Why Fair Trade Matters When Free Trade Falls Short

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton Professor Z. John Zhang explains how the elegant theory of free trade relies on assumptions that simply don’t hold in today’s global markets, which is why calls for fair trade have grown more urgent. He shares how tariffs force a collective choice between who wins and who loses as a result.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#tradepolicy #economics #globaleconomics #tariffdebate #tariffs #economicsecurity ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Free versus fair trade. It is a question drawing a lot of attention these days due to the push by the current White
  2. House administration looking for fair trade and using tariffs to try and reach that goal. But from a variety of
  3. different senses, the question to ask is, is it better to want to see free or fair trade? John Zang is a professor of
  4. marketing here at the Wharton School. He recently penned an opinion piece for Fortune talking about that topic
  5. specifically and he joins us right now. Hi John, how are you? >> Very good. How about you Dan?
  6. >> I'm doing well. Thanks for your time. Uh obviously this is a very important topic
  7. right now and give us your sense of why it was something that you felt you needed to talk about at the moment.
  8. Well, you know, free trade is the ideal and it is good if everybody believe in it and also everybody will practice it
  9. and but in the real world you know that that's not the case and uh so that's why
  10. in fact that we need to actually talk about the free trade we also need to talk about the merits of fair trade
  11. simply because uh a lot of other countries put tariffs on the US exports And uh it's really a uh I think a very
  12. easy point to make that US probably need to do the same thing. >> Yeah. So I guess it's not that
  13. surprising that at some point we were going to see a push by an administration round tariffs and the topic of fair
  14. trade be brought up. Correct. >> Yes. And uh in fact in my piece I was basically making the point that uh it's
  15. not easy and uh to actually talk about fair trade in this country simply because uh lot of people believe in the
  16. uh free trade free trade is almost like a religion. If you look into the theory that supports the free trade and there
  17. are lots lots of assumptions that need to be made for free trade uh to be the ideal and yet in practice those
  18. assumptions are just not uh very realistic. And so what I was trying to look into is why exactly that given that
  19. those assumptions are not very realistic and uh yet a lot of people still talking
  20. about free trade and that they really want to stick to it. Is it the is it the historic pattern I guess that we've seen
  21. here in our country around free trade that makes it so much harder to talk about fair trade? Yes, you can imagine
  22. that uh if you want to go ahead and raise the tariff and uh one of the first things you notice is that uh consumers
  23. may have to pay a higher price which basically means a large number of consumers in the country and may have to
  24. pay a higher price for the goods they purchase that are imported by the US and uh but if you actually and uh in the
  25. meantime and uh raise lower the tariff okay if you lower tariff a lot of people in the country will benefit from it. But
  26. if you look at the other side of the coin and when you actually raise the tariff and you would protect the workers
  27. who are in the import competing industries and uh and so which means that those people will benefit but on
  28. the other hand if you lower the tariff you may actually hurt those people and very very badly. So essentially what
  29. you're looking at is that on the one hand if you add and uh lower the tariff and you're going to hurt some of the uh
  30. workers in some small communities really badly but on the other hand if you lower
  31. the tariff you're going to benefit large number of people and by a small amount.
  32. So this is really the case where in the Chinese proverb they're basically saying
  33. that uh instead of try instead of injuring 10 fingers probably it's better to break one finger. In fact American
  34. politicians always follow that rule you always break the one finger instead of trying to injure 10 fingers.
  35. >> But at some point don't you run out of finger run out of fingers if you if you
  36. follow that path. >> Let me say it again actually here. So essentially in that kind of a situation
  37. either you're going to injure 10 fingers which means you raise the tariff and uh
  38. let everybody pay a slightly higher price or you're going to bring uh break break one finger which in that case is
  39. lower the tariff and uh hurt the some of the uh uh small number of people in the
  40. community badly. Right? Politicians always favor and in and uh break one finger instead of injuring 10 fingers.
  41. Now, now part of of the reason why we're seeing this, and you bring this up, is the topic of economic security, and it's
  42. part of the reason why we are seeing certain companies make moves to support the US economy, to bring home
  43. manufacturing, to, you know, think about different ways that they can, you know,
  44. boost the the economy of the US so that uh our economy, you know, continues to thrive and and be at the level with some
  45. of other countries around the world. Well, under free trade in the past few decades, you notice that a lot of
  46. American companies move away from from US and go to some other countries and uh in fact that that's indeed what you
  47. expect when you have a asymmetric trade, right? So if you are company and that produces in US and uh you're going to
  48. sell in domestic market and uh and uh and uh easily and uh but on the other hand that in fact they have to pay high
  49. tariffs to sell in foreign countries. So in that case it's probably much easier for you to relocate and to some other
  50. countries where and uh and when you sell to the US you don't pay tariffs and when
  51. you sell in domestic market in those countries you also don't pay taxes. So that's a much better situation for
  52. companies. So that's why there has been a giant sucking sun and uh as was what Ross Perau was saying and uh for
  53. American capital and American companies. >> Part of your article does talk about the
  54. political ramifications of free versus fair trade and the challenge that it can really be for politicians when they
  55. start to discuss one over the other. >> Yeah. When you do a finger arithmetic and you're always going to be in favor
  56. of uh free trade simply because free trade will benefit large number of people out there and uh fair and uh but
  57. only help uh and uh only hurt a few very few uh people and uh if you do fair trade you're going to hurt a large
  58. number of people and uh only benefit uh and uh hugely a small number of people. So that's why and uh in terms of uh the
  59. political calculus it's always a good idea to uh support the free trade and also the other factor is that uh you
  60. know the capital is mobile and uh workers are not so which means that when you have a free trade if I have the
  61. capital I can go around the world and deploy my capital and uh make a slight higher return right but in the meantime
  62. that of course that going to hurt some of the communities very very badly simply because you closed the factories
  63. and you would want a middle-aged uh worker and then to uh transit into some other different trade and uh to make a
  64. living. >> Do you expect that at least the way we have gone in the last few months under
  65. this new administration that we're going to probably try and follow the path of fair trade more so than free trade for
  66. the foreseeable future? Well, the Trump administration is certainly trying to do that. Of course,
  67. you can imagine that uh there is a lot of resistance. That's really one of the reasons why I want to write that
  68. particular piece. And uh so I was uh I really want to and uh articulate and what exactly is behind this free trade
  69. and the fair trade uh uh debate and also that uh what I really want to point out
  70. is that uh probably we all need to and uh have and share the sacrifice and probably I sorry uh probably we want we
  71. all want to share the sacrifice to give a fair trade a John, always great to talk with you.
  72. Thanks very much for your time today, sir. >> Thank you so much. >> Thank you. John Zang who is marketing
  73. professor here at the Wharton

Brief Summary

John Zang discusses the complexities of free trade versus fair trade and the implications of tariffs in the current political climate.

Key points

  • The Trade Debate: Free vs Fair. John Zang discusses the complexities of free and fair trade in today's economy.
  • The Religion of Free Trade. Zang compares free trade to a religion, highlighting its deep-rooted belief in society.
  • The Finger Metaphor. Zang uses a Chinese proverb to illustrate the trade-offs in tariff policies.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes