The Science and Art of Self Assurance
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
For their book, The Confidence Code, authors Katty Kay and Claire Shipman looked at research showing women lack the self-assurance they deserve in their careers – and just as important, examined what they should do about it. More: http://knlg.net/1vFiMIV 📂 Leadership
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- I'm Adam Grant I'm here with caty K co-author of The Confidence Code welcome catd thank you Adam so what drove you to
- write this book you know we wrote another book six as so often happens you write one book and you end up writing
- another book so we wrote a book about six years ago on the value of women in the workforce and for that book we
- interviewed a lot of senior women in business in the military in politics and we were struck by phrases that they
- would use phrases like I'm just lucky to have got where I've got to or I was in the right place at the right time or you
- know I think I'm not quite ready for that promotion yet and it occurred to us that we never heard men say things like
- this and what was going on how could this be what is it you all think you deserve that next promotion immediately
- and uh it just struck us that something was happening with women in the professional space that was not
- happening in their home lives when you ask them about their kids or their friends they think they're great you
- know they're they're totally confidence of their ability to make friendships or be great mothers or supportive wives but
- get them into the professional space and we wondered if it was just anecdotal or
- if there was actually data behind this and what led you to the initial idea that it was a confidence Gap as opposed
- to humility let's say because they were whole it wasn't just words they weren't saying one thing
- and doing another they genuinely believed they weren't good enough and when you start looking into all of the
- date warton's done some of it uh Columbia business school has done run numbers on men overestimate their
- abilities by some 30% women routinely underestimate their abilities you talk to all the psychologists who are working
- in Business Schools who will put men and women in front of scientific reasoning qu quizzes the women will routinely
- think they've done less well than they've done the men will think they've done better than they've done in reality
- they've done about the same so it's that women's perception of their ability excuse below their actual ability it's
- not that they're just saying I'm not very good but actually thinking they're really good they don't believe they are
- as good as they are and that's why that's what the confidence Gap is women don't believe they are as good as they
- are and you point out that it's not just women but that as a BBC journalist you'd
- actually experience this oh yeah I'm you know riddled with this and have been for
- the last 30 years of my career I my favorite was I spent years in America saying that the only reason I've been
- successful in America is cu I speak the way I do I it can't possibly be my talents right or my ability or my hard
- work and that is preposterous it had to be some external factor and in my case it was the fact that I speak with a
- British accent which makes people think I'm smarter than I am and I actually believed this Adam I mean for years I
- believed this CLA will tell you my co-author she's been banging on about this one for years and we all find
- Claire's thing that that she had was that she only became moscow's CNN's Moscow correspondent because she
- happened to be in the right place and that is very common for women and what did you do when you noticed that there
- were people with British accents here who weren't successful well you that that would
- violate the theory at some level you always find some reason they must have some
- problem okay so um so you identify the Gap no one's ever asked me that before good well the the the confidence Gap um
- you know a lot of data behind it right um so what what do we do about it where does it come from and and how do we
- start to to solve the problem it led us to then on this rather uh tangential uh quest to find out what confidence is we
- thought that if we were going to try and grow confidence we were better off if we
- knew what we were dealing with so we would we interviewed dozens of neurologists and psychologists for the
- book and we would always start off with this simple question can you define confidence for us and inevitably we'd be
- met by a pause hm well it's complicated and we went into this with a couple of misconceptions first of all we
- thought that confidence was the same as self-esteem a general feeling that you're a valuable person I have high
- self-esteem I think I'm a valuable person the universe is a friendly place um it's an almost sort of moral
- emotional quality that is pervasive to who you are as a human being we all we were wrong confidence is
- not the same as self-esteem we also thought and this was wrong too that confidence is a Manor a mannerism it's a
- Bravado a sense of swagger it's that thing of dominating meetings or speaking loudest and longest we were wrong as
- well confidence is nothing to do with a manner it's to do with a belief that you
- can succeed at something so we' ask all these neurologists and psychologists what is confidence and finally it was
- Richard Petty who's a psychologist at Ohio State who said to us that he thought the best definition of
- confidence was this confidence is the stuff that turns thoughts into action which is beautifully simple and the
- great thing about that idea is that not only does it turn thoughts into action I
- want to introduce myself to that interesting looking person at a party but I feel nervous about doing so
- confidence gets you across the room to shake somebody's hand and introduce yourself when you do it when you take
- the action you grow your confidence so it's a wonderfully virtuous circle it's about confidence is about action even
- when you take the action ineffectively though so you make the introduction it's a complete disaster what happens then
- yes even if you fail even if you meet a you have to meet hurdles when you try something new it's inevitable right
- you're always going to meet hurdles you introduce yourself to that person they brush you
- off think to yourself what's the worst that's happened did the sky fall on your head did the earth open up and swallow
- you whole because that person brushed you off no you're still standing you're still there and in a sense even if you
- fail you've learned that you can take a risk try something hard even if you fail
- you're still there now if you keep doing that eventually you'll succeed if you introduce yourself to the next person
- the chances are pretty slim that they're going to brush you off as well you've learned that you can do something and
- that your world doesn't fall apart because you try something that's outside your comfort zone I read the news every
- night to millions of people around the world it doesn't test my confidence working at Wharton business
- school would terrify me I'm absolutely convinced I'd be useless at doing what you do the only way I would ever find
- out would be to try that's how you build confidence you take something that is challenging to you that seems difficult
- that is new and hard and outside your comfort zone a small thing or a big thing and you keep going and overcome
- hurdles and you succeed to some degree and that's how you build confidence what I like about this a lot is it's an
- interesting Counterpoint to the self-esteem movement right which which we all know from mountains of evidence
- did almost no good and a lot of harm um and this is different right this isn't about looking in the mirror and saying
- I'm really great it's actually about increasing your ability as you said convert thoughts into action so do you
- have any other favorite strategies for boosting confidence then okay so here's another reason that there's a confidence
- Gap one of the reasons that there's a confidence gap between men and women women find action often harder than men
- because we are more risk averse because we the fear of failure is enormous for us seems to be bigger than it is for men
- the other thing that women do is we think a lot we run around inside our own heads I sent Adam that email he didn't
- get back to me after half an hour maybe he's mad at me I did maybe the Hall of Warton is mad at me maybe everyone at
- Penn is mad at me because I didn't get back to them that's the way women work we extrap we take one small thing a a
- small slight a small criticism a small thing we've done wrong and it holds us back from acting and trying hard things
- because we're running around in our own heads and one of the things we think about in The Confidence Code is you have
- to think less you actually have to draw a line under those thoughts women dwell on the things they've done wrong it's
- what happens in review processes uh it's what happens in negotiations with bosses and what
- happens when we're there's one piece of work we didn't manage to hand in on time
- that day even though we've done five other good pieces of work we'll remember the one piece of work we didn't do so
- well we need to find a way to draw a red line under that it's interesting though
- because everything you say to me sounds like a list of desirable attributes and for everybody yeah and so is isn't isn't
- a possible solution here just to get men down to the level of reasonable confidence you know we're asked about
- that and and and some and counter point is we're asked well aren't we trying aren't we at risk RIS of pushing women
- into overconfidence I don't think we're at any risk of pushing women into overconfidence I see no evidence that
- we're going to suddenly become um you know Leeman Brothers Redux all of us I just don't think that's going to
- happen ideally everyone needs a little bit of overconfidence and it's interesting that
- psychologists disagree about most things but the one thing they actually do agree
- about is that a little bit of overconfidence is better than a little bit of underconfidence men probably have
- too much and it might be better for all of us if some of it came down particularly if you're thinking of a
- cultural environment in the office space right if you're thinking of meeting environments or uh employee employer
- relations that is to some extent a mannerism but I think the priority is to get women over this hump of
- underconfidence because that's what's stopping them from part of what's stopping them from taking action and
- getting to the next level mhm so you've talked a little bit about stretching outside of comfort zones um if you were
- going to create sort of your wish list of a couple of of steps that women and also men lacking confidence ought to
- take what else would go on that list be prepared to fail get over the fear of failure that the sort of techie Buzz
- phrase fail fast is a great one for women women hold themselves to a very high standard we know this women are 25%
- more prone to perfectionism than men are we're perfectionists at work we're we're
- perfectionists as wives we're perfectionists as mothers we're perfectionists in the yoga studio You
- Name It We Want to Be Perfect at it if you're going to try and be perfect you're never going to get there it's an
- impossible standard right no one is ever going to be perfect but this pursuit of perfection
- is something that holds us back from taking risks because it makes us very scared of failing and I think one one of
- the first things that people who are underc confident need to do is give up trying to be perfect it'll be the single
- biggest thing that they can do to help them take risks and be prepared to fail in closing is there a point that you
- feel has been misunderstood or oversimplified that you want to set the record straight on okay yes one is the
- idea some people have said to us well aren't we just trying to make women like men and we wrestled with this when we
- were writing the book basically do you have to be a jerk to be confident because I think a lot of women look
- around at them and they see a a very male model of confidence in the professional space that frankly is
- unappealing and in accessible to us because it's downright foreign and it was Christine lagard uh the head of the
- IMF who was who was really helpful to us in explaining this she said it essential
- for women to be authentic don't give up the very qualities that make you valuable an
- ability to listen ability to build consensus a high EQ that's good at reading a room warmth warmth is an
- amazing quality to have it's a very powerful quality don't give up all of that in the pursuit of a mannerism
- bravado and Swagger which doesn't really suit you and when you try it doesn't work for you anyway so you want to be
- confident in that you want your voice to be heard you don't want to apologize you
- don't as Cheryl Samberg says want to lean back but you want to do it in a way that is authentic to who you are as a
- woman and that's critical I think for people we're not asking people to become somebody different we just asking them
- to bring their perception of their abilities in line with their abilities and when you're there you're in The
- Sweet Spot okay thank you caddy thank you [Music]
Brief Summary
Caty K discusses the confidence gap between men and women, emphasizing action over perfectionism to boost confidence.
Key points
- The Confidence Gap. Women often underestimate their abilities compared to men, leading to a confidence gap.
- Defining Confidence. Confidence is not self-esteem or bravado; it’s about believing you can succeed.
- Authenticity in Confidence. Women should embrace their unique qualities rather than conform to male models of confidence.
Episode highlights
- The Confidence GapWomen often underestimate their abilities compared to men, leading to a confidence gap.“Women routinely underestimate their abilities.”1:39Dec 23, 2014
- Defining ConfidenceConfidence is not self-esteem or bravado; it’s about believing you can succeed.“Confidence is the stuff that turns thoughts into action.”5:03Dec 23, 2014
- Authenticity in ConfidenceWomen should embrace their unique qualities rather than conform to male models of confidence.“Don’t give up the very qualities that make you valuable.”11:41Dec 23, 2014
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





