How Does Prioritizing Diversity Reshape Sports? | Kenneth Shropshire — Opportunity Matters Series

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Kenneth L. Shropshire, faculty director for Wharton’s Coalition for Equity and Opportunity delves into the world of sports alongside guests Xavier Gutierrez, the NHL's first Latino president and CEO, and Jonathan Beane, the NFL's senior vice president and chief diversity and inclusion officer.

The conversation examines the unique role sports play in providing access and opportunities for underserved communities, and why women are more likely to foster a positive and inclusive work environment. They also address the diversity challenges in team ownership and highlight the ongoing efforts to increase opportunities for minorities in leadership roles within sports organizations. This interview is part of a special 4-part series called “Opportunity Matters.”

#dei #inclusion #diversity #sports ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU 📂 Leadership 🏷️ Opportunity Matters

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. welcome to Opportunity Matters this is Ken Shropshire it's a an exciting Series where we've been looking at these ways
  2. that we can bring about greater access to those who don't traditionally have access and I'm excited today in this
  3. episode to talk about the area this near and dear to me Sports and I mean Sports is kind of this
  4. this mystical space to think about this whole topic because it is the Jackie Robinson Trope that most people think
  5. about is leading America into the state that it's in that almost a decade before
  6. schools were legally desegregated in the United States baseball integrates so people often think that Sports is the
  7. space where this can happen most readily and so we'll talk about that we'll talk
  8. about the problems that still exist in sport and some of the solutions that some to of the uh representatives of two
  9. of the great leagues in the United States uh have have asserted so let me introduce the guest formally as I've
  10. done U throughout this podcast series our our first is Javier Gutierrez a friend of mine from the
  11. Arizona uh location also a California guy he's the first Latino president and CEO in the history of the National
  12. Hockey League leading the Arizona Coyotes Hockey Club and currently the only Latino leading a major league
  13. sports team in this Ro Javier overse all business operations strategic planning significant organizational decision-
  14. making and government relations for the club previously and could have been on some other episodes as well he served as
  15. managing director at Clear Lake Capital group a leading private investment firm that oversees 25 billion of
  16. institutional Capital Javier graduated from Harvard College somebody has to go there and Stanford law school and for
  17. two decades built a sterling reputation in business investment and finance h here thank you for for joining me and
  18. thanks so much for having me Jonathan Bean he is the senior vice president and chief diversity and inclusion officer
  19. began that role with the NFL in 2020 he spearheads the League's overarching de strategy and implementation and works
  20. closely with senior leadership to drive actionable change throughout the league and all 32 clubs over the course of his
  21. career Jonathan has led companies to Foster more inclusive cultures and has established himself as a successful
  22. diversity strategist prior to joining the NFL being served as the senior vice president of global diversity and
  23. inclusion for 21st Century Fox Jonathan thanks for joining in thank you Ken did you ever work for any boring companies
  24. that you know you no comment okay well let let's get underway I mean I said you know I want to kind of lay
  25. the ground work of what's going on uh in sports and kind of how we've gotten to the place that that we're in um and and
  26. Javier why don't we start with you and and in your unique role as as the first Latino in the space and also you didn't
  27. mention in the intro um is is he currently the the well certainly one of the first Latino owner
  28. in the National Hockey League uh is the guy that bought the team that convinced you to leave
  29. a more traditional space to to come in how's how's this journey been what kinds of things uh in terms of equity and
  30. opportunity did you want to accomplish as you came in um and yeah just just how's it been just just kind of kind of
  31. lay lay the groundwork of this this journey you've had for where are we now year three and a half almost four season
  32. four if you can believe it okay no okay I appreciate this yeah no I appreciate it and and um you you know I I I applaud
  33. everything that you're doing to continue to uh be a leader in talking about the importance of opportunity and opening
  34. doors um yeah you know you you you mentioned Alex Morel the first Latino owner in the history of the National
  35. Hockey League and and one of the few owner majority owners of any professional sports team in in the
  36. history of the professional the the major professional teams in in America um is a longtime friend uh business
  37. partner we actually own the largest Latino owned bank uh together in in California um and and he approached me
  38. uh shortly after buying the team and and he said listen the reason why you should
  39. do this you need to do this is because of the incredible power of sports to make a difference and and to make an
  40. impact and what he said was I want us to be a beloved Sports organization I want
  41. to win but I want us to be beloved and really the way you do that is by making an impact and making a difference on the
  42. ice in terms of rebuilding a franchise from the ground up uh via the draft you know we have a a historic number of
  43. draft picks in the NHL uh on the business side you know we've been at the Forefront of putting our games over the
  44. air for free we've been at the Forefront of really bringing that bridge to growth
  45. cohorts of young female diverse techsavvy and Purpose Driven and using content and actually fashion and
  46. merchandise you know we have one of the first fashion design working with us that created a jersey
  47. that their players actually wear during games I I definitely want to come back and and you you struck an issue that I
  48. think is very important the power that you have with the franchise to provide opportunities in the community but I
  49. want but I want to get get Jonathan in for a moment be before we do that the the NFL has has been uh Stellar in
  50. addressing you know one of the issues the way we used to think about diversity in sports was I this idea of of playing
  51. the game who's not playing and the issue was the closer you were to the ball the less likely you were to be
  52. a person of color so there were no black quarterbacks now that issue that issue is is addressed what what are the big
  53. issues with with with the National Football League now and and and the big successes too yeah Ken thanks for that
  54. and and and also Javier congratulations on on the success that you explained and
  55. and we hope to see that in in all the industry and and hopefully we will uh sooner rather than later for us uh as it
  56. pertains you know it always goes to the top and we we certainly want to increase
  57. our diverse ownership uh in the organization right now we really have one primary uh owner who happens to be
  58. diverse and that's shod KH um you know we also um Kim Pula certainly uh is is a critical piece as well but shodon is the
  59. solo primary owner who happens to be diverse and and he's been an owner for quite a while um that has been something
  60. that has been one of the biggest priorities of the league obviously when you look at at numbers and you look at
  61. um how expensive it is to own a club uh that certainly does uh uh lower the numbers uh a little bit but I certainly
  62. think that there's a lot of people like Jose Feliciano who who I have met and who think I think he's awesome uh that
  63. there are people out there one thing that we have done is we've been very intentional on our efforts to really um
  64. attract more diverse ownership and and I think what's important is we want the primary ownership but we also want those
  65. limited partners as well and we've had two clubs that have been for sale over the last couple years uh the first one
  66. being the Denver Broncos and the second one being the most recent one is the Washington commanders and in both cases
  67. you see significant diverse ownership with Melody Hobson condo rice and Sir Lewis Hamilton uh with the Broncos and I
  68. think the biggest diverse owner um with Magic Johnson and others at the Washington commanders and and before
  69. that process even started for both of those clubs we made a statement and and um where we said as people are putting
  70. together organizations are putting together together their offers for a club uh we will see it very favorably
  71. for there to be diverse ownership as a part of that overall package and proposal um just making it very clear
  72. that that is something that we are looking for and hoping for uh going forward and and we've been able to see
  73. that I mean one thing too that is of course important and I think can you mention that is ownership of course at
  74. the very top is is very critical but also these other roles the head coach role roles the G general manager roles
  75. the president roles and we have seen some good progress in some of those areas in particular for with President
  76. uh in August of 2020 Jason Wright was the first uh African-American president in the history of the National Football
  77. League today we have five African-American presidents uh at the league and we feel very proud about that
  78. um we also have uh one of them being uh Sandra Douglas Morgan who uh who really it's it's it's it's amazing as a black
  79. woman the first person in that role too um so we are seeing some nice Improvement there we look at general
  80. manager we have more diverse uh general managers that we've had in the history of the league with nine eight of which
  81. who happen to be African-American and that doesn't include the two Who currently are interims right now and
  82. Jojo and champ at the at the um uh at the Las Vegas Raiders and and and also the Los Angeles Chargers uh and and
  83. I think you know obviously we're still working on that head coach issue and we're going to continue to do so but we
  84. feel very confident that we'll see change there let me ask and jav I do want to come back to the the business
  85. impact question in the community but but but Jonathan reminds me of uh an important issue that that that you you
  86. two can discuss in a way that that kind of none of the other areas have had uh as much opportunity to do and that and
  87. that is uh women's access in in leadership uh in your respective leagues where it there aren't women playing the
  88. game in in your leagues and how that balances with this this one always um you know the puzzle when I talk about
  89. this in class is we've got men who have played the game that have difficulty getting in some of these positions
  90. sometimes how do we balance that against the idea that that we need to have women
  91. in these positions too and one person that we were talking to uh in the entertainment industry said you know my
  92. focus is on on black people and getting black black people in I guess part of the the question is I throw all these
  93. issues in at once you how do how do we get the the Focus right this whole idea of diversity is there a proper mix are
  94. we sometime somehow negatively impacting one group if we focus you know women's month as AO or Latino history month or
  95. Black History Month how do how do we do the balance in this this this whole space that is one thing that I have
  96. realized especially in the role that I've been in for almost three and a half years now at the National Football
  97. League is you cannot make the kind of transformational change in a particular area without also making the change in
  98. another area which will support each other and and I'll be direct about that if we're talking about us doing a better
  99. job of having more diversity in particular with uh African-Americans and Latinos and and Asians and in areas of
  100. leadership um you're not going to get that leadership without also driving more inclusivity and diversity and
  101. diverse representation with women and it's interesting because there is um there there are there is someone who I
  102. do a lot of work with and is um and and is a player and it was interesting there
  103. was a comment that was said to me that was there was a clear change in the culture and the
  104. environment of the clubs that he worked with when women were on staff and that was with so with other
  105. aspects of diversity like people of color that got better and more inclusive with women on
  106. staff and vice versa so one thing drives the other interesting um there is no need to say
  107. I'm going to lock in on one thing and then leave the others behind it is the commitment to all of it holistically
  108. which drives the Improvement in those areas um so I so just to be direct I don't think that we are going to get the
  109. progress that we need in particular with particular groups whether they be black
  110. groups Latino groups and others without also having that progress and in particular with women women will drive
  111. that increased Pro progress for us Javier I think that's a really good point Jonathan that one thing will
  112. actually exponentially impact something else I I'll I'll add a kind of a slightly uh different point to this
  113. which is we ask ourselves constantly what what's what is the goal right what is the end goal so number one one of the
  114. goals is we want to be a best-in-class business operation and business organization and if you don't have have
  115. diverse voices especially if you don't have female voices you're not going to make the best decisions they're just
  116. they're they're going to be impacted you're going to not have the full perspective the full Viewpoint um you
  117. know full insight as an organization so so it starts with if we want to be the best business let's bring the best
  118. people and that includes bringing the best amount of and the highest amount of perspective to make the best decisions
  119. number two as an organization and as a business what do we want to do we we are consumer business very high-profile
  120. consumer business so what do those consumers look like in in particular what is the growth a look like in the
  121. consumer Market in America it's young female diverse techsavvy and purpos griven I constantly talk about those
  122. growth cohort so we want to a bridge to those growth cohorts which by the way is
  123. one of the key value propositions that we offer to our partners right our Media Partners our business partners uh from a
  124. business perspective if we want to be a bridge to those growth cohorts you really need those folks in the seat
  125. giving you that type of perspective of attracting that because a monolithic Viewpoint will not get you the
  126. understanding or at least the openness of understanding how to capture those growth cohorts and I don't ascribe to
  127. this theory that you know only an African-American can sit in that seat in order you help you attract other
  128. African-Americans or the African-American Market that's not what I'm saying what I'm saying is having
  129. them in the seat as Jonathan alluded to creates a culture in an environment in which you're asking and you're open to
  130. saying are we capturing all the distinct perspectives that we need as an organization and are we capturing the
  131. distinct and unique approaches in order to capture those growth cohorts so so I want to say you you guys have have been
  132. the ideal as I as I've been thinking about the series that in terms of this broad issue that's
  133. that's been on my mind uh and it's been on my mind a lot because of the issues that have been raised recently with
  134. anti-Semitism and islamophobia my response to a lot of people has been the best Professionals
  135. in this space are always trying to think about everybody and always are trying to
  136. figure out how do you include everyone and how do you make sure there's not bias going against anyone and the best
  137. professionals are always saying too there's not a universal approach for each group I I need to do whatever it is
  138. I need to do to address these issues and I need to constantly stay stay on top of
  139. these issues so I'm I'm not I'm not dragging you guys in with my my view viewpoint but I it it's it's one that
  140. that uh I I think people that are being critical of the work in the space need to have a better understanding of what
  141. what the true professionals do so the the one the one last area I want to cover we've got uh about uh three
  142. minutes left is this area of of business opportunities that that a league that that a franchise can provide to people
  143. that don't normally have access to do business wi with with a league or or team uh Jonathan why you why don't you
  144. take a a minute and then Javier I'll ask you to kind of close out with with a a last minute on on the kinds of things
  145. that are available the kinds of things a can you are doing and El can do yeah Ken absolutely this piece is
  146. really critical um you look at the NHL you look at the NFL huge organizations multi-billion dollar organizations um
  147. very profitable organizations very connected to the fan base organizations and more and more becoming Global uh
  148. with that said uh we need to just as we need to have diversity and representation um uh in terms of our
  149. employees we need to have diversity in terms of the organizations and businesses that we're working with and
  150. share the pie um we wouldn't be who we are today without all of these communities that we're talking about and
  151. so for us we're really really focused and and made it a huge priority around increasing the number of diverse vendors
  152. that we work with and when we say that it's not just just in one particular space uh events is critical marketing's
  153. critical um B uh banking's critical Finance um we've actually had a lot of success in that area uh n working with
  154. the national black Bank Foundation uh with a Ashley uh and and Ashley Bell and others um but we believe that and and
  155. this is not only at the league office but also at the clubs is you have to in order for us to get better have better
  156. Solutions uh have the best Partners working with us we have to have a diverse lens and be very focused on
  157. bringing in a variety of different people from different backgrounds and organizations that can service in a
  158. variety of different ways so that's critical for us we've been working on that uh very hard for two plus years uh
  159. specifically and and there's still a lot more work to to get done but we're doing
  160. some good work there Javier in in the last minute what's what's the what kinds of things have you guys been doing yeah
  161. no I'll Echo everything that Jonathan said I don't want to repeat it because it's it's absolutely true right like
  162. these are drivers of economic activity especially in local communities and it it goes beyond just game day it's you
  163. know content and and Merchandising and and our licensing and so it's it goes beyond that equality health is a local
  164. Health Organization here that really targets the lower income primarily Latino African-American community uh in
  165. in greater Phoenix area they came to us to actually sign up and sponsor the largest street hockey program in the NHL
  166. in Arizona by the way and why because they knew that that was their Target and they were trying to make Health Care
  167. accessible and and really break down walls and barriers around the issues of Health Care why not do it with an
  168. organization that can help them do that in a very unique way because that organization is focused on that just
  169. like we're trying to make hockey accessible through street hockey how that's how we're trying to Target these
  170. growth in diverse uh segments they wanted to align with that so it's it's not just seeing it as bringing them into
  171. the supply chain and procurement it's also being that resource for those Enterprises to then also make that
  172. difference in the community and so for me that's that's the power that we have to combine our platforms our voices our
  173. impact with the business opportunities that make sense for the league for the team
  174. for our partners for the community um as much as these are the right things that
  175. we are doing Ken they're the right business decisions and that's what bothers me whenever there's critique I
  176. go great give me a critique as to why this is not a good business decision as as a as a business guy as a private
  177. Equity guy tell me why this is not a good business decision because I can tell you why it is Javier that that
  178. that's a great uh point to to end on the idea of this whole Space the idea of looking for opportunities and the idea
  179. that it can be positively business impactful if you do it the right way so thank you both thank you Jonathan thank
  180. you Javier for joining us on Opportunity [Music] Matters I'm farita Griffith managing
  181. director for the Wharton Coalition for equity and opportun in partnership with Wharton Works led by
  182. Professor Damon Phillips Business Roundtable and second chance business Coalition we're bringing together
  183. Business Leaders academics State leaders and Justice impacted communities for discussions on creating Pathways to
  184. sustainable employment for individuals who are formally incarcerated to learn more and register go to
  185. ceo. Warton do.edu

Brief Summary

Javier Gutierrez and Jonathan Bean discuss diversity in sports leadership and community impact in the NHL and NFL.

Key points

  • The Jackie Robinson Trope. Exploring how sports led America towards desegregation, even before schools were legally desegregated.
  • Diversity in Sports Leadership. A discussion on the importance of diverse leadership in sports organizations.
  • Economic Impact of Diversity. How diverse vendors and partnerships can drive economic activity in local communities.
  • Opportunity Matters. A discussion on creating pathways to sustainable employment for individuals.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes