Doha Debacle: What's Next for Global Commerce
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Progress toward unfettered international commerce stumbled last week with the collapse of the World Trade Organization's Doha talks, a seven-year effort to establish new global trade rules. The lengthy talks were complicated by the rapid emergence of China and India as major economic powers -- powers with commercial and strategic interests to protect, and the clout to do so. Many observers say the talks' collapse is a setback for poorer nations, which need access to larger markets in order for their economies to grow. Wharton professors Stephen Kobrin, whose research interests include globalization, and Marshall Meyer, an authority on China's economy, recently spoke to Knowledge@Wharton about the talks' collapse, global commerce and China's interest in the rules governing trade. 📂 Public Policy
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] This podcast is brought to you by Knowledge at Wharton. Please visit knowledge.warton.upen.edu
- for more information. Progress toward unfettered international commerce stumbled last week with the
- collapse of the World Trade Organization's Doha Talks, a seven-year effort to establish new global trade
- rules. The lengthy talks which commenced in Doha, Qar and ended in Geneva were complicated by the rapid emergence of
- China and India as major economic powers. Powers with commercial and strategic interests to protect and the
- clout to do so. It was far from clear in the aftermath of the collapse that the talks would resume in the foreseeable
- future. Some negotiators wondered if an agreement among so many nations was even
- possible. The fundamental reality is that it has become too complex. WTO general director Pascal Lami told the
- Financial Times. Wharton professors Steven Cobrin, whose research interests include globalization and Marshall
- Meyer, an authority on China's economy, recently spoke to knowledge at Wharton about the collapse of the talks, global
- commerce, and China's interests in the rules governing trade. Welcome, Professor Cobin. The World Trade
- Organization's talks set the rules for governing international trade among more than 150 member nations. Now that the
- current round of talks, the Doha talks have broken down. What's the practical effect, trade is going to continue? No,
- I think in the short run, the threat isn't going to be dramatic. There'll be some minor impact on world GDP. I think
- the more serious threat in the longer run is the multilateral trading system as a whole in terms of how seriously
- countries take the World Trade Organization, how willing they are to abide by its principles and especially
- how willing they are to abide by a negative decision in one of their tribunals. If that's the case, then what
- does trade look like in the absence of a global agreement of some sort? Well, the
- the absence of a quote global agreement is the absence of a fairly major but still marginal
- uh extension of the rules. Mhm. So, we still have a rule-based international trading system. We've had a series of
- negotiations since the period immediately after World War II. The GAT the GAT through the current DA round.
- Okay. They've been incremental. they've built on one another culminating with the emergence of the World Trade
- Organization in 1994. Right? So we have a fairly broad-based system of rules to govern the international trading system.
- Okay. Uh the question is extending those rules uh further into agriculture services and other issues which this
- round was going to do and perhaps as you mentioned enforcing the rules if this harms the WTO's authority in some way.
- Well, one of the major uh advances with the creation of the WTO in 1994 was a serious tribunal. The big change with
- the WTO viz the GAT is it was much more difficult for a country to ignore a finding that wasn't in its favor. I see.
- And to to date, none of the major countries has. Okay. But there's still no way to compel a country to go along
- with a WTO finding. Mhm. It's based on a belief in mutual self-interest and a belief in the benefits of a multilateral
- system. And the danger is that without the talks proceeding that that could erode. There was a uh Wall Street
- Journal article immediately after the talks collapsed that said the they could uh signal an end to some 60 years of uh
- continuous expansion of global free trade deals. That does sound pretty dramatic, but it sounds similar to what
- you've just described. I think it is overly dramatic. I think it may signal an end to the incremental progress again
- since the f first gat talks in the late 40s. And what's happened since then is first the lowhanging fruit was grabbed
- off the tree earliest and second the world economy has become much more inclusive. And if you think about the
- 60s, the Kennedy round, which was one of the major post-war rounds, you probably
- had eight or nine countries that needed to uh come to agreement to reach a deal,
- right? Even in the Uruguay round, most of the developing countries were sidelined. All of a sudden, I think
- rightfully so, in the Doha round, you have 163 countries which in of which probably 60 or 70 have a major voice in
- the negotiations. I see. And so I think what's changed is the ease and that's too strong a word but the process of
- multilateral negotiations with the WTO meeting as a whole. Mhm. And able to hammer out an agreement among all the
- members. Exactly. So I think any further progress may require somewhat of a different process. Okay. There were a
- lot of uh reasons that the bro talks broke down. But in addition to having uh more inclusiveness and many more
- countries participating, the the role in which they participated was different. I mean with China in
- India, Brazil emerging as major economic powers, they had a lot more perhaps they
- had more clout than they did before. Um certainly they had interests that had to
- be contended with. Yeah. And and that's what I was talking about just previously. I I think that's true in the
- sense that uh a lot of the developing countries have become serious players in the world economy and have a serious
- voice in the negotiations. Okay. And that means that as diverse as the 30 or 31 OECD members are, that pales when you
- start to consider China and India and Uruguay uh whose levels of economic development, whose objectives, whose
- political systems, whose economic beliefs differ vastly among themselves and visav the traditional members of the
- OECD? I see. Do you think that it's possible for the traditional economic powers in North America and Europe and
- Asia uh and these emerging economic powers to ever reach an agreement on trade given their divergent interests
- and and especially under the rules of these talks in which I believe any one member can veto uh a particular um um
- portion of the agreement uh and make the whole agreement come to a crashing halt.
- I think in effect one member can veto it. I don't think that's what happened this time around. No. Okay. Uh I think
- it may represent as I said before a change in the nature of process. The the our ability to reach a multilateral
- agreement on a wide uh reaching set of issues among60 different countries may be beyond our
- reach at this point. Uh may not be possible. uh we may have to e a e either a negotiate on smaller pieces uh among
- all of the countries or b even break down into regional negotiations which then tend to come together in a
- community in a committee of a whole. Oh I see. So that you achieve free trade on
- a regional level and then move to a global level. Uh as I said before we may have to break the negotiations down into
- smaller pieces. I think the to use the standard analogy the bicycle will keep moving ahead but I think it's going to
- have to do it at a different pace and in a very different way given the change in
- the dynamic of the number of countries participating in the divergent interests. Is there any reason to think
- that these talks would resume anytime soon in their in their current form or do you think that some of the if they do
- resume they'll resume in one form or another of some of the different um uh uh scenarios that you've described
- regional or or one one measure at a time. Uh they could resume. I think it would
- be very difficult to reach a broad-based agreement without some sort of major shock that got everyone's attention. uh
- and and and force people to make compromises and agree. I think what's much more likely is they again we take
- smaller pieces of the puzzle, solve those and then stitch them together. Uh do you think it's possible that the
- collapse of the talks um in this particular round will energize free trade critics in the United States? It's
- always been everybody's favorite uh whipping boy. Uh I'm not sure that they need energizing. I think a lot of
- concerns about trade uh revolve around the business cycle. Uh and as times get more difficult,
- I think more and more people will start to question the benefits of free trade, the value of outsourcing, the value of
- inward flows of investment. Uh so the collapse of the talks certainly isn't going to help, but I suspect it's not
- going to be a major factor in energizing opposition to globalization or free trade. Trade's always been a tough
- issues for US voters to resolve. Uh and it's likely that it's going to be an important issue in this fall's
- presidential election. On one hand, people generally understand that free trade in the long term is necessary to
- spread economic opportunity globally, but on the other hand, it can the the long term can mean a very long time
- between paychecks. So, it's tempting for politicians to latch on to free trade as an issue to
- beat each other over the head with. Do you think that um uh well, if you were a voter or if you were giving advice to
- voters, um how would you say they should approach this issue? I mean, how do you
- try to get a a handle on the importance of free trade? I believe in an open economy. That doesn't mean a lack of all
- regulation or restriction. Okay? In any open system, any country that's open to the world economy, they're going to be
- winners and losers. And that's clear. People are more concerned about the losers as they feel more threaten
- themselves economically. Uh I think one of the things we need to do, which has been talked about for 50
- years, is building more of a secure safety net for people who fall through the cracks of free trade. Mhm. I think
- it may be beneficial to the economy as a whole and it isn't clear in every instance but I think generally it is
- true. Uh it free trade doesn't represent a gain for any individual or every industry. I think there have to be has
- to be more attention paid to providing some form of support for those who lose jobs uh need retraining, need temporary
- employment, uh unemployment payments and the like. Thanks for joining us, Professor. Uh when we first asked you
- about your reaction to the collapse of the trade talks, you said that China wants to protect its inefficient
- farmers. What about their agricultural system is inefficient? Well, you know, China
- still has more farmers, uh, more rural population than urban population. Last numbers I
- saw, 42% urban, 58% rural. Uh, rural population is shrinking maybe 1% a year, which is a very very dramatic rate of
- urbanization given the size of the country, but still huge rural population. Now, let's look at Chinese
- geography. Um, you got 1.3 roughly billion people. 58% are rural. That translates into roughly
- 770 million quote rural residents. They live at very high density. Almost all of
- them in an area that's like the equivalent to the US east of the Mississippi River.
- So you've got a lot of rural pop, you got lot large rural population concentrated in a very small area. Some
- say that 40% of the world's farmers live in China. Maybe it's 38% today. Mhm. Working 10%
- of the world's arable land. Now this tells you that farm plots or rice patties in China are very very small.
- and they're not really conducive to consolidation largescale farming because in the south of China at least
- inner Mongolia would be a little different where they have grasslands but um uh but the south of China much of
- this is terrorist this is historical this has been going on for years and it's very hard to convert terrorist rice
- patties into large efficient farms um so conse consequence is smallcale at least for grains smallcale production
- okay which by global standards is going to be inefficient absolutely yeah so are
- there other geographic areas in China where agriculture could occur but does not or
- is that just or are the areas that are farmable being farmed um we most people in the US don't realize that China's
- land mass is about the same as the US but two3 third of its desert or you know mountain that you really can't do
- anything about. So the answer is yeah if they had a lot more water and water is becoming a huge crisis in the north of
- China. They're planning to divert water like the old Grand Canal you know from uh from three gorges up north in China
- to relieve the pressures on the Beijing and Tanzhin water supplies. No, no, no. They're losing through urbanization and
- desertification a lot of farmland. The obvious place would first be again try to get the
- grasslands of Inner Mongolia more productive, keep the sandstorms down and then if they could find any water
- anywhere, begin to irrigate say Chingghai province um and uh get some intensive agriculture as Israel has
- done. They have Israel as a model um but so far their attempt to emulate that model has not been terribly successful.
- Okay. Is there a problem with the access to technology that um that American farmers have or would the technology not
- make a big difference given the the nature of the farming there? Well, it does make a difference but in an area
- not critical to China. Mhm. Okay. Small plot intensive agriculture is great for produce
- and there's a very active very profitable produce market in China. So um uh and some of the produce is high
- value is exported brings money into China. Mhm. So you you go to this town called Shoguang which is in the middle
- of Shandong province between Ginan the capital and Ching Dao where large companies like Higher and High sense are
- located and you will see trucks from all over this all over China coming together
- and just just you've never seen so much produce in your life and they have to move it very quickly because obviously
- it deteriorates. Mhm. And uh this is a city of about a town of about a million, you know, one traffic light, one movie
- theater. Uh but um you you can see how active this this this kind of highv value produce industry is in China. But
- that's not going to feed the masses of China. Right? No, what China needs is is rice for the south, wheat, and also
- soybeans. And presently they're huge they are importing huge quantities of these. But because of the price gap,
- um, even with elevated world prices, they've got to do something to protect their farmers. They've formerly used
- direct subsidies. Mhm. But I think they want the right to impose tariffs if they
- think their domestic producers are going to be overwhelmed. And this is a matter
- of national self-sufficiency. As mentioned to you earlier, uh, China sees what's happening with petroleum in the
- United States. They don't want to be dependent on foreign sources um for um fundamental
- food stuffs again wheat, rice to some extent soybeans and their dependence is much greater than already much greater
- than you think it is because let's say they're importing 12% of their food supply which I I think is approx is
- probably a good number to use as a rough number. Could be 10, could be 15. I'm going to say 12. um doesn't sound like
- too much, but if you got 58% of your population, 60% of your population sort of growing food for themselves,
- okay, that means it's you're really not looking at at 12 over 100. You're looking at say 12 over 42.
- In other words, food that's in the market. And 12 over 42 is is roughly 30% of the of the food that's in the market,
- right, is imported. And that means that they're just terribly vulnerable to global price fluctuations at least in
- the urban areas of China. Which is why you would said it's really a strategic it's very much a strategic issue for
- them not entirely. And there's something else going on um aside from the the uh global fluctuations in price of grain uh
- for many many reasons including some say ethanol. China's had a particular problem this year not with grain but
- with meat. They've had something called blue ear disease which has destroyed a lot of of of of their pigs. Okay. And as
- a consequence, the price of meat in China has shot up uh between 40 and 50% in the last 12 months. Mhm. It means the
- overall food prices have shot up about 25%. And in a country where say 354% of the
- household budgets food, um uh this has had very very dramatic impact on people. And uh the the the
- Chinese need to do what they can to kind of keep these prices in check on the one
- hand, but also to protect their domestic producers and their incomes, right? And
- for China, it well in many nations uh the the government will try to protect its its uh its farmers for um domestic
- political reasons. Sure. And one might think that that's less important in China. They don't vote. Ah, but they do
- other things. They vote with their feet. Yes. And by meeting voting with their feet is they riot.
- And and through 2005, the Chinese government actually published statistics on what they call mass disturbances. No
- one knew quite what that meant. Was it two or more people or 12 or more people? But whatever it was, it was. And you
- could see the graph going up exponentially. And they stopped releasing these numbers. But your
- anecdotal accounts tell you that discontent in rural communities has shot up in China. Uh some people tell me that
- premier wjao first thing he looks at in the morning are these reports of discontent particularly in rural areas.
- We've read in the newspaper various accounts of riots and uh the government is very very sensitive to this. This is
- a historical thing in China. It's not just under communism that they've had spontaneous riots. It was part of the
- political process in China. instead of going to the ballots box, people would just get out there and riot for and
- sometimes for five years in a row. But the Chinese government really wants to minimize this for all kinds of reasons
- as you can imagine. Of course. Um so then is it in China's interest to uh I mean to return to the talks or see the
- talks revived? I mean a lot of people are saying that they they threw in this last minute demand on the uh on on some
- of the tariff uh negotiations to derail the talks. it would seem that it's in their best
- interest to have some sort of a trade agreement. Uh I would think so. Again, I'm not an expert on trade, but I I I I
- would think that um um from the point of view of the export economy in which they've so heavily depended, yeah, it is
- in their interest to have a trade agreement. Um but I think right now um the the the priority for the Chinese
- the the current Chinese government um is national self-sufficiency. uh in food and again protecting the farmers among
- whom discontent where where discontent is is is I think very high right now. Okay. For all kinds of reasons given the
- the um uh geographical situation there. Is it a reasonable expectation for them to be
- self-sufficient uh agriculturally? That's a very interesting question because just as
- think of this geopolitically um just as the world depends heavily on the Middle East for oil,
- the world unfettered would depend heavily on the English-speaking countries, US, Canada, Australia particularly for
- the global supply of grain. There are many reasons for this and the question that's being raised is can the world
- afford to be that dependent on one block of countries. Mhm. And uh the answer I think remains unknown. Okay. But that's
- I think there there lies the issue. US, Canada and Australia particularly US and
- Canada are uniquely positioned to supply the world with grain and that has the n
- to do with the nature of weather patterns. Um I don't know if you recall but the
- Soviet Union used to go through periodic I won't say starvations. China did have
- a great starvation and great great leap forward but Soviet Union used to have periodic food shortages and it wasn't
- just due to socialism. See, if you look if you look at the crop bands in the Soviet Union, you know, the wheat's
- grown in the south, say in in Georgia and Ukraine, so on and so forth, the crop bands run east to west. In the US
- and Canada, they run north to south. And that means look, you know, where's our wheat belt? Where's our corn belt? You
- can just see these vertical stripes across the map. US and Canada. So weather patterns shift, but you still
- get production, right? You got somewhere somewhere on the somewhere you're getting production. Exactly. Okay. That
- doesn't happen in Eurasia much more vulner vulnerable to climate changes and China in particular as well
- as India by the way have another huge problem called water. The north of China the wheat area is
- arid. Desertification is happening. If you've ever been in Beijing in a sand in a sandstorm, you'll know what the word
- desertification means. You know, you know, when they tell you that, you know, over a good weekend, 318,000 tons of
- sand were deposited in Beijing. Um, and it's not the kind of sand, you know, it's in your kid's sandbox. I
- mean, this is the kind of stuff that when it gets into jet engines, makes the engine manufacturers very happy. It's
- like throwing an abrasive into your vehicle's engine, right? Or in the aircraft engine. Um when you see this
- happening, you know that their capacity to grow food is going to be constrained going forward
- unless either climate change reverses or they find some way to engineer water supplies in the north of China. I don't
- know the topography of India all that well, but I understand that there are similar problems in India. Certainly.
- Yes. Okay. Well, this has been fascinating. Thank you so much for for joining. More than welcome. It was fun.
- For more information, please visit knowledge.warton.upen.edu. [Music]
Brief Summary
The episode analyzes the collapse of the Doha Talks and China's agricultural inefficiencies in global trade.
Key points
- Collapse of Doha Talks. The Doha Talks, aimed at establishing global trade rules, have collapsed after seven years.
- Impact of Trade Talks Collapse. The breakdown of trade talks may energize critics of free trade in the U.S.
- China's Agricultural Inefficiency. China's agricultural system is inefficient due to small farm plots and a shrinking rural population.
- The Global Food Supply Question. Can the world rely on a few countries for grain? The answer remains unknown.
- China's Water Crisis. Desertification in northern China threatens food production and water supplies.
Episode highlights
- Impact of Trade Talks CollapseThe breakdown of trade talks may energize critics of free trade in the U.S.“The collapse of the talks certainly isn’t going to help.”8:58Aug 6, 2008
- China's Agricultural InefficiencyChina's agricultural system is inefficient due to small farm plots and a shrinking rural population.“China wants to protect its inefficient farmers.”11:01Aug 6, 2008
- The Global Food Supply QuestionCan the world rely on a few countries for grain? The answer remains unknown.“Can the world afford to be that dependent on one block of countries?”21:15Aug 6, 2008
- China's Water CrisisDesertification in northern China threatens food production and water supplies.“Desertification is happening. If you've ever been in Beijing in a sandstorm...”22:52Aug 6, 2008





