were trying to accomplish there well I'm the opposite
  124. of quitting I think another one of the most audacious things that comes out and think like a freak dates back to Super
  125. Freakonomics I remember reading that you said that that basically terrorists should buy life insurance and thinking
  126. there was an awfully interesting way that you could use that information which you then went and did tell us a
  127. little so you thought yeah you you were thinking a step ahead of most people reading I was just right with you
  128. thinking like a social scientist well a lot of people were thinking so right in super fre economics we described this
  129. algorithm that levit worked on with a a British bank that was trying to catch terrorists from nothing more than retail
  130. banking data that was for our purposes anonymized and so there were all these metrics that seemed to indicate someone
  131. who might be uh you know either we couldn't tell from their banking dat it wasn't like we know that they're buying
  132. bomb making materials although that would have showed up but they're not that stupid but if they were consorting
  133. with other people um but then there were other Clues um that would uh raise the that would move the needle for
  134. indicating that someone is is quite possibly involved in it but then there was one argument that we made in super
  135. fre economics that if you really um one really good indicator is that young men who are prone to thinking about
  136. terrorism are not going to buy life insurance from their bank because why would you because if you if you kill
  137. yourself in the commission of a crime it's not going to pay out so why would you waste the money that was the
  138. argument we made so basically we were saying here's this algorithm we made here are what here are the metrics that
  139. comprise the algorithm there's one or two that are too good we're not going to tell you but here's by the way is
  140. another really good one that we will tell you which is that you should buy life insurance from your bank now this
  141. was done for real the algorithm was real and we were really trying to catch people and it worked to some degree we
  142. think it worked to some degree but the life insurance thing was just a red herring or it was a it was a trap and
  143. the idea was that very few people buy life insurance from their banks anyway like very very very few people even
  144. though most banks offer it and the same is in Britain but by putting that in our
  145. book and then when we went to uh Britain for book tour what most people were saying when they interviewed us is you
  146. idiots why would you go to the trouble to build a a tool to catch terrorists then tell them how to evade it and then
  147. we were just like well yeah maybe we huh because that's the tool yeah so um because that was the tool so then the
  148. algorithm was already in place uh by that point so anybody that saw us talking about this or saw journalists
  149. there yelling at us for giving away this clue what are they maybe now a little bit more likely to do if they're guilty
  150. to cover their tracks go buy some life insurance from their bank then the algorithm being in place we could look
  151. at that data and see who already fit the profile and now additionally ran out and
  152. bought some life insurance and that increased the likelihood even a little bit more that those people were bad guys
  153. that generated a new smaller list that we then passed on to the authorities there do you know what was done with
  154. that list so my colleague Lev presented It To The Head or near head of uh the Intelligence
  155. Division he presented it it was literally an envelope with a wax seal because he'd been given the envelope
  156. from the bank because we were again we weren't allowed to see any identifying data on any of the people and it was a
  157. little bit it it was a little bit um maybe James Bond outtake combined with uh the very end of Raiders the Lost Arc
  158. where they get the arc and it and it goes into the warehouse and the camera pulls back and you see that there are 8
  159. million boxes so we have no idea uh whether this list that we were quite sure had some value for anti-terror uh
  160. purposes um whether or to what degree it was put to use uh that that wasn't part
  161. of the game we were allowed to play in basically yeah so in closing um other than saying I don't know when working on
  162. Freakonomics the book the radio the podcast the movie um through that whole process what's the biggest lesson you've
  163. taken away about how to think like a freak oh the biggest lesson um I I guess I should know that by now
  164. shouldn't I since this is kind of my thing um you know I it's amazing that I'm coming up blank to the question that
  165. should be the first one that I don't come up blank to um I I guess I really um so this is more of a philosophical
  166. answer than a a kind of tactical or strategic answer to me the challenge is always going to be the blend between the
  167. empirical or scientific or data whatever you want to call that and the intuitive
  168. or the human or the Humane whatever you want to call that and what I mean by that is especially in this era of big
  169. data which is kind of what we've been doing for a long time now not as systematically as a lot of firms and
  170. governments are doing it now but you know we believe in it we believe that if you get a pile of data representing a
  171. million decisions that that's better than asking three people what decisions they made so while I very much believe
  172. that to be true and I very much applaud all the instincts for all of us to kind of work with data in aggregate to
  173. distill the biggest truths I also know that we're humans and that we're fallible and bi I shouldn't say fallible
  174. although we're fallible too we're biased in a lot of ways so that even if you could tell me or I could tell you the
  175. most foolproof strategic way to reach a decision or the best decision to make or
  176. the best strategy or the best set of numbers to embrace there might be a lot of good reasons why you still won't be
  177. successful and that's because the people that you are now employing that strategy
  178. on or the people that you're now offering those incentives to don't respond the way way you think about the
  179. problem and that requires a lot of humility um and that's something that people in government in business in
  180. Academia in journalism uh everywhere where you know people in all those fields are really used to like when we
  181. come up with something and we put it into play we're used to people like snapping up and saying okay we're going
  182. to do this now that's a lot of power that's a lot of authority but with that power and authority comes I think the
  183. need for humility to understand that when you make decisions like that put out incentives whatever they are big or
  184. small governmental or non that there are people on the other end of that and how
  185. it affects their lives the decision makers don't often think through very well how they'll respond to the
  186. incentives and so on and so that to me is the balance to be as scientific as you can while understanding that even if
  187. I can present a 100 people with the science that says hey you should really do this 90 of them might have a really
  188. good reason for not wanting to do it they might be wrong I might be right but it doesn't mean I'll win the argument
  189. and being right doesn't win that many arguments um weirdly enough I mean there are a lot of people who are right about
  190. a lot of things who who don't get their way so I think that's really the the trickiest part I mean I'm working on a a
  191. radio Podcast episode right now about the flu vaccine very very simple it's pretty effective the flu vaccine about
  192. 60% or so influenza along with pneumonia is always one of the 10 leading causes of death in the US which most people
  193. don't think about or don't know and um and yet very few people a lot of people who should get the flu vaccine don't why
  194. it's kind of a conundrum so we're going through all these different layers of Behavioral and uh PR um and uh um you
  195. know financial decisions to try to figure out how is something as seemingly simple as this so hard to accomplish and
  196. that is what I'm constantly reminded is the people the smart money may be smart but unless it can deliver on something
  197. that really raises everyone's Behavior then it's not worth that much thank you for joining us my pleasure Adam
  198. [Music] thanks

Brief Summary

Adam Grant talks with Steven Dubner and Levitt about their book, problem-solving, and the importance of acknowledging uncertainty in decision-making.

Key points

  • The Motivation Behind 'Think Like a Freak'. Boredom led to the creation of this thought-provoking book.
  • The Power of 'I Don't Know'. Acknowledging uncertainty can lead to better problem-solving.
  • The Upside of Quitting. Exploring the benefits of quitting and how it can improve lives.
  • The Challenge of Decision Making. Even with the best strategies, success isn't guaranteed due to human biases.
  • Understanding the Flu Vaccine Dilemma. Despite its effectiveness, many people avoid the flu vaccine. Why is that?

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes