The Candidates on Health Care and Entitlements

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In the closing weeks of the U.S. presidential campaign, the candidates are focused largely on the global financial meltdown, which is formidable enough. But looming behind this front-burner concern are the very difficult long-term economic challenges of restoring Social Security and Medicare to solid footing, and providing health care coverage to the millions of Americans who are uninsured or inadequately insured. 📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] This podcast is brought to you by Knowledge at Wharton. Please visit knowledge.warton.upen.edu
  2. for more information. I think the middle is probably where we ought to be if we want to get something
  3. done because I think the evidence shows that um although there are some people who are in favor of the extremes either
  4. complete government takeover of the health care system under a sing so-called singlepayer system or a
  5. complete market oriented system with little regulation and high deductible health plans with health savings
  6. accounts which has kind of been the right-wing's answer. U um although some elements of government uh intervention
  7. and health savings accounts are present in both candidates plans uh the the the evidence on what uh ordinary Americans
  8. want indicate that they don't want to go to either extreme. They want something kind of like what they have now only uh
  9. that's able to um deal better with people who uh at the moment are uninsured. And that's part that's
  10. actually somewhat feasible to deal with. The part that's of course much more challenging is they'd also like a system
  11. that gives them exactly the same benefits as they get now, just doesn't cost as much. Uh, and so both of the
  12. candidates, as you would kind of predict if you were a political theorist, have tended to occupy the middle of the
  13. distribution of preferences, uh, offering elements in their plans, uh, many of which are quite similar. Like
  14. both candidates would want to offer you a choice of health plans, not a single plan. Uh both candidates want to use uh
  15. the private sector to provide uh a lot of the insurance if not all of the insurance and uh and both of them uh
  16. envision uh uh putting in place uh some devices they hope will improve quality and lower cost like greater use of
  17. information technology more use of preventive care and things like that. So both in terms of their overall
  18. frameworks and in terms of kind of the specific interventions uh that they propose, they're actually
  19. more similar than different. The most important thing to know about the uninsured is there's no single way
  20. to characterize the uninsured. It's very heterogeneous group. Some of them of course are the kinds of people you see
  21. in the newspaper stories for the most part. uh very lowincome people, very sick, really sad cases and and we really
  22. uh you know it's hard not to read those stories and think somebody ought to do something about this. Uh but on the
  23. other hand, there are a fair number of uninsured people who are either or both either pretty well uh and well or pretty
  24. well off and still they decide not to take insurance and the uh the individual mandate in the Massachusetts plan was
  25. targeted at these people and the intent was to make them behave more responsibly. uh they don't do it in part
  26. because they have a misperception especially the poster child I often say for an uninsured person is Fonzi who was
  27. a healthy uh person in his 20s worked part-time at the motorcycle shop so didn't have access to group insurance
  28. and didn't think he would ever need insurance but even healthy young men uh may eventually need insurance but uh uh
  29. it's um um sometimes hard to persuade them that that's a better use of their funds than other things that they could
  30. spend money on. There's partly a value judgment there. How how much uh um do we think a person has to have as income
  31. before we be able to say they could afford insurance? Uh but at least one calculation we did, you can believe this
  32. or not, the definition was to say, well, if other people, if most other people like you already have private insurance,
  33. we would say you could afford insurance. And about half of the uninsured fell into that category. if you don't want to
  34. be quite that hard-nosed about it, you could get a smaller fraction. But, um, it it's it's certainly true that a um
  35. that a a sizable chunk of the uninsured uh depending on your definition of affordability probably could even pay
  36. for their own health insurance and not and and not be um totally unable to uh have adequate other consumption. Um, and
  37. so, uh, part of the impediment, I think, to covering the uninsured is that if you
  38. direct subsidies to all of the uninsured, you actually would end up paying a fairly large part of that
  39. subsidy to people who really don't need it. And for or and whose uh, otherwise similar um, uh, citizens wouldn't be
  40. getting the same kind of subsidy. So, it's it's hard to pick up everybody uh, with a single instrument.
  41. I think there's two uh at least two maybe more uh complicated issues that both candidates are trying to duck uh
  42. that probably a critical voter ought to watch for. The first one is they both uh
  43. want to say that they can cover the uninsured without um the typical American who after all is insured and is
  44. not in poor health and and um is not um if the person works for a large firm necessarily worried about their health
  45. insurance. They want to convince that person they're not going to have to pay much more in taxes. Uh and unfortunately
  46. the reality is um um according to nonpartisan estimates of the cost of these plans or even according to common
  47. sense uh if we want to um reduce the number of uninsured people in the US uh those of us who um have the ability to
  48. pay are probably going to be asked to use that ability to pay some amount. The round number I carry around in my head
  49. is if you're a taxpaying household in the US a and you want to make a dent in the number of uninsured neither of these
  50. plans will totally eliminate it. you ought to be thinking about an extra thousand dollars a year or so more in
  51. taxes. So people don't want to talk about that and the so that the mechanism that's actually going to collect enough
  52. money to uh fund the programs they're proposing hasn't been put in place. Uh the other thing that people don't want
  53. to talk about is that the uh primary um uh determinant of and driver on spending
  54. growth has actually not been inefficiency or waste or even conspiracies. Either take your pick of who you want to
  55. be your enemy, doctors, health insurers, employers trying to be nasty to workers.
  56. It's actually been um uh our ourselves who uh desire to have um improved healthcare technology which we have been
  57. able to get. Uh that's actually substantially improved life expectancy at all ages, but it's done so at a cost.
  58. And so if you really want to control cost, at least if you want to stop it from growing the way it's historically
  59. been growing, the the the difficult message is you may have to give up somewhat on um the uh rate at which you
  60. add beneficial but costly new technology. And only somebody with tenure actually could say that, not
  61. somebody running for office. So I don't want to be totally pessimistic here. each one uh has some
  62. things that might work and might help, although I'm somewhat skeptical whether they'll help enough. So part of the core
  63. of the idea that McCain is trying to pursue, one that I think he's had a hard time explaining in sound bites is that
  64. by um taking away uh the tax advantage that I get and that any employees whose employer provides health insurance gets,
  65. the tax advantage arises because Penn pays, I figure about $9,000 toward my health insurance. That's part of the
  66. reason why I work here, but I don't pay any tax on that. So, I get that tax break and um and I um uh because I do so
  67. I'm inclined to choose the most generous policy that's offered. I also get the tax break even on the part that I
  68. explicitly pay because we have a cafeteria plan. Well, McCain's idea is by taking away that tax break, replacing
  69. it with a credit, the $5,000 per family, 2500 per person, but the credit is predetermined. It doesn't get any
  70. bigger. If you choose a more expensive plan, people will be incentivized to choose more frugal plans and that will
  71. help to at least lower the level of spending, maybe curtail it. Uh the other thing that actually is in both of their
  72. proposals is to put more effort into research on comparative effectiveness of new technologies to try to look more
  73. carefully at new technologies uh to judge which ones are really not only beneficial but beneficial enough uh to
  74. cover the cost. But as soon as you put in that last phrase, people start to get very worried. Uh what if there's a
  75. technology that's beneficial for me, but it has a really high cost. I'd really like somebody to pay for that for me.
  76. Even if I wouldn't pay for it myself, we kind of know uh what your mother always
  77. told you whenever you asked to do anything you shouldn't. Well, what if everybody did that? And that and in a
  78. way that's our problem. So uh that's one of the features that uh that is present.
  79. Um the the uh the main structural change uh and this maybe kind of shows you why
  80. it's implausible at least until things get a lot worse would be uh at least the way I've described it would be to think
  81. of people being offered a variety of health plans and the health plans uh offer as part of their product different
  82. attitudes toward new technology. There'd be the prudent care health plan that would wait for a while when new
  83. technology came out for one thing to see if there are side effects like there were with vio and wouldn't give you
  84. access to it right away and would limit access more. And then there could also be a plan with with of course a premium
  85. that rose more rapidly that would give you the the firstest with the mostest whatever you wanted and you and your
  86. doctor as soon as you agreed on it that other plan would pay for it. Uh and so the the at least the market solution
  87. would be that people would choose between these two plans, the high spending plan and the low spending plan,
  88. and we'd declare victory and pull out. They would have each gotten what they wanted. But um but health plans, for
  89. perhaps obvious marketing reasons, haven't been too eager to pursue offering the frugal plan. Most of them,
  90. whether they're frugal or generous, pretend they're generous. So, and it's to their advantage to do so, obviously.
  91. For more information, please visit knowledge.warton.upen.edu. [Music]

Brief Summary

Health care reform plans are similar, but covering the uninsured poses financial challenges and requires tax increases.

Key points

  • Healthcare Reform Preferences. Americans prefer a middle-ground approach to healthcare, avoiding extremes.
  • Understanding the Uninsured. The uninsured population is diverse, not just low-income individuals.
  • Cost Control Challenges. Controlling healthcare costs may require sacrificing new technologies.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes